U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[iaafr]

Spoiler: show

NANOOK claimed immortal/unkillable.
Macdougall randed a D0 neighbourhood that lasts until EoD1 with PunchyTheCat, Apogee, Dragon D. Luffy, 112, Trustworthy Liberal post

ITA1 SHOTS LIST

Spoiler: show

Dragon D. Luffy - Jackofhearts2005 - MISS
motel room - Justplayingitcool - MISS
TonyStarkPrime - Hyena - MISS
tedxtr - Justplayingitcool - MISS
NANOOK - Ephemeral - MISS
Justplayingitcool - TonyStarkPrime - HIT, Town

Justplayingitcool claimed Jailkeeper. post

Dragon D. Luffy claimed to be able to talk to spec chat through a randomised spec chatter daily Amy 1 Amy 2 post Ranmilia's thoughts carotte's thoughts
112 claimed a persuader (targets a person at night and forces them to vote for another target) here
hollowkatt claims a piercing cop check on Maple, villager post
(at some point before here Trustworthy Liberal claimed survivor)

Trustworthy Liberal dies, Pacifist/Endgame Arsonist 3p thing
Relm dies, Town Fruit Vendor
hollowkatt dies, flip redacted

Maple claims to have received a banana post. Maple claims to be a miller (before HK's cop) post and says NOT TO USE PROTECTIVES ON THEM. There are more complexities, but probably don't use pro-villa stuff on them. (ISO them for more I guess)
Adam claimed to be a strongwiller (makes a night action unroleblockable). post (post)

ITA2 SHOTS LIST

Spoiler: show

Timsup2nothin - Poison - MISS
Urist - Rej - [/color]HIT, Town Doctor/Vig thing (cool role)
Hyena - Sloonei - MISS
Poison - Timsup2nothin - MISS
iaafr - motel room - HIT, Town Odd Night Somewhat Guilty Vigilante
Maple - DaisyCloud - MISS
Ephemeral - DaisyCloud - MISS
WerewolfHunter - Xalt - MISS
PunchyTheCat - DaisyCloud - MISS
sheepsaysmeep - cayvie - MISS
xalt - DaisyCloud - MISS
MartinGG99 - Exalt - HIT, Town Role Cop?
polypies73 - cayvie - MISS
DaisyCloud - funnygirl55 - HIT, Mafia Mikey Sub Out Traveller Thing
ThisIsNotAceMarvel - DaisyCloud - MISS
112 - Sloonei - MISS
Marcher Jovian - sprityo - MISS
Long Con - NANOOK - Refunded/failed
jumpluff - Long Con - MISS
SilverKeith - Ephemeral - MISS
nutella - Sloonei - MISS
Adam - AWESOME-O - MISS

SPRITYO has received +5 additional votes today - Was a joke by Mac
A fight has broken out between Hank and Poison chan! TL;DR On top of the normal 2 elims, whichever has the most votes gets eliminated. Hank initiated it as the gladiator.

PunchyTheCat claimed D3 Innocent Child. post (UPDATE: As usual, Punchy has claimed a bunch of roles and I refuse to put them on here unless multiple people tell me it's seriously worthwhile and tell me what to search.)
cavyie claimed to receive a box and a warning not to open it. post and gave it to Nanook here, I am sceptical this worked but including it anyways.
Hank claimed Lorde, reusable(?) gladiator. post
[NOT UP TO DATE FROM ABOUT 7 PM - 11 AM AUSTRALIAN TIME]

ITAs have been announced for 6 PM Pacific Time in the first 24 hours of day 2!!!! (Same time as D1 ITA2 - awesome claiming responsibility in some way

polypies73 dies, Town Popcorn Event Host
112 dies, Town Force Voter/Persuader

Popcorn (polypies's event)
cayvie, 112, polypies, martingg, silverkeith, awesom-o, speedchuck, and xalt are playing a game of popcorn for their lives + presumably-related mod post + tedxtr + tonystarkprime arrived
(If you don't know what popcorn mafia is, read this https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?ti ... corn_Mafia except it can be different #s and stuff)
cayvie's popcorn summary of shots
cayvie says she claimed her role and awesome shot tedxtr to preserve her role

MartinGG has claimed a death-related role, per cayvie here in the popcorn event

D1 Unvotables with ISO links:

Spoiler: show

SilverKeith
Jackofhearts2005
Timsup2nothin
DrWilgy
shizune
Apogee
polypies73
Justplayingitcool
sabie12
Adam_
Epignosis and NANOOK were also not included in the poll, but were not posted in this list by Mac.

