U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[PunchyTheCat]

when are we allowed to tinfoil long con

[sheepsaysmeep]

after he stops killing exactly in our poe and is still alive in lilo

[Long Con]

if the poisoner is village and in our poe of like 6 people they should definitely claim btw

any chance the poisoner could be neutral as well. I agree if they are village they should claim however an evil could fake claim that as well

If the poisoner claims and agrees to be leashed I don't care if they are 3P or what. They poison who town tells them to they get to live.

I poisoned Punchy. I am town. I was going to reveal after Punchy's death, ideally a scum death.

this infuriates me

this is literally so ridiculous and baseless that i might consider never playing with long con again

i've been absurdly villagery

Take it up with the Healer, it's out of my hands as of mid-Night-1.

[DaisyCloud]

it's weird because I got sheep, and others as null so I'm not pushing them to be shot at. and them I got some i feel scummy about but they are not on the list.

Anyone who isn't on the list there is a reason. If a bunch of people agree that is a bad reason let Nanook know. But overcoming a reason takes more than just "tone is wolfy." Tone reads really are generally junk, tbh.

I disagree. tone reads are not junk. also in a closed set up we can't necessarily ever really know. also we can't always trust people's claims.

if mechanics say such and such supposedly happened so player a has to be a wolf but player a is just maybe a weaker player and actually is town,, that easily for wolves to be like oops if thry yeet them or shoot them.

this is something to consider with iwan for example.

I mean i use the tools im good at. I'm not saying I'm so pro player but thst doesn't mean idk how to find scum.

[beeboy]

Dont ITA maple, he doesn't deserve it wtf.

[Timsup2nothin]

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME-the stump-can't kill him, gotta trust him...could be 3P but does it even matter?

Seem locked on claims or roles or targets

DaisyCloud-ITAed a wolf (buss unlikely) Hyena gave her a heart and if she is wolf says that would kill him
Hyena-Hands out hearts to town that boomerang him if handed to wolves and gave one to DaisyCloud, also silenced
Epignosis-claims town vig, uncontested credit on Speedchuck, could be SK so watch leash
Logic-Read as sale alignment with Nanook by Poison
Timsup2nothin-silenced, seemingly obviously by wolves-yes this is me, deal with it
sheepsaysmeep-targeted by mafia gaslighter Ephemeral with fake redcheck

Role claims less locked

cayvie-claims town vig with pelt of Tedxtr...this pelt also claimed much later by ColonialBob
colonialbob-claims comparator power, choose two and kills both if unaligned-claims Tedxtr and Awesome O kills
Justplayingitcool-claims town jailkeeper, tasked with keeping Tim alive-may be town, may be leashed
iaafr-claims to have captured wolf Ephemeral trapped in a dungeon, seems plausible
Long Con-poisoner leashed

Role claims at least somewhat NAI

beeboy-reset time providing an extra day phase
Apogee-claims to have ability to cancel night wolfchat
DDL-has communicated with spec chat
WerewolfHunter-claims to be a self resolving ice cream sandwich that is going to just melt and fired an ITA at very important wolf Xalt

Seas but walking

PunchyTheCat-poisoned so no point killing

Got nothin goin for them

sabie12
Sprityo

On kill list

ColinIsCool
DrWilgy

[DaisyCloud]

Dont ITA maple, he doesn't deserve it wtf.

maple is being yeeted. they are jester and earned it. they been game solvey. in theory their posts that are supposed to be towny is wrong but im too tired to dive into their iso. far as i know they been helping town solve the game and not mafia.

only reason we don't is if we have strong enough reasons to think their winning ends game or something.

[DaisyCloud]

could we talk about what MacDougall said about nanook now? they are supposedly deadable and mafia?

[DaisyCloud]

[mention]Timsup2nothin[/mention] ^

cause looks like yiu copy pasted

[sheepsaysmeep]

could we talk about what MacDougall said about nanook now? they are supposedly deadable and mafia?

x

[DaisyCloud]

could we talk about what MacDougall said about nanook now? they are supposedly deadable and mafia?

x

what do you mean by x?

[iaafr]

ok only skimmed a bit to look for ITAs and it seems like they're more delayed

reiterating request for somebody to @ me in this game when people find out definitively when the ITA window is

ill shoot on the list no matter what; probably just shooting colin

[Timsup2nothin]

it's weird because I got sheep, and others as null so I'm not pushing them to be shot at. and them I got some i feel scummy about but they are not on the list.

Anyone who isn't on the list there is a reason. If a bunch of people agree that is a bad reason let Nanook know. But overcoming a reason takes more than just "tone is wolfy." Tone reads really are generally junk, tbh.

