Overtime Mafia [Post-Game]

[tedxtr]

my progression at EoD1 is about the most clearing thing that somebody still alive in this game could have

if you are a villager not seeing it then we can just thunderdome tomorrow, idrc

[tedxtr]

by realising that nobody as a wolf would claim there

and 7 people being on the same wagon without caring one bit

even after the fact, nobody is able to give a reason as to why LC would've had to claim as a scum there. which is what i asked of you in the first place.

7 people isn't an argument. If LC was really scum who just got caught lying, his teammates would be forced to bus. I've outed a good reason scum LC has to claim.

lol

so your 25% scenario was more common sense than my 75% assumption

and no, your reason for that is about as good as a reason as your push on me for D1.

[tedxtr]

"if LC was scum then he must've gotten bussed"

"if ted was scum he NEEDED to bus syn to clear himself"

you gotta be kidding me, do you actually have any reads that make sense in this game

[Alison]

my progression at EoD1 is about the most clearing thing that somebody still alive in this game could have

if you are a villager not seeing it then we can just thunderdome tomorrow, idrc

k

[Alison]

"if LC was scum then he must've gotten bussed"

"if ted was scum he NEEDED to bus syn to clear himself"

you gotta be kidding me, do you actually have any reads that make sense in this game

If LC was scum then he was outed who got caught lying. There is 0 reason for his scum teammates to not bus him there.

Your EOD1 progression is not clearing and I don't see how you could possibly believe that a bus there is out of your scumrange.

[Alison]

Are you seriously trying to sit there and tell me we should clear you just because you voted Syn D1. What a load of shit.

[Alison]

You've spent 0 effort trying to solve me and just treating me as a default misexe you can get any time you want, you constantly insist that you should be treated as lock clear just because you voted a mafia member at one point, despite knowing that many games on the Syndicate are lost after a scum exe D1 because someone gets falsely cleared from a hard bus, and you've insisted that LC's partners wouldn't bus him after he was caught lying as your rationale for knowing that LC was town.

[tedxtr]

who are the wolves?

hint: i am not one of them.

[Alison]

who are the wolves?

hint: i am not one of them.

If you aren't then my best guess is Marmot/Wilgy.

[tedxtr]

i know it's hard to fathom a world where i'm not scum fypov (for whatever reason)

but gonna talk to you as though you've been a wrong villa on me

me and marmot are basically never w/w ; so there's a pretty high chance it's not me

and in a me / syn / marmot world, you have to realise that I've bussed the partner i didn't talk about at all and had my other scum partner as a solid scum lean for the ~entire game.

[tedxtr]

reading over isos, idk what I would've done with that "can't claim rule" applied

it's hard to get any town read outside of the claims

[tedxtr]

i think we just go for marmot tomorrow and figure it out from there

seems to be the wolfiest player alive.

[tedxtr]

and skimming wilgy's iso, his questions make no sense from an advancing his reads perspective.

maybe it's as simple as marmot / wilgy.

either way, one of them two should go next. let's not repeat an LC thing tomorrow, somehow.

[Esooa]

Just gonna drop my PoE now in case I die

Alison>Wilgy>marmot

consider if Alison's trying to let sig go deep but I doubt it

Consider Ted if Alison is town but I doubt it

[Esooa]

And by consider I mean I'm mostly over susing Ted I thought about it and it's way too tin foil idc I'd probably just hard clear Ted right now

[Alison]

i know it's hard to fathom a world where i'm not scum fypov (for whatever reason)

but gonna talk to you as though you've been a wrong villa on me

me and marmot are basically never w/w ; so there's a pretty high chance it's not me

and in a me / syn / marmot world, you have to realise that I've bussed the partner i didn't talk about at all and had my other scum partner as a solid scum lean for the ~entire game.

So if I discount you/Marmot, then it has to be either you/Wilgy or Wilgy/Marmot. So are you saying we should exe Wilgy?

[Alison]

To be clear hard clearing someone for voting out one scum is actually nuts and I have no idea why you're doing it Esooa.

[Alison]

i think we just go for marmot tomorrow and figure it out from there

seems to be the wolfiest player alive.

Why not me?

[sig]

Well how did that happen, I'll probably read up on the second half of the day. Work was crazy yesterday so didn't have any free time to pop in.

[Marmot]

Why is sig derpcleared, and is it something we can talk about?

[falcon45ca]

Why is sig derpcleared, and is it something we can talk about?

Was wondering that myself. Let's talk about it

[Marmot]

Lol, I was just starting to wonder where you were falcon.

[falcon45ca]

I'm here and def still think Alison is scum

[Esooa]

To be clear hard clearing someone for voting out one scum is actually nuts and I have no idea why you're doing it Esooa.

I'm not

[sig]

Why is sig derpcleared, and is it something we can talk about?

I don't think I am? Just not caught up all the way yet.

[sig]

Why is sig derpcleared, and is it something we can talk about?

I don't think I am? Just not caught up all the way yet.

Having said that dont lynch me pls k thx promise I'm a civ.

[sig]

Sig can't you just like, read the posts that were put in the night chat lol I hate all of this people asking stuff that's in thread to be explained

If this is in regard to my Allison question then no. Since quite honestly nobody was giving good reasoning and being dumb about it. Also there's no reason why people can't just give reasoning again, it helps catch scum who don't pay attention.

