Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Poison]

Maybe the mafia have known Herm was 3p since n1

Then why didn't they kill him?

[Herm]

Good morning!

[Poison]

So is odd town in any way?

some people told me that before today but i don't like how they've approached this game

I agree tbh

[Dyslexicon]

Ahhh!! Nice... So you are slanking this game because?

Because I signed up for this game forever ago, when I actually had more time to play. When this game began, I was also in another game on MU and spent the time I had on mafia there. This game has now ended, so I can be around here a bit more. Also, I was absolutely not in a position to follow a game this size, and still am not. That is why. Is that a problem?

You want to scum read me so hard. xD

[MacDougall]

I'm gonna go with Herm being 3p and the mafia being Oddmerta and Tedxtr. Any objections with this theory?

remind me why ted?

He's currently voting weird. He spent today trying to discredit me and has been hostile and paranoid today in a situation where town should be confident. And we're forgetting that somehow he acted through Tim's now confirmed roleblock?

[juliets]

What does "ninja modified" mean?

[Poison]

Ted can be scum, I can see the possibilities there. Basically my scum reads atm

BTW is long con checked?

[Dyslexicon]

What does "ninja modified" mean?

Ninjas are normally immune to trackers and watchers, I believe? So that, plus something?

[MacDougall]

I think the mafia roleblocked Tutuu to fire at Alison last night but missed for some reason. Perhaps someone else protected Alison, or perhaps Alison hasn't mentioned she has a BP. Or perhaps they didn't fire at Alison but instead fired at me or SPF and one of us had a vest.

I think they shot at Alison n1 and Tutuu saved her.

I think they double stacked on Hally with the 3p.

imagine not rolling unlimited-claiming unconditional cop with a bulletproof vest every single game

but more seriously, my theory was that whoever did the roleblocking and whoever did the killing were different people.

here's a narrative for you to chew on. 3P can roleblock targets. they go "hm, a lot of people suspect there's a scum-sided roleblocker in the game. the mafia know it isn't them, so they'll know 3P can roleblock. only one protective is on alison, and alison is a big threat to them because she's the one that can most rapidly mech solve the game. what if I roleblocked tutuu, the scum expect me to do that so they can shoot alison, and then the scum shoots alison?" and then they execute their plan and the mafia goes and fires at MR instead.

there are some holes in this narrative, like the 3P taking a massive risk in assuming the mafia knows what they're doing. but it's an idea.

the other idea is that a redirector redirected the roleblocker. if the redirector had some ability to mess with the roles of who they block, that could explain why tutuu was given a notification despite her not being supposed to receive one.

I think the truth is simply that the town have someone who either can't claim, or won't claim that actually landed a save on who the mafia were really trying to target.

[MacDougall]

What does "ninja modified" mean?

Ninjas are normally immune to trackers and watchers, I believe? So that, plus something?

There is confirmed a strongkiller in the game. Almost certainly a ninja to counter the tracker watcher. If Ted is strong then he just works through a roleblock.

[Poison]

Ahhh!! Nice... So you are slanking this game because?

Because I signed up for this game forever ago, when I actually had more time to play. When this game began, I was also in another game on MU and spent the time I had on mafia there. This game has now ended, so I can be around here a bit more. Also, I was absolutely not in a position to follow a game this size, and still am not. That is why. Is that a problem?

You want to scum read me so hard. xD

Ikrrrr I cannot believe playing a game with 7k posts.

Ikrrrr x2. I think I'm getting my tunnel vision here

[Dyslexicon]

There is confirmed a strongkiller in the game. Almost certainly a ninja to counter the tracker watcher. If Ted is strong then he just works through a roleblock.

Yeah. But if you're talking about N1, he targeted Tim, and Tim didn't die or anything. WE DID THAT.

[juliets]

What does "ninja modified" mean?

Ninjas are normally immune to trackers and watchers, I believe? So that, plus something?

There is confirmed a strongkiller in the game. Almost certainly a ninja to counter the tracker watcher. If Ted is strong then he just works through a roleblock.

Ohh yes that would make sense.

[Sloonei]

Day 4



'And now I'll set you free.'

Herm has been eliminated. He was...