Host Posts including lists of people we can't vote
search #chartz

corrections solicited as always, ping me with stuff you want included so i see it as overnight catchup may be ruff
i am not gonna spoiler this btw, use your scroll wheel
remember to go look at the shots in context rather than just looking at the shots and saying people who shoot villagers are wolves

this was jumpluffs last chartzpost which has a lot of info, sheep

[ThisIsNotAceMarvel]

sheepsaysmeep idk Scumish

wait this is illegal i disallow it

This lumps are not yours to control!

[PunchyTheCat]

Apogee idk
AWESOM-O town
beeboy scum lean
cayvie idk
ColinIsCool idk
colonialbob town
DaisyCloud Town supreme
DDL idk
DrWilgy idk but gut feeling Scumish
Ephemeral needs to be solved
Epignosis idk
Hyena town and super nice player
iaafr town
iwan town
Jackofhearts2005
Justplayingitcool
Logic can go either way but townish
Long Con idk
Maple need to be resolve, Maple's read took the game
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME The mighty stump
Poison Chan town?
PunchyTheCat YOU ARE TOWN STOP YOUR NON SENSE
sabie12 no opinion
sheepsaysmeep idk Scumish
Shizune idk who this person is
speedchuck town
Sprityo idk but I'm scared of this pr
tedxtr town
TenThousandCalories gut feeling scum
ThisIsNotAceMarvel LSP
Timsup2nothin YOU ARE TOWN STOP YOUR NON SENSE
Urist idk
WerewolfHunter idk

Making one of this list, is super lame, but not as lame as yours.

wwh is v

why is spirit scary and why beeboy

[Maple]

Tim wolf. Maple wolf.
JPIC wolfy.

Liberal / Hyena 3P/scum/lover role.

Sheep is weird and it's a non AI weird.

Ted is Null. He can be like this as either alignment.

You know there are more things that could go here

Spoiler: show

I know it's rather a broad spectrum but the thing is I trust the fact you two are from the same alignment and connected. But hinting lovers would not be a bad move for scum or third party either you know.

Hmm. Do you think we were connect from the start? Or, do you think we somehow "connected" at some point after the game officially started?

What's the point of this continued softing?

I'm not softing anything! We're not lovers, neighbors, masons, etc. at all. I just wanna know how Poison arrived at this conclusion and where it's coming from since it's pretty interesting!

Ah. Interesting

ISOing apogee, saw this chain. Anyone know what this is all about?


Lots of ingsoc RP.

I'm not reading back more than a few pages

But I kinda liked sheep, tl, urist

We will band together and remove the thoughtcriminals with the principles of INGSOC

Spoiler: show

First batch of reads, wondering how he got to them. 3p!TL wolf!pov is the same as village; Urist appears to most likely be a correct read, not exactly noteworthy but wondering how they got there.

I'm mixed on the whole Insomnia(ted)/Tim situation.

Cause I felt like I saw Ted do something I'd seem him do as a wolf
But Tim is kinda mixed vibes right now too
We will see

Put a pin in this, see if it goes anywhere. Pretty waffly for what is ultimately likely v/v conflict, sussed both. Don't like that.

oh no Tim's wolfing

He's doing the "hey fellow town, pls give me a reason to shoot/vote town and turn y'all against one another" thing

Yeah. Tim can join the list of potential thoughtcriminals

Of course, everyone is a thoughtcriminal even if you haven't crimethinked yet

Kind of an ironic read to wolf read someone given the context lol

Lots of Tim focus, not a whole lot of anything else.

Someone shoot jpic plz

Tony was obvious town

At this point the ONLY thing he had said about TSP was "bad Tony."

TSP had taken his shot at Hyena, who Nanook had stated was town.

The read on TSP as "obv town" is made up, whole cloth, on the spot, to convince people to shoot JPIC.