I disagree. tone reads are not junk. also in a closed set up we can't necessarily ever really know. also we can't always trust people's claims.

if mechanics say such and such supposedly happened so player a has to be a wolf but player a is just maybe a weaker player and actually is town,, that easily for wolves to be like oops if thry yeet them or shoot them.

this is something to consider with iwan for example.

I mean i use the tools im good at. I'm not saying I'm so pro player but thst doesn't mean idk how to find scum.

I play with a whole lot of players who are gonna "tone" exactly the same regardless of alignment. That's the basic point of the game.

I'm at least consistent, I laughed in the face of every single person who "tone read" me this game, no matter their read.

But either way, keep those skills sharp because once the obvious potential wolves have been resolved there's gonna be a new game with about 15 people and one or two wolves and it is gonna be hard.

[iaafr]

could we talk about what MacDougall said about nanook now? they are supposedly deadable and mafia?

x

what do you mean by x?

"press x to doubt" reference

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

could we talk about what MacDougall said about nanook now? they are supposedly deadable and mafia?

x

what do you mean by x?

X is for doubt

[iaafr]

ok only skimmed a bit to look for ITAs and it seems like they're more delayed

reiterating request for somebody to @ me in this game when people find out definitively when the ITA window is

ill shoot on the list no matter what; probably just shooting colin

straight after posting this i just got an impulse to hero shoot beeboy

wait is beeboy still on the list idek

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Reminder of the shot list:

Shoot Colin and wilgy until they’re dead

After Colin and wilgy are dead:

Spoiler: show

Sprit/Beeboy

If those two also die, then and only then can you can shoot at

Spoiler: show

LC/apogee/sabie

[Timsup2nothin]

@Timsup2nothin ^

cause looks like yiu copy pasted

I updated my list because I moved Punchy. In the crazy exchange between Mac and Nanook I really got the impression That Mac was kidding, first off, and I also haven't figured any way to make it matter since Nanook is by all indications unkillable.

[Apogee]

Has JPIC like done anything since an early claim

Yes yes I'm aware he self resolves to a degree yes yes

[Timsup2nothin]

[mention]NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME[/mention]

If Long Con is really a poisoner I think he is a very easy leash because his target is definitely identified. I wouldn't ITA him at this point.

[iaafr]

alright ill follow the list to a T this time and not even jump a tier

[Apogee]

Like there are a fair number of claims I'm going if they don't die soon or do something further to confirm themselves they are probably a wolf.

[Timsup2nothin]

Has JPIC like done anything since an early claim

Yes yes I'm aware he self resolves to a degree yes yes

I kinda think he kept me alive. The wolves clearly wanted me silenced, so that implies they would have killed me if they thought it would work. That could be wrong, but my inclination to stay alive makes me prefer that JPIC not get ITAed. I keep trying to meet the activation requirements for my own night powers, which would mean I don't need JPIC and he can protect someone else, so that's an additional benefit.

[PunchyTheCat]

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME-the stump-can't kill him, gotta trust him...could be 3P but does it even matter?

Seem locked on claims or roles or targets

DaisyCloud-ITAed a wolf (buss unlikely) Hyena gave her a heart and if she is wolf says that would kill him
Hyena-Hands out hearts to town that boomerang him if handed to wolves and gave one to DaisyCloud, also silenced
Epignosis-claims town vig, uncontested credit on Speedchuck, could be SK so watch leash
Logic-Read as sale alignment with Nanook by Poison
Timsup2nothin-silenced, seemingly obviously by wolves-yes this is me, deal with it
sheepsaysmeep-targeted by mafia gaslighter Ephemeral with fake redcheck

Role claims less locked

cayvie-claims town vig with pelt of Tedxtr...this pelt also claimed much later by ColonialBob
colonialbob-claims comparator power, choose two and kills both if unaligned-claims Tedxtr and Awesome O kills
Justplayingitcool-claims town jailkeeper, tasked with keeping Tim alive-may be town, may be leashed
iaafr-claims to have captured wolf Ephemeral trapped in a dungeon, seems plausible
Long Con-poisoner leashed

Role claims at least somewhat NAI

beeboy-reset time providing an extra day phase
Apogee-claims to have ability to cancel night wolfchat
DDL-has communicated with spec chat
WerewolfHunter-claims to be a self resolving ice cream sandwich that is going to just melt and fired an ITA at very important wolf Xalt

Seas but walking

PunchyTheCat-poisoned so no point killing

Got nothin goin for them

sabie12
Sprityo

On kill list

ColinIsCool
DrWilgy

where is maple

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

If Long Con is really a poisoner I think he is a very easy leash because his target is definitely identified. I wouldn't ITA him at this point.

I think he still belongs on third tier tbh

Probably will remove him from vig pool, we’ll see

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME-the stump-can't kill him, gotta trust him...could be 3P but does it even matter?

