U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[Apogee]

Hey uh why is Cayvie town

Cause I definitely thought they were scummy at some point
And reading Xalt there is at least one mediocre interaction

[Timsup2nothin]

Honk take: All the players we cannot vote for are confirmed town.

Is this spewing us not mafia?

I think it spews the no vote list mostly town for sure

That kind of speculation looks just town when you do it. When you have actual information its hard to look just "off the cuff" so that's something I love doing as a wolf. But I personally would probably NOT tell the truth.

That said, does anyone have a copy of the "no vote" list from day one?

@Timsup2nothin

Silverkeith
Jackofhearts2005
Timsup2nothin
DrWilgy
Shizune
Apogee
polypies73
Justplayingitcool
sabie12
Adam_

I don't think there is a wolfflip?

Not yet. Jack got janitored but was probably town I think since no town has stepped up to claim him or a janitor role. I think SK got janitored also? And there are still some suss folks on there. I dunno.

As a wolf I'd never have said that if it was true, but the temptation might have been there and some wolves aren't like me.

[DaisyCloud]

Honk take: All the players we cannot vote for are confirmed town.

Is this spewing us not mafia?

I think it spews the no vote list mostly town for sure

That kind of speculation looks just town when you do it. When you have actual information its hard to look just "off the cuff" so that's something I love doing as a wolf. But I personally would probably NOT tell the truth.

That said, does anyone have a copy of the "no vote" list from day one?

@Timsup2nothin

Silverkeith
Jackofhearts2005
Timsup2nothin
DrWilgy
Shizune
Apogee
polypies73
Justplayingitcool
sabie12
Adam_

I don't think there is a wolfflip?

Not yet. Jack got janitored but was probably town I think since no town has stepped up to claim him or a janitor role. I think SK got janitored also? And there are still some suss folks on there. I dunno.

As a wolf I'd never have said that if it was true, but the temptation might have been there and some wolves aren't like me.

no keith was Spanish Nutella, town

[Timsup2nothin]

Hey uh why is Cayvie town

Cause I definitely thought they were scummy at some point
And reading Xalt there is at least one mediocre interaction

Claimed vig and claimed a kill that went uncontested for a long time...now ColonialBob has also claimed that kill though so <shrug>. I think Bob's claim is pretty sketchy, but YMMV.

[DaisyCloud]

oh okay. yeah, I can see being confused by your role. you should talk to MacDougall and get it sorted if you haven't already.

actually sorry that comes off as mean and condescending. i didn't mean to put you down. just of you still have questions he be the best to help you out.

I think by the time macdougal can let me know how it works the next day should already have begun lol.

So did you already submit the action or you're waiting for clarification on the mechanics from Mac first before submitting it? I can see how the logistics of that role could be kind of confusing.

yay! sabie is here!

[sheepsaysmeep]

bob is more clear than cayvie becasue the awesome kill seems to be undeniably his

[Timsup2nothin]

Spoiler: show

Honk take: All the players we cannot vote for are confirmed town.

Is this spewing us not mafia?

I think it spews the no vote list mostly town for sure

That kind of speculation looks just town when you do it. When you have actual information its hard to look just "off the cuff" so that's something I love doing as a wolf. But I personally would probably NOT tell the truth.

That said, does anyone have a copy of the "no vote" list from day one?

@Timsup2nothin

Silverkeith
Jackofhearts2005
Timsup2nothin
DrWilgy
Shizune
Apogee
polypies73
Justplayingitcool
sabie12
Adam_

I don't think there is a wolfflip?

Not yet. Jack got janitored but was probably town I think since no town has stepped up to claim him or a janitor role. I think SK got janitored also? And there are still some suss folks on there. I dunno.

As a wolf I'd never have said that if it was true, but the temptation might have been there and some wolves aren't like me.

no keith was Spanish Nutella, town

That's right. I forgot.

Hey where'd you find that list?

[Apogee]

Honk take: All the players we cannot vote for are confirmed town.

Is this spewing us not mafia?

I think it spews the no vote list mostly town for sure

That kind of speculation looks just town when you do it. When you have actual information its hard to look just "off the cuff" so that's something I love doing as a wolf. But I personally would probably NOT tell the truth.

That said, does anyone have a copy of the "no vote" list from day one?

@Timsup2nothin

Silverkeith
Jackofhearts2005
Timsup2nothin
DrWilgy
Shizune
Apogee
polypies73
Justplayingitcool
sabie12
Adam_

I don't think there is a wolfflip?

