Jack Attack Mafia (Day 5)

[Hally]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

do you think her claim should clear her?

[nutella]

where was the scum kill N1 though if nanook was the sk shot and fg was the vig shot

maybe it was blocked or doctored?

[nutella]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

do you think her claim should clear her?

no, I don't

[Hally]

where was the scum kill N1 though if nanook was the sk shot and fg was the vig shot

maybe it was blocked or doctored?

well if town has a blocker they need to claim asap because whoever they blocked N1 is probably outed scum

i dont think a doctor should claim if there is one, especially not if their target is already widely town read

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

It's difficult to qualify beyond that spiritual level of feeling the right way when I read her posts. She struck me as earnest and genuine in a way that she has tended to strike me when I have correctly viewed her as a civilian in the past.

Is there a reason you think she'd have to bother with all that claiming stuff at the start of Day 2 as a mafioso?

[nutella]

now that I know wilgy was town I kinda wonder if colin expressed tmi on him (in addition to the potential jay tmi)

he had a fairly easy-seeming town meta read of wilgy based on like not very much


but then again on the other hand I do remember kinda feeling a slight townread from wilgy's few existing posts before I got his rolecard lol

[Hally]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

do you think her claim should clear her?

no, I don't

why not?

[nutella]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

It's difficult to qualify beyond that spiritual level of feeling the right way when I read her posts. She struck me as earnest and genuine in a way that she has tended to strike me when I have correctly viewed her as a civilian in the past.

Is there a reason you think she'd have to bother with all that claiming stuff at the start of Day 2 as a mafioso?

i probably need to reread it. had she seen wisp's claim of town!lc or did she post her 3p result unprompted

[Hally]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

It's difficult to qualify beyond that spiritual level of feeling the right way when I read her posts. She struck me as earnest and genuine in a way that she has tended to strike me when I have correctly viewed her as a civilian in the past.

Is there a reason you think she'd have to bother with all that claiming stuff at the start of Day 2 as a mafioso?

i probably need to reread it. had she seen wisp's claim of town!lc or did she post her 3p result unprompted

she posted hers after

[JaggedJimmyJay]

i probably need to reread it. had she seen wisp's claim of town!lc or did she post her 3p result unprompted

To my memory Wisp had at least softed his claim before Daisy posted her result. I would need to review the timeline.

[Hally]

she was basically cc-ing wisps check

[Millium]

I'll most likely end up on Nutella
or hitting one of the more spicy targets like JJJ, and Alison, just in the off case I die sooner than later, confirming one of them in town worlds would be great
don't really have to think about Hally, she is just town
Spacy can be a wolf if I squint my eyes really hard and pretend they didn't play god awful trying to fake a check on Long con for absolutely no reason
In a redirector world? aka Daisy being the wolf with a redirector, knowing the redirector is silent, could just very adamantly claim they thought their check was real
but it's doubtful they don't still get lynched? so ehhhhhh?

[nutella]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

do you think her claim should clear her?

no, I don't

why not?

I think especially if she hadn't seen wisp's post yet, which i vaguely remember her post kinda sounding like she hadn't, it couldve been a way to keep LC in the POE? idk if that makes sense over her just being redirected, but maybe she's on the scum team with the redirector and..... yeah idk where i'm going with this tbh it's too much for me to wrap my head around rn

[nutella]

she was basically cc-ing wisps check

oh huh. i thought i remembered thinking from the wording of her post that she might not have seen/read wisp's post and didn't realize her claim was contradictory to info already in the thread

if it was clear she realized that, it's prob more likely she was just being transparent about stuff being weird lol

[Spacedaisy]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

It's difficult to qualify beyond that spiritual level of feeling the right way when I read her posts. She struck me as earnest and genuine in a way that she has tended to strike me when I have correctly viewed her as a civilian in the past.