Why? I mean, I might have been inclined to shoot JPIC. I don't have a clear read on JPIC but he did shoot a townie so maybe? But this kind of blatant false push is a wolf all day long where I come from.

So like even though I don't really know what to feel on tim. I generally? like this post/line of reasoning/the whole think Ephemeral and Tim have worked on re:Nanook

But I can't really get out of my head it's like the level 2 easy push to make. Where pushing against JPIC is like the simple wolfy push. But pushing against those pushing JPIC is almost as simple.
So I don't disagree Nanook looks bad. But I'm worried about the push kinda

I guess the takeaway is Tim is still a bundle of null send help

Not sure I quite understand this line here. "Fakable but a good push"? Do they villa read JPIC or is it sort of a holistic read? Would want more details here.

@Apogee, are you going to push me? I'm getting the vibe that you seem to want to? Based on that previous 'wat' and on you suggesting I was softing a role with TL earlier. D:

No

That wat was more of I can't really believe that someone would suggest Punchy didn't want to take ITA shots. Don't know how much you know punchy though.
And generally the wolf-indicative movement around ITAs is popping in

I didn't really? suggest you were softing a role with TL but um that whole conversation was just like ?!?

And I wouldn't have pushed you if you were softing for the soft

Weird walkback-and-forth-and-back-again on Hyena here

The Party's report on suspected malfeasance:

Good standing among the party and strong supporters of Big Brother:
Hollowkatt

Thoughtcriminals:
Daisycloud
Ephemeral
Maple
Speedchuck

This does not reflect the chance these people have to be mafia in the slightest

their RP and non-reads are getting a lot of focus here.

Wait sheep I still need to know

Sheep says meep

Or

Sheep say smeep

When you at a party and tell a joke, but no one reacts to it

so you tell it again and someone says "we heard you the first time"

rest in peace my man

is juliets immune to tk today? why isn't she in the poll

:fry:

Is host assistant

Honestly, frying Urist here shows some inconsistency. Apogee's memes have entered wolfy territory for sure. 1) telling the same bad joke twice is awkward. Not wolfy, but its still something that sticks out. This post here, towards a supposed v read, frying them as either a meme is just whatever or it shows that they aren't really making reads.

Overall, there's been extremely little actual content from apogee. Keep in mind, I've skipped about 50 random ass posts and grabbed the most relevant ones so far.

Not liking him so far.

[VOTE: thisisnotacemarvel] aubergine! They will soon feel the wrath of Dr Sloonman’s full power.

I think this is going to be another game where a lot of people tunnel Ace

Maybe correctly
But not for the reasons shared so far

What is this post actually?

Doing it anyways for shits and giggles
Nanook 3p
Hyena lost wolf
Maple thought criminal
Apogee v
Punchy v
Tim v
Marcher 3p
Slooni w
112 v
nutella v
Daisy v
WWH w

Reads (mixed with a lil RP). Why do they have me specifically as a thought criminal lol

I know for a fact that there were other "thought criminals", such as like Eph who did the same exact thought crimes as me. Idk if this is selfish, but that feels weird.

Why slooni w? Why wwh w? Both these guys ended up seeming like villagers, and I don't really see anything in his ISO saying he thinks they're wolfy.

Why Hyena lost wolf read at all? Not consistent with their prior Hyena reads posts. Why Marcher 3p in general? Genuine question.

[VOTE: exalt] aubergine

For the next phase of my plan!

Sloonei rping an evil mastermind seems appropriate

Evil? Do... do my henchman think I’m evil?

Apologies master sloonei we will refer to you as brillant and controversial from here on out

99ppp this is their only interaction with slooni on the first page, their supposed wolf read.

ALRIGHT LISTEN UP HERE


I am right here right now hard claiming the following: Strongman Alignment Day Cop. I have blown my load on Maple. They are town. I pierce misdirection.

Truly Hollowkatt is a worthy member of the Inner Party.

He will recieve Big Brother's Order of the Day and his name memorialized in the Ministry of Truth's records

Why are my scum reads like this?

Okay so if redacted then it's janitor? Or something else?
Does that even clear maple?

