U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Has cayvie been scummy or is she just kinda there?

[Marcher Jovian]

Has cayvie been scummy or is she just kinda there?

Her d0 felt kinda pretty bad
It just felt like super archetypical mafia entrance
She’s just kinda been there since
She’s had a few decent takes imo which is why she was trending up

[PunchyTheCat]

Has cayvie been scummy or is she just kinda there?

Her d0 felt kinda pretty bad
It just felt like super archetypical mafia entrance
She’s just kinda been there since
She’s had a few decent takes imo which is why she was trending up

sheeping MJ's takes on cayvie for now on because they've been correct so far

[PunchyTheCat]

Apogee
AWESOM-O
beeboy
colonialbob
DrWilgy
Epignosis
iwan
Jackofhearts2005
Justplayingitcool
Long Con
polypies73
sabie12
Shizune
speedchuck
Sprityo
TenThousandCalories
Urist

anyone have reads on this list

was going to ask about colonialbob because he's voting me

[tedxtr]

i'm not used to punchy sheeping other people ; i know what it means for people's reads if he personally trashes on them but I don't know what that means for that person's reads if he sheeps them

[sheepsaysmeep]

Apogee
AWESOM-O
beeboy
colonialbob
DrWilgy
Epignosis
iwan
Jackofhearts2005
Justplayingitcool
Long Con
polypies73
sabie12
Shizune
speedchuck
Sprityo
TenThousandCalories
Urist

anyone have reads on this list

was going to ask about colonialbob because he's voting me

beeboy is gun to my head villa, and i'd like to think im decent at reading beeboy

more of a tone thing and ideally theres more readable content from him but pls dont shoot there yet or anything

[PunchyTheCat]

jesus christ am i allowed to ask why someone has a read on logic for once without backlash jesus

[sheepsaysmeep]

punchy you were in team mafia and witnessed a bunch of people being able to locktown logic within a couple of hours right

maybe an unfair expectation here given that im also having trouble getting into the game but i do think he should be being clearer already here as villa

[ThisIsNotAceMarvel]

Apogee
AWESOM-O
beeboy
colonialbob
DrWilgy
Epignosis
iwan
Jackofhearts2005
Justplayingitcool
Long Con
polypies73
sabie12
Shizune
speedchuck
Sprityo
TenThousandCalories
Urist

anyone have reads on this list

was going to ask about colonialbob because he's voting me

Apogee town
AWESOM-O scum lean
beeboy townish
colonialbob idk
DrWilgy idk
Epignosis idk
iwan votes makes me think town but idk
Jackofhearts2005 idk persona avatar in my experience are scum
Justplayingitcool middle ground can go both ways
Long Con idk
polypies73 idk yet
sabie12 idk
Shizune idk
speedchuck idk
Sprityo ??? we were told not to trust, but I'm really afraid of the pr
TenThousandCalories arrived late don't know what to think about that
Urist OMGUS for me before, null

[Maple]

List of Vilagers/Vetoes

DaisyCloud
Shot a wolf. It's the type of role that wolves look at and say "yeah, this is our get deep for free card". Doming them, when funny was under 0 pressure and Daisy still had like 5 active shots in the air, is basically never a wolf. If they are, they're a godtier role, but we aren't getting into that for now.


DDL
Cool role, seems legit, prob village based on mechs. I don't feel like elaborating because I highly doubt anyone has their sites on him lol


NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Claiming stumped, they also claim not to have a vote and all the other bullshit that makes a stump a stump. For now, gonna take their word for it and assume the slot is just a voice talking to us. I'll lol if they're like 3p executioner or some shit, that'd be hilarious


Ephemeral

LOCK OF THE WEEK. I can elaborate on why this guy is a villager if people really want me to, but as others have been saying basically all game, I'm the authority on Eph here. If anyone can read past this stupid bullshit, it's me. And my read is that this guy is a villager. I don't want to let him die this early, this easily, and for free. He's a 0 accountability wagon, and people like him dying this easily is how we lose. Don't let it happen


Hyena
Villagery ass MFer. After ISOing the guy, he's pure. I'd put this read on the same teir as Marcher. Towncore, listen to what he says, and if he has ultra strong feelings at ITAs consider what he's saying. I know sometimes hyena's good thoughts get ignored, and I don't want that happening here.


