U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[Justplayingitcool]

JPIC should be helping to solve the game instead of resting on their laurels

@Justplayingitcool

This is a pretty solid fact. Keeping me alive is appreciated a lot more specifically by me than it is generally. Might wanna round out your claim to the good graces of town.

Yeah, that’s on me. Been hard keeping up with this game. Idk why I join games with 50+ people as I never give it the attention that it deserves.

I would like some cliffnotes

[Timsup2nothin]

JPIC should be helping to solve the game instead of resting on their laurels

@Justplayingitcool

This is a pretty solid fact. Keeping me alive is appreciated a lot more specifically by me than it is generally. Might wanna round out your claim to the good graces of town.

Yeah, that’s on me. Been hard keeping up with this game. Idk why I join games with 50+ people as I never give it the attention that it deserves.

I would like some cliffnotes

We are comparing the cases of ColonialBob and Colin...neither of their ISOs is terribly long.

[Timsup2nothin]

Produce input Bender!!!!

[Justplayingitcool]

Alright, I will look at two of those once I have access to a computer. iirc one of them was shadibg me so lock-wolf

[iaafr]

other short isos that we would appreciate verdicts on:

apogee
beeboy
drwilgy
iwan
sabie12

[Timsup2nothin]

Y'know, there's only four wolves laft and there's a LOT of players. No wonder so many people look towny.

[Justplayingitcool]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

[DaisyCloud]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

but they will die. and we can know what you are. but we are supposed to already know what you are tho see.

if you are 3rd party id do this all the time if i had this role. take my strongest scum reads that isn't gonna be voted out and pit then against you and see their flips when they die. id never pit a say town reads on u.

how do we know bob is town or 3rd party but wins with town?
if you are town aligned id test a scum read player against you too.

something to think about. depending on if we believe Bob is town aligned and we don't yeet. it's sooo scummy what they did and makes 0 sense. we should yeet. how do we trust that they do what we tell him?

also what if he isn't yeeted out or vigged out and we decide not to use you for this purpose. which 2 do we have him go with? and again do we trust him to do it?

[DaisyCloud]

Y'know, there's only four wolves laft and there's a LOT of players. No wonder so many people look towny.

bruh

[DaisyCloud]

btw reading poison iso made me even more distrustful of tim and jpic

she sussed them both early and also claimed 95% accurate reads d1

i feel compelled to sheep her because of her powerful aura and my endless guilt

She got over the suss Rabbit...and I got over sussing her...not like lock clear over but over enough...that's why SHE WASN'T ON THE LIST.

I'm actually not pissed about you shooting off the list as much as I am about all the people who shot on the list and missed and YOU have to get our hit. WTF?

I'm pretty sure we know who to blame for that.

[iaafr]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

[Timsup2nothin]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

Take THAT JPIC!!!

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

but they will die. and we can know what you are. but we are supposed to already know what you are tho see.

if you are 3rd party id do this all the time if i had this role. take my strongest scum reads that isn't gonna be voted out and pit then against you and see their flips when they die. id never pit a say town reads on u.

how do we know bob is town or 3rd party but wins with town?
if you are town aligned id test a scum read player against you too.

something to think about. depending on if we believe Bob is town aligned and we don't yeet. it's sooo scummy what they did and makes 0 sense. we should yeet. how do we trust that they do what we tell him?

also what if he isn't yeeted out or vigged out and we decide not to use you for this purpose. which 2 do we have him go with? and again do we trust him to do it?

I don’t understand what you’re saying here, can you rephrase?

[Justplayingitcool]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

You townread me. What happened with the progression there???

Also, how do I ISO people. I know about the post thing underneath the avatar, but if I am looking for a specific person that I can't find a recent post of theres...

[Justplayingitcool]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

You townread me. What happened with the progression there???

Also, how do I ISO people. I know about the post thing underneath the avatar, but if I am looking for a specific person that I can't find a recent post of theres...

[Timsup2nothin]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

You townread me. What happened with the progression there???

Also, how do I ISO people. I know about the post thing underneath the avatar, but if I am looking for a specific person that I can't find a recent post of theres...

The player list in the first post is ISO links

[Justplayingitcool]

My wifi stinks

[DaisyCloud]

I’ll ask joe if it’ll work. If it does bob should check jpic against me tonight probably.

