Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Idk dude usually sprit is a hard read but this game he feels super townie to me

Especially his interaction with broseph earlier it just reeked of tired townieness

This was addressed to SPF fwiw

[sprityo]

The exclamation points are unnecessary. I'm not some shrill crybaby. You still havent addressed not having any backing to your reads or points. especially me

It's not clear to me what kind of backing you're looking for. Do you want quotes? Links? Academic citations? When I say "sprityo did this" or "sprityo did that" I assume you know what I'm talking about. If you have some specific point I made that you want me to back up, tell me which ones.

Here's the cliff's notes on my case on you.

a) MacDougall said you'd scumread him if you were town, but you refused to.
b) I think this is scummy.
c) Then, you redirected the conversation from you to JPIC.
d) I think this is you trying to goad Mac into attacking JPIC and either forgetting about the case on you, or townreading you for also scumreading JPIC.
e) I think this is scummy, too.

Feel free to specify a letter and why you don't think that point is adequately supported by logic and I'll get back to you on it.

a) There's definitely been more than one occasion that I have scumread mac but it is not a given. I'm sure Mac would want me to because it's entertaining for him.
b) okay, your opinion.
c) If that's how you see it, alright. That's not the intended effect. I welcome the attention honestly.
d) You can't control mac. He's a free spirit. That's the worst idea I could do.
e) a misinterpretation to a silly idea to a wrong opinion.

[tedxtr]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

[staypositivefriend]

Idk dude usually sprit is a hard read but this game he feels super townie to me

Especially his interaction with broseph earlier it just reeked of tired townieness

This was addressed to SPF fwiw

i have zero meta on spirit but i thought the way he handled mac's fos on him was pretty awkward

[Samusamu]

[VOTE: ted] aubergine

This vote is couse alise meta scumreading ted?

Feels like pocketing.

[staypositivefriend]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

friendship ended with ted, now the rolling panda in your avatar is my only friend

[nutella]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

[Alison]

nutella is...

...probably town.

I think if I was scum here I'd be freaking out because half the playerlist has just confirmed themselves town and I have no viable misexes. I expect to see desperation and attempts to undermine the towncore, not an immediate response of "yeah I agree with most of these reads".

12 players confirmed, 10 to go.

This feels like a bait for me, do you actually still think the same?

This feels crazy but I want to townread Samu off this. I don't know if it's English not being his native language causing him to use unorthodox turns of phrase, but I feel like the use of the word bait here strongly indicates that he felt it was some kind of provocation or (intentionally?) controversial idea by me to post that nutella is town. That makes no sense, especially since I wouldn't even know he was going to scumread nutella at the time I made that post.

But.

Do mafia often think that town is trying to provoke them by doing this? Like if he's mafia he knows what nutella is. He knows I'm town. If he sees me reading nutella town he's just going to think "oh, this is a townie townreading another townie" (or, if I am bad at the game, he might think "oh, this is a townie townreading my wolf buddy, great"). He's not gonna come anywhere close to viewing it as a provocation or trap or anything like that. It only makes sense if he's town and feels provoked by me townreading nutella because he genuinely thinks she's obvscum and anyone voting her must be trolling or doing something spicy.

[staypositivefriend]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

is it cause i sr you?

[juliets]

Ted is playing scummy on purpose apparently lol.

Because that's what town do on day 1 coming off multiple scum rands...

I need to take a short break. I'm up to this post and just wanted to make a quick comment. I didn't have as strong a reaction about ted being mafia until I got to this post and another like it that tutuu posted. It doesn't make sense to me that ted would want to post scummy on Day 1 coming off other games where he randed scum. I don't understand that, @tedxtr maybe you could explain. If you already did thats fine, I'll get to it soon.

And then do I understand correctly that you voted tutuu in part because she read you as scum after you admitted that you were playing scummy? Maybe I misunderstood or maybe you've already addressed this too, if so I'll get to it.

I'll be gone for a bit and then come back and pick up where I left off.

