MartinWP69 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 3:14 pm
In fact, when I saw Quokka's POE for the first time last night, my immediate impression was that they were mafia. It necessitated that the mafia team outside of nutella must be in me/fuskdall/TopSecretPortfolio, and that almost certainly isn't right. Does anyone think that POE has a chance of being correct?
I think it does have a chance from my pov yes but I would include Akemi.
I don't townread quokka much but don't think his responses to you in that exchange were particularly sus
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Tue Dec 22, 2020 1:58 pm
nutella's AtE with :i knew this was going to happen" "should never have subbed in" is NAI according to Alison, but I'm no longer RPing as Alison...
not ate really
I understand people pushing on my slot considering how poorly it seems to have played before I replaced in
I think some people pushing me are doing it in an opportunistic manner and I'm trying to sort it out
I found your lengthy post to be pretty bad, and am judging you solely on that.
My Shell wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 3:59 pm
What are your current feelings on fuskdall and pony? I feel I have less grip on them than other slots atm
If nutella flips wolf, I really think she basically outed fusk as her teammate.
I know everyone thinks I'm being ridiculous about my reaction to the fake mason claim with Fuskfall, but if someone claimed I was Mason with them for 2 days straight and never remarked on it...it makes you wonder, no?
I don't remember anything from Pony really. Only that Fusk seems to think it's Sloonei, but I saw a very non-sloonei-esque joke by them today, so I'm gonna veto that idea.
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:14 pm
I don't remember anything from Pony really. Only that Fusk seems to think it's Sloonei, but I saw a very non-sloonei-esque joke by them today, so I'm gonna veto that idea.
My Shell wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 3:59 pm
What are your current feelings on fuskdall and pony? I feel I have less grip on them than other slots atm
If nutella flips wolf, I really think she basically outed fusk as her teammate.
I know everyone thinks I'm being ridiculous about my reaction to the fake mason claim with Fuskfall, but if someone claimed I was Mason with them for 2 days straight and never remarked on it...it makes you wonder, no?
The last part of my post is weird. I meant if someone claimed I was Mason with them, I wouldn't just roll with it for 2 days. Unless I have TMI on that person as being Town.
Fusk never questioned my motives or considered I was wolf pocketing him. Why?
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:14 pm
I don't remember anything from Pony really. Only that Fusk seems to think it's Sloonei, but I saw a very non-sloonei-esque joke by them today, so I'm gonna veto that idea.
It's definitely not sloonei
Martin was my other Sloonei guess, but that's off the table too.
I miss knowing where Sloonei is. I just miss Sloonei.
My Shell wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 3:59 pm
What are your current feelings on fuskdall and pony? I feel I have less grip on them than other slots atm
If nutella flips wolf, I really think she basically outed fusk as her teammate.
I know everyone thinks I'm being ridiculous about my reaction to the fake mason claim with Fuskfall, but if someone claimed I was Mason with them for 2 days straight and never remarked on it...it makes you wonder, no?
The last part of my post is weird. I meant if someone claimed I was Mason with them, I wouldn't just roll with it for 2 days. Unless I have TMI on that person as being Town.
Fusk never questioned my motives or considered I was wolf pocketing him. Why?
I mean seriously day zero / day one mason claims are just a thing. Besides for the fact that I assumed it was a hidden message on your identity and I still assume that it is a hidden message on your identity and until pressed I wasn't going to state this.
MartinWP69 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 3:14 pm
In fact, when I saw Quokka's POE for the first time last night, my immediate impression was that they were mafia. It necessitated that the mafia team outside of nutella must be in me/fuskdall/TopSecretPortfolio, and that almost certainly isn't right. Does anyone think that POE has a chance of being correct?
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:14 pm
I don't remember anything from Pony really. Only that Fusk seems to think it's Sloonei, but I saw a very non-sloonei-esque joke by them today, so I'm gonna veto that idea.
It's definitely not sloonei
Martin was my other Sloonei guess, but that's off the table too.
I miss knowing where Sloonei is. I just miss Sloonei.
I had Martin as Sloonei on day 1, and when I said that I thought Sloonei was a wolf, this was what I had in mind. But I think I know who Sloonei is in any case.
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:14 pm
I don't remember anything from Pony really. Only that Fusk seems to think it's Sloonei, but I saw a very non-sloonei-esque joke by them today, so I'm gonna veto that idea.
It's definitely not sloonei
Martin was my other Sloonei guess, but that's off the table too.
I miss knowing where Sloonei is. I just miss Sloonei.
I had Martin as Sloonei on day 1, and when I said that I thought Sloonei was a wolf, this was what I had in mind. But I think I know who Sloonei is in any case.
When I live-time solve with you, I think you're town.
When I don't see you in the thread, I default on you being wolf.
MartinWP69 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 3:14 pm
In fact, when I saw Quokka's POE for the first time last night, my immediate impression was that they were mafia. It necessitated that the mafia team outside of nutella must be in me/fuskdall/TopSecretPortfolio, and that almost certainly isn't right. Does anyone think that POE has a chance of being correct?