Marcher Jovian
Consistently villagery, protown, actually giving a shit. Seems to be a legit villager


nutella
After the fiasco that was last game, sort of have a grasp on how they play. Not really a meta read, more of a tonal/this is what I'd see a villager them be like


PunchyTheCat
SOULREAD PLEASE SHEEP, I UNDERSTAND WHY YOU MIGHT WANT TO KILL HIM BUT FAITH PLS TY


tedxtr
Early Denny's read, the guy stuck to his guns when pressured on it, but then backed off when new info came up and is giving the thread space rather than forcing through their own shit. This is always a villager.


ThisIsNotAceMarvel
Their ISO is legit. Not the most raw solving-power in there, but they come off as natural and their friendly/joky interactions with people comes off as genuine and unforced. Mix that with their solving, and they're probably a vilager.


Timsup2nothin
This guy feels like Phighter lol Abbrasive in unnecessary ways, and super tunneled on things that are pretty anti-town. But it isn't wolfy.


xalt
Guy has a pretty bad ISO. It's awkward, the jokes don't land, his posts are pretty bad. He isn't really all that pro-town, he doesn't really have a whole lot of good solving, and his reads are basic without much shown depth. This guy might as well be a wolf. However, deep in his heart, I see something. A kernal of villageriness. Something unshackably green at his core. Despite everything, he is a villager.


WerewolfHunter
Fix the broken OP lol anyway I didn't really like them when I was reading them live, but actually going through their posts independently they seems legit. Don't have a very detailed read idk lol


Jumpluff
I shouldn't have to explain this one my guys. I don't think anyone wants to kill them, so I'm not going to :hattip:



THESE READS ARE IN A RANDOM ORDER PLS SHEEP TY

[Hyena]

I commend whoever removed the “trustworthy” liberal from our ranks. Neutrality like that is best dealt with separately, and not with the power of the vote.

It is rather interesting that you posted this literally after fox talked me off for doing so
I don't think there is any pattern but it could actually be a way to people feign contribution (yeah I'm not one to talk but still)

Fox.

[sheepsaysmeep]

manti whom am i peeking

[Hyena]

Hyena
Villagery ass MFer. After ISOing the guy, he's pure. I'd put this read on the same teir as Marcher. Towncore, listen to what he says, and if he has ultra strong feelings at ITAs consider what he's saying. I know sometimes hyena's good thoughts get ignored, and I don't want that happening here.

I commend whoever removed the “trustworthy” liberal from our ranks. Neutrality like that is best dealt with separately, and not with the power of the vote.

It is rather interesting that you posted this literally after fox talked me off for doing so
I don't think there is any pattern but it could actually be a way to people feign contribution (yeah I'm not one to talk but still)

Fox.

Sorry, I had to, Manti, lol. Though really guys, I really do not shitpost all the time. I'll let you guys know when I actually have something that you really should consider. I haven't got there just yet, but I think I'm getting close.

[Maple]

[mention]WerewolfHunter[/mention] [mention]Long Con[/mention], [mention]iaafr[/mention], [mention]Urist[/mention], [mention]AWESOM-O[/mention]
[mention]DaisyCloud[/mention], [mention]Dragon D. Luffy[/mention], [mention]Logic[/mention], [mention]colonialbob[/mention]
[mention]nutella[/mention], [mention]Urist[/mention], [mention]Timsup2nothin[/mention], [mention]Adam_[/mention], [mention]SilverKeith[/mention], [mention]cayvie[/mention], [mention]112[/mention]
[mention]sprityo[/mention]

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

[PunchyTheCat]

i 110% agree with the WWH read

idkdc about eph he's a dickhead anyway wouldn't be too sad if he died

[Maple]

manti whom am i peeking

Someone who 1) isn't getting shot 2) isn't an ez clear for someone 3) is actually gonna be useful if they're green checked (not a complete potato)

Telling you to target a specific person is bad mechanically in case there's anti-check measures (which there probably are, given that we have a Strongman Cop)

[Hyena]

Has my shot been processed?

You missed

should i try for sloonei too

I don't like the Ace vote, and I'm not as sure about wanting to call Exalt scum anymore right now until he posts more. So yeah, I wouldn't be against it.

@Hyena why was the player called Sloonei worth shooting based on these votes?

Because the only other time you low-efforted, you were scum. Plus, nobody seemed to be talking about you, which in my eyes, meant that people didn't wanna draw attention to you? If that makes sense? I actually felt pretty good about the shot, to be honest. It wasn't one of those, "hmm, this could flip either way, but I'm still curious" kind of shots. It was one of those "yo, this could actually be mafia here" kind of shots.

