Shadow Corridors Mafia [GAME OVER]

#5001

and i forgot to say, after he survives this first yeet, he will then be killable

#5002

Why do you keep asking me to claim? I do not think that is a good idea at this stage.

#5003

turniphead is sus for not saying hello to me after 4 years

#5004

Kylemii wrote: ↑Thu Dec 10, 2020 9:51 pm turniphead is sus for not saying hello to me after 4 years

sus noted

#5005

KZA wrote: ↑Thu Dec 10, 2020 4:47 pm Are we setting NIK aside for now? I feel like everyone is forgetting he's alive lol

Yes we are. Because its obvious from all the CW and scum flips that NIKs town
why are you bringing this up big guy

#5006

NIK coming in hot

#5007

Kylemii wrote: ↑Thu Dec 10, 2020 9:51 pm turniphead is sus for not saying hello to me after 4 years

I said it with my eyes

#5008

Has TH still not claimed?

He should probably at least partial claim

#5009

Ok if you think it's a good idea to claim, I'm the mayor.

#5010

I guess now’s the time to say I [tracked/watched] TH do the NK

#5011

Well he went to thunal at least, which I assume was the NK cause martin wasn’t SRing her afaik

#5012

Lol no you didn't

#5013

I didn't target anybody last night, if you got that result from tracking me I was switched with someone else.

#5014

I was trying to hold off in case he claimed the town secrets role, but it didn’t seem super likely to me tbh. Claiming mayor I know is a lie so I think he’s probably just mafia

#5015

#5016

Maybe you think it's a lie but I'm claiming mayor regardless, it's the best move as town to do so.

#5017

Think about it

#5018

Also I don't go by he much jic u were wondering. I use they/them atm

#5019

I mean

You aren’t being subtle about it, might as well just make it explicit at this point yeah

Cause this mayor claim is obviously not true, I don’t think scum is going to be fooled by it kek

#5020

Turnip Head wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 3:30 am Also I don't go by he much jic u were wondering. I use they/them atm

Oh my bad, I wasn’t aware. Will correct

#5021

Eh idk, I see what you’re claiming, I gotta think about it ig

#5022

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 3:31 am I mean

You aren’t being subtle about it, might as well just make it explicit at this point yeah

Cause this mayor claim is obviously not true, I don’t think scum is going to be fooled by it kek

Ok cool. I must have been switched last night if that helps your investigation

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #5023

OOH A CLAIM BATTLE

my immediate reaction is th is more believable and nook is less believable

cool we have a definitive 1 for 1 in them tho

#5024

I’m kind of considering that we might be in the 10% world where TH is town

Idk

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #5025

Oh wait maybe not it sounds like TH is actually town secret role maybe and they can actually both be town loooooool damn

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #5026

Idk occams razor one of them is lying still bc is it reasonable to assume there was a swap/busdrive of some kind still

Im confused and should go to bed

#5027

I mean TH is definitely lying

But he could still be town lying so

Idfk

#5028

I don't get why you are considering a 10% TH town world if they are tracked to the kill

#5029

Hi Kyle

#5030

I think TH's reaction was towny

We have a dead busdriver who died last might who made a switch that nobody knows

TH's slot, was a slot we all thought was scum

Its not unreasobale Martin switched TH to someone else

Compare Thundercat's reaction to TH's reaction

#5031

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME why did u decide to wait for 3 nights before u use your track on n4, and why on the Myo slot?

#5032

Answering that would require me to claim whether it’s a watch or a track, soooooooo

Pass

#5033

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 7:36 am Answering that would require me to claim whether it’s a watch or a track, soooooooo

Pass

Okay but can you answer why you believe that there's a 10% chance that TH is town if they've claimed Mayor and you know for a fact that they entered Thunal's house

#5034

I mean if its a watch then you have a 100% red peek on TH, TH being busdriven can mess up with a track, it doesnt interact with a watch

So you already revealed u have a track by saying TH might be town

Or u mistakingly thought that TH being busdriven interacts with a watch. Unless u thought u were redirected yourself?

#5035

Unless thunal was busdriven

Ah i get it, didnt thought of that

#5036

But no, even if thunal was busdriven, u saw TH visiting someone (as a watcher)

#5037

Oh so u saw TH visiting someone but if thunal was busdriven and u watched her, u think that TH might be a visiting town pr that visites someone completely unrelated

#5038

I actually don't feel great about the TC wagon now. They've essentially confirmed that tutuu's check on them is accurate by reaction, but they could be 3P. Even if they're mafia, the fact that so many people have claimed roles today means that tonight is when we're at the most risk of having a lot of people drop dead from soupkill mechanics. In that context it might not be appropriate to remove TC's second life, because you'd rather actually get a mafia out of the game for parity reasons.