Not yet. Jack got janitored but was probably town I think since no town has stepped up to claim him or a janitor role. I think SK got janitored also? And there are still some suss folks on there. I dunno.

As a wolf I'd never have said that if it was true, but the temptation might have been there and some wolves aren't like me.

So right now with flips its:

Silverkeith -- dead town
Jackofhearts2005 -- dead, janitored
Timsup2nothin -- alive
DrWilgy -- alive
Shizune -- dead town
Apogee -- alive
polypies73 -- dead town
Justplayingitcool -- alive
sabie12 -- alive
Adam_ -- dead town

And like besides sabie and wigly I think most of the living have other things going for them?

[Timsup2nothin]

bob is more clear than cayvie becasue the awesome kill seems to be undeniably his

The Awesom kill was about the wolfiest thing that happened that night tho.

[DaisyCloud]

I'm surprised MacDougall hasn't given us some surprise event or something

[Apogee]

Cayvie and bob are both claiming awesome?

Didn't awesome like shoot a wolf or something

[sheepsaysmeep]

bob is more clear than cayvie becasue the awesome kill seems to be undeniably his

The Awesom kill was about the wolfiest thing that happened that night tho.

really? you dont think it was protown?

[sheepsaysmeep]

oh yeah he shot a wolf hm

[sheepsaysmeep]

idk

apogee, they both claimed the ted kill

first cayvie claimed to shoot ted, then later bob claimed to have backed up a role and used it to shoot both ted and awesome simultaneously

[sheepsaysmeep]

maybe bob delaying his claim timing is kinda sketch lol

too lazy to sort out claims today theyre both on paper >rand villa

[beeboy]

So day actions do not get returned.
But Punchy would get to stay alive.

[sabie12]

Cayvie and bob are both claiming awesome?

Didn't awesome like shoot a wolf or something

I think they both claimed the ted kill

[beeboy]

Although if your action works each day or every even day.
I guess you could use it again idk.

[sheepsaysmeep]

tbh punchy no longer giving a shit after being poisoned might be wolf indicative

[Apogee]

So day actions do not get returned.
But Punchy would get to stay alive.

I mean at the absolute worst

It's healing punchy and giving us a second elimination

Which I suppose depends on how you read punchy but seems pro-town overall

[Apogee]

tbh punchy no longer giving a shit after being poisoned might be wolf indicative

Can you really say this after team mafia though

Idk

[beeboy]

No no no punchy is just dying a lot slower now.

[sabie12]

I'm surprised MacDougall hasn't given us some surprise event or something

He's probably asleep or something. All the events and things seem to happen when I'm asleep since we are in pretty much opposite time zones haha oh well.

[Apogee]

No no no punchy is just dying a lot slower now.

Oh I see

[beeboy]

Actually maybe I am wrong.
I asked about someone dying on d4 and if my role would give them another day.
EoD might still happen.

[Apogee]

I'm having a really hard time thinking about in what situations an extra day before night is bad

And if actions don't refresh it's really a second elimination (pro-town) and more time to talk (pro-town)

Like a day arsonist 3p or a timed maf power up role maybe are where it goes bad

But it sounds like edge cases

[beeboy]

I can undo my action if you guys really think its bad.
But I think it just doubles our ITA phase and gives us another yeet so I don't think I will for that 1 player that really wants to submit an action.

[DaisyCloud]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Honk take: All the players we cannot vote for are confirmed town.

Is this spewing us not mafia?

I think it spews the no vote list mostly town for sure

That kind of speculation looks just town when you do it. When you have actual information its hard to look just "off the cuff" so that's something I love doing as a wolf. But I personally would probably NOT tell the truth.

That said, does anyone have a copy of the "no vote" list from day one?

@Timsup2nothin

Silverkeith
Jackofhearts2005
Timsup2nothin
DrWilgy
Shizune
Apogee
polypies73
Justplayingitcool
sabie12
Adam_

I don't think there is a wolfflip?

Not yet. Jack got janitored but was probably town I think since no town has stepped up to claim him or a janitor role. I think SK got janitored also? And there are still some suss folks on there. I dunno.

As a wolf I'd never have said that if it was true, but the temptation might have been there and some wolves aren't like me.

no keith was Spanish Nutella, town

That's right. I forgot.

