U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Nanook you are already cleared town...part of this exercise is seeing who Long Con picks on his own...please don't try to call shots in ITAs

Meh if I think someone is probably town I’m gonna try to guide shots away from them

[Long Con]

I’ll save any bitching until after a flip kek

The way nature intended!

[Timsup2nothin]

I’ll save any bitching until after a flip kek

After everyone has let rip we go back and look for info.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Inb4 we have to wait for joe for a flip

[WerewolfHunter]

I wouldn't have been comfortable using pics of myself

[Long Con]

I wouldn't have been comfortable using pics of myself

Obviously I'm extremely good looking, so it's no prob.

[ColinIsCool]

Sorry folks I am visiting with my sister and largely AFK. Once again if you need something ping me but it looks like we’re pretty much dead in the water in POEland again so I doubt there’s much I can do for you

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I tried to get the missus to do it and she hard declined kek

[WerewolfHunter]

5 hour werewolf night

[Timsup2nothin]

Nanook you are already cleared town...part of this exercise is seeing who Long Con picks on his own...please don't try to call shots in ITAs

Meh if I think someone is probably town I’m gonna try to guide shots away from them

At this point though pretty much everyone left has at least a little bit of "probably town" about them. I wanna be able to say "that was a towny shot" not "okay, well you listened to Nanook so, yeah whatever."

[WerewolfHunter]

I wouldn't have been comfortable using pics of myself

Obviously I'm extremely good looking, so it's no prob.

Let's see the flip. I prob would have went their as well

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Listening to me is townie

[Long Con]

Nanook you are already cleared town...part of this exercise is seeing who Long Con picks on his own...please don't try to call shots in ITAs

Meh if I think someone is probably town I’m gonna try to guide shots away from them

At this point though pretty much everyone left has at least a little bit of "probably town" about them. I wanna be able to say "that was a towny shot" not "okay, well you listened to Nanook so, yeah whatever."

I want that too.

[Timsup2nothin]

In before Joe says "that was hilarious but hell no you don't get to shoot anyone"

[Long Con]

Listening to me is townie

How possible is it that Joseph could make a scum stump role, in your opinion?

[Timsup2nothin]

Listening to me is townie

but no

[juliets]

Iwan has been shot and killed.

Spoiler: show

Iwan was a delayed watcher. Each night he watches someone and gets the results the next night.

Town

[sabie12]

That video was beautiful LC

[Long Con]

God quacking dammit.

[Timsup2nothin]

Sigh

[Timsup2nothin]

RIP Iwan

[sabie12]

Sadface

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Listening to me is townie

How possible is it that Joseph could make a scum stump role, in your opinion?

Unless there’s an unclaimed one id say it’s 0% kek

[Timsup2nothin]

Never chop, good 'til we drop

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME-the stump-can't kill him, gotta trust him...could be 3P but does it even matter?

Seem locked on claims or roles or targets

DaisyCloud-ITAed a wolf (buss unlikely) Hyena gave her a heart and if she is wolf says that would kill him
Hyena-Hands out hearts to town that boomerang him if handed to wolves and gave one to DaisyCloud, also silenced
Epignosis-claims town vig, uncontested credit on Speedchuck, could be SK so watch leash
Logic-Read as sale alignment with Nanook by Poison
PunchyTheCat-poisoned, I think by confirmed wolf Speedchuck, but almost certainly by wolves
Timsup2nothin-silenced, seemingly obviously by wolves-yes this is me, deal with it
sheepsaysmeep-targeted by mafia gaslighter Ephemeral with fake redcheck

Role claims less locked

cayvie-claims town vig with pelt of Tedxtr...this pelt also claimed much later by ColonialBob
colonialbob-claims comparator power, choose two and kills both if unaligned-claims Tedxtr and Awesome O kills
Justplayingitcool-claims town jailkeeper, tasked with keeping Tim alive-may be town, may be leashed
iaafr-claims to have captured wolf Ephemeral trapped in a dungeon, seems plausible