It very very likely clears maple

For someone who says they aren't paying much attention to the game, it feels somewhat odd that they picked up on this and immediately thought it was true. There was other mechanical bullshit yesterday that they had doubts for, too.

For example, Nanook claim. That claim is like never not villager, so idk why they call that 3p and a reasonable push (despite being unyeetable and unkillable mechanically)

town reads
Apogee
Adam
Jumblepuff (prob messed up name lol)

Neutral
Silver Keith (a little annoyed I can't read any of their posts lol)

Lean evil
Xalt

i hate this i hate this i hate this

apogee is too high

i haven't seen a single thought on any of these reads

Making a read on me this early in a large game is >rand wolf it's true

Source: Anni and Bastard Fiesta

is this the basis of the wwh w read? lol

vetoing any shots on

Punchy
Dragon D. Luffy (claimed medium)
Marcher Jovian
Ace Marvel
Maple
jumpluff (making lists)
Hyena
iaafr

encouraging shots on

DaisyCloud
cayvie
sheepsaysmeep

any thoughts?

Cayvie probablemente sea pueblo o por lo menos creo que voy a poder determinar mejor su alineación en el futuro.

Cayvie is a problem to be determined in the future?

Is there mech with cayvie

I could shoot there I think. Felt somewhat bad vibes at some point

I never actually saw this post before. This is massive. This is the dude who got people to start shooting at cayvie? And getting shots on there instead of like JPIC and shit, this dude's a wolf.

motel room
awesom-o
polypies
sprityo
Rej (claimed a force voting role)
DaisyCloud (I think she is a villager fwiw but I think it would be good to have Daisy opinions)
Xalt

for those looking for people to investigate and maybe shoot at

I'll look into a few of these later

Awesom-o can be scum though

Ah yes, Awesome the guy who later killed xalt. A bunch of villagers in here too: motel, Rej, Daisy. Spyro who's prob v. Only flipped wolf is Xalt at the bottom, and a rando Poly.

This is not a good shooting list

ITA = motel room

lowaccountability "why are you voting me omgus" shot lets gooooo

:fry:

Rabbit watcha doing

Frying a shot on someone on a shots list you signed off on lol

ITA = cayvie

kind of an oof here lol

completely ignoring the potential wolves who were in the cards, too

I like my Cayvie shot

I don't like quite as much the other people shooting cayvie
*shrug*

I like my Cayvie shot

I don't like quite as much the other people shooting cayvie
*shrug*

I'm like the only other shooter what

Sheep too

Is there a reason I should particularly like you?

Daisy is hard village

That's not a role that gets bussed

Why not

Like I don't think it's a bus

But why is the role the determining factor

shading daisy after the hit lol

Maple is like incredibly likely peeked.

Tbh though if anyone in this game was going to do some go deep mechanical weirdness it might be manti as I understand it

But yeah treat as peek yada yada

like call me comf town but push on peeps like Daisy

TMI bro

has awesome done anything

He did his lmao tell

And not much else no

Kinda vacuous ISO

his what now

Besides Maple who gets implicated

I'll look for that tomorrow

the ez turn around on me after I'm not worth anything anymore. This guy is def wolfing.

In summation: put him on your shots lists boyos

[Maple]

is there anything to the jpic sus that isnt "omg why would you shoot tsp" though

Shoot TSP
Get pushed
Claim joat
Peace out

[PunchyTheCat]

i'm ignoring maple and IF they flip v i will come back to that

[Maple]

why do we townread long con

was he on xalt?

He basically told me to fuck off when I told him to move his vote lol

[iaafr]

would be pretty funny if we treated maple as outed wolf and then let maple make the shots list and followed it anyway

[PunchyTheCat]

i honestly seriously can't see v tim in this argument with me

it can't possibly be v/v from my pov

[ThisIsNotAceMarvel]

wwh is v

why is spirit scary and why beeboy

I don't want to deal with the consequences of killing Super High School Level Good Luck

And gut feeling

[Maple]

i'm ignoring maple and IF they flip v i will come back to that

Fair enough

[Maple]

would be pretty funny if we treated maple as outed wolf and then let maple make the shots list and followed it anyway

That would be pretty funny, wouldn't it

[PunchyTheCat]

wwh is v

why is spirit scary and why beeboy

I don't want to deal with the consequences of killing Super High School Level Good Luck

And gut feeling

was there a specific post that made you feel that way about beeboy?