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:14 pm
I don't remember anything from Pony really. Only that Fusk seems to think it's Sloonei, but I saw a very non-sloonei-esque joke by them today, so I'm gonna veto that idea.
It's definitely not sloonei
Martin was my other Sloonei guess, but that's off the table too.
I miss knowing where Sloonei is. I just miss Sloonei.
I had Martin as Sloonei on day 1, and when I said that I thought Sloonei was a wolf, this was what I had in mind. But I think I know who Sloonei is in any case.
When I live-time solve with you, I think you're town.
When I don't see you in the thread, I default on you being wolf.
Who's your POE?
Martin's right that I'm frustrated, and it's because we have to chop Nutella today and I don't care to change it. Game state reasons are significant enough: I've seen enough saves in my life to categorize what happened to Nutella as such. I can't really reevaluate on that. If it will help Martin out, I'll make the full case.
After that I think Marmot is fairly obvious scum, but I'd reevaluate should we come to F7. But let's hold off on that for just a second.
MartinWP69 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:26 pm[VOTE:
nutellaphant] aubergine to resolve that problem once and for all. Threadstate feels like they’re mafia and the team has decided to distance.
Quokka is my first guess for a partner if this vote is correct.
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:14 pm
I don't remember anything from Pony really. Only that Fusk seems to think it's Sloonei, but I saw a very non-sloonei-esque joke by them today, so I'm gonna veto that idea.
It's definitely not sloonei
Martin was my other Sloonei guess, but that's off the table too.
I miss knowing where Sloonei is. I just miss Sloonei.
I had Martin as Sloonei on day 1, and when I said that I thought Sloonei was a wolf, this was what I had in mind. But I think I know who Sloonei is in any case.
When I live-time solve with you, I think you're town.
When I don't see you in the thread, I default on you being wolf.
Who's your POE?
Martin's right that I'm frustrated, and it's because we have to chop Nutella today and I don't care to change it. Game state reasons are significant enough: I've seen enough saves in my life to categorize what happened to Nutella as such. I can't really reevaluate on that. If it will help Martin out, I'll make the full case.
After that I think Marmot is fairly obvious scum, but I'd reevaluate should we come to F7. But let's hold off on that for just a second.
I don’t remember saying you’re frustrated. I remember asking why you didn’t talk to me during my weirdness phase.
MartinWP69 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:26 pm[VOTE:
nutellaphant] aubergine to resolve that problem once and for all. Threadstate feels like they’re mafia and the team has decided to distance.
Quokka is my first guess for a partner if this vote is correct.
I am back and I will move my vote back onto nutellaphant.
Martin you are twisting my words again. You clearly said that I didn't give a read on you, but my post was obviously a read and you are splitting hairs by saying there's a difference between calling you POE and calling you mafia, when my post had reasons to scumread you. It clearly showed a picture of you as mafia. I think my POE can easily be right.
MartinWP69 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:26 pm[VOTE:
nutellaphant] aubergine to resolve that problem once and for all. Threadstate feels like they’re mafia and the team has decided to distance.
Quokka is my first guess for a partner if this vote is correct.
nutellaphant wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 11:51 pm
I'm reorganizing the fridge!
Akemi Homura: chicken breast
Paprika: bell pepper (closest thing to paprika that would be in a fridge. or I guess maybe leftover paprikash or goulash)
nutellaphant: doesn't belong in the fridge. but could also be ice cream in the freezer
Boringboi666: well she used to be baby carrots but i think shes like a spicy chipotle hummus to go with the carrots
Quokka: Oregon marionberry jam
PonySparkPrime: honey mustard
MartinWP69: ???
My Shell: ??
1337: ???
Fuskdall: ???
dodo: ???
Maid: ???
Nurse Wilgy: ???
Let me know if I missed anyone!
So this is blatant copy paste pandering. It's straight from a game, etc. I cannot exactly explain why I think town doesn't do this because I think it's a player by player thing. But like.
1337 wrote: ↑Tue Dec 15, 2020 10:26 pm
I think nutellaphent is mafia
nutellaphent and i are really close. i love her more than i love life itself.
i think I can read her better than anyone and i don't think i am seeing baddie nutella yet.
nutellaphent, are you bad this game?
of course not!
1337 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 16, 2020 7:10 am
Guys after reading this I have to day I'm very excited to play this, game everyone here fells really good at mafia and this is looking to be na amazing game. It is unfortunate I rolled miller and I understand if you have to kill me d1 but it is worth noting that I become innocent child if I get best rper! Not that I'm rping anyone this is just me going try hard.
This is believable, and the right thing to do given the role he claimed.
dodo wrote: ↑Wed Dec 16, 2020 2:52 pm
does anyone want to counterclaim mafia? i am no longer sure how reliable my source is <_<
i no longer know if it make sense to EVER trust a third tier seasoning
speaking of anthropomorphized foods, has anyone seen my nutellaphant? i need to ask her something
MartinWP69 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 16, 2020 3:39 pm
I would like to figure out if 1337's miller claim was roleplay or serious, so I am reviewing the games they linked to for their meta (though there are only two games and they are both on The Syndicate, but I do believe 1612 is an experienced player in other communities).
