Bread Mafia [Game Over]

[Alison]

p sure this game is gonna be like radiohead mafia where people start off being vaguely suspicious of me but then i claw my way into the towncore by helping to bury the mafia team

i'm peacing out for a bit, cya

I think the comparison to Radiohead is very apt because I have a lot of townreads near the start of the game and they're all mutually townreading each other too with only a few exceptions.

[tutuu]

I'm surprised that everyone has nutella in their towncore. I'm not seeing it.

I'm not seeing any trace of scum nutella and several traces of town nutella. No offense to nutella, but I think I am good enough at reading her that she wouldn't be able to fool me continuously for so long without giving me the slightest hint that something's up.

Also she's basically committed to hard sheeping me. So if she is scum then she's forced to townside right now and we'll just make her bus all her teammates and then catch her once we've proven there's a deepwolf.

Okay, I will sheep you.

i feel like i've played this game before, and i lost

Lol

[JaggedJimmyJay]

nutella's play feels to me like a person who is following the development of the game, seeing it coalesce around an early consensus, and doing her part to promote that. there's a certain energy in this thread right now, and not everyone has it. the ones that do have it are town reads.

i'm sure that's vague, but whatever

I'm going to be honest - I think that you're scummy Jimbo but the last time we played I tunneled you a lot and I was wrong so I'm afraid to say it in case I'm wrong again.

what's got you spooked toots

[staypositivefriend]

p sure this game is gonna be like radiohead mafia where people start off being vaguely suspicious of me but then i claw my way into the towncore by helping to bury the mafia team

i'm peacing out for a bit, cya

I think the comparison to Radiohead is very apt because I have a lot of townreads near the start of the game and they're all mutually townreading each other too with only a few exceptions.

yeah it actually gives me extremely similar vibes, because i started out being broadly in everyones "null/sus" pile in that game and then gradually worked my way up as an extremely strong towncore formed

the only difference is that nutella is probably town this time

[staypositivefriend]

also i will say that i dont find jagged ~that~ towny yet, but i'm withholding judgement. i don't know what's gonna cause me to make that judgement, but i think his alignment is gonna become more obvious to me as the day goes on

[tutuu]

nutella's play feels to me like a person who is following the development of the game, seeing it coalesce around an early consensus, and doing her part to promote that. there's a certain energy in this thread right now, and not everyone has it. the ones that do have it are town reads.

i'm sure that's vague, but whatever

I'm going to be honest - I think that you're scummy Jimbo but the last time we played I tunneled you a lot and I was wrong so I'm afraid to say it in case I'm wrong again.

what's got you spooked toots

It's hard to verbalize. I just read your posts and my gut reaction is to feel that they're manipulative.

[nutella]

also i will say that i dont find jagged ~that~ towny yet, but i'm withholding judgement. i don't know what's gonna cause me to make that judgement, but i think his alignment is gonna become more obvious to me as the day goes on

same

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

The towniest thing about jay is that he’s encouraging reads I think are good or mostly good and doing exactly nothing to stop a poe forming that potentially includes him

[nutella]

but his post about the threadvibes was a decent hit of town points

[nutella]

The towniest thing about jay is that he’s encouraging reads I think are good or mostly good and doing exactly nothing to stop a poe forming that potentially includes him

this too

generally his attitude toward the thread is >rand town

[JaggedJimmyJay]

It's hard to verbalize. I just read your posts and my gut reaction is to feel that they're manipulative.

okay. if you're town i think you'll come around.

[Made]

booting into sheep mode

[nutella]

my main poe is michelle/made/longcon/omega in roughly that order, then the zero posters as default poe, then tutuu bc i still feel kinda icky around half the time she says stuff

[Made]

nutella's play feels to me like a person who is following the development of the game, seeing it coalesce around an early consensus, and doing her part to promote that. there's a certain energy in this thread right now, and not everyone has it. the ones that do have it are town reads.

i'm sure that's vague, but whatever

I'm going to be honest - I think that you're scummy Jimbo but the last time we played I tunneled you a lot and I was wrong so I'm afraid to say it in case I'm wrong again.

what's got you spooked toots

It's hard to verbalize. I just read your posts and my gut reaction is to feel that they're manipulative.

[EllieDelight]

ok i give up on catching up. this is what i have to say instead:

Michelle, the only meta i have is that Ive spectated one game. Played one mafia where we won(some would say town was really bad that game but i like to think im just that good) And one town where we won.
Ive played all of those with Esooa, and she's fine at this game I guess, I think I know how to spot her mafia though so I'll pay attention to that.