Spoiler: show

Lotus Flower
Album: The King of Limbs

'Slowly we unfurl as lotus flowers.’
Each Night you will identify a Radiohead album. If there is a song from that album associated with a non-civilian role in the game, you will be given a glimpse of that song’s role card. There is no guarantee that you will receive a complete role card, but you will never receive a false role. In the event that an album features multiple non-civilian songs, you will only receive a report from one song/role at a time.
If there is no non-civilian role associated with that album, a random civilian role from that album (if there are any) will be notified of your search (you will not be identified in this message.)
If you do not receive a vote in the final poll on Day 1, you gain a bulletproof vest for Night 1 only.
Upon your death, you may reveal the description of a mafia role of your choice.

You are a Civilian. You win when all threats are eliminated.

It is Night 4. Players have 24 hours to submit their night actions.
Note: The start of the next Day phase may be delayed ~1 hour.

[MacDougall]

Mafia roleblocked Tutuu so they could fire at Alison
Player X stopped that kill (roleblocked the killer or has an actual save and is forced to not claim it or hiding their claim)
3p killer scanned King of Limbs and killed Radishes whose song is from that record

This is my understanding of events and I am sticking to it.

[MacDougall]

Or not I guess moving on.

[staypositivefriend]

sigh

[Dyslexicon]

Ikrrrr I cannot believe playing a game with 7k posts.

Ikrrrr x2. I think I'm getting my tunnel vision here

Yeah, I can't do it.

And also yeah, I don't know why. Just every time you come into the thread you have it out for me for some reason. Is it the face? You can be honest. It's the face, isn't it? =p

[Dyslexicon]

Wtf lol what HAHAHA! I was half hoping that would be the case xD

[MacDougall]

There is confirmed a strongkiller in the game. Almost certainly a ninja to counter the tracker watcher. If Ted is strong then he just works through a roleblock.

Yeah. But if you're talking about N1, he targeted Tim, and Tim didn't die or anything. WE DID THAT.

He targeted Tim despite Tim roleblocking him. Strong.

[Dyslexicon]

Oddmerta tried to soft the song that Herm flipped. Oddmerta is absolutely scum.

[MacDougall]

Herm's flip gives us a fair bit of info now. His role is different from what I understood it as.

[MacDougall]

Oddmerta tried to soft the song that Herm flipped. Oddmerta is absolutely scum.

That's why Herm townread him. I am assuming that Lotus Flower are words in that message.

If Oddmerta got a message, and Herm believed it, then Oddmerta has to be town. It makes sense that Oddmerta stays off the wagon now. Oddmerta is absolutely town lol.

[Dyslexicon]

Can you guess why I asked you to check King of Limbs?

I'm using flowery language to get my point across

^Here. Looks like a soft to me.

[TonyStarkPrime]

I didn’t visit MR. Has Herm claimed 3P or something or is life going as normal

Herm 3p makes odd mafia directly, do you think odd is mafia?

Enlighten me as to why.

[staypositivefriend]

Can you guess why I asked you to check King of Limbs?

I'm using flowery language to get my point across

^Here. Looks like a soft to me.

yeah this might make him town in theory

[TonyStarkPrime]

okay wait I figured it out I'm smart

[Dyslexicon]

Oddmerta tried to soft the song that Herm flipped. Oddmerta is absolutely scum.

That's why Herm townread him. I am assuming that Lotus Flower are words in that message.

If Oddmerta got a message, and Herm believed it, then Oddmerta has to be town. It makes sense that Oddmerta stays off the wagon now. Oddmerta is absolutely town lol.

Wait what? This makes no sense. Also, I didn't read Herm's role actually, so I will do that. But does this mean we're actually missing confirmations from town? Or are there no songs from Amnesiac or something?

[MacDougall]

If there is no non-civilian role associated with that album, a random civilian role from that album (if there are any) will be notified of your search (you will not be identified in this message.)

Okay so there are no mafia in any of the albums that he scanned at all?

No mafia in Kid A, Amnesiac or King of Limbs.

Anyone dare claim a song from those three records? Lol.

[Alison]

How about a good info-cfd?

no

the answer will always be no in games you play with me sorry

I don't believe in CFDs unless we have really strong reason, like a trust tell, a cop check or other mech info, or a really convincing defense/really damning scumslip happening at EoD. I don't have many hard rules when I play mafia but this is one of them. (well, technically this isn't really a hard rule since there's exceptions)

It was a joke.

sorry I am just conditioned to fight against the idea because I have seen way too many good games destroyed by someone going "hey let's exe someone else" and then we lose

also I think there has been some discussion and some people feel CFD is offensive because it stands for Chinese Fire Drill so some people are using flash wagon instead

[TonyStarkPrime]

ha herm town nice work spa

[Dyslexicon]

I thought he was trying to soft Herm's song, and got caught. But that kind of doesn't make sense I guess. =p

[Alison]

So is odd town in any way?

some people told me that before today but i don't like how they've approached this game

if it's worth anything I was the biggest odd defender and now I think he has high scum equity

[TonyStarkPrime]

I probably should get off my behind at this point

[MacDougall]

Oddmerta tried to soft the song that Herm flipped. Oddmerta is absolutely scum.