Hey where'd you find that list?
[/quote]

Players

Apogee
beeboy
cayvie
ColinIsCool
colonialbob
DaisyCloud
DDL
DrWilgy
Epignosis
Hyena
iaafr
iwan
Justplayingitcool
Logic
Long Con
Maple
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Poison Chan
PunchyTheCat
sabie12
sheepsaysmeep
Sprityo
TenThousandCalories
Timsup2nothin
WerewolfHunter

Dead

Day 1 -
Tonystarkprime - The Embodiment of Champs Hero Syndrome - Town
Trustworthy Liberal - Jinx - Indie
Relm - Chevalier D'Eon - Town
hollowkatt - [Redacted]
Exalt - George A Tsoukalos - Town
Funnygurl555 - [NSM] Mikey - Mafia
motel room - The Shame After Masturbation - Town
Rej - Victor Steinberg - Town
112 - Darth Vader - Town
Adam_ - A Power Rack - Town
Marcher Jovian - [Redacted]
MartinGG99 - That One Roblox Character (oof!) - Town
polypies73 - Wario - Town
Silverkeith - Spanish Nutella - Town
xalt - Katarina - Mafia
Jumpluff - Bun 2 Head reads - Town
Hank - Randy Marsh - Indie
nutella - Tim Hortons - Mafia
Sloonei - Dr. Eggman's Existential Crisis - Town

Night 1

AWESOM-O - iaafr - Town
ThisIsNotAceMarvel - LSP Town
speedchuck - Geese Lycan - Mafia
Jackofhearts2005 - Redacted
tedxtr - L from Death Note - Mafia
Urist - Redacted

Modkilled

Shizune - Shizune - Town


Disappeared

Ephemeral

Thread Summary

Day 1

Random.org Neighbourhood Event
Day 1 Begins
ITA Window 1 Opens
Shots Fired!
ITA 1 Starts
ITA 2 Starts
Fight breaks out between Hank and Poison Chan
Day 2 ITA announcement
Popcorn fallout + shots
Jumpluff mod-killed
End of day post, Hank, Nutella and Sloonei flip
Day 1 Votes
End of Night 1
Timsup2nothin Can't Post or Vote
Punchy Poisoned
ITA 3 Rescheduling
ITA 3 Time Day 2
ITA 3 Starts

[DaisyCloud]

rip, I messed it up and there is a broken quote. sorry

[Timsup2nothin]

oh yeah he shot a wolf hm

Catch up Sheep!!!

Awesome shot THE wolf. He shot Xalt the janitor anytime vig wolf that HAD TO hit a fellow wolf first. Revealing Xalt is what unraveled the whole Maple is lock cleared by vaporized cop Hollowkatt gambit. Awesom was the most cleared town of anyone in the game that wasn't outright green flipped.

And yeah Bob has to score a mixed two-fer to get kills, according to his claim, and he hit Ted and Awesome supposedly as a pair.

Cayvie had previously claimed Ted as well. I think her claim is valid and Awesome was just the faction NK, but again YMMV. But if you look at the order of flips in the night report I think it is telling.

[Timsup2nothin]

rip, I messed it up and there is a broken quote. sorry

There's no "no vote" list from day one there tho...

It was there, but it got removed.

[DaisyCloud]

tbh punchy no longer giving a shit after being poisoned might be wolf indicative

he said he was going camping. so idk.

[sheepsaysmeep]

Apogee - chat disabling, town role, uncomfirmed
beeboy - night skipping, town role, almost confirmed
cayvie - vig who mightve shot ted, sortable role after nights/villagery role to claim, unconfirmed, probably real anyways for claiming the shot at sod
colonialbob - town backup, killed awesome/supposedly ted, somewhat validated
DaisyCloud - claimed to be green peek by hyena, also shot wolves
DDL - medium and probably real
Hyena - claimed cop
iaafr - he got eph which would be protown if his role is as he described, villagery anyways idk
Logic - poisonpeeked to be with nanook, iaafr says logic has high chance of having been targeted by wolf role to give message
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME - poisonpeeked to be with logic
Timsup2nothin - veritably silenced

uh, Epignosis?
Justplayingitcool - claimed jailkeeping
PunchyTheCat - claimed track on me, accurate
sheepsaysmeep - objectively here in terms of mech, unverified alignment peeking claim
WerewolfHunter - ita'ed a wolf and claimed something

--a line--

Long Con
Sprityo

ColinIsCool
DrWilgy
iwan
sabie12

Maple

[DaisyCloud]

VOTES:

Which two players would you like to tap out?