[sheepsaysmeep]

i, too, am a strongman cop

[SilverKeith]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

[sheepsaysmeep]

jk i rescind

[sheepsaysmeep]

for legal purposes

[ThisIsNotAceMarvel]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

No is the same in Spanish

[Hyena]

unvote sprit
vote hyena

because we eliminated tony on his birthday last game and it was a bad idea.

You didn't even do it right.

[Maple]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

[Marcher Jovian]

jk i rescind

ftr are you rescinding cop or just the strongman bit?

[tedxtr]

i'm macho cop

maybe

[PunchyTheCat]

cop bullshit is bullshit

[PunchyTheCat]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

silverkeith is in his own tier below null

spirit may be joining him

[Maple]

[VOTE: 112] aubergine
[VOTE: sloonie] aubergine

This is the way.

[Sloonei]

Has my shot been processed?

You missed

should i try for sloonei too

I don't like the Ace vote, and I'm not as sure about wanting to call Exalt scum anymore right now until he posts more. So yeah, I wouldn't be against it.

@Hyena why was the player called Sloonei worth shooting based on these votes?

Because the only other time you low-efforted, you were scum.

im gonna stop you right there because this just isn’t even true.

[PunchyTheCat]

should i read my role pm

[Hyena]

I commend whoever removed the “trustworthy” liberal from our ranks. Neutrality like that is best dealt with separately, and not with the power of the vote.

It is rather interesting that you posted this literally after fox talked me off for doing so
I don't think there is any pattern but it could actually be a way to people feign contribution (yeah I'm not one to talk but still)

[VOTE: iwan] aubergine

lol, this is a bad vote. I'm the one that initially suggested what he was saying. Do you think he's just easier to push than me?

[Maple]

If the three kills were 112, Sloonie, Hank I would be a happy boi

[Hyena]

Has my shot been processed?

You missed

should i try for sloonei too

I don't like the Ace vote, and I'm not as sure about wanting to call Exalt scum anymore right now until he posts more. So yeah, I wouldn't be against it.

@Hyena why was the player called Sloonei worth shooting based on these votes?

Because the only other time you low-efforted, you were scum.

im gonna stop you right there because this just isn’t even true.

Coronavirus mafia.

[SilverKeith]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

No.

No creo que creas que tu lista está 100% correcta.

Entiendo que creas que tu lista mayormente sea correcta (a pesar de que incluyas a alguien como a Tim), cosa que respeto, y que quieras resolver el juego en base a la misma.

Pero me da por las bolas que gente defienda a otras personas que yo legítimamente crea que son mafiosos y tengan razones de segunda para hacerlo. Así es como perdimos ani, porque cada vez que alguien quería poner a un mafioso en la mesa, siempre había otra persona (sea pueblerino o mafioso) que lo sacaba.

Entonces no, si me vas a venir con un post donde sacas a 10 personas de la mesa, discrepo.

Cómo alternativa, siempre me podrías vender uno de tus reads mafiosos. Lo que quizá estaría dispuesto a escuchar de no ser porque le disparaste a Daisy, quién muy probablemente sea pueblo. Ya tuviste tu chance de equivocarte, dejame la mía ahora, gracias.

[PunchyTheCat]

[VOTE: 112] aubergine
[VOTE: sloonie] aubergine

This is the way.

That is the way. Exept Sheep>Sloonei.

[Sloonei]

I commend whoever removed the “trustworthy” liberal from our ranks. Neutrality like that is best dealt with separately, and not with the power of the vote.

It is rather interesting that you posted this literally after fox talked me off for doing so
I don't think there is any pattern but it could actually be a way to people feign contribution (yeah I'm not one to talk but still)

[VOTE: iwan] aubergine

lol, this is a bad vote. I'm the one that initially suggested what he was saying. Do you think he's just easier to push than me?

[Maple]

should i read my role pm

That would be wise

[sheepsaysmeep]

jk i rescind

ftr are you rescinding cop or just the strongman bit?

yes.

[PunchyTheCat]

Has my shot been processed?

You missed

should i try for sloonei too

I don't like the Ace vote, and I'm not as sure about wanting to call Exalt scum anymore right now until he posts more. So yeah, I wouldn't be against it.

@Hyena why was the player called Sloonei worth shooting based on these votes?

Because the only other time you low-efforted, you were scum.

im gonna stop you right there because this just isn’t even true.