Is there a reason you think she'd have to bother with all that claiming stuff at the start of Day 2 as a mafioso?

i probably need to reread it. had she seen wisp's claim of town!lc or did she post her 3p result unprompted

I saw Wisp's apparent and sudden determination that LC was good, directly after I had a 3p read on LC. Which made me feel it was necessary at that point to try and temper things, because I knew something was wrong with one of our reads. As things progressed in the discussion it required me claiming, which i had no intention to do until i thought I might have a solid scum read. But here we are, with two outed cops and no red checks yet.

[Millium]

[mention]nutella[/mention]
I mean that's exactly what I thought they were doing before the full claim to be fair
So our thoughts are kinda similar there

I am pretty sure she saw my post also

[Hally]

I'll most likely end up on Nutella
or hitting one of the more spicy targets like JJJ, and Alison, just in the off case I die sooner than later, confirming one of them in town worlds would be great
don't really have to think about Hally, she is just town
Spacy can be a wolf if I squint my eyes really hard and pretend they didn't play god awful trying to fake a check on Long con for absolutely no reason
In a redirector world? aka Daisy being the wolf with a redirector, knowing the redirector is silent, could just very adamantly claim they thought their check was real
but it's doubtful they don't still get lynched? so ehhhhhh?

just tell me where you check so i know who to voyeur

unless this is like an obviously bad strategy for some reason

[nutella]

@JaggedJimmyJay I didn't understand why you felt a townie spark from daisy so early on, I didn't really

It's difficult to qualify beyond that spiritual level of feeling the right way when I read her posts. She struck me as earnest and genuine in a way that she has tended to strike me when I have correctly viewed her as a civilian in the past.

Is there a reason you think she'd have to bother with all that claiming stuff at the start of Day 2 as a mafioso?

i probably need to reread it. had she seen wisp's claim of town!lc or did she post her 3p result unprompted

I saw Wisp's apparent and sudden determination that LC was good, directly after I had a 3p read on LC. Which made me feel it was necessary at that point to try and temper things, because I knew something was wrong with one of our reads. As things progressed in the discussion it required me claiming, which i had no intention to do until i thought I might have a solid scum read. But here we are, with two outed cops and no red checks yet.

ok

[Hally]

she was basically cc-ing wisps check

oh huh. i thought i remembered thinking from the wording of her post that she might not have seen/read wisp's post and didn't realize her claim was contradictory to info already in the thread

if it was clear she realized that, it's prob more likely she was just being transparent about stuff being weird lol

yeah, she pretty explicitly said she didnt believe wisp amd then outed her check shortly after

also why would w!daisy fake a 3P check there? then we flip lc and he flips town and...? what would daisy do then?

[Millium]

Subtlety is not my middle name!
but u also could have not forced me to completely out, since LC was just 3p in your check anyways? its not like that was our main priority.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]Jackofhearts2005[/mention]

nutella

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]nutella[/mention] what'd you like about Wilgy before you occupied his skin?

[Long Con]

I'll most likely end up on Nutella
or hitting one of the more spicy targets like JJJ, and Alison, just in the off case I die sooner than later, confirming one of them in town worlds would be great
don't really have to think about Hally, she is just town
Spacy can be a wolf if I squint my eyes really hard and pretend they didn't play god awful trying to fake a check on Long con for absolutely no reason
In a redirector world? aka Daisy being the wolf with a redirector, knowing the redirector is silent, could just very adamantly claim they thought their check was real
but it's doubtful they don't still get lynched? so ehhhhhh?

just tell me where you check so i know who to voyeur

unless this is like an obviously bad strategy for some reason

I would rather try a possibly bad strategy than proceed without one.

[nutella]

she was basically cc-ing wisps check

oh huh. i thought i remembered thinking from the wording of her post that she might not have seen/read wisp's post and didn't realize her claim was contradictory to info already in the thread

if it was clear she realized that, it's prob more likely she was just being transparent about stuff being weird lol

yeah, she pretty explicitly said she didnt believe wisp amd then outed her check shortly after

also why would w!daisy fake a 3P check there? then we flip lc and he flips town and...? what would daisy do then?

