Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]

[staypositivefriend]

i will be hardpushing on JPIC tomorrow and not stopping

[Alison]

what argument even?

Town Watcher being the most powerful town role period?

it is tho

I mean this is a silly debate because it lacks context. It depends so much on the setup. If we're only going by common town roles, then cop is better in a mostly vanilla game, while Watcher is great in role madness games where you can get a lot of info off a single watch. Vigilante is by far the most powerful in the hands of someone with good reads, and by far the least powerful in the hands of someone with bad reads, etc.

[Alison]

im gay

nice mindmeld, you're town

[Timsup2nothin]

someone clue me in on where we're at with MR

MR claimed to have graverobbed Nutella power and protected Alison last night, which seems to account for the no kill.

However there is some question based on what Alison was told by Sloonei that she may have been jailkept or roleblocked.

It is plausible that some town Jailkeeper actually did the save, but why Radishes would make a fake claim out of the blue into a counter is an issue.

I am inclined to believe Radishes for the most part here.

[Alison]

someone clue me in on where we're at with MR

he's town

[staypositivefriend]

im gay

nice mindmeld, you're town

the classic "im gay" towntell, it works every time!

[Timsup2nothin]

There are now 20 players, and 80% plus of them are civilians. I know that was probably obvious and useless, but I just got my "this is your power tonight" notice.

[TonyStarkPrime]

There are now 20 players, and 80% plus of them are civilians. I know that was probably obvious and useless, but I just got my "this is your power tonight" notice.

so exactly 4 non town left?

[TonyStarkPrime]

3 wolves one rogue?

[TonyStarkPrime]

this might actually be a town win

[Timsup2nothin]

Yeah...that tracks TSP.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Yeah...that tracks TSP.

get spec chat in here to call this a joat soft

[Hally]

i have now played five cumulative game days with spf

scum has been killed on all five

spf is too powerful

pretty sure that it's physically impossible for us to lynch wrong when we're in a game together

clearly

[Hally]

3 wolves one rogue?

dope

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Ok someone let me know when everyone can accept that I’m cleared and/or when I need to start trying again

[Oddmerta]

Well tim, I still don't trust you but you are loking a bit better now

[Herm]

should i be worried that every post i read from herm is about whether watcher is a good role

what about the flipped mafia though

you should maybe be worried but it's a really weird line for scum to take, no?

i mean maybe but im probably gonna kill it though

Let me know in advance first lol.

[TonyStarkPrime]

jpic
[nude]
wolf

[TonyStarkPrime]

could be nanook i guess someone say that I tmied

[Timsup2nothin]

Ok someone let me know when everyone can accept that I’m cleared and/or when I need to start trying again

I'm leaning that you are a third party post capper myself, with unknown additional and almost certainly dangerous powers, so I think you shouldn't relax yet.

[TonyStarkPrime]

nanook probably can get away with the claim but I'm still not sure why JPIC couldn't have

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Ok someone let me know when everyone can accept that I’m cleared and/or when I need to start trying again

I'm leaning that you are a third party post capper myself, with unknown additional and almost certainly dangerous powers, so I think you shouldn't relax yet.

If I had post capped joe I 100% would’ve claimed it and trolled him kek

[Alison]

i still think herm is town!

[Herm]

Am I confirmed now yet or...?

no but there’s one mafia in you/jpic and if he flips anything except post-capper you’re getting turboed

Oh right. Mac said two negative actions happened to him last night.

I assume Sprityo was the one sent for the kill.

Not sure if they would send a Role Cop as well?

[Alison]

Ok someone let me know when everyone can accept that I’m cleared and/or when I need to start trying again

I'm leaning that you are a third party post capper myself, with unknown additional and almost certainly dangerous powers, so I think you shouldn't relax yet.

If I had post capped joe I 100% would’ve claimed it and trolled him kek

no you wouldn't, you'd have been turboexed if you claimed a postcap on mac since no town does that

[Herm]

i still think herm is town!

I am town.