Role claims at least somewhat NAI

beeboy-reset time providing an extra day phase
Apogee-claims to have ability to cancel night wolfchat
DDL-has communicated with spec chat
WerewolfHunter-claims to be a self resolving ice cream sandwich that is going to just melt and fired an ITA at very important wolf Xalt

Got nothin goin for them

Long Con
sabie12
Sprityo

On kill list

ColinIsCool
DrWilgy


Maple-various claims, most of them wolfy...also the center of a very expensive clearing plot by known wolves


WHEN ITAS HAPPEN WE WILL BE SHOOTING AT

ColinIsCool
DrWilgy
sabie12
Sprityo

[sheepsaysmeep]

lol we actually killed our watcher

[Timsup2nothin]

lol we actually killed our watcher

Not our finest hour.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Uh no sabie is not on the ITA list

We’ll be lucky to get two dead, we only need a list of three

[sheepsaysmeep]

top priority are colin and wilgy

then sabie sprityo long con, maybe apogee if we dont think thats self resolving but probably unnecessary for todays list

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

If you insist on a list of four put DDL on there or something, I’m hard shielding sabie today

[sheepsaysmeep]

dont shoot ddl lol

[juliets]

HEADS UP AGAIN

ITA ANNOUNCEMENT:

ITA'S WILL BE TOMORROW, HOPEFULLY AT 7:00 PM EDT SO YOU'LL HAVE TIME BEFORE END OF DAY AT 10:14 EDT.

PLEASE NOTE THOUGH THIS TIME COULD CHANGE! CHECK THE LINKS ON THE FIRST PAGE FOR UPDATES!

[Timsup2nothin]

Uh no sabie is not on the ITA list

We’ll be lucky to get two dead, we only need a list of three

I was thinking if we give people more choices we might learn more from who they pick. Has Sabie really done something more towny? Can you point to that?

I'm not disagreeing but I was also thinking maybe put Long Con Duck on there and see if anyone shoots at him too.

[sheepsaysmeep]

all shots should be on

coliniscool
drwilgy

if those are dead

long con
sprityo
sabie (dont tell nanook)

apoogee

idk

im mostly just hoping the first two die today

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Uh no sabie is not on the ITA list

We’ll be lucky to get two dead, we only need a list of three

I was thinking if we give people more choices we might learn more from who they pick. Has Sabie really done something more towny? Can you point to that?

I'm not disagreeing but I was also thinking maybe put Long Con Duck on there and see if anyone shoots at him too.

I don’t really want sabie or LC on there

I’d be fine with apogee tho

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Beeboy can also be on there over LC and sabie tbh

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

But yeah I’d rather just cluster shots on colin/wilgy and go to sprit/apogee then if somehow all four are dead we can talk about LC/sabie then


We don’t need “readable moments by decision who yo shoot” right now, we need to clear the POE and see if the game ends

[Timsup2nothin]

Okay, got a lot of time before ITAs so let's get more input.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Anyways I’ll be back later

[Timsup2nothin]

But yeah I’d rather just cluster shots on colin/wilgy and go to sprit/apogee then if somehow all four are dead we can talk about LC/sabie then


We don’t need “readable moments by decision who yo shoot” right now, we need to clear the POE and see if the game ends

The "clear the POE and see if the game ends" is gonna come from night vigs. There's three wolves besides Maple, so even if Colin and Wilgy are two there's one left. Vigs have to have enough targets that they don't overlap shots though.

[Timsup2nothin]

Tentative ITA shooting list:

Shoot until dead:

Dr Wilgy
ColinIsCool

Then fire at:

Long Con
Sprit
Apogee
Sabie
Beeboy

If you have a SOLID clear...not "gosh they seem towny to me" but something that really is a towny ACTION they have taken, please @ me. There will be discussion and if there seems to be agreement among a few people they will be removed.

If someone higher up the clear list REALLY seems wolfy to you, convince four other people and @ me and they can be added to the list.

