Overtime Mafia [Post-Game]

[Long Con]

So you think I intended to clash with a real doc claim? How does that make a scum victory?

[Alison]

So you think I intended to clash with a real doc claim? How does that make a scum victory?

if you thought the real doc was Marmot or Wilgy or someone you could exe, then them CC-ing would be pretty good for you. Under that scenario, you'd vote Marmot/Wilgy off, and then thunderdome Esooa and rely on eg. me to help vote her.

[Long Con]

That's not what I was going for. I was just doing cover, hoping that a) the doc would take it, and b) would get that I'm trying to help her. I'm not really down with fake claim shenanigans as a wolf.

[Long Con]

I think I have one fake claim conflict in my entire Mafia history as a wolf. And that one was earlier this year, and it was either fake claim or straight up lose the game.

[Marmot]

The Syndicate isn't exactly known for its roleclaims. Heck roleclaiming was typically against the rules for the first few years of the Syndicate's existence.

[Marmot]

I think I know who the doctors are, and I don't understand why you'd add another claim to the mix of those people. I think claiming early to cover for them makes sense (see tutuu in Making Friends claiming Mason), but cc'ing at this point in the game doesn't.

[Marmot]

CC'ing as a VT that is.

[Grand Scheme]

I think I know who the doctors are, and I don't understand why you'd add another claim to the mix of those people. I think claiming early to cover for them makes sense (see tutuu in Making Friends claiming Mason), but cc'ing at this point in the game doesn't.

so it's okay to cover early in the game but as soon as day 2 starts it's way too late.

You understand that I don't come from a heavy claiming culture, yet I'm probably scum trying to brute force my way past two genuine claims.

You are very likely a wolf.

[Long Con]

^ I authorize this handsome stranger to speak for me

[Marmot]

I think I know who the doctors are, and I don't understand why you'd add another claim to the mix of those people. I think claiming early to cover for them makes sense (see tutuu in Making Friends claiming Mason), but cc'ing at this point in the game doesn't.

so it's okay to cover early in the game but as soon as day 2 starts it's way too late.

You understand that I don't come from a heavy claiming culture, yet I'm probably scum trying to brute force my way past two genuine claims.

You are very likely a wolf.

?

[Marmot]

Lol

[Esooa]

I mean, I specifically asked you to hard claim

[falcon45ca]

I mean, I specifically asked you to hard claim

True, I remember that!

[Grand Scheme]

Hard claims make the best cover.

[Marmot]

So do alter-egos.

[Long Con]

They totally do.

[Long Con]

I don't get it, really, I claim doctor but all someone has to do is say is that a hard claim? And then I have to to say oh no, it was just cover. Like, that's what I'd say if I really was a doctor, you know?

[Long Con]

Wolves might claim doctor, but I'd say it's pretty rare for wolves to counterclaim doctor.

[tedxtr]

so i've skimmed marmot's last scum game because they obv haven't played in a while and I wanted to have an idea about how they play

still feel like going for them is optimal. i do feel like there's a slight difference in tone, but they fail at being villagery or having any villagery thoughts.

this claim thing is pretty lame and LC shouldn't go based only off of it.

[tedxtr]

in the end, we're prob gonna get schooled by some wolves that we don't expect

I personally have a hard time getting any confident read in and most of it is because there are about 3 new people (even if one of them is claimed doc) and the people that I know are playing as if they're other people (Alison, tutuu)

kinda hard to get my teeth into this game but I'll try having better posts during the night and settle for some reads, no matter how bad they are

even tho it's not really my style

[tedxtr]

assuming tutuu and Esooa are telling the truth

i feel good just straight up flipping alison here because i'll probably never be able to get a villager read there

or marmot. i think this LC thing is a mistake.

if he does end up flipping a wolf though, it'll probably be for entirely unrelated reasons, but the current push on him is such a cop out. what are his motives for claiming there as a wolf when he really doesn't need to?

[Esooa]

he hard claimed a role he isn't. Do you make nothing of that?

[Long Con]

It was for the right reasons.

[tedxtr]

he hard claimed a role he isn't. Do you make nothing of that?

villagers do dumb stuff all the time

[Long Con]

he hard claimed a role he isn't. Do you make nothing of that?

villagers do dumb stuff all the time

I just forgot that no one is allowed to doc cover past Day 1. I should study more I guess.

[Esooa]

he hard claimed a role he isn't. Do you make nothing of that?

villagers do dumb stuff all the time

And the strongman shot on mac?

[tedxtr]

what about that?

[DrWilgy]

I have no clue about the unholyfuckery that is occuring.

I'm voting Alison and LC. After sleeping on the Alison kerfunkle, I think it's best we resolve one of the 50-50s.

Voting LC because I trust papa Joeseph.

