U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[iaafr]

i have a TR on colin

[Maple]

I agree with whoever said that everybody being parked on Maple is bad for thread health but I don’t think we can really move forward until we resolve that slot.

Why can't we move forward until we resolve Maple? I don't understand that.

That's a good question. My answer will be sheeping Poison Chan on someone I have in my scum pool. [VOTE: iaafr] aubergine

Looking at my null and scum list from a different angle, "Do I have a reason to believe this person is not town" as opposed to "not mafia" I could at least remove these 6 from the pool.

Yes:
iwan - Iwan has little content, and has been around. He has more than the null reads but for some reason my gut is telling me there's potential out of him.
Hyena - Maybe. IDK.
WerewolfHunter - Will apparently die on night 3 unless "frozen." Their content is underwhelming and not very much hunting though.
Justplayingitcool - Been absent since daystart. someone mentioned theyre town because of some flip
Maple - Putting in the most work today. I actually don't know how well of a lynch this is today. What are some key interactions Maple has had with everyone still alive?
PunchyTheCat - Punchy is poisoned and will die at the end of the day unless healed. I'll take this with a grain of salt.

No:
TenThousandCalories
beeboy
colonialbob
DrWilgy
Epignosis
Logic
Apogee
ColinIsCool
sabie12
iaafr

Grammar is not my strong-suit.

It appears you missed Sheep here

[iaafr]

sorry you happened to try to use a jumpy PR to evaluate other ppl but ya im a jumpy PR i dont wanna be pressured

[Hyena]

i have a TR on colin

Okay, but I'm still going to pressure him anyway. Just chill for a bit.

[VOTE: unvote] aubergine

[sprityo]

I agree with whoever said that everybody being parked on Maple is bad for thread health but I don’t think we can really move forward until we resolve that slot.

Why can't we move forward until we resolve Maple? I don't understand that.

That's a good question. My answer will be sheeping Poison Chan on someone I have in my scum pool. [VOTE: iaafr] aubergine

Looking at my null and scum list from a different angle, "Do I have a reason to believe this person is not town" as opposed to "not mafia" I could at least remove these 6 from the pool.

Yes:
iwan - Iwan has little content, and has been around. He has more than the null reads but for some reason my gut is telling me there's potential out of him.
Hyena - Maybe. IDK.
WerewolfHunter - Will apparently die on night 3 unless "frozen." Their content is underwhelming and not very much hunting though.
Justplayingitcool - Been absent since daystart. someone mentioned theyre town because of some flip
Maple - Putting in the most work today. I actually don't know how well of a lynch this is today. What are some key interactions Maple has had with everyone still alive?
PunchyTheCat - Punchy is poisoned and will die at the end of the day unless healed. I'll take this with a grain of salt.

No:
TenThousandCalories
beeboy
colonialbob
DrWilgy
Epignosis
Logic
Apogee
ColinIsCool
sabie12
iaafr

Grammar is not my strong-suit.

It appears you missed Sheep here

No, sheep is in my town list, so they were never an option to be added.

[iaafr]

[mention]Poison Chan[/mention] [mention]WerewolfHunter[/mention] [mention]sprityo[/mention]

find other things to do im claiming self resolving pr

i will fullclaim d3 if i live to d3

[Maple]

It'd be ill advised to kill a high poster like iaafr here because most of the big boys are dead already and we need to weed out some fish. Otherwise, after me and a few of us are all dead, this game is gonna be like 100 posts each phase.

[Maple]

Noted, spyro.

[sheepsaysmeep]

how do i sort by postcount

anyone

[iaafr]

how do i sort by postcount

anyone

go to the subforum this game is in and click the postcount of the game itself

[sheepsaysmeep]

how do i sort by postcount

anyone

go to the subforum this game is in and click the postcount of the game itself

o7

you did a protown thing today

[sprityo]

Spoiler: show

Cause all the reasons to suspect Maple and that stuff with the people who claimed to have checked them is just ... there. Until it’s not. Like a cloud hanging over us

Okay, do you have a read on me then? I don't even recall interacting with you so far this game. D:

Not really! Most of the game is slanky and/or blendy to me and tbh I’m kind of waiting past the gun shooty thing if I survive to even try differentiating those people

But this is what I mean. You said you can't move forward in the game until Maple is dead, but you haven't evaluated me yet. The way you phrased your post made it seem like there was nothing else you could do right now until Maple was dead, which, as I just showed you, is completely false. :P

tl;dr -- Stop being lazy. :P

No, I said I don’t think we can move forward until Maple is resolved. The lack of activity and large number of votes is evidence enough of that. Otherwise we just have this same conversation at the next yeet and that’s no good.