And my pfp might count as anime(i pray not). Its a japanese game in an anime style but it's not a show or movie.

Also im Sourdough so im good.

[tutuu]

my main poe is michelle/made/longcon/omega in roughly that order, then the zero posters as default poe, then tutuu bc i still feel kinda icky around half the time she says stuff

As if you ever felt non-icky about the way I choose to phrase my posts

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’d fight pretty hard against a Michelle kill tbh

I’m confident I’m good at reading her and she’s currently more townie than not

[JaggedJimmyJay]

my main poe is michelle/made/longcon/omega in roughly that order, then the zero posters as default poe, then tutuu bc i still feel kinda icky around half the time she says stuff

generally same, though i am less icky about tutuu. if i bothered to rainbow she'd be a light green or somate

i'm kinda blank on esooa, but i'm content to follow my town reads for now

[nutella]

my main poe is michelle/made/longcon/omega in roughly that order, then the zero posters as default poe, then tutuu bc i still feel kinda icky around half the time she says stuff

As if you ever felt non-icky about the way I choose to phrase my posts

it's not the phrasing it's the content for the most part

[Made]

I’d fight pretty hard against a Michelle kill tbh

I’m confident I’m good at reading her and she’s currently more townie than not

(the reader not the read)

[nutella]

ok i give up on catching up. this is what i have to say instead:

Michelle, the only meta i have is that Ive spectated one game. Played one mafia where we won(some would say town was really bad that game but i like to think im just that good) And one town where we won.
Ive played all of those with Esooa, and she's fine at this game I guess, I think I know how to spot her mafia though so I'll pay attention to that.

And my pfp might count as anime(i pray not). Its a japanese game in an anime style but it's not a show or movie.

Also im Sourdough so im good.

so you read enough to know there was discussion about the anime pfps

[Esooa]

ok i give up on catching up. this is what i have to say instead:

Michelle, the only meta i have is that Ive spectated one game. Played one mafia where we won(some would say town was really bad that game but i like to think im just that good) And one town where we won.
Ive played all of those with Esooa, and she's fine at this game I guess, I think I know how to spot her mafia though so I'll pay attention to that.

And my pfp might count as anime(i pray not). Its a japanese game in an anime style but it's not a show or movie.

Also im Sourdough so im good.

I honestly find it funny you think you could find me as mafia lmao

[tutuu]

ok i give up on catching up. this is what i have to say instead:

Michelle, the only meta i have is that Ive spectated one game. Played one mafia where we won(some would say town was really bad that game but i like to think im just that good) And one town where we won.
Ive played all of those with Esooa, and she's fine at this game I guess, I think I know how to spot her mafia though so I'll pay attention to that.

And my pfp might count as anime(i pray not). Its a japanese game in an anime style but it's not a show or movie.

Also im Sourdough so im good.

I honestly find it funny you think you could find me as mafia lmao

Towny ego. (This is @ everyone else who is having trouble finding Eso as town).

[tutuu]

my main poe is michelle/made/longcon/omega in roughly that order, then the zero posters as default poe, then tutuu bc i still feel kinda icky around half the time she says stuff

As if you ever felt non-icky about the way I choose to phrase my posts

it's not the phrasing it's the content for the most part

What do you disagree with in my content?

[nutella]

I’d fight pretty hard against a Michelle kill tbh

I’m confident I’m good at reading her and she’s currently more townie than not

i mean i'll be giving her a chance to do her thing more on d1 when she has time, i have a good record of reading her too, just if she's town i'm not there yet from her entrance and need more data

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@EllieDelight you’re new to mafia in general, not just the syndicate, yeah?

[EllieDelight]

lol dude i know i can, you literally showed me how you play mafia. get fucked kid if youre mafia this game youre as good as toast

[DaughterOfOmega]

Why is nobody talking about LC's scumslip

I highlighted it too

So this is the first time I feel like Alison is trying to force attention toward something that is pushing a scum read onto a player, and acting as if no one else had seen it, although other commented on it, and moved on.

Why is nobody talking about LC's scumslip

I highlighted it too

looked like an obvious joke to me

don't see how that's scummy

I don't think he wrote that post in a way that was meant to be taken as a joke though. Like it's sandwiched between two relatively seriously looking reads. I think there's a pretty serious chance that he was just trying to throw out some random made up reads and picked two random names he saw skimming through the thread without realizing he picked the host.