It does not look like 1612 has ever claimed miller in a previous game, or at least not in either of the ones they provided for this game. Furthermore, they never claim to be new to mafia, only new to The Syndicate. Thus, it is unlikely that 1337 is roleplaying when they say that they are new or that they are a miller.
But that got me wondering if anyone here is new. I thought Made was new, but they linked to games from as far back as 2014, so it appears they are an experienced player returning from a long absence. Duskfall's earliest linked game is from April of this year, but he looks like a confident and skilled player in each of those games. Therefore I think Duskfall is also not an inexperienced player. There is nobody in this game who would qualify as "new" or "inexperienced", but I am at a loss as to why anyone would want to roleplay as a noob when they are experienced and their sockpuppet character is too. It is baffling behavior, but for now I feel it is NAI.
I think this is a great point. I'm not about to check everyone's past games, though. If there are no real newbies here and yet someone is pretending to be new, then they're being suspicious.
MartinWP69 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 16, 2020 3:57 pm
I have a strange observation to make about Maid, so please forgive me if this is confusing to any of you.
I feel as though Maid looks like they are searching for wolves instead of townies. Another way to put it is they are looking for suspects instead of making reads. I am referring to posts like these ones when I say this:
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Tue Dec 15, 2020 12:32 pm
My Day 1 scum read is actually proven to be 100% accurate in every game I've played on here and on MU. nutella is lock scum.
1337 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 16, 2020 7:10 am
Guys after reading this I have to day I'm very excited to play this, game everyone here fells really good at mafia and this is looking to be na amazing game. It is unfortunate I rolled miller and I understand if you have to kill me d1 but it is worth noting that I become innocent child if I get best rper! Not that I'm rping anyone this is just me going try hard.
Good RP, you are pocketing everyone, well done!
Maid also voted for 1337 following the miller claim but unvoted once others started coming to their defense. I think it looks opportunistic, and the unvote was nervous backtracking.
I actually find Maid's wolf-hunting to be townie and not wolfy. How interesting. I like your posts so far Martin!
So far, I have Alison, Maid, and Martin as town. I'm more hesitant on 1337 due to Martin's post, though I'll leave them be because of their claim
Interesting tell and I'm not even joking. It just feels so awkward. The whole "this is a great point" on what is obviously not a great point bs.
nutellaphant wrote: ↑Thu Dec 17, 2020 4:39 pm
Vote on me aside, NurseWilgy is sus. They're asking for a case on dodo (who I personally am okay with at the moment), and they're voting for me due to lack of content. They don't know where they're at in the game.
cmon this is just a wolf I don't need to post any more
Quokka wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:31 pm[VOTE:
nutellaphant] aubergine
I am back and I will move my vote back onto nutellaphant.
Martin you are twisting my words again. You clearly said that I didn't give a read on you, but my post was obviously a read and you are splitting hairs by saying there's a difference between calling you POE and calling you mafia, when my post had reasons to scumread you. It clearly showed a picture of you as mafia. I think my POE can easily be right.
Do you believe that your POE can easily be right? Your poe includes nutella, right? and then those three?
Akemi Homura wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:14 pm
I don't remember anything from Pony really. Only that Fusk seems to think it's Sloonei, but I saw a very non-sloonei-esque joke by them today, so I'm gonna veto that idea.
It's definitely not sloonei
Martin was my other Sloonei guess, but that's off the table too.
I miss knowing where Sloonei is. I just miss Sloonei.
I had Martin as Sloonei on day 1, and when I said that I thought Sloonei was a wolf, this was what I had in mind. But I think I know who Sloonei is in any case.
When I live-time solve with you, I think you're town.
When I don't see you in the thread, I default on you being wolf.
Who's your POE?
Martin's right that I'm frustrated, and it's because we have to chop Nutella today and I don't care to change it. Game state reasons are significant enough: I've seen enough saves in my life to categorize what happened to Nutella as such. I can't really reevaluate on that. If it will help Martin out, I'll make the full case.
After that I think Marmot is fairly obvious scum, but I'd reevaluate should we come to F7. But let's hold off on that for just a second.
I don’t remember saying you’re frustrated. I remember asking why you didn’t talk to me during my weirdness phase.
Quokka wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:31 pm[VOTE:
nutellaphant] aubergine
I am back and I will move my vote back onto nutellaphant.
Martin you are twisting my words again. You clearly said that I didn't give a read on you, but my post was obviously a read and you are splitting hairs by saying there's a difference between calling you POE and calling you mafia, when my post had reasons to scumread you. It clearly showed a picture of you as mafia. I think my POE can easily be right.
Do you believe that your POE can easily be right? Your poe includes nutella, right? and then those three?
Yes. Made has trended down for me as well, but I think the solve can be for example nutella, Martin and PonyStarkPrime. I don't see why that can't be the mafia team and I dislike that Martin is trying to push me off it by ridicule.
Quokka wrote: ↑Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:31 pm
All this sudden sus on me comes at a bad timing, I think mafia is trying to set me up as a mischop. I won't stand for it.
Your wagon was me following Martin.
It wasn’t a bad timing at all.
masons don't claim in day 0