I guess you have a point yeah, she was probably just redirected

[Long Con]

she was basically cc-ing wisps check

oh huh. i thought i remembered thinking from the wording of her post that she might not have seen/read wisp's post and didn't realize her claim was contradictory to info already in the thread

if it was clear she realized that, it's prob more likely she was just being transparent about stuff being weird lol

yeah, she pretty explicitly said she didnt believe wisp amd then outed her check shortly after

also why would w!daisy fake a 3P check there? then we flip lc and he flips town and...? what would daisy do then?

I guess you have a point yeah, she was probably just redirected

Even though the game is likely complicated in unknown ways, that does still feel right.

[nutella]

@nutella what'd you like about Wilgy before you occupied his skin?

i don't remember specifically, it's always hard to tell with him since he has a jokey and lax tone regardless of alignment but i did feel something there that pointed to him being on his own

[Long Con]

I'll most likely end up on Nutella
or hitting one of the more spicy targets like JJJ, and Alison, just in the off case I die sooner than later, confirming one of them in town worlds would be great
don't really have to think about Hally, she is just town
Spacy can be a wolf if I squint my eyes really hard and pretend they didn't play god awful trying to fake a check on Long con for absolutely no reason
In a redirector world? aka Daisy being the wolf with a redirector, knowing the redirector is silent, could just very adamantly claim they thought their check was real
but it's doubtful they don't still get lynched? so ehhhhhh?

I like that you consider JJJ a spicy target. We'll get there.

[nutella]

I'll most likely end up on Nutella
or hitting one of the more spicy targets like JJJ, and Alison, just in the off case I die sooner than later, confirming one of them in town worlds would be great
don't really have to think about Hally, she is just town
Spacy can be a wolf if I squint my eyes really hard and pretend they didn't play god awful trying to fake a check on Long con for absolutely no reason
In a redirector world? aka Daisy being the wolf with a redirector, knowing the redirector is silent, could just very adamantly claim they thought their check was real
but it's doubtful they don't still get lynched? so ehhhhhh?

I like that you consider JJJ a spicy target. We'll get there.

you still suspect him yeah?

I caught him in ziggy and you were his teammate there, do you think he is similar here? bc I don't

[sabie12]

I'll most likely end up on Nutella
or hitting one of the more spicy targets like JJJ, and Alison, just in the off case I die sooner than later, confirming one of them in town worlds would be great
don't really have to think about Hally, she is just town
Spacy can be a wolf if I squint my eyes really hard and pretend they didn't play god awful trying to fake a check on Long con for absolutely no reason
In a redirector world? aka Daisy being the wolf with a redirector, knowing the redirector is silent, could just very adamantly claim they thought their check was real
but it's doubtful they don't still get lynched? so ehhhhhh?

I like that you consider JJJ a spicy target. We'll get there.

I would go more for alison out of those options. LC you are very adamant about voting jay whether jokingly or seriously. Did you give reasoning why? Who else would you go for besides jay?

[Long Con]

My original reasons for suspecting him are well-known. And many times since then, his "thread activities" and such have seemed like a level 1 JJJ channeling a former town self, can't you see that he's going through the motions?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

he's going through the motions?

I hear this at least once in just about every game I play these days. If you don't believe me yet, then I am not sure you're capable of believing me.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

nutella, are we in "nutella called me town, therefore she is bad" mode?

[nutella]

nutella, are we in "nutella called me town, therefore she is bad" mode?

nope

I just don't see whatever it is LC sees, and this has been true since before I subbed in


I don't think you're "going through the motions" in the fake way at all

[Spacedaisy]

Subtlety is not my middle name!
but u also could have not forced me to completely out, since LC was just 3p in your check anyways? its not like that was our main priority.

i wasn't blaming you. I didn't catch on at first you were claiming but after my initial caution against town clearing him it became clear and by then hally was on me thinking i was lying so I had to lay my cards on the table. I didn't intend to force you to out your role.