This weird disparity between the content of the post (clearly implying ted is scum) vs the tone (asking if she misunderstood, the qualifying language used) is kind of offputting to me. On the other hand if there's someone who talks to their scumreads like this it's probably juliet because that's just in her personality

Alison, I do talk to everyone like this when I play mafia and am trying to probe a read (town or mafia). I've witnessed too many misunderstandings between people because someone feels like the other is not showing them respect. You are quite right it's just in my personality. It's NAI, I do it no matter which faction I am.

Ok back to catching up. Someone ping me if I'm needed here.

[Alison]

It’s more than four hours and I’m still townreading sprit, wtf am I supposed to do with this

what about trying to convince other people (specifically the people who scumread sprit) that sprit is town

Ok

Sprit is town

Are you convinced yet?

Shockingly, no

[nutella]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

is it cause i sr you?

no it's cause your smattering of takes doesn't feel much like the spf I saw in g6 and sf3

[tedxtr]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

I was also warming up to a villa lean on you, but now you’re completely in my pocket

I’m such a sucker for your disconnected and overly reasonable play style, it’s like you’re begging to get town read

[Alison]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

yeah, I had the same reaction when I read the catchup. Was just kind of flat. Basically the stuff I talked about with Samu's reads seeming like they're thrown out because a wolf feels obligated to make up some reads, but times ten. rip

[nutella]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

I was also warming up to a villa lean on you, but now you’re completely in my pocket

I’m such a sucker for your disconnected and overly reasonable play style, it’s like you’re begging to get town read

aren't you voting for me


i legit don't know what to do with this i'm so used to you scumreading me is this a pocket

[staypositivefriend]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

is it cause i sr you?

no it's cause your smattering of takes doesn't feel much like the spf I saw in g6 and sf3

that's because my intent was to quickly catch up on the 13+ pages that i missed so that i can be more in the action

also, i don't find you sr'ing me to be scummy, but my problem w/your iso so far is that i've gotten the impression that your focus has been on discrediting townreads moreso than it has been finding town/scum. a lot of the reads you outed felt like you were giving yourself wiggle room to push on people who were being townread

but hey, maybe that's just your playstyle, since i've never actually played w/you until now

[Alison]

Kind of think it's because of the big tonal shift from the excited, energetic entrance into the anemic catchup where you'll quote a post and then just write "town" below it and it's like zzz

Can you talk to me about why you're low-energy right now?

[nutella]

no you made that wolfrange post that was lock town let's just be pals

[Alison]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

is it cause i sr you?

no it's cause your smattering of takes doesn't feel much like the spf I saw in g6 and sf3

that's because my intent was to quickly catch up on the 13+ pages that i missed so that i can be more in the action

also, i don't find you sr'ing me to be scummy, but my problem w/your iso so far is that i've gotten the impression that your focus has been on discrediting townreads moreso than it has been finding town/scum. a lot of the reads you outed felt like you were giving yourself wiggle room to push on people who were being townread

but hey, maybe that's just your playstyle, since i've never actually played w/you until now

I think this amount of hedging is firmly in nutella's town range.

[Samusamu]

tim rolled scum and he's not gonna be lynched until the f3

This is a bold prediction. We should bet!

Question first though...

Why would wolf Tim sheep your avatar reads?

well, why wouldn't he? mafia tend to be a lot more reactive, and they have a tendency to reply to content as opposed to creating it on their own. it gives the impression of scumhunting without having to put work in

I'm crying cause happiness. He uses reactive term, this guy is locktown.