Poll ended at Wed Aug 05, 2020 6:59:59 am
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.


112
6
8%
Voters: ThisIsNotAceMarvel, Urist, PunchyTheCat, Adam_, sheepsaysmeep, Maple

AWESOM-O
3
4%
Voters: Apogee, colonialbob, Sloonei

beeboy
0
No votes
Voters: None

cayvie
3
4%
Voters: Hyena, nutella, 112

ColinIsCool
0
No votes
Voters: None

colonialbob
0
No votes
Voters: None

DaisyCloud
0
No votes
Voters: None

DDL
0
No votes
Voters: None

Ephemeral
1
1%
Voters: SilverKeith

Exalt
0
No votes
Voters: None

Funnygurl555
0
No votes
Voters: None

Hank
4
5%
Voters: AWESOM-O, Adam_, ColinIsCool, Poison Chan

hollowkatt
0
No votes
Voters: None

Hyena
2
3%
Voters: speedchuck, DrWilgy

iaafr
0
No votes
Voters: None

iwan
1
1%
Voters: iaafr

Jumpluff
1
1%
Voters: Long Con

Logic
2
3%
Voters: Hyena, tedxtr

Long Con
1
1%
Voters: Epignosis

Maple
5
6%
Voters: Poison Chan, Justplayingitcool, cayvie, Timsup2nothin, TenThousandCalories

Marcher Jovian
2
3%
Voters: Hank, Marcher Jovian

MartinGG99
4
5%
Voters: ThisIsNotAceMarvel, colonialbob, Dragon D. Luffy, Sloonei

motel room
0
No votes
Voters: None

nutella
2
3%
Voters: sprityo, speedchuck

Poison Chan
1
1%
Voters: Hank

PunchyTheCat
3
4%
Voters: Timsup2nothin, Dragon D. Luffy, Logic

Rej
0
No votes
Voters: None

Relm
0
No votes
Voters: None

sheepsaysmeep
1
1%
Voters: tedxtr

Sloonei
7
9%
Voters: Epignosis, iaafr, nutella, Maple, 112, AWESOM-O, sheepsaysmeep

speedchuck
2
3%
Voters: ColinIsCool, PunchyTheCat

Sprityo
0
No votes
Voters: None

tedxtr
2
3%
Voters: cayvie, sprityo

TenThousandCalories
1
1%
Voters: DaisyCloud

ThisIsNotAceMarvel
0
No votes
Voters: None

Tonystarkprime
1
1%
Voters: TonyStarkPrime

Trustworthy Liberal
0
No votes
Voters: None

Urist
0
No votes
Voters: None

WerewolfHunter
0
No votes
Voters: None

xalt
3
4%
Voters: WerewolfHunter, Long Con, Urist

Non Player Option
19
25%
Voters: Dunny, MartinGG99, jumpluff, JaggedJimmyJay, MacDougall, polypies73, Carotenoid, TonyStarkPrime, juliets, xalt, M Plus 7, Amy, Exalt, hollowkatt, motel room, Rej, Marcher Jovian, SilverKeith, Jackofhearts2005

[mention]Timsup2nothin[/mention] this has day 1 vote results

[sheepsaysmeep]

yeah i mean now we can just leash bob though so it's not something that needs resolved soon

also a parity cop and stuff

doesnt matter

[DaisyCloud]

I think i should say what Epignosis claims. but idk plus I could be wrong

[DaisyCloud]

also it is probably better to say nothing and stuff because leaving mafia in the dark be better and pro-town

but we still are not sure if Ephemeral is town tho right?

[sheepsaysmeep]

im accepting a lot of mech too easily etc etc take more looks at it late game but immediate poe seems ~fine

[sheepsaysmeep]

i think iaafr's claiming a guilty on eph anyways

[DaisyCloud]

i think iaafr's claiming a guilty on eph anyways

yeah. i think so. but like wouldn't scum try to silence town?

why would town have that type of role?

day is when town can yeet by votes and scum hunt. i mean this site allows nite chat, my community has in game nite talk. so still it seems like this be a role mafia would benefit if thry had it not town.

I suppose since it prevents eph from doing nite actions too if they had nite actions instead of day then maybe..