[sheepsaysmeep]

ig jpic freezing himself underwater for 100 years post-claim is a bad look yeah

[Maple]

Apogee's ISO is super wolfy regardless of my alignment. Give it a looksie, he should be on shats lists tomorrow.

[Timsup2nothin]

So this is just a general narrative thing.

I got here around three in the morning running on four hours sleep. Maple had five votes, which seemed catastrophically weird. All on my own with my head full of fuzz I found the kill flips and pieced together that HK was a wolf, meaning Maple's green check was bad, and got my vote onto Maple before EoD.

I think the people who were active in the thread after the popcorn madness and somehow failed to make that connection are going to include at least some wolves.

[Maple]

ig jpic freezing himself underwater for 100 years post-claim is a bad look yeah

[iaafr]

Apogee's ISO is super wolfy regardless of my alignment. Give it a looksie, he should be on shats lists tomorrow.

just like martin was, eh?

though i dont get credit because i didnt have the balls to stick to the townread

[DaisyCloud]

ita's are immensely protown if town is organized and efficient with them

set up some sort of a consensus group of 3-4 good shots

even if its constituents are villagers, it's poe and protown for them to die

someone shooting directly against consensus and hitting villa in a way that ends up benefiting scum should in most cases eat death

nah i stan hero shooters

anni needed hero shooters and we mightve won if insomnia's on ara or xander's on amrock hit


though im not sure this is a gamestate that needs hero shooters


just as a generality; sticking to lists isnt necessarily the best and im not gonna be part of the chorus of "omg why would you hero shoot" kneejerkers ever

I like both sides if this argument. you need a bit of both. and it depends on who exactly is making these lists and who listens or not listens.

also depends on flips too . do say player a follow the list made by player b and shoots player C. player c flips town? what does this mean? you got to now figure out is player a yown and was wrong? what about player b? are they both mafia? both town? 1 of them is town and the other mafia? because player b could be mafia and knows player A was town but wrong and took advantage. or plsyer A can be mafia and player be a misguided town.

also looking at yolo shots. that depends too. on flips and what have yous.

if player D been all afk then shoots in ita and gets a town well 99.99% that is mafia taking opportunities. but it could be a scumbly yown that doesn't really care about following the game or dcum hunting. they could have been looking at the lists too or just yolo.

it all depends because what if player e just shoots and kills scum? they can be wolf looking for cred. or town and they went with their guts and own reads and beliefs of the game.

nothing wrong with going away from lists. if you think ones making them are scummy. but lists are good too if you are unsure. and being wrong as town stinks but it can happen.

[ThisIsNotAceMarvel]

wwh is v

why is spirit scary and why beeboy

I don't want to deal with the consequences of killing Super High School Level Good Luck

And gut feeling

was there a specific post that made you feel that way about beeboy?

You know how I feel my slots, if just feel it, and I'm 63.78% right most of the time.

[Maple]

FAQ

Are you open wolfing?

Spoiler: show

Is that alignment indicative?

Spoiler: show

[Maple]

Apogee's ISO is super wolfy regardless of my alignment. Give it a looksie, he should be on shats lists tomorrow.

just like martin was, eh?

though i dont get credit because i didnt have the balls to stick to the townread

[PunchyTheCat]

urist's iso was absurdly villagery idk what i was thinking

[iaafr]

reading maple town now lmao

[Maple]

reading maple town now lmao

[PunchyTheCat]

i also lied iaafr has felt villagery as of late

[iaafr]

i also lied iaafr has felt villagery as of late

just lock me in you wont regret it

[Jackofhearts2005]

like i'd think that maple was more of a long term plan than call all wolves villagers until flips out him in a few days

I mean, specifically keeping Xalt and Nutella (and Maple)’s roles alive long enough to do what they do is enough reason to make that play.

well yeah but the context of that post was responding tim's "punchy is likely scum due to maplespew" take

I know.

I’m just saying like I wouldn’t be surprised at 0-2 wolves in that list of 3 players. Cause 0 is still worth defending just the three wolves we know were being defended (assuming a Maple red flip).