@sig You tinfoiled nutella earlier on the basis of NKA. What makes you think it's due to nutella orchestrating scum kills around her rather than a doc dodge? We have two docs and a bus driver, and scum failed to kill the first two nights (suggesting that they might have hit a healed target).

#5039

tutuu wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 7:39 am I mean if its a watch then you have a 100% red peek on TH, TH being busdriven can mess up with a track, it doesnt interact with a watch

So you already revealed u have a track by saying TH might be town

Or u mistakingly thought that TH being busdriven interacts with a watch. Unless u thought u were redirected yourself?

I don’t see any reason a game with a town ninja couldn’t have a scum one shot ninja or something along those lines in it

#5040

Wait wtf town ninja who was a town ninja

#5041

The vig huh

Well alright

#5042

Man i dont believe thundercat is survivor thats just lame and the host doesnt seem to like lame roles

There are 5 non towns but LC is townsiding and mafia traitor doesnt count for parity

So rly there are de facto 3 anti-town members for the purposes of parity

I think thundercat is the obliterator and we need him dead at some point anyway, we will need to double yeet him at some point, so might as well now. Dunno

#5043

Think about the l o n g. .t e r m. g u y s

#5044

Like its a 3 day investment to yeet thundercat

First yeet, vanish on the 2nd day, yeet on 3rd day

Even if we kill all the other mafia we will need to do this 3 day investment to kill him

Why not get rid of his first life now

Yeet another mafia tomorrow

Finish him the day after tomorrow

#5045

tutuu wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 9:04 am Like its a 3 day investment to yeet thundercat

First yeet, vanish on the 2nd day, yeet on 3rd day

Even if we kill all the other mafia we will need to do this 3 day investment to kill him

Why not get rid of his first life now

Yeet another mafia tomorrow

Finish him the day after tomorrow

We have to find the other mafia members too, and getting rid of them now makes it harder for a big soupkill to achieve parity.

#5046

Basically, even if TC is mafia, the diff between exeing TC and exeing TC's teammate is that exeing TC's teammate makes it a lot harder to lose to a masskill.

#5047

Alison wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 7:46 am I actually don't feel great about the TC wagon now. They've essentially confirmed that tutuu's check on them is accurate by reaction, but they could be 3P. Even if they're mafia, the fact that so many people have claimed roles today means that tonight is when we're at the most risk of having a lot of people drop dead from soupkill mechanics. In that context it might not be appropriate to remove TC's second life, because you'd rather actually get a mafia out of the game for parity reasons.

@sig You tinfoiled nutella earlier on the basis of NKA. What makes you think it's due to nutella orchestrating scum kills around her rather than a doc dodge? We have two docs and a bus driver, and scum failed to kill the first two nights (suggesting that they might have hit a healed target).

The more I think about it the only way it would work is if she was telling traitor, I mean there's a world where she is on the team and hard bussed, but that's more outsider her meta.

I just find it odd mafia, based off whom flipped wouldn't go to kill her or another big town read and instead just be picking off people who aren't posting as much.

I'd definitely not move to lynch nutella today though that would be rash.

#5048

sig wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 9:33 am I just find it odd mafia, based off whom flipped wouldn't go to kill her or another big town read and instead just be picking off people who aren't posting as much.

Why is that odd, when we have 2 docs and a bus driver? How do you know nutella wasn't targeted and saved on the first two nights? This line of logic doesn't add up to me.

#5049

I could see lynching TC now so we don't have someone who's got an extra day hanging around in case things go south for town later.

Of course if he's a 3rd party with that qe just wasted a phase so it's a toss up.

Also and this just hit me it seems like the mafia is targeted CFC players at this point. The last two assumed mafia kills were thunal and Flanders both from CFC correct?

Could this have some bearing on leftover mafia members who is left from that site?

#5050

Alison wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 9:34 am
sig wrote: ↑Fri Dec 11, 2020 9:33 am I just find it odd mafia, based off whom flipped wouldn't go to kill her or another big town read and instead just be picking off people who aren't posting as much.
Why is that odd, when we have 2 docs and a bus driver? How do you know nutella wasn't targeted and saved on the first two nights? This line of logic doesn't add up to me.

I'm kind of ignoring that as a factor, even if she was saved why wouldn't mafia hit her again?

Honestly this a very down the rabbit hole type discussion. I don't have any information to back this up or lead to this theory I was just throwing it out there to see what other people think.

I've been in so many TS games were we town core mafia and they just ride to the end. It hasn't ever been nutella, but she's been in enough/read those games that it was something I wanted to bring up.