Or we’ll make a small pool maybe.

yeah, we should make a pool.

there is a janitor(s) out there. this way we have some control and mafia just gonna have to guess. idk

[iaafr]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

You townread me. What happened with the progression there???

Also, how do I ISO people. I know about the post thing underneath the avatar, but if I am looking for a specific person that I can't find a recent post of theres...

well a lot of people are towny now and theres only 4 scum so im getting paranoid in different places

shot poison on paranoia

[iaafr]

also yes use the playerlist on the first page of this game

[iaafr]

Spoiler: show

Players

Apogee
beeboy
cayvie
ColinIsCool
colonialbob
DaisyCloud
DDL
DrWilgy
Epignosis
Hyena
iaafr
iwan
Justplayingitcool
Logic
Long Con
Maple
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Poison Chan
PunchyTheCat
sabie12
sheepsaysmeep
Sprityo
TenThousandCalories
Timsup2nothin
WerewolfHunter

Dead

Day 1 -
Tonystarkprime - The Embodiment of Champs Hero Syndrome - Town
Trustworthy Liberal - Jinx - Indie
Relm - Chevalier D'Eon - Town
hollowkatt - [Redacted]
Exalt - George A Tsoukalos - Town
Funnygurl555 - [NSM] Mikey - Mafia
motel room - The Shame After Masturbation - Town
Rej - Victor Steinberg - Town
112 - Darth Vader - Town
Adam_ - A Power Rack - Town
Marcher Jovian - [Redacted]
MartinGG99 - That One Roblox Character (oof!) - Town
polypies73 - Wario - Town
Silverkeith - Spanish Nutella - Town
xalt - Katarina - Mafia
Jumpluff - Bun 2 Head reads - Town
Hank - Randy Marsh - Indie
nutella - Tim Hortons - Mafia
Sloonei - Dr. Eggman's Existential Crisis - Town

Night 1

AWESOM-O - iaafr - Town
ThisIsNotAceMarvel - LSP Town
speedchuck - Geese Lycan - Mafia
Jackofhearts2005 - Redacted
tedxtr - L from Death Note - Mafia
Urist - Redacted

Modkilled

Shizune - Shizune - Town


Disappeared

Ephemeral

Thread Summary

Day 1

Random.org Neighbourhood Event
Day 1 Begins
ITA Window 1 Opens
Shots Fired!
ITA 1 Starts
ITA 2 Starts
Fight breaks out between Hank and Poison Chan
Day 2 ITA announcement
Popcorn fallout + shots
Jumpluff mod-killed
End of day post, Hank, Nutella and Sloonei flip
Day 1 Votes
End of Night 1
Timsup2nothin Can't Post or Vote
Punchy Poisoned
ITA 3 Rescheduling
ITA 3 Time Day 2
ITA 3 Starts

ill even post it here for your convenience

[DaisyCloud]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

but they will die. and we can know what you are. but we are supposed to already know what you are tho see.

if you are 3rd party id do this all the time if i had this role. take my strongest scum reads that isn't gonna be voted out and pit then against you and see their flips when they die. id never pit a say town reads on u.

how do we know bob is town or 3rd party but wins with town?
if you are town aligned id test a scum read player against you too.

something to think about. depending on if we believe Bob is town aligned and we don't yeet. it's sooo scummy what they did and makes 0 sense. we should yeet. how do we trust that they do what we tell him?

also what if he isn't yeeted out or vigged out and we decide not to use you for this purpose. which 2 do we have him go with? and again do we trust him to do it?

I don’t understand what you’re saying here, can you rephrase?

that's fair. I literally wrote out my whole thiught process yo get me to the conclusion that this is a good idea and shred all my doubts

it makes sense to me but it's jumbled.

[Justplayingitcool]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

You townread me. What happened with the progression there???

Also, how do I ISO people. I know about the post thing underneath the avatar, but if I am looking for a specific person that I can't find a recent post of theres...

well a lot of people are towny now and theres only 4 scum so im getting paranoid in different places

shot poison on paranoia

How do we know there is only four left? I see Poison is still in the active playerlist so I assume she didn't die?

[DaisyCloud]

oh dang Shizune was town

[Timsup2nothin]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

You townread me. What happened with the progression there???