Okey, not , just town vibe

[staypositivefriend]

Kind of think it's because of the big tonal shift from the excited, energetic entrance into the anemic catchup where you'll quote a post and then just write "town" below it and it's like zzz

Can you talk to me about why you're low-energy right now?

my catch-up was "low energy" in the sense that i needed to quickly catch up on the 13 pages that i missed before i go do yard work. my intent was to get a general impression of where the game was so that i could come back in a little while and engage with people instead of perpetually playing catch-up

i don't mind you sr'ing me for that, i'll prove myself later =)

[nutella]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

is it cause i sr you?

no it's cause your smattering of takes doesn't feel much like the spf I saw in g6 and sf3

that's because my intent was to quickly catch up on the 13+ pages that i missed so that i can be more in the action

also, i don't find you sr'ing me to be scummy, but my problem w/your iso so far is that i've gotten the impression that your focus has been on discrediting townreads moreso than it has been finding town/scum. a lot of the reads you outed felt like you were giving yourself wiggle room to push on people who were being townread

but hey, maybe that's just your playstyle, since i've never actually played w/you until now

I agree with the majority of the consensus townreads tbf, I'm just pushing back a bit on the ones I don't quite see

[Alison]

Kind of think it's because of the big tonal shift from the excited, energetic entrance into the anemic catchup where you'll quote a post and then just write "town" below it and it's like zzz

Can you talk to me about why you're low-energy right now?

my catch-up was "low energy" in the sense that i needed to quickly catch up on the 13 pages that i missed before i go do yard work. my intent was to get a general impression of where the game was so that i could come back in a little while and engage with people instead of perpetually playing catch-up

i don't mind you sr'ing me for that, i'll prove myself later =)

I'm suspending judgement of you right now tbh, since my bad read on you is mostly tonal rather than content based and tone - especially this kind of tone - is more sensitive to stuff like life circumstances or who you're talking to. It's why I asked if there was anything that was making you feel low-energy, just in the case explanation was something simple like being tired or hungry or whatever.

I'm probably going to sort you with more confidence once I see you get into gear a bit more and interact with Hally more.

[Alison]

Okay Samu, you're town. Your catchup was good. Maybe not accurate in the sense that I agreed with it, but I can see the town mindset there.

[tedxtr]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

I liked her early on but I think we might have had similar reactions that catchup post just now

I was also warming up to a villa lean on you, but now you’re completely in my pocket

I’m such a sucker for your disconnected and overly reasonable play style, it’s like you’re begging to get town read

aren't you voting for me


i legit don't know what to do with this i'm so used to you scumreading me is this a pocket

I was lurking the thread and was close to submitting a post saying “I think nutella is townier but will keep my vote on her until I have something better”

This is such a weird feeling I’m having, I can’t believe I’m town reading you

[MacDougall]

Mac is scared of my true power. you should be too.

town

I was hoping nutella would out through Sprityo. There's no way town nutella reads him town.

[tedxtr]

Ahhhh spf might be wolfing

I’m actually sad I had to type this out

friendship ended with ted, now the rolling panda in your avatar is my only friend

Please prove me wrong don’t break my heart

[tedxtr]

Mac, why’d you decide to make a full 180 on your decision of slanking the game?

Did you actually rand a good wolf team and feel like you are compelled to try?

[Samusamu]

I cannot believe how my mood matches my avatar! I'm gonna take a little walk.

Just too much pages fluffing dear poison.

I know you are mostly a reactive player but there was a lot to say in these pages to react.

I'm skkiping a lot of thing that are asked or answered causa i dont want to spent to many time being up.

[Dyslexicon]

Wait, this is like the one site I'm not always town. But I'm town this game. Super promise.

Missed you Dizzy, I hope you post gifs this game

Also you should consider signing up for my job after this one

I... can't. Would love to. But I will pla champs finals at some point, and won't sign up for more games before that.

[dyachei]

tedxtr why is it wolfy? And not just kind of not villagery?

[Samusamu]

But u dont have excuses in that moment.

[Herm]

there is a world where jpic is town that enjoys being scum read because it awakens a fuzzy feeling in his nether region

lame

I'm kinkshaming

Stop it, Nutty!

[Alison]

Mac, why’d you decide to make a full 180 on your decision of slanking the game?

Did you actually rand a good wolf team and feel like you are compelled to try?

what are you implying about me???

[Herm]

Hey Samu! How are you?

[Alison]

I don't think I'm prepared for a Mac/nutella war

I want my townreads to all townread each other

[Herm]

I cannot believe how my mood matches my avatar! I'm gonna take a little walk.