That's why Herm townread him. I am assuming that Lotus Flower are words in that message.

If Oddmerta got a message, and Herm believed it, then Oddmerta has to be town. It makes sense that Oddmerta stays off the wagon now. Oddmerta is absolutely town lol.

Wait what? This makes no sense. Also, I didn't read Herm's role actually, so I will do that. But does this mean we're actually missing confirmations from town? Or are there no songs from Amnesiac or something?

How does it make no sense? He scans an album and a random town gets a message. The message is probably lyrics from the song or something. Oddmerta then softs that so Herm sees it. Herm then says "Oddmerta did something that makes him town".

Oddmerta is town.

[Alison]

I think the truth is simply that the town have someone who either can't claim, or won't claim that actually landed a save on who the mafia were really trying to target.

got it, that makes a lot of sense to me. it would fit with the way the night action claims have gone today.

[MacDougall]

So now I am thinking that mafia are Ted and Samu. Tell me why they aren't.

[Dyslexicon]

If there is no non-civilian role associated with that album, a random civilian role from that album (if there are any) will be notified of your search (you will not be identified in this message.)

Okay so there are no mafia in any of the albums that he scanned at all?

No mafia in Kid A, Amnesiac or King of Limbs.

Anyone dare claim a song from those three records? Lol.

I have a song from another record. Rip.

I can't believe that role was actually real. Holy shit, that is some weird thing. Herm was like "Oh, yeah, and I was tracked because one, but only one person, get's notified. That explains it all." Sounded like the most desperate story, and then it was true. LOL

[MacDougall]

Ted was acting like Herm was a misyeet all day. TMI. Ted is a TMI machine too.

[TonyStarkPrime]

I assume whoever got the message couldn't directly claim it, but we're assuming it was Odd anyways?

[MacDougall]

If there is no non-civilian role associated with that album, a random civilian role from that album (if there are any) will be notified of your search (you will not be identified in this message.)

Okay so there are no mafia in any of the albums that he scanned at all?

No mafia in Kid A, Amnesiac or King of Limbs.

Anyone dare claim a song from those three records? Lol.

I have a song from another record. Rip.

I can't believe that role was actually real. Holy shit, that is some weird thing. Herm was like "Oh, yeah, and I was tracked because one, but only one person, get's notified. That explains it all." Sounded like the most desperate story, and then it was true. LOL

What record?

[MacDougall]

Alison can you cop check Ted plz lol

[TonyStarkPrime]

No one gave off hints that Herm informed them previosuly though

[staypositivefriend]

So now I am thinking that mafia are Ted and Samu. Tell me why they aren't.

do we have a reason to believe that wilgy is town?

[Dyslexicon]

Ok. I get it. I didn't actually read Herm's role before now. And now I have to track fucking Oddmerta lol.

Actually, I should just not track.

[MacDougall]

So Alison is on a record he scanned and didn't get alerted. So I am assuming that at least once, maybe even twice based on how the votes went here that the person who got notified was the dead town LOL.

[Alison]

What does "ninja modified" mean?

Ninjas are normally immune to trackers and watchers, I believe? So that, plus something?

There is confirmed a strongkiller in the game. Almost certainly a ninja to counter the tracker watcher. If Ted is strong then he just works through a roleblock.

ted was tracked to tim the same night he violated the roleblock - so what is mafia ted doing at tim's house?

[MacDougall]

So now I am thinking that mafia are Ted and Samu. Tell me why they aren't.

do we have a reason to believe that wilgy is town?

Poison confirmed he's a song from OK Computer. We already have a dead mafia from OK Computer.

[MacDougall]

What does "ninja modified" mean?

Ninjas are normally immune to trackers and watchers, I believe? So that, plus something?

There is confirmed a strongkiller in the game. Almost certainly a ninja to counter the tracker watcher. If Ted is strong then he just works through a roleblock.

ted was tracked to tim the same night he violated the roleblock - so what is mafia ted doing at tim's house?

Rolecopping him?

[Dyslexicon]

What record?

I don't know if I should say. It's from an album there have been no flips from yet.