Coronavirus mafia.

6 posts apart

[AWESOM-O]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

I don't even know what I'm doing

[Maple]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

No.

No creo que creas que tu lista está 100% correcta.

Entiendo que creas que tu lista mayormente sea correcta (a pesar de que incluyas a alguien como a Tim), cosa que respeto, y que quieras resolver el juego en base a la misma.

Pero me da por las bolas que gente defienda a otras personas que yo legítimamente crea que son mafiosos y tengan razones de segunda para hacerlo. Así es como perdimos ani, porque cada vez que alguien quería poner a un mafioso en la mesa, siempre había otra persona (sea pueblerino o mafioso) que lo sacaba.

Entonces no, si me vas a venir con un post donde sacas a 10 personas de la mesa, discrepo.

Cómo alternativa, siempre me podrías vender uno de tus reads mafiosos. Lo que quizá estaría dispuesto a escuchar de no ser porque le disparaste a Daisy, quién muy probablemente sea pueblo. Ya tuviste tu chance de equivocarte, dejame la mía ahora, gracias.

The translator isn't doing very good work. Are you asking me to elaborate on specific reads? And you're saying that town-shielding is inherently anti-town citing anni?

[AWESOM-O]

guess i'll just sheep manti (i think that's him)? on sloonei or something

[PunchyTheCat]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

I don't even know what I'm doing

just don't vote in his towncore except for eph tim and someone else i'm forgetting

[Maple]

Someone who speaks spanish please explain

[Adam_]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

i'm not even in your v list. i'm not going to captain cause i really want another game day with jumpluff and i'm begging wolves not to kill jumpluff, but i'm not exactly acknowledging your sovereignty. you didn't take a stance on the glad arena in your list either. i will be here at some point, something else big going on today and i'm trying to play when jumpluff is awake

[SilverKeith]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

No.

No creo que creas que tu lista está 100% correcta.

Entiendo que creas que tu lista mayormente sea correcta (a pesar de que incluyas a alguien como a Tim), cosa que respeto, y que quieras resolver el juego en base a la misma.

Pero me da por las bolas que gente defienda a otras personas que yo legítimamente crea que son mafiosos y tengan razones de segunda para hacerlo. Así es como perdimos ani, porque cada vez que alguien quería poner a un mafioso en la mesa, siempre había otra persona (sea pueblerino o mafioso) que lo sacaba.

Entonces no, si me vas a venir con un post donde sacas a 10 personas de la mesa, discrepo.

Cómo alternativa, siempre me podrías vender uno de tus reads mafiosos. Lo que quizá estaría dispuesto a escuchar de no ser porque le disparaste a Daisy, quién muy probablemente sea pueblo. Ya tuviste tu chance de equivocarte, dejame la mía ahora, gracias.

The translator isn't doing very good work. Are you asking me to elaborate on specific reads? And you're saying that town-shielding is inherently anti-town citing anni?

Estás sacando a muchas personas de la mesa en una etapa de juego muy temprano. No me gusta. Difiero.

Puedo escucharte en tus reads de mafiosos si quieres.

[AWESOM-O]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

I don't even know what I'm doing

just don't vote in his towncore except for eph tim and someone else i'm forgetting

i still want to vote xalt for voting me before i even posted and still voting me right now lmao

[PunchyTheCat]

Not.

I don't think you think your list is 100% correct.

I understand that you think your list is mostly correct (even though you include someone like Tim), which I respect, and that you want to solve the game based on it.

But I give it a ball that people defend other people that I legitimately believe are gangsters and have second-rate reasons to do so. This is how we lost ani, because every time someone wanted to put a mobster on the table, there was always another person (be it a small town or a mobster) who took him out.

So no, if you are going to come to me with a post where you take 10 people off the table, I disagree.

As an alternative, you could always sell me one of your gangster reads. Which maybe he would be willing to hear if it wasn't because you shot Daisy, who is most likely a town. You already had your chance to be wrong, leave me mine now, thanks.

[Maple]

i'm not even in your v list. i'm not going to captain cause i really want another game day with jumpluff and i'm begging wolves not to kill jumpluff, but i'm not exactly acknowledging your sovereignty. you didn't take a stance on the glad arena in your list either. i will be here at some point, something else big going on today and i'm trying to play when jumpluff is awake

I think that Hank has higher wolf equity than Poison, and I would also expect Dougall to put a wolf gladiator into this game after anni, especially after the strongman cop and what it implies.