Also, how do I ISO people. I know about the post thing underneath the avatar, but if I am looking for a specific person that I can't find a recent post of theres...

well a lot of people are towny now and theres only 4 scum so im getting paranoid in different places

shot poison on paranoia

How do we know there is only four left? I see Poison is still in the active playerlist so I assume she didn't die?

Poison and Calories dude got killed in ITAs and haven't been updated yet.

[Justplayingitcool]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

You townread me. What happened with the progression there???

Also, how do I ISO people. I know about the post thing underneath the avatar, but if I am looking for a specific person that I can't find a recent post of theres...

well a lot of people are towny now and theres only 4 scum so im getting paranoid in different places

shot poison on paranoia

How do we know there is only four left? I see Poison is still in the active playerlist so I assume she didn't die?

Poison and Calories dude got killed in ITAs and haven't been updated yet.

What did they flip as?

[iaafr]

Would also like to point out that for someone who has been shaded this game, I don’t believe I have received a single vote

i voted you for like 10 minutes about an hour ago before switching to colin

You townread me. What happened with the progression there???

Also, how do I ISO people. I know about the post thing underneath the avatar, but if I am looking for a specific person that I can't find a recent post of theres...

well a lot of people are towny now and theres only 4 scum so im getting paranoid in different places

shot poison on paranoia

How do we know there is only four left? I see Poison is still in the active playerlist so I assume she didn't die?

mac didnt update the 2 ita hits

tenthousandcalories and poison both flipped town

[Timsup2nothin]

OP says 11 wolves to start. Five shown dead. HK janitored is a wolf sacrifice. Ephemeral is as good as dead. That's seven.

[DaisyCloud]

Spoiler: show

Players

Apogee
beeboy
cayvie
ColinIsCool
colonialbob
DaisyCloud
DDL
DrWilgy
Epignosis
Hyena
iaafr
iwan
Justplayingitcool
Logic
Long Con
Maple
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Poison Chan
PunchyTheCat
sabie12
sheepsaysmeep
Sprityo
TenThousandCalories
Timsup2nothin
WerewolfHunter

Dead

Day 1 -
Tonystarkprime - The Embodiment of Champs Hero Syndrome - Town
Trustworthy Liberal - Jinx - Indie
Relm - Chevalier D'Eon - Town
hollowkatt - [Redacted]
Exalt - George A Tsoukalos - Town
Funnygurl555 - [NSM] Mikey - Mafia
motel room - The Shame After Masturbation - Town
Rej - Victor Steinberg - Town
112 - Darth Vader - Town
Adam_ - A Power Rack - Town
Marcher Jovian - [Redacted]
MartinGG99 - That One Roblox Character (oof!) - Town
polypies73 - Wario - Town
Silverkeith - Spanish Nutella - Town
xalt - Katarina - Mafia
Jumpluff - Bun 2 Head reads - Town
Hank - Randy Marsh - Indie
nutella - Tim Hortons - Mafia
Sloonei - Dr. Eggman's Existential Crisis - Town

Night 1

AWESOM-O - iaafr - Town
ThisIsNotAceMarvel - LSP Town
speedchuck - Geese Lycan - Mafia
Jackofhearts2005 - Redacted
tedxtr - L from Death Note - Mafia
Urist - Redacted

Modkilled

Shizune - Shizune - Town


Disappeared

Ephemeral

Thread Summary

Day 1

Random.org Neighbourhood Event
Day 1 Begins
ITA Window 1 Opens
Shots Fired!
ITA 1 Starts
ITA 2 Starts
Fight breaks out between Hank and Poison Chan
Day 2 ITA announcement
Popcorn fallout + shots
Jumpluff mod-killed
End of day post, Hank, Nutella and Sloonei flip
Day 1 Votes
End of Night 1
Timsup2nothin Can't Post or Vote
Punchy Poisoned
ITA 3 Rescheduling
ITA 3 Time Day 2
ITA 3 Starts

ill even post it here for your convenience

see my brain is melting cause I was about to ask if there a way to bookmark this post so I can do isos...and it's literally at beginning of game from MacDougall. like can I go crawl under a rock now

[iaafr]

TenThousandCalories has died.

Spoiler: show

They were Thomas Kesler (Multiversal power level)

Anytime during day 1 you may PM me the name of another player. That player will be immune to death until you die.