[Esooa]

what about that?

Why did they strongman him?

[MartinGG99]

temp thread lock



You may select up to 2 options


Alison
4
16%
Voters: Long Con, tedxtr, Marmot, DrWilgy
Esooa
0
No votes
Voters: None
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
Long Con
7
28%
Voters: Esooa, DrWilgy, Marmot, falcon45ca, Alison, tutuu, sig
MacDougall
0
No votes
Voters: None
Marmot
3
12%
Voters: Long Con, tedxtr, sig
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
0
No votes
Voters: None
Poison / DrWilgy
1
4%
Voters: falcon45ca
sig
0
No votes
Voters: None
tedxtr
0
No votes
Voters: None
tutuu
0
No votes
Voters: None
Skip
0
No votes
Voters: None

[MartinGG99]

Long Con
7
28%
Voters: Esooa, DrWilgy, Marmot, falcon45ca, Alison, tutuu, sig

Obviously, the person with 7 votes (Long Con) has died. They were

Spoiler: show

Vanilla Town

Regarding Nanook, they were

Spoiler: show

Vanilla Town

I would also like to say that the past 48 hours has been enlightening, and it would appear to me that different players have different perspectives or opinions on rules and how they should be handled.

I have personally come to the conclusion that my mod-kill of Nanook was at least partially wrong, and how I worded the rule. That said, post-game I will be posting my thoughts regarding my actions, and as well as asking for your guys thoughts and opinions because I strive to try and become the best host that I can be, and it would be important to me if you guys could do that post-game.


Anyways, Night 2 ends in a little less than 24 hours from now. Remember your SoD2 post-cap is still in effect until SoD3.

[Long Con]

The nice thing about Mafia is you always get to learn.

Spoiler: show

Good luck to my wolf teammates I guess?

[Esooa]

lmaoo bruh

anyways LC never hard claim a role you don't have pleasee lol

[Marmot]

LC might be learning something, but I feel like I haven't learned anything.

[tutuu]

to say that im moderately annoyed would be an understatement

[tutuu]

imagine forcing me to out myself and then having the audacity to talk shit to me

[tutuu]

dont feel like playing

[Alison]

rip

I wanna exe ted for previous behavior, TMI-ing LC town when everyone else thought he was scum, and saying he thought the wolves were deep and then wanting to go for a level 1 exe on me

[Alison]

I think I'm just back to my old POE of ted, Marmot, Wilgy.

[DrWilgy]

I still have no clue what happened re claims.

[tedxtr]

“TMIng LC town”

All I’ve done was to say that he has no incentive to do what he’s done as a wolf and that his push was a cop out.

But classic, I made a simple point and instead of having common sense I gotta be scum for it

[Alison]

“TMIng LC town”

All I’ve done was to say that he has no incentive to do what he’s done as a wolf and that his push was a cop out.

But classic, I made a simple point and instead of having common sense I gotta be scum for it

Literally everyone thought LC was scum as shit but somehow you're the only person who magically knows the push was wrong. He was caught faking a roleclaim.

[tedxtr]

so the fact that everyone thought wrong makes me scum?

lol

[Alison]

so the fact that everyone thought wrong makes me scum?

lol

yes

that's what TMI means

[tedxtr]

if you really wanna yeet me, "you were right and had common sense" isn't exactly a case that's gonna get me exe'd

good luck

man this game is about the weirdest one I've had in a while. should just retire from normals.

[Alison]

It wasn't common sense dude LC literally lied about being a doctor

how the fuck would you think or know he was town

[tedxtr]

by realising that nobody as a wolf would claim there

and 7 people being on the same wagon without caring one bit

even after the fact, nobody is able to give a reason as to why LC would've had to claim as a scum there. which is what i asked of you in the first place.

[Alison]

So you think I intended to clash with a real doc claim? How does that make a scum victory?

if you thought the real doc was Marmot or Wilgy or someone you could exe, then them CC-ing would be pretty good for you. Under that scenario, you'd vote Marmot/Wilgy off, and then thunderdome Esooa and rely on eg. me to help vote her.

^^^

[Alison]

I know I'm town. Esooa and tutuu are the docs. sig has played much townier than you/Marmot/Wilgy, and also has a derpclear in his favor. Even if you disregard the derpclear he's still townie on play.

So either there's two mafia in [you/Marmot/Wilgy] or sig is mafia. I think the former is the most likely possibility right now.

[Alison]

by realising that nobody as a wolf would claim there

and 7 people being on the same wagon without caring one bit

even after the fact, nobody is able to give a reason as to why LC would've had to claim as a scum there. which is what i asked of you in the first place.

7 people isn't an argument. If LC was really scum who just got caught lying, his teammates would be forced to bus. I've outed a good reason scum LC has to claim.