Don't kill me.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Ok someone let me know when everyone can accept that I’m cleared and/or when I need to start trying again

I'm leaning that you are a third party post capper myself, with unknown additional and almost certainly dangerous powers, so I think you shouldn't relax yet.

If I had post capped joe I 100% would’ve claimed it and trolled him kek

no you wouldn't, you'd have been turboexed if you claimed a postcap on mac since no town does that

I mean

I’m pretty sure I could get away with claiming it on joe specifically

[Alison]

Am I confirmed now yet or...?

no but there’s one mafia in you/jpic and if he flips anything except post-capper you’re getting turboed

Oh right. Mac said two negative actions happened to him last night.

I assume Sprityo was the one sent for the kill.

Not sure if they would send a Role Cop as well?

Mac was not targeted for killing last night. I believe your derpclear though!

Sprityo was sent to mess with Mac's night results ([mention]MacDougall[/mention] make sure you see this bit, just in case you did have mech info from night actions) and we think JPIC might have role copped him. it's unclear what nanook did, some think he post capped mac. another possibility is that JPIC did the post cap.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I already claimed what I did, if I target the NK I get an extra vote the next day. It isn’t that unclear tbh, either you believe my claim or you think I’m lying, either way pretty clear!

[Herm]

Oh, I thought the negative actions implied attacks.

No one else said anything surviving attacks.

I get it, my bad.

So in that case, they probably rolecopped him.

[Oddmerta]

I should not be sussed for wanting jpic to die today and spirit to die tomorrow

[Timsup2nothin]

nanook probably can get away with the claim but I'm still not sure why JPIC couldn't have

Nanook claimed "witness at the NK and get rewarded a second vote."

I can see JPIC as "role cop that also post caps" but honestly I think post capper conflicts with "screw up Mac's results." Like I'd want Macposting as much as possible if I screwed up his results.

So I'm thinking the post capper is third party.

I know, everyone thinks I'm the third party, bet we'll deal with that bridge later.

[TonyStarkPrime]

I should not be sussed for wanting jpic to die today and spirit to die tomorrow

hmm raising questions that haven't yet been posed?

[TonyStarkPrime]

I guess I do that all the time so it's not exactly a bad thing

[Oddmerta]

I should not be sussed for wanting jpic to die today and spirit to die tomorrow

hmm raising questions that haven't yet been posed?

Yes

[Timsup2nothin]

I already claimed what I did, if I target the NK I get an extra vote the next day. It isn’t that unclear tbh, either you believe my claim or you think I’m lying, either way pretty clear!

Well...there is a middle ground called I acknowledge that you MIGHT be lying.

[Oddmerta]

Lovely night we're having

[Hally]

Oh, I thought the negative actions implied attacks.

No one else said anything surviving attacks.

I get it, my bad.

So in that case, they probably rolecopped him.

i wanna believe this derp tbh

[Timsup2nothin]

Lovely night we're having

It is.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Oh, I thought the negative actions implied attacks.

No one else said anything surviving attacks.

I get it, my bad.

So in that case, they probably rolecopped him.

i wanna believe this derp tbh

I do

[Alison]

I already claimed what I did, if I target the NK I get an extra vote the next day. It isn’t that unclear tbh, either you believe my claim or you think I’m lying, either way pretty clear!

when I said unclear I meant that there are a few possibilities.

1) you could be town and did what you said you did

2) you could be mafia and post capped nanook

3) you could be mafia and did something else unspecified to nanook, while jpic your buddy post capped nanook (this one is less likely since it involves the whole mafia team going to top town's house, but I have to cover the possibility)

4) you could be rogue and did something nefarious to nanook (collecting his song name for your soup kill, dousing him in gas, post capping him, whatever) while JPIC and sprityo role copped + misled nanook

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I already claimed what I did, if I target the NK I get an extra vote the next day. It isn’t that unclear tbh, either you believe my claim or you think I’m lying, either way pretty clear!

Well...there is a middle ground called I acknowledge that you MIGHT be lying.

That’s...I already said the “you think I’m lying” option tho

[Hally]

nanook probably can get away with the claim but I'm still not sure why JPIC couldn't have

Nanook claimed "witness at the NK and get rewarded a second vote."