This is again, where it feels like the agenda of Alison isn't to be genuinely solving the alignment of the players, it's trying to force a discussion of whether or not LC is mafia for their post.

tutuu's probably town

I've seen overtime so not ready to clear her yet but I did like that post

Talks about how she agrees that someone made a towny post, but makes sure to sow some seeds of doubt, leaving room for flexibility to call them evil.

like he sandwiched it in between two actual reads

Alison goes back to pushing attention toward LC, and the one post they made.

Actually tutuu ignoring me for this long is a scumtell, I change my mind on townreading her

[VOTE: tutuu] aubergine

I dislike the fake feeling I got from this post. It's already Alison's third mafia read of the game, and it lacks a real thought process, it feels like someone just wanting to call tutuu evil.

I'm sorry about the rand michelle

We see the fourth mafia read in a short time from Alison, and again the focus seems more about trying to sow seeds of evilness around instead of investigating alignments.

Actually tutuu ignoring me for this long is a scumtell, I change my mind on townreading her

[VOTE: tutuu] aubergine

I'm getting my future told to me right now, I love you Alison-chan but you are not the most interesting thing that's happening around me right now.

this is not a great response honestly

like I outed a real read on you and you brush it off with fluff

I don't think given our dynamic and history together that you would do this as town

I'm sorry about the rand michelle

the alison mindmelds go on and on and on

I don't like this. y'alls last mindmeld alison was bad?

nutella and me mindmeld regardless of our respective alignments, I don't think she even sees it as AI at this point she's just using it as a fancy "I agree"

oh, there's probably a baddie in the anime avatar association

This is a wolfy ass post

both michelle and daughterofomega have given weird townreads of made that are out of tune with the rest of the thread


is that just the team lmao

Sometimes you have to realize that the evil want to fit in and gain the innocent's favor. You want to attack the people on their own, or giving takes that put themselves outside of the majority. This is something that some town do, because their ideas and thoughts are genuine, and instead of tailoring their responses to gain credit, they just say what is true to them.

Any credit given to this slot for posting thoughts that go against the grain should be revoked because they are clearly aware it is a townie thing to do and are fishing for cred for it

I didn't want to talk in-between every quote because I became confused on where some quotes started, and where others ended!

I will just write my conclusion after going through her game again. Alison continuously gave out half-hearted evil reads, and was trying to push certain reads over and over, when the other players had already moved on from these posts. These reads don't seem to be coming from someone spending time actively thinking, and starting from a clean slate. From my perspective Alison has an agenda to try and find targets to call mafia, and less of a focus on solving.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’d fight pretty hard against a Michelle kill tbh

I’m confident I’m good at reading her and she’s currently more townie than not

i mean i'll be giving her a chance to do her thing more on d1 when she has time, i have a good record of reading her too, just if she's town i'm not there yet from her entrance and need more data

Get on my level kid

[Alison]

lol dude i know i can, you literally showed me how you play mafia. get fucked kid if youre mafia this game youre as good as toast

lock town

[JaggedJimmyJay]

potentially a dumb read with personal bias:

tutuu directed her suspicion of me directly to me, in the second person, instead of talking about me externally in a third-person blob of shade. Made did that now that i think of it, so that's something i can reconsider. it seemed like tutuu desired to connect with me there

[nutella]

my main poe is michelle/made/longcon/omega in roughly that order, then the zero posters as default poe, then tutuu bc i still feel kinda icky around half the time she says stuff

As if you ever felt non-icky about the way I choose to phrase my posts

it's not the phrasing it's the content for the most part

What do you disagree with in my content?

your read of me

[Made]

ok i give up on catching up. this is what i have to say instead:

Michelle, the only meta i have is that Ive spectated one game. Played one mafia where we won(some would say town was really bad that game but i like to think im just that good) And one town where we won.
Ive played all of those with Esooa, and she's fine at this game I guess, I think I know how to spot her mafia though so I'll pay attention to that.

And my pfp might count as anime(i pray not). Its a japanese game in an anime style but it's not a show or movie.

Also im Sourdough so im good.

I honestly find it funny you think you could find me as mafia lmao

Towny ego. (This is @ everyone else who is having trouble finding Eso as town).