Just too much pages fluffing dear poison.

I know you are mostly a reactive player but there was a lot to say in these pages to react.

I'm skkiping a lot of thing that are asked or answered causa i dont want to spent to many time being up.

You can at least skip the first 1-7 pages. Only fluff I think.

[Herm]

I don't think I'm prepared for a Mac/nutella war

I want my townreads to all townread each other

Mac and Cheese with a side order of Nutella.

Probably tastes atrocious.

[tedxtr]

tedxtr why is it wolfy? And not just kind of not villagery?

I didn’t like the sprit read, felt like she painted it in a bad light

It felt like a wolf that’s grabbing a textbook way of faking reads but it’s applied in the wrong context, thus not actually sorting the game in a genuine way

It has just now occurred to me that you probably don’t know I’m insomnia, I’m still stuck on the fact that you actually think I have a good wolf game

[Alison]

I cannot believe how my mood matches my avatar! I'm gonna take a little walk.

Just too much pages fluffing dear poison.

I know you are mostly a reactive player but there was a lot to say in these pages to react.

I'm skkiping a lot of thing that are asked or answered causa i dont want to spent to many time being up.

You can at least skip the first 1-7 pages. Only fluff I think.

Disagree. Lots of people bleeding town in those pages. I read those pages and came to the conclusion that there were so many obvious townies in the game that I would be best served by focusing my efforts on confirming and organizing my townreads rather than trying to pin down wolves one by one.

[dyachei]

tedxtr why is it wolfy? And not just kind of not villagery?

I didn’t like the sprit read, felt like she painted it in a bad light

It felt like a wolf that’s grabbing a textbook way of faking reads but it’s applied in the wrong context, thus not actually sorting the game in a genuine way

It has just now occurred to me that you probably don’t know I’m insomnia, I’m still stuck on the fact that you actually think I have a good wolf game

you do have a good wolf game though

and I know who you are

[Samusamu]

I think both Tim and Poison are >rand W, Tim perhaps more than Poison but if that's the case I'll make sure to not interact with Tim because I don't wanna get into a huge back on forth that nobody's gonna get anything out of.

Will probably post something about each of them a lot later if I'm still convinced on their alignments.

or maybe I'll do so D2 and meme for the rest of the phase

Are you seriously not wolf? Wolf!ted would be like "Poison is a easy read"

Poison acting like trying to do a real research after other guy say she was wolf.

[Alison]

I continue to have problems with getting a good read on dyachei. They've posted quite a bit now and are still null for me. Is anyone here good at reading dya?

[tedxtr]

tedxtr why is it wolfy? And not just kind of not villagery?

I didn’t like the sprit read, felt like she painted it in a bad light

It felt like a wolf that’s grabbing a textbook way of faking reads but it’s applied in the wrong context, thus not actually sorting the game in a genuine way

It has just now occurred to me that you probably don’t know I’m insomnia, I’m still stuck on the fact that you actually think I have a good wolf game

you do have a good wolf game though

and I know who you are

weirdchamp

[Alison]

Samusamu, your scumreads are poison and nutella right?

[Samusamu]

*takes out the lie detector*

@Timsup2nothin, @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME talk to me. Are you scum this game?

Again

[dyachei]

I continue to have problems with getting a good read on dyachei. They've posted quite a bit now and are still null for me. Is anyone here good at reading dya?

my d1 isn't my strong point. I tend to do much better after n1. Ask anyone in anni

[tedxtr]

Mindmelding with nutella actually gave me like an impulse to solve the game

This is amazing, I’ve been awakened

[tedxtr]

Sucks that it happened at 1AM and I probably won’t give a damn by the time i wake up

[Alison]

I continue to have problems with getting a good read on dyachei. They've posted quite a bit now and are still null for me. Is anyone here good at reading dya?

my d1 isn't my strong point. I tend to do much better after n1. Ask anyone in anni

Alright, I believe you. I'll give you a D1 immunity from execution pass. Show us you're town D2 onwards.