IF YOU WANT TO SEE CHANGES IN THE LIST DO NOT WAIT UNTIL THE LAST MINUTE

[Long Con]

Hold off on me this time if possible. There's a reason, and I'll tell you on Night 2.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

But yeah I’d rather just cluster shots on colin/wilgy and go to sprit/apogee then if somehow all four are dead we can talk about LC/sabie then


We don’t need “readable moments by decision who yo shoot” right now, we need to clear the POE and see if the game ends

The "clear the POE and see if the game ends" is gonna come from night vigs. There's three wolves besides Maple, so even if Colin and Wilgy are two there's one left. Vigs have to have enough targets that they don't overlap shots though.

ITAs can potentially help speed things along, and make our vig shots more useful


I’m making the shot list this time around, I expect people to adhere to it

[sheepsaysmeep]

i really think beeboy role is >rand town but like

not something i stand in the way of ig his actual content is meh

please dont shoot it before real poe

a villa flip would be very i told you soo

[Timsup2nothin]

But yeah I’d rather just cluster shots on colin/wilgy and go to sprit/apogee then if somehow all four are dead we can talk about LC/sabie then


We don’t need “readable moments by decision who yo shoot” right now, we need to clear the POE and see if the game ends

The "clear the POE and see if the game ends" is gonna come from night vigs. There's three wolves besides Maple, so even if Colin and Wilgy are two there's one left. Vigs have to have enough targets that they don't overlap shots though.

ITAs can potentially help speed things along, and make our vig shots more useful


I’m making the shot list this time around, I expect people to adhere to it

Yeah whatever. If it's a consensus list I will, if it is made up of "Nanook says so that's how it is" and "Nanook has a feeling" then no I might not and I'll encourage people to ignore it.

[Timsup2nothin]

Being a stump makes you unkillable, it doesn't make you right.

[Apogee]

Sheep when did I move out of "probably top town"

Down to top of your POE

[sheepsaysmeep]

ive always been wolfreading you lol

there was just a brief period of time where i was locking most claims town and then slowly realized your claim wasnt going to be confirmed and thougbt about it more

[Apogee]

ive always been wolfreading you lol

there was just a brief period of time where i was locking most claims town and then slowly realized your claim wasnt going to be confirmed and thougbt about it more

One moment

[Apogee]

Spoiler: show

112
Apogee
beeboy
hollowkatt
Hyena
iaafr
Jumpluff
Justplayingitcool
Maple
MartinGG99
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Poison Chan
PunchyTheCat
sheepsaysmeep
Silverkeith
Timsup2nothin
xalt

my villagers off the top of my head

i intend on sheeping manti over any of this

just putting this on the record for postgame etc etc

adam, apogee, awesome, bee, daisy, ddluffy, hyena, iaafr, jack, jump, maple, marcher, martin, nanook, nutella, poison, punchy, sheep, silverkeith, insomnia, tim, wwhunter, xalt


my villas

i think

village

sheep
manti
ddl - wolfy by posts but the claim is almost certainly real and almost certainly a village role if it exists?
rej - i remember him being dead yet here he is. if he's not actually dead i'll read the iso oops

notably villagey

adam
daisy
poison
jump
punchy

somewhat villagey

apogee
eph - big iso sheeping manti
iaafr
marcher
silverkeith
tedxtr
tim
wwhunter

maaaaybe villagey; i am unlikely to attempt to explain or defend but here you go

bee
colonial
hyena
nanook
naletlu
poly
ace
xalt

maaaaybe villagey but immediately tried to profit off of my placement of him here and now im scared

awesome

>rand village but likely self resolves anyway

jpic

idk

colin
wigly
epignosis
iwan
jack
martin
shizune
speedchuck - maybe one lower idk
sprityo - iso is impossible to read send sheepable takes here
tenthousandcalories

below null i guess?