Town.

@Poison Chan has died.

Spoiler: show

They were Tsukishima Kei. Each night you may send the host the name of two players. You will learn whether those two players are on the same team or not.

Town.

[Justplayingitcool]

Who killed calories?

[DaisyCloud]

what if the ita pool was all town

[Timsup2nothin]

Who killed calories?

Not sure...they were on the list and I think a dew people shot at them.

[Timsup2nothin]

what if the ita pool was all town

Then the four wolves are somewhere else.

[DaisyCloud]

what if the ita pool was all town

Then the four wolves are somewhere else.

bruh

that's not what I meant and you know it

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Let’s not go off the deep end before we have need to

[iaafr]

Who killed calories?

i just checked and iwan, werewolfhunter, and colonialbob all shot, bob was the one who hit

wwh has cred from sussing xalt and shooting at xalt d1

people are split on bob read

ive found iwan tonally towny but that might not be good enough

[Timsup2nothin]

what if the ita pool was all town

Then the four wolves are somewhere else.

bruh

that's not what I meant and you know it

I know, it's just the only answer that isn't worse. Like "then we're really screwed" is clearly worse. "I haven't the faintest idea and it looks like no one else does either" is clearly worse. "My next tier includes you actually" isn't very nice to say out loud. So I did the best I could.

[Timsup2nothin]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Tier One

Beeboy
DrWigly
ColonialBob

Tier Two

Colin
Iwan

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

[DaisyCloud]

ita=TenThousandCalories

HIT

found it.

someone should put all these together or make a list or something

also maybe update the one jumpluff made. she had one whole big one and it had all the claims and deaths too.

i remember random people died during the day on day 1.

[Timsup2nothin]

One in there?

Two?

Maple is one?

One or two running lose?

[Justplayingitcool]

Quickly skimmed Bob's ISO. Tonally sounds pretty wolfy. 1/3 of his posts are just jokey type responses, some mechanical discussion but not much solving (I appreciate the irony because I haven't done much either).

[Timsup2nothin]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Tier One

Beeboy
DrWigly
ColonialBob

Tier Two

Colin
Iwan

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

Anyone got any input here?

[DaisyCloud]

I think spirtyo made some sort of list but his had mistakes.. i forget if it was just flips or something. idk.

that is why it is probably better to use jumpluff's as a template and not try to make a new one.

I would do it but I'm on my phone and it will be sooo difficult. of no one does it ill probably do it and hate myself forever for getting 0 sleep and I wish I wasn't on my phone.

[iaafr]

alright in repentance for shooting poison ill update jumpluffs #chartz tomorrow

tomorrow though, not today

eta 14 hours or something

[Timsup2nothin]

I think spirtyo made some sort of list but his had mistakes.. i forget if it was just flips or something. idk.

that is why it is probably better to use jumpluff's as a template and not try to make a new one.

I would do it but I'm on my phone and it will be sooo difficult. of no one does it ill probably do it and hate myself forever for getting 0 sleep and I wish I wasn't on my phone.

The host posts at the start of the game get updated with a lot of stuff and you can find the flips just by ISOing Mac.

[Timsup2nothin]

alright in repentance for shooting poison ill update jumpluffs #chartz tomorrow

tomorrow though, not today

eta 14 hours or something

Good man.

[DaisyCloud]

I think spirtyo made some sort of list but his had mistakes.. i forget if it was just flips or something. idk.

that is why it is probably better to use jumpluff's as a template and not try to make a new one.

I would do it but I'm on my phone and it will be sooo difficult. of no one does it ill probably do it and hate myself forever for getting 0 sleep and I wish I wasn't on my phone.

The host posts at the start of the game get updated with a lot of stuff and you can find the flips just by ISOing Mac.

does it have all the claims made? the ita stuff? im.sorry if I'm being obtuse. iirc jumpluff had all that stuff compiled

[Justplayingitcool]

ColinIsCool... you could say that he is just playing it cool

In all seriousness, he seems better than bob but not by too much. I see signs of solving and I feel like they have contributed more than Colonial in terms of content when you consider that they have less posts.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Broseph confirms that if mafia is checked against me with rej’s role, the mafia would die and I would survive.

Will figure out a poll tomorrow morning!