NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:19 pm
Like Colin not being mafia is nice to know but it would’ve been nicer imo to know Hally and LC were both hard confirmed lol
Hally can be bad without me being bad. We are not a package deal.
tutuu wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:26 pm
is it dumb if i want to vote nutella
does anyone scumread nutella or is she consensus townread
her perspective bothers me at points and shes like
somewhere bottom 5 in my personal poe but idk if thats misguided or what
but hally being real almost means nutella has to be real?
also from hally pov mr is confirmed scum and nutella still has the claim on that kill?
and also at other points her perspective feels totally fine to me and like fairly impressive if scum
in my book in a vacuum she had a less towny d2 than hally tho
she just shaded hally on the previous page which i dont understand because i also thought (idk why) that town!nutella and town!hally come together in one package
the other option for a wolf!hally world is that it's hally/LC and hally carried the kill out of paranoia that someone would see LC visit and be like "hey wait a tick"
but i think that one's less likely
either way i think the only world where w!hally redirects colin is one where w!hally is forced to carry kp; i think otherwise they just let themselves be "cleared"
feel like proto/dizzy is realistically the PoE for today tbh
Hally wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 9:56 pm
@ColinIsCool what did i do last night?
everyone else should say who they targeted too
i will not disclose my action until colin posts
Targeted Dizzy
kay this checks out
i redirected you to wwh so you actually tracked her
she targeted dizzy which is why you got that result
that plus wwh not getting nk’d means you actually have a track and did not have a kill last night
it’s at the very least a soft clear
actually genius
also conveniently means we don't have a track result on hally themselves...............
but yes it's a smart way to check colin
4/60
i mean, the point wasn’t to get a result on me
the point was to confirm colin as real
i did that
i mean...ok
ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:19 pm
I don’t see what scum Hally has to gain by concocting a roundabout way of clearing me, or by trying to clear me at all.
i do lol but w/e
Benson wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:21 pm
Why is Colin cleared if there can be 5 wolves technically? He still can be a wolf with tracking abilities.
Like it's good. But not a sure thing.
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:17 pm
Why would you do that Hally we could’ve cleared both you and LC
shrug
i assumes tutuu was checking in the clear group and would hard clear me because ppl were telling her to do that
i was post capped so i couldn’t coordinate anything and this seemed like a good idea
I gave tutuu a check pool in the POE
This was very meh tbh
it wouldn’t have been meh if i had redirected colins kill to wwh and outed him as mafia
seems like he’s just town though
lol, this combined with the previous post of yours i just quoted has me feeling Some kind of way
but yeah i think we probably just yeet proto today and if the game continues we can think about this hally stuff more
linki: no, me and hally are not necessarily a package, i think there is a potential world where they faked the claim. nothing to do with me successfully killing radishes, just them potentially taking advantage of it to clear it as a red flip if it wasn't
Benson wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:34 pm
Can we at least wait until I'm sober to yeet. Please and thanks. I'm not opposed to it tomorrow because at least we have nighttalk.
Hally wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:37 pm
you all have a skewed perception of me as a player if you think i’m smart enough as scum to fake claim this stuff
im not a string mechanical player. i would never in a million years think to fake claim what i’ve claimed this game as scum lol
i mean, in the world where LC is your partner he could prob come up with it idk
but i don't know that i really think that's the world?
i townread alison and i even expressed cold feet on the page that she got yeeted
also i shared the same townread of proto for d0 but i noted a downtrend d1
but ok tutuu
if you throw out all mech who do you think it is
nutella?
im fine with a nutella proto poe idgaf
also linkiedit: buying hally saying they couldnt come up with this claim as scum
it is a really weirdly specific claim and its "good" in the sense of "hard to come up with as a fake but easy to buy as something the host would put in"
Benson wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:36 pm
lol. I thought he posted for some reason.
Hally, why isn't your role scary enough to kill? Like the wolves knew I was never saving you.
why would they kill me when half the players are still tinfoiling me as a wolf
they need the poe as wide as possible
killing me confirms me town and by extension nut and lc are also confirmed
it also removes me from the poe
that’s a game losing play for scum if they do that
Fine. I wanted to see how you'd approach that.