cayvie
logic
long con
sabie
sloonei
urist

gladiatored poison who is probably village

hank

alphabetical within tiers

donot play the game by sheeping this list or some shit if i flip early because i saw a lot of these names for the first time just now and spent like 30 seconds in some iso's

in recent games ive often been citing lists like these as out of my wolfrange. thinking aboout it now i havent legitimately wolfed in so long that i have no idea whether i might actually be able to fake an omegalist like this lol but pretend im correct that i cant wolf anyways

below nulls are especially unconfident and gutbased/somewhat forced; i would rather sheep manti than hard push for those tbh

not spoiling this is very much intentional

just cleared myself gg glgl sheep out manti controls my vote

apogee is sub null for me

relative to my recent experiences with him he's pretty low impact and not at all villagery despite having so many posts

his scumreads have also been kinda boring idk

tbf i dont have any real wolfreads beyond "lacking" either right now

i am also voting apogee.

fancy vote tags go

the village

apogee - as accurately concluded in anni, chatblock roles are very likely village. posting is still lightly wolfy but who cares
cayvie - shot ted i guess leave it as clear until late game tinfoils, starting to feel more like mu anni (she was town) after overnight posting
daisy - shot woofs, shot by woofs iirc, general villageyness and villagey anticonsensusness, villagey emotions
ddl - medium? still think this is a villa role and a real role he has but not been paying attention to his posts lol
iaafr - meta and his self depreciation of wolfgame, interactions with some dead wolf, conviction that he is clearly villa, behavior and flip floppiness matches how i expect villa rabbit to play, im pocketed
punchy - he feels like villa play in both team mafia and anni. claiming a track on me and thinking he had a guilty was probably real. i still think this should be healed.
sheep - yes.
werewolfhunter - generally villagery, shot xalt, proud of xalt shot

light village

beeboy - he still needs more posts for me to not feel like he must be resolved. Post 49 is something he tends to do as villa a lot in mashes and points to villa here. he claimed some stronk protown day action which he intended on using today, and that's probably a villagery thing to hardclaim early game in general, so hopefully that plays out soon and helps to clear him or something idk
hyena - hyena
logic - lamist is meta warranted and indicative of village here; i just need more from him but matches with v game thus far
poison - can be a wolf but is distinctly in villa game
tim - wary of his wolfgame but like spec chat game, engaging in 1 on 1s while he doesnt need to, stuff with punchy felt v/v despite punchy protesting this conclusion

nanook and spirtyo

nanook - nanook
sprityo - i recall him being slightly non w/w-y at some point with nutella but will need to double check.

--a line--

below a line

tenthousandcalories gut pulls him above the rest wowee

colin - he's literally just not solving in his iso lol. it doesnt make him wolf, but he fails to pass above line.
colonialbob - poe? i find the way he presents vote decisions overexplainy/awkward and >rand wolf in Post 3416 but really dont know. i may check if this is just a playstyle thing when the two of us are in f3 together.
drwigly - he used ;_; instead of ;-; what the fuck
epignosis - epignosis
iwan - trying to explain sub-nulls is getting tedious because there isnt much of an explanation tbqh. my reads are generally sort by postcount/start resolving lower impact less content slots, which i do think is somewhat warranted by the gamestate and the fact that it currently feels like town is winning.
long con - i swear every iso in this list is a carbon copy of the others

an island outside of this list

jpic - claim and stuff exists, and i dont want to think about it. honestly sorta feels like ted iso page 1 spews him v? but ted good at faking this stuff and the switch from ted back to let it self resolve after hard pushing jpic is sorta unnatural idk. wont be surprised if jpic does flip v but would prefer that he reappears
maple - lol.

peek

sabie - peek

Apogee
cayvie
DaisyCloud
DDL
iaafr
Logic
Maple
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
PunchyTheCat
sheepsaysmeep
Timsup2nothin
WerewolfHunter

almost always all village

are the thumbs up or are they down

Shrug

[Apogee]

I'm starting to wonder if this post is getting me an OMGUS:

If I'm throwing out reads purely based off of where I think I recall *shrugs* or *headtilts*

I kinda want to look at Rabbit and/or Sheep. But at least rabbit has a good claim and sheep might too right.

Who is DrWigly
And who is Iwan

I'm going to read them