[Timsup2nothin]

reading maple town now lmao

This is your "yeah let's chop Apoc" moment right here.

[PunchyTheCat]

JPIC's post where he quoted people saying stuff about TSP before and after the shot was villagery but i'll keep him in null for now

iaafr if itas were in 10 minutes who would you shoot

[iaafr]

reading maple town now lmao

This is your "yeah let's chop Apoc" moment right here.

doesnt count if i dont hardpush it

thats my secret

[iaafr]

JPIC's post where he quoted people saying stuff about TSP before and after the shot was villagery but i'll keep him in null for now

iaafr if itas were in 10 minutes who would you shoot

apogee, possibly, lmao

[iaafr]

ephe flip would be nice too

idk i dont have hard susses rn

maybe sabie...?

[DaisyCloud]

how come Tim's title keep changing

[PunchyTheCat]

i wanna be a loan shark smh

[Timsup2nothin]

how come Tim's title keep changing

What?

[Long Con]

reading maple town now lmao

Deja vu.

[Maple]

I also have a pro town day action and if I am going to die let me know if I should use it.
It's optimal to use it tomorrow though.

The ITA mechanic is likely being enabled by someones "anything" role.
I don't think it's a mechanic that is a public game feature.

So how it works is likely not known information.

The ITA mechanic is likely being enabled by someones "anything" role.
I don't think it's a mechanic that is a public game feature.

So how it works is likely not known information.

Beeboy ISO is light. 15 posts, low volume. He has some starter fluff d0, nbd. First three game-y posts, all mech related stuff.

Anyone have any sick read cliffs they want to give me.
Talking about ITAs and roles is incredibly lame.

people who have only played with village!me and thus think im a wolf here because im different should noto be citing meta i verifiably try far harder as wolf

plsplspls anyone who can verify this @beeboy @PunchyTheCat @Maple

@Adam_
I find his motivation is a lot more game based then it is alignment-based.
Although an argument can be made he prefers scum which would create a trend that favors scum.

Last of his post. His ISO is basically devoid of anything, which is unusual for bb. Honestly, it's to the point that it's probably NAI. That said, his limited time being focused on only mech crap is NAGL, but not so bad a look that I'd turbo kill him. Again, the activity seems so low that it's prob just NAI.

Overall, peeps should attempt to coax bb into playing more and try to get him to make reads and stuff. IME he's a pretty obv-villager when he gets into the game, and he's actually one of the stronger mash players in this game. If he continues to potato, just put him down.

[DaisyCloud]

how come Tim's title keep changing

What?

below your name. or has my memory been fried and u always had that title

[iaafr]

how come Tim's title keep changing

What?

below your name. or has my memory been fried and u always had that title

hes had that one all game

[Maple]

reading maple town now lmao

Deja vu.

hattips are my staple

[MacDougall]

Night ends in a lil under 5 hrs

[Timsup2nothin]

how come Tim's title keep changing

What?

below your name. or has my memory been fried and u always had that title

It's custom and I don't think it ever changes...

[PunchyTheCat]

Weak Wolves:
Cayvie
Wolves:
Ephemeral, sabie12, Apogee, Long Con
Really Fucking Obvious Wolves:
Maple, Tim, sheep

long con is purely gut idk i just feel like he's going in wolfchat hee hee i'm wrecking the village dumb villies hahahaha

[Maple]

Overall, I don't think beeboy belongs on shots lists tomorrow, though def pressure him into making villagery posts. If he doesn't comply, give him ITA2 pressure

[PunchyTheCat]

i am a consensus village read right

[PunchyTheCat]

Overall, I don't think beeboy belongs on shots lists tomorrow, though def pressure him into making villagery posts. If he doesn't comply, give him ITA2 pressure

there is no ita2

[Maple]

i am a consensus village read right

You're consensus village to me

[Maple]

Overall, I don't think beeboy belongs on shots lists tomorrow, though def pressure him into making villagery posts. If he doesn't comply, give him ITA2 pressure

there is no ita2

There'll only be ITA1 tomorrow?

[Jackofhearts2005]

I’m kinda tilted at Punchy vs Tim.

Like there’s no good reason they should scumread each other that much.

Maybe they’re both scum.