Seem locked on claims or roles or targets

DaisyCloud-ITAed a wolf (buss unlikely) Hyena gave her a heart and if she is wolf says that would kill him
Hyena-Hands out hearts to town that boomerang him if handed to wolves and gave one to DaisyCloud, also silenced
Epignosis-claims town vig, uncontested credit on Speedchuck, could be SK so watch leash
Logic-Read as sale alignment with Nanook by Poison
Timsup2nothin-silenced, seemingly obviously by wolves-yes this is me, deal with it
sheepsaysmeep-targeted by mafia gaslighter Ephemeral with fake redcheck

Role claims less locked

cayvie-claims town vig with pelt of Tedxtr...this pelt also claimed much later by ColonialBob
colonialbob-claims comparator power, choose two and kills both if unaligned-claims Tedxtr and Awesome O kills
Justplayingitcool-claims town jailkeeper, tasked with keeping Tim alive-may be town, may be leashed
iaafr-claims to have captured wolf Ephemeral trapped in a dungeon, seems plausible
Long Con-poisoner leashed

Role claims at least somewhat NAI

beeboy-reset time providing an extra day phase
Apogee-claims to have ability to cancel night wolfchat
DDL-has communicated with spec chat
WerewolfHunter-claims to be a self resolving ice cream sandwich that is going to just melt and fired an ITA at very important wolf Xalt

Seas but walking

PunchyTheCat-poisoned so no point killing

Got nothin goin for them

sabie12
Sprityo

On kill list

ColinIsCool
DrWilgy

where is maple

In their own “dying today” tier

[Long Con]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

If Long Con is really a poisoner I think he is a very easy leash because his target is definitely identified. I wouldn't ITA him at this point.

I think he still belongs on third tier tbh

Probably will remove him from vig pool, we’ll see

Can stumps be poisoned? Asking for a friend

[juliets]

While we wait, here's a tip about formatting ITAs. The format is:

ITA=juliets

Use the "dead" tags to get the red and the "B" tags to get the bold.

Simple.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

If Long Con is really a poisoner I think he is a very easy leash because his target is definitely identified. I wouldn't ITA him at this point.

I think he still belongs on third tier tbh

Probably will remove him from vig pool, we’ll see

Can stumps be poisoned? Asking for a friend

No idea! It won’t kill me, idk if he’ll let you target me or not

[PunchyTheCat]

my own opinion zzz

shoot first:

Maple

shoot after maple dies:

colin
drwilgy

then you can shoot:

Logic
beeboy
spirityo
colonialbob

[Timsup2nothin]

Like there are a fair number of claims I'm going if they don't die soon or do something further to confirm themselves they are probably a wolf.

Something to keep in mind is that basically since the list was made hardly anyone has died. It has been a looooooong time, but with no night phase the wolves haven't really had any chance to kill anyone. I'm guessing they have about three, maybe four kill power coming N2, so I suggest figuring out who you think they are most likely to be targeting.

[PunchyTheCat]

i seriously don't understand why we're just ignoring maple and hoping on eliminating them

just end them in itas ez

[Apogee]

Like there are a fair number of claims I'm going if they don't die soon or do something further to confirm themselves they are probably a wolf.

Something to keep in mind is that basically since the list was made hardly anyone has died. It has been a looooooong time, but with no night phase the wolves haven't really had any chance to kill anyone. I'm guessing they have about three, maybe four kill power coming N2, so I suggest figuring out who you think they are most likely to be targeting.

Oh I have

And I know where I'm pushing if they aren't dead

But this is one of the couple of things I'm not going to share ahead of time

And yeah a long time without flips to be sure

[PunchyTheCat]

ok only skimmed a bit to look for ITAs and it seems like they're more delayed

reiterating request for somebody to @ me in this game when people find out definitively when the ITA window is

ill shoot on the list no matter what; probably just shooting colin

straight after posting this i just got an impulse to hero shoot beeboy

wait is beeboy still on the list idek

i think he was the guy who said they healed me

but also i'm still poisoned so idc

no other objections here

[Apogee]

ok only skimmed a bit to look for ITAs and it seems like they're more delayed

reiterating request for somebody to @ me in this game when people find out definitively when the ITA window is

ill shoot on the list no matter what; probably just shooting colin

straight after posting this i just got an impulse to hero shoot beeboy

wait is beeboy still on the list idek

i think he was the guy who said they healed me

but also i'm still poisoned so idc

no other objections here

Beeboy did the double day

Which was thought to maybe heal you

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Shooting bob is a hard no

[Timsup2nothin]

my own opinion zzz

shoot first:

Maple

shoot after maple dies:

colin
drwilgy

then you can shoot:

Logic
beeboy
spirityo
colonialbob

Poison flipped town with a compare alignment power...and she had announced logic/Nanook as same alignment. I think that's a pretty good clear on Logic.

[WerewolfHunter]

My main question is whether nanook after that earlier thing is actually evil or not now.