[sig]

Never mind I see why people think i should be derp cleared this also explains the LC thing. B

[sig]

Okay sweet, I should make kt a habit to catch up on the thread before posting but meh.

I still think next phase we need to look at Alison which is a reverse of what I was previously saying, since in hindsight I don't like her progression on lynching herself ect.

[MartinGG99]

Err, woops. Forgot to lock the thread 35 minutes ago. SoD3 in about an hour and half.

[MartinGG99]

It is now SoD3.

Falcon45ca has died. They were

Spoiler: show

Vanilla Town

Day 3 ends in 48 hours from now.

Please see the post after this to see your current posts-in-topic limit.

@Alison
@Esooa
@Marmot
@DrWilgy
@sig
@tedxtr
@tutuu

[MartinGG99]

Here are the post counts (sorry for the delay):

Post count limit check:

New SoD2 posts-in-topic limits:

Alison: 138
Esooa: 150
Marmot: 99
Poison / DrWilgy: 76
sig: 100
tedxtr: 126
tutuu: 150

You can go over these by another 75 posts, but for each of those posts over the SoD2 limits, your SoD3 post limits will be reduced by 1!
Also if I somehow screwed up on your post limit calculation, please @ or PM me.

Alison 147, 9 posts over the limit
Esooa 177, 27 posts over the limit
Marmot 60, 0 posts over the limit
Poison / DrWilgy 32, 0 posts over the limit
sig 42, 0 posts over the limit
tedxtr 74, 0 posts over the limit
tutuu 185, 35 posts over the limit

New Post-in-topic limits:

Alison 213
Esooa 225
Marmot 135
Poison / DrWilgy 97
sig 117
tedxtr 149
tutuu 225


As always, you can exceed these by another 75 posts, but this will reduce your SoD4 post-cap limit by how much you exceeded these limits!

[Alison]

Why is sig derpcleared, and is it something we can talk about?

He appeared not to know mafia had a strongman.

[tutuu]

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Still dont feel like playing but i'll try to suck it up

[tutuu]

I think drwilgy can be mafia with pretty much anyone whereas with marmot i think the possible combinations are much lower

So i think drwilgy being yeeted first is optimal should you agree with what i just said, even if u think marmot is independently scummier

[tutuu]

Wont comment on the nk

[tutuu]

I think alison was towny in her assertiveness when interacting with eso and ted, my reasons to lock her as town died together with LC though

[tutuu]

Still cant believe LC was town and did that shit

[sig]

Still cant believe LC was town and did that shit

I can see it, more of an old school move.

[sig]

Alison, Marmot, or wilgy is really the pov at this point.

Ted still has some good will from his d1 vote. He could be deep wolfing. But, I'd rather not risk another wasted day on that.

[sig]

Risk wasting a day just based off that*

[sig]

[VOTE: marmot] aubergine

[sig]

Did alot of people vote without giving any reasoning or dropping it in the thread or what?

[sig]

I do plan to like put in some work this phase and iso everyone. God help us all is all that it's now up to the guy who hasn't seriously played mafia in like a year to like actually do work and help catch scum.

[tutuu]

Alison, Marmot, or wilgy is really the pov at this point.

Ted still has some good will from his d1 vote. He could be deep wolfing. But, I'd rather not risk another wasted day on that.

agree with everything

i dont think ted can be with marmot, it would have been suicidal for wolf!ted

don't think its alison + ted either

i kinda dont feel like alison + marmot can be a thing even tho its a bit of a stretch. i just feel like the way she wanted to suicide - why do that when marmot was next on the chopping block for literally everyone?

i could see maybe alison + sigurd in some weird weird world

i really do think wilgy fits with absolutely everyone and is the correct yeet

marmot is also probably scum, but he is most likely with wilgy imo

[Marmot]

I think drwilgy can be mafia with pretty much anyone whereas with marmot i think the possible combinations are much lower

So i think drwilgy being yeeted first is optimal should you agree with what i just said, even if u think marmot is independently scummier

Marmot is not indecently scummier because I've seen his rolecard.

[Marmot]

Wow autocorrect

[Marmot]

Did alot of people vote without giving any reasoning or dropping it in the thread or what?

Is this going to be like every other game I've played since returning from hiatus? We catch mafia Day 1, then get a couple misyeets, then activity drops off a cliff and mafia wins?

[Marmot]

At least we have two players we absolutely can't yeet today in esooa and tutuu.

[Marmot]

Alison, Marmot, or wilgy is really the pov at this point.

Ted still has some good will from his d1 vote. He could be deep wolfing. But, I'd rather not risk another wasted day on that.

agree with everything

i dont think ted can be with marmot, it would have been suicidal for wolf!ted

don't think its alison + ted either

i kinda dont feel like alison + marmot can be a thing even tho its a bit of a stretch. i just feel like the way she wanted to suicide - why do that when marmot was next on the chopping block for literally everyone?

i could see maybe alison + sigurd in some weird weird world

i really do think wilgy fits with absolutely everyone and is the correct yeet

marmot is also probably scum, but he is most likely with wilgy imo

I mean, I woulda loved to role mafia with Wilgy two games in a row.