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

K I’m locking in elli as town unless esooa is red in which case they’re probably partners

[EllieDelight]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
yup, this is my third* game, if you dont count the one where i was literally just a bystander and was super preoccupied.
this is my first time on this site, im from MU

[Made]

potentially a dumb read with personal bias:

tutuu directed her suspicion of me directly to me, in the second person, instead of talking about me externally in a third-person blob of shade. Made did that now that i think of it, so that's something i can reconsider. it seemed like tutuu desired to connect with me there

true i am town, maybe she is too

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

lol dude i know i can, you literally showed me how you play mafia. get fucked kid if youre mafia this game youre as good as toast

lock town

Jinx

[Alison]

That wall on DoO made me feel slightly better about them mostly because I suspect they're scumreading me for playstyle differences and that's townie

[nutella]

lol dude i know i can, you literally showed me how you play mafia. get fucked kid if youre mafia this game youre as good as toast

nice

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
yup, this is my third* game, if you dont count the one where i was literally just a bystander and was super preoccupied.
this is my first time on this site, im from MU

Hi welcome to the site we’re happy to have you here!

[nutella]

ellie town

just grogu and mac left to sort

[JaggedJimmyJay]

potentially a dumb read with personal bias:

tutuu directed her suspicion of me directly to me, in the second person, instead of talking about me externally in a third-person blob of shade. Made did that now that i think of it, so that's something i can reconsider. it seemed like tutuu desired to connect with me there

true i am town, maybe she is too

what i meant was, you did the third-person shade thing. i like that less.

[staypositivefriend]

michelle/made/long con has one at the very least

[Alison]

potentially a dumb read with personal bias:

tutuu directed her suspicion of me directly to me, in the second person, instead of talking about me externally in a third-person blob of shade. Made did that now that i think of it, so that's something i can reconsider. it seemed like tutuu desired to connect with me there

FWIW I often switch between second and third person perspectives as town based on what I think will be more persuasive or productive. Generally I use second person pronouns when I want to give them a chance to help me get there on them, or otherwise engage deeply with them even if I suspect them, and third person pronouns when I no longer care and just want to convince everyone else to bury them.

[tutuu]

potentially a dumb read with personal bias:

tutuu directed her suspicion of me directly to me, in the second person, instead of talking about me externally in a third-person blob of shade. Made did that now that i think of it, so that's something i can reconsider. it seemed like tutuu desired to connect with me there

You're a wonderful human being so of course I'd love to connect with you Jay <3.

[nutella]

[snip]

I will just write my conclusion after going through her game again. Alison continuously gave out half-hearted evil reads, and was trying to push certain reads over and over, when the other players had already moved on from these posts. These reads don't seem to be coming from someone spending time actively thinking, and starting from a clean slate. From my perspective Alison has an agenda to try and find targets to call mafia, and less of a focus on solving.

i think that's just how alison solves, the takes weren't fabricated or anything imo, and not intentionally pushy

but i'm feeling more and more that this is a real opinion you have so aight

[tutuu]

my main poe is michelle/made/longcon/omega in roughly that order, then the zero posters as default poe, then tutuu bc i still feel kinda icky around half the time she says stuff

As if you ever felt non-icky about the way I choose to phrase my posts

it's not the phrasing it's the content for the most part

What do you disagree with in my content?

your read of me

Well I'm town so if you're town as well we're in this cahoots together sweetheart.

[nutella]

potentially a dumb read with personal bias:

tutuu directed her suspicion of me directly to me, in the second person, instead of talking about me externally in a third-person blob of shade. Made did that now that i think of it, so that's something i can reconsider. it seemed like tutuu desired to connect with me there

convince me why that's AI

[Made]

michelle/made/long con has one at the very least

i thought we were friends

[tutuu]

ok i give up on catching up. this is what i have to say instead:

Michelle, the only meta i have is that Ive spectated one game. Played one mafia where we won(some would say town was really bad that game but i like to think im just that good) And one town where we won.
Ive played all of those with Esooa, and she's fine at this game I guess, I think I know how to spot her mafia though so I'll pay attention to that.

And my pfp might count as anime(i pray not). Its a japanese game in an anime style but it's not a show or movie.

Also im Sourdough so im good.

I honestly find it funny you think you could find me as mafia lmao

Towny ego. (This is @ everyone else who is having trouble finding Eso as town).

You continually letting me know that you desire to sheep me strokes my ego and it makes me like you and I don't like that. What if you're Mafia? I do like my ego being stroked, you're probably impressed still by last game, but. I have mixed feelings right now that are fighting with each other.