I believe I'm dying night 3 unless something happens. However I will only know that after the fact is my assumption

[Apogee]

Shooting bob is a hard no

Bob is never a today yeah

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

My main question is whether nanook after that earlier thing is actually evil or not now.

I believe I'm dying night 3 unless something happens. However I will only know that after the fact is my assumption

Not that I’m aware of!

[DaisyCloud]

While we wait, here's a tip about formatting ITAs. The format is:

ITA=juliets

Use the "dead" tags to get the red and the "B" tags to get the bold.

Simple.

thank you so much for this! ♡

[PunchyTheCat]

my own opinion zzz

shoot first:

Maple

shoot after maple dies:

colin
drwilgy

then you can shoot:

beeboy
spirityo
colonialbob

Poison flipped town with a compare alignment power...and she had announced logic/Nanook as same alignment. I think that's a pretty good clear on Logic.

okay yeah that's fine

why are we not shooting maple in itas

[Timsup2nothin]

i seriously don't understand why we're just ignoring maple and hoping on eliminating them

just end them in itas ez

They are the consensus chop for EoD.

For myself, Maple getting chopped will further my requirements to activate my own night powers, oddly enough, so I'd rather they die that way. But if they do die in ITAs we might be able to get useful vote movements so that would be okay too.

They claimed really early (like before they were lock wolf) that shooting them in ITAs would kill the shooter, so Nanook the unkillable is a good choice to shoot at them and you are poisoned anyway so what the hell...but I don't think other people really should.

[WerewolfHunter]

My main question is whether nanook after that earlier thing is actually evil or not now.

I believe I'm dying night 3 unless something happens. However I will only know that after the fact is my assumption

Not that I’m aware of!

It felt kind of real but prob not

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

He claimed PGO that included ITAs at some point

Which probably isn’t true but meh

He’s just dying today so it doesn’t matter tbh

[Timsup2nothin]

PGO stands for...?

[DaisyCloud]

Like there are a fair number of claims I'm going if they don't die soon or do something further to confirm themselves they are probably a wolf.

Something to keep in mind is that basically since the list was made hardly anyone has died. It has been a looooooong time, but with no night phase the wolves haven't really had any chance to kill anyone. I'm guessing they have about three, maybe four kill power coming N2, so I suggest figuring out who you think they are most likely to be targeting.

Oh I have

And I know where I'm pushing if they aren't dead

But this is one of the couple of things I'm not going to share ahead of time

And yeah a long time without flips to be sure

didn't we have a bunch of people die nite 1 or day 1 outside of itas? or was all that the popcorn game

[DaisyCloud]

i seriously don't understand why we're just ignoring maple and hoping on eliminating them

just end them in itas ez

They are the consensus chop for EoD.

For myself, Maple getting chopped will further my requirements to activate my own night powers, oddly enough, so I'd rather they die that way. But if they do die in ITAs we might be able to get useful vote movements so that would be okay too.

They claimed really early (like before they were lock wolf) that shooting them in ITAs would kill the shooter, so Nanook the unkillable is a good choice to shoot at them and you are poisoned anyway so what the hell...but I don't think other people really should.

wut. u sound scary

[Timsup2nothin]

Like there are a fair number of claims I'm going if they don't die soon or do something further to confirm themselves they are probably a wolf.

Something to keep in mind is that basically since the list was made hardly anyone has died. It has been a looooooong time, but with no night phase the wolves haven't really had any chance to kill anyone. I'm guessing they have about three, maybe four kill power coming N2, so I suggest figuring out who you think they are most likely to be targeting.

Oh I have

And I know where I'm pushing if they aren't dead

But this is one of the couple of things I'm not going to share ahead of time

And yeah a long time without flips to be sure

didn't we have a bunch of people die nite 1 or day 1 outside of itas? or was all that the popcorn game

Yeah lots of people...but the list was made after EoD2...since then we had ITAs where one person on the list flipped villa, and Long Con Duck got a vig shot and flipped one more villa. But there don't seem to have been any wolf kills, so the "but if you're so clear why haven't the wolves NKed you" tinfoil would be too early.

[WerewolfHunter]

i seriously don't understand why we're just ignoring maple and hoping on eliminating them

just end them in itas ez

They are the consensus chop for EoD.

For myself, Maple getting chopped will further my requirements to activate my own night powers, oddly enough, so I'd rather they die that way. But if they do die in ITAs we might be able to get useful vote movements so that would be okay too.

They claimed really early (like before they were lock wolf) that shooting them in ITAs would kill the shooter, so Nanook the unkillable is a good choice to shoot at them and you are poisoned anyway so what the hell...but I don't think other people really should.

wut. u sound scary

Love thar respinse. I'm going to prob die anyway so honestly dying a day earlier wouldn't be that bad. Either way it proves or disprove it