I think at most it be independent role if it's not a scummy role. idk. i don't claim to be an expert in such things.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Beeboy’s thing sounds cool

Sheep I think you’re being a wee bit generous with the mech clears lol

[Timsup2nothin]

Apogee - chat disabling, town role, uncomfirmed
beeboy - night skipping, town role, almost confirmed
cayvie - vig who mightve shot ted, sortable role after nights/villagery role to claim, unconfirmed, probably real anyways for claiming the shot at sod
colonialbob - town backup, killed awesome/supposedly ted, somewhat validated
DaisyCloud - claimed to be green peek by hyena, also shot wolves
DDL - medium and probably real
Hyena - claimed cop
iaafr - he got eph which would be protown if his role is as he described, villagery anyways idk
Logic - poisonpeeked to be with nanook, iaafr says logic has high chance of having been targeted by wolf role to give message
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME - poisonpeeked to be with logic
Timsup2nothin - veritably silenced

uh, Epignosis?
Justplayingitcool - claimed jailkeeping
PunchyTheCat - claimed track on me, accurate
sheepsaysmeep - objectively here in terms of mech, unverified alignment peeking claim
WerewolfHunter - ita'ed a wolf and claimed something

--a line--

Long Con
Sprityo

ColinIsCool
DrWilgy
iwan
sabie12

Maple

Epi claims the vig hit on Speedchuck. He's either town vig or SK on a leash. Not sure which and don't really care, but I need to give him an approved hit list.

[Hyena]

Okay. I am here. ♡

[Maple]

I believe in yall

[Maple]

Fam time atm

[Maple]

I'll try to get to my computer before eod to get my legacy up

[Hyena]

Here are the D1 vote results with better formatting:

112 (6 votes): Ace, Urist, Punchy, Adam, Sheep, Maple
Awesome (3 votes): Apogee, ColonialBob, Sloonei
Cayvie (3 votes): Hyena, Nutella, 112
Ephemeral (1 vote): SilverKeith
Hank (4 votes): Awesome, Adam, Colin, Poison
Hyena (2 votes): Speedchuck, DrWilgy
Iwan (1 vote): Iaafr
Jumpluff (1 vote): Long Con
Logic (2 votes): Hyena, Tedxtr
Long Con (1 vote): Epi
Maple (5 votes): Poison, JPIC, Cayvie, Tim, 10KCalories
Marcher (2 votes): Hank, Marcher
MartinGG (4 votes): Ace, ColonialBob, DDL, Sloonei
Nutella (2 votes): Sprityo, Speedchuck
Poison (1 vote): Hank
Punchy (3 votes): Tim, DDL, Logic
Sheep (1 vote): Tedxtr
Sloonei (7 votes): Epi, iaafr, nutella, Maple, 112, awesome, Sheep
Speedchuck (2 votes): Colin, Punchy
Tedxtr (2 votes): Cayvie, Sprityo
10Calories (1 vote): Daisy
Tony (1 vote): Tony
xalt (3 votes): WWL, Long Con, Urist

[sheepsaysmeep]

imagine if maaple survives the yeet ffs

[DaisyCloud]

I believe in yall

I believe in this town too! we will take out all the nafoa!!

[Hyena]

And here they are again from biggest wagon to smallest:

Sloonei (7 votes): Epi, iaafr, nutella, Maple, 112, awesome, Sheep
112 (6 votes): Ace, Urist, Punchy, Adam, Sheep, Maple
Maple (5 votes): Poison, JPIC, Cayvie, Tim, 10KCalories
Hank (4 votes): Awesome, Adam, Colin, Poison
MartinGG (4 votes): Ace, ColonialBob, DDL, Sloonei
Awesome (3 votes): Apogee, ColonialBob, Sloonei
Cayvie (3 votes): Hyena, Nutella, 112
Punchy (3 votes): Tim, DDL, Logic
xalt (3 votes): WWL, Long Con, Urist
Hyena (2 votes): Speedchuck, DrWilgy
Logic (2 votes): Hyena, Tedxtr
Marcher (2 votes): Hank, Marcher
Nutella (2 votes): Sprityo, Speedchuck
Speedchuck (2 votes): Colin, Punchy
Tedxtr (2 votes): Cayvie, Sprityo
Ephemeral (1 vote): SilverKeith
Iwan (1 vote): Iaafr
Jumpluff (1 vote): Long Con
Long Con (1 vote): Epi
Poison (1 vote): Hank
Sheep (1 vote): Tedxtr
10Calories (1 vote): Daisy
Tony (1 vote): Tony