[TonyStarkPrime]

jack daw isn't scum. why is the scum team shooting fg?

If she was truthful then it was literally impossible to chop her. That's a decent reason.

M a y b e
T h e r e
I s
N o
M a f i a

Spoiler: show

yeah that's right. I wasn't really thinking about it.

[nutella]

I'd be happy to be checked by wisp, don't want to say too much yet but my role can potentially be helpful if we can coordinate well

[JaggedJimmyJay]

yeah that's right. I wasn't really thinking about it.

Tony's mafia. His "suspicion" of me has been vague horseshit all game long. He can hardly stick a random take into the thread without immediately pulling back on it. He has no real opinions of anything.

Each of you out there: I challenge you to tell me what TonyStarkPrime's read is on you -- not what takes he has given on assorted posts, but what his read is.

[TonyStarkPrime]

yeah that's right. I wasn't really thinking about it.

Tony's mafia. His "suspicion" of me has been vague horseshit all game long. He can hardly stick a random take into the thread without immediately pulling back on it. He has no real opinions of anything.

Each of you out there: I challenge you to tell me what TonyStarkPrime's read is on you -- not what takes he has given on assorted posts, but what his read is.

and what is a read but a collection of assorted takes?

[nutella]

lol what are reads


we just dont know

[TonyStarkPrime]

yeah that's right. I wasn't really thinking about it.

Tony's mafia. His "suspicion" of me has been vague horseshit all game long. He can hardly stick a random take into the thread without immediately pulling back on it. He has no real opinions of anything.

Each of you out there: I challenge you to tell me what TonyStarkPrime's read is on you -- not what takes he has given on assorted posts, but what his read is.

like. to borrow an idea from Epi, I don't believe that you believe this.

[TonyStarkPrime]

tony and jay have gone full on omgus at this point

[nutella]

lmao the host is voting in the night poll

[TonyStarkPrime]

I should be cleared from the way I viewed Pawn's spot but that's neither here nor there.

[nutella]

yeah that's right. I wasn't really thinking about it.

Tony's mafia. His "suspicion" of me has been vague horseshit all game long. He can hardly stick a random take into the thread without immediately pulling back on it. He has no real opinions of anything.

Each of you out there: I challenge you to tell me what TonyStarkPrime's read is on you -- not what takes he has given on assorted posts, but what his read is.

like. to borrow an idea from Epi, I don't believe that you believe this.

I don't believe that you believe this

[nutella]

I should be cleared from the way I viewed Pawn's spot but that's neither here nor there.

elaborate?

[nutella]

cursory glance shows you thought he couldn't be 3p for "reasons"


hm

[TonyStarkPrime]

yeah that's right. I wasn't really thinking about it.

Tony's mafia. His "suspicion" of me has been vague horseshit all game long. He can hardly stick a random take into the thread without immediately pulling back on it. He has no real opinions of anything.

Each of you out there: I challenge you to tell me what TonyStarkPrime's read is on you -- not what takes he has given on assorted posts, but what his read is.

like. to borrow an idea from Epi, I don't believe that you believe this.

I don't believe that you believe this

I'm still thinking about it. Jay giving up on his POE and all of his interactive reads to take shots at me feels pretty forced.

[TonyStarkPrime]

cursory glance shows you thought he couldn't be 3p for "reasons"


hm

I'm not talking about those reasons and will not because I was clearly wrong. But it doesn't make sense for a wolf, especially a wolf who knows that pawn is the SK (but I don't think the wolves did know that), to present that as a thought.

[nutella]

wdym giving up on his poe

[TonyStarkPrime]

That probably should unalign me from Colin, and I really want Jay to try to create a compelling case I'm mafia from there