I can see JPIC as "role cop that also post caps" but honestly I think post capper conflicts with "screw up Mac's results." Like I'd want Macposting as much as possible if I screwed up his results.

So I'm thinking the post capper is third party.

I know, everyone thinks I'm the third party, bet we'll deal with that bridge later.

i don’t think post capper necessarily conflicts with the result tampering

doesn’t matter though. the post capper isn’t town or they would have claimed. so whether they’re 3p or scum doesn’t matter. we’re just killing jpic and if he’s not the capper we’re killing nook

[Oddmerta]

Like if you thought that there was no way in hell that jpic was a town cop you'd want him gone first

[Alison]

nanook probably can get away with the claim but I'm still not sure why JPIC couldn't have

Nanook claimed "witness at the NK and get rewarded a second vote."

I can see JPIC as "role cop that also post caps" but honestly I think post capper conflicts with "screw up Mac's results." Like I'd want Macposting as much as possible if I screwed up his results.

So I'm thinking the post capper is third party.

I know, everyone thinks I'm the third party, bet we'll deal with that bridge later.

we'll find out after we exe JPIC!

[Alison]

Oh, I thought the negative actions implied attacks.

No one else said anything surviving attacks.

I get it, my bad.

So in that case, they probably rolecopped him.

i wanna believe this derp tbh

I do

i also do

[TonyStarkPrime]

I should not be sussed for wanting jpic to die today and spirit to die tomorrow

hmm raising questions that haven't yet been posed?

Yes

luckily I was the only one on this track and I had no intention of reading back to find who it was going to implicate

[Alison]

nanook probably can get away with the claim but I'm still not sure why JPIC couldn't have

Nanook claimed "witness at the NK and get rewarded a second vote."

I can see JPIC as "role cop that also post caps" but honestly I think post capper conflicts with "screw up Mac's results." Like I'd want Macposting as much as possible if I screwed up his results.

So I'm thinking the post capper is third party.

I know, everyone thinks I'm the third party, bet we'll deal with that bridge later.

i don’t think post capper necessarily conflicts with the result tampering

doesn’t matter though. the post capper isn’t town or they would have claimed. so whether they’re 3p or scum doesn’t matter. we’re just killing jpic and if he’s not the capper we’re killing nook

the hard world is figuring out whether it's correct to exe nook if jpic flips capper tbh

[TonyStarkPrime]

nanook probably can get away with the claim but I'm still not sure why JPIC couldn't have

Nanook claimed "witness at the NK and get rewarded a second vote."

I can see JPIC as "role cop that also post caps" but honestly I think post capper conflicts with "screw up Mac's results." Like I'd want Macposting as much as possible if I screwed up his results.

So I'm thinking the post capper is third party.

I know, everyone thinks I'm the third party, bet we'll deal with that bridge later.

i don’t think post capper necessarily conflicts with the result tampering

doesn’t matter though. the post capper isn’t town or they would have claimed. so whether they’re 3p or scum doesn’t matter. we’re just killing jpic and if he’s not the capper we’re killing nook

the hard world is figuring out whether it's correct to exe nook if jpic flips capper tbh

it's not

[Hally]

nanook probably can get away with the claim but I'm still not sure why JPIC couldn't have

Nanook claimed "witness at the NK and get rewarded a second vote."

I can see JPIC as "role cop that also post caps" but honestly I think post capper conflicts with "screw up Mac's results." Like I'd want Macposting as much as possible if I screwed up his results.

So I'm thinking the post capper is third party.

I know, everyone thinks I'm the third party, bet we'll deal with that bridge later.

i don’t think post capper necessarily conflicts with the result tampering

doesn’t matter though. the post capper isn’t town or they would have claimed. so whether they’re 3p or scum doesn’t matter. we’re just killing jpic and if he’s not the capper we’re killing nook

the hard world is figuring out whether it's correct to exe nook if jpic flips capper tbh

i don’t think nook should be allowed to endgame regardless of what jpic flips. if jpic flips capper we don’t have to turbo nook but i don’t really want him endgamimg