The wagon on iaafr is growing. If we both voted there right now, it would be two votes away from tying with Maple. Would you like to vote there with me?

[VOTE: iaafr] aubergine

have you read my iso?

A quick read will show your first 5 pages offer nothing. The other 3 give about as much content as what i've given. Any alignment reads/guess you've put out are unsupported by anything other than "I think." There might be a few exceptions but you are 90% fluff and 10% rabbit.

[iaafr]

cant see the 15 lowest posters on this interface tho lol

[Maple]

it refuses to show me more names than this

[sprityo]

how do i sort by postcount

anyone

go to the subforum this game is in and click the postcount of the game itself

I'm sure we can all agree post count does not equal productivity or value. It doesn't indicate alignment either.

[sheepsaysmeep]

we are in the 6900s of post numbers nice

[Hyena]

omg, I'm not trying to yeet iaafr. Colin has been saying that we can't make progress until Maple has died, and when I've given him opportunities to do things that would help him progress the game (e.g. making a read on me, iaafr, and people on the iaafr wagon), he hasn't done so. He's been focused entirely on Maple. I just want Colin to talk about other things so that I can actually evaluate him.

[iaafr]

ya i dont think this gamestate is particularly sbpcable

[Justplayingitcool]

we are in the 6900s of post numbers nice

nice

[ColinIsCool]

I’m not sure if I can just abandon the giant blinking billboard light that says “what the gosh darn heck is Maple up to and what was all that about” for my gut whispering “hey iaafr looks kinda weird here”.

Can some of you explain that position a wee bit more

So, you agree with people that iaafr looks weird?

Big chungus has looked very different here than in other games I’ve played with big chungus, imo. Less active and less of an outward desire to do townsolvey things. Big chungus did explain that big chungus feels burn-out but

Okay, what do you think about the people that are voting for him right now?

Sprit town, I liked Poison over Hank but haven’t re-evaled and I forgot who the other person is, one sec.

[Maple]

anyone recieve a banana yet

[iaafr]

I’m not sure if I can just abandon the giant blinking billboard light that says “what the gosh darn heck is Maple up to and what was all that about” for my gut whispering “hey iaafr looks kinda weird here”.

Can some of you explain that position a wee bit more

So, you agree with people that iaafr looks weird?

Big chungus has looked very different here than in other games I’ve played with big chungus, imo. Less active and less of an outward desire to do townsolvey things. Big chungus did explain that big chungus feels burn-out but

Okay, what do you think about the people that are voting for him right now?

Sprit town, I liked Poison over Hank but haven’t re-evaled and I forgot who the other person is, one sec.

could you explain why sprit town?

i have no idea how to read him or players of that type in general

[Hyena]

sbpcable

what? o.O

[Hyena]

anyone recieve a banana yet

No.

[ColinIsCool]

Oh, WerewolfHunter, they seem kinda too earnest to me tbh and the whole thing about the being frozen or whatever is rankling me because like, why wouldn’t that be resolved by now if there was a role to help them. Assuming we will know sooner rather than later because either they die or are lying I guess

[WerewolfHunter]

@Poison Chan @WerewolfHunter @sprityo

find other things to do im claiming self resolving pr

i will fullclaim d3 if i live to d3

I have claimed and I am doing other things at the moment so not sure what you mean

[sprityo]

anyone recieve a banana yet

Oh. Banana, Huh?

[Justplayingitcool]

Beeboy, DrWilgy, Colonialbob, Epignosis, iwan, Justplayingitcool, spirityo, TenThousandCalories

still think jpic is town but yeah the rest of this list all has potential equity

though i am offhandedly entertaining the possibility that hyenas snowing me and townepignosis is seeing something im not, i... still think hyenas town...

why is jpic town?

I don’t know who that is.

justplayingitcool

he hasnt shown up past d1 either

we need some prods for all the people who disappeared mid d1 and havent shown up again tbh

What was your thought process between these two posts. You had me as a townread, but then it felt like you were suspecting me soon after?

So... anyone else want to shade me as scum after calling out ted within my first few posts?

sure lets give him some time for this

Not too sure what you mean by this post?