But let's be fair: we are almost always going for the low PoE before the tin foil catches up. I can convince people the theories are plausible, but I don't think we're actually going there before a couple more misyeets or a mechanical confirmations.
But I suppose if they're all in the PoE, their only hope may be the tin foil.
tutuu wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:42 pm
if i throw away all of the mech stuff i think its nutella yes. purely by my perception of scumminess of day talk, i scumread nutella most
obviously im not going to insist, and i guess the proper way is to still to go with mechanics
but if i was more selfish here i was gonna peek nutella like i wanted to. idk i could be wrong!
in jack attack i got mech cleared and didn't really feel like putting in effort and so my posts were objectively not towny at all bc i felt i could just rely on the claim
could say this is kinda similar tho i'm less cleared and i personally feel like my play has been p objectively towny but if you don't see it idk what to tell you
Hally wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:37 pm
you all have a skewed perception of me as a player if you think i’m smart enough as scum to fake claim this stuff
im not a string mechanical player. i would never in a million years think to fake claim what i’ve claimed this game as scum lol
i mean, in the world where LC is your partner he could prob come up with it idk
but i don't know that i really think that's the world?
hm
Every situation like this, I think "man, I have to remember this as a wolf, and use something like it as a grand sneaky claim scheme!" I never really do though, my claim schemes have, to date, been much less inspired, like "I know Tony is that role and will claim it, but he hasn't been on since night ended so I'll claim it instead and see where that goes" and cross my fingers.
This game just might be terribly balanced (no offense) based on the roles and the player distribution. And I suppose it could be that the wolves had some great roles that were snuffed before they could do anything.
Maybe I'm just so biased towards fake claiming and mechanics because that's how I'd wolf here. And that's what I expected in a game where almost everyone has some power.
I'll go now since I haven't contributed meaningfully since D1.
Benson wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:49 pm
This game just might be terribly balanced (no offense) based on the roles and the player distribution. And I suppose it could be that the wolves had some great roles that were snuffed before they could do anything.
Maybe I'm just so biased towards fake claiming and mechanics because that's how I'd wolf here. And that's what I expected in a game where almost everyone has some power.
I'll go now since I haven't contributed meaningfully since D1.
dont get emo sometimes we dont need to do anything but shitpost and annoy the clears while they carry
i have highly enjoyed your presence, you think very similarly to me overall
Benson wrote: ↑Fri Jul 24, 2020 10:49 pm
This game just might be terribly balanced (no offense) based on the roles and the player distribution. And I suppose it could be that the wolves had some great roles that were snuffed before they could do anything.
Maybe I'm just so biased towards fake claiming and mechanics because that's how I'd wolf here. And that's what I expected in a game where almost everyone has some power.
I'll go now since I haven't contributed meaningfully since D1.
dont get emo sometimes we dont need to do anything but shitpost and annoy the clears while they carry
i have highly enjoyed your presence, you think very similarly to me overall
This is my only solace during these dark days
(unless you've pocketed me)
tutuu wrote: ↑Thu Jul 23, 2020 9:54 pm
@Timsup2nothin can u pls hard claim ur role btw? (is that even legal? dont do it if its illegal)
like, specifically the nationality of ur philosopher. actually no, can u claim the whole thing? (the flavor) (but only if its legal)
u softed a bit about some of the philosophy of ur person on d0. i wanna know if it holds up, and i wanna know that he's not a FILTHY GREEK
I already said I was German and you are welcome to check. I am an inventor. I built Rabbit a soapbox to stand on so he could make more posts. If you search the thread for "soapbox" you will see that I used the word earlier, and if you ISO me you will find that I said specifically to Rabbit "If I had a PR I'd give it to you." My claim may not seem like much, but it is clearly verifiable.
It also has more powerful options, but the more powerful the thing that I build the higher the risk it will fail. The soapbox is like 10% daily...Rabbit use it freely I think you get notified first thing at SoD if it breaks that day. I can only build things as gifts, not for myself...and didn't want to make someone something they would be relying on heavily and have it break.
he only mentioned risk of the invention itself failing (and ive already experienced the soapbox breaking after 3 out of the 10 posts it was supposed to give me n2)
never mentioned risk of dying due to attempting invention