[iaafr]

@Poison Chan @WerewolfHunter @sprityo

find other things to do im claiming self resolving pr

i will fullclaim d3 if i live to d3

I have claimed and I am doing other things at the moment so not sure what you mean

im saying get your vote off me im claiming a PR that will prove im town and im town so if youre town you should be trying to find a vote thats not town

[WerewolfHunter]

Oh, WerewolfHunter, they seem kinda too earnest to me tbh and the whole thing about the being frozen or whatever is rankling me because like, why wouldn’t that be resolved by now if there was a role to help them. Assuming we will know sooner rather than later because either they die or are lying I guess

I'm honestly kind of confused lol. My paranoia thought is it was one of the people who died and was redacted.

also, at the rate this game is going it may even be over before day 3 end

[ColinIsCool]

I’ve been scum with sprit before and seen it a lot and I don’t think he’s within that meta right now. Imo he is more of a background player as scum and doesn’t insert himself into the thread with big pictures.

[WerewolfHunter]

I just realized it doesn't say I'm notified if I am so maybe someone did it and I don't know

[iaafr]

What was your thought process between these two posts. You had me as a townread, but then it felt like you were suspecting me soon after?

that wasnt a sus that was just a statement of what i thought was fact (but was wrong because i didnt realize you posted on d2)

Not too sure what you mean by this post?

im saying you deserve not to be primarily pushed early today because of apparently good associations for you but i mean its still not a full clear imo

[Justplayingitcool]

@Poison Chan @WerewolfHunter @sprityo

find other things to do im claiming self resolving pr

i will fullclaim d3 if i live to d3

I have claimed and I am doing other things at the moment so not sure what you mean

im saying get your vote off me im claiming a PR that will prove im town and im town so if youre town you should be trying to find a vote thats not town

Ah, you're a self-resolving pr too huh. Welcome to the club.

[sprityo]

Iaafr is probably scum. Gut saying so. Also he has literally nothing about ted, xalt, funnygurl and HK. I'm gonna go with this for now.
[VOTE: Iaafr] aubergine

I did say I was sheeping Poison on this one, but [mention]iaafr[/mention] can you explain this?

[sheepsaysmeep]

i, too, am a self resolving pr

[ColinIsCool]

If I keep answering your questions will one of you please address mine?

Here’s what I want an outsider’s opinion on: what the heck kind of name for a person is “Sweeney Todd”? First name Sweeney last name Todd? We all just gonna let that slide?

[Justplayingitcool]

What was your thought process between these two posts. You had me as a townread, but then it felt like you were suspecting me soon after?

that wasnt a sus that was just a statement of what i thought was fact (but was wrong because i didnt realize you posted on d2)

Not too sure what you mean by this post?

im saying you deserve not to be primarily pushed early today because of apparently good associations for you but i mean its still not a full clear imo

Yeah, that's fair

[Maple]

i, too, am a self resolving pr

[Maple]

Is cayvie green checked or did that not happen

[iaafr]

Iaafr is probably scum. Gut saying so. Also he has literally nothing about ted, xalt, funnygurl and HK. I'm gonna go with this for now.
[VOTE: Iaafr] aubergine

I did say I was sheeping Poison on this one, but @iaafr can you explain this?

i have never backread in this game aside from isos

i just wasnt in the thread with any of those people past early d0, and in d0 i sussed xalt

i later also voiced sus of xalt and the fact that punchy defending xalt could mean xalt is scum

i also briefly defending martin and awesom-o but recanted my defenses because i didnt feel engaged enough to want to put my reads on the line

idk

[ColinIsCool]

Like you don’t see musicals about guys named “Williamson Brad”.

[sheepsaysmeep]

Is cayvie green checked or did that not happen

i, the one who claimed to be strongman peeking her, did not successfully peek her at least

she did shoot a wolf uncounterclaimedly right

[Maple]

Right, shot a wolf, awesome.

[WerewolfHunter]

back after dinner

[Hyena]

If I keep answering your questions will one of you please address mine?

Here’s what I want an outsider’s opinion on: what the heck kind of name for a person is “Sweeney Todd”? First name Sweeney last name Todd? We all just gonna let that slide?

Maybe Sweeney had sweet knees when he was born, but his parents couldn't spell. :P

Also, I'm satisfied with your answers. ♡

[sabie12]

I'm sorry I want to be more involved. Took a new position at work while also still trying to do my old job because they haven't hired anyone and got stuck on a long call with a very difficult case. Very emotionally draining for me and I need a break from being here for a little bit. Not trying to do an ATE or like feel bad for me or anything. I'm just explaining why I'm not able to be here right now. I just need to go eat and take a nap or something and I'll come back and catch up. Not trying to leave the game just need a break.

[juliets]

[mention]Timsup2nothin[/mention] has been unsilenced.

[Maple]

Welcome back, Tim

[Justplayingitcool]

Hello Tim, please tell the class that you were roleblocked (assuming you have no active power) and no harm has befallen you from me. I am a good boy.