dizzy
made
michelle
wilgy
are my top 4
i have others in my peripheral poe but those are whom i feel most strongly about
dizzy
haven't played a game with a silencer in 5+ yrsSloonei wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:53 pm Not that anyone asked, but I'm comfortable voting 112 now after resisting it for a few reasons.
The one that put me over the top was my analysis of the response to my silencing on Day 2. 112 was the first person to point out that I was voting without posting, but she didn't seem to even consider the possibility that I was silenced. A mafia member would presume that, with their silencer dead, there should be no silenced player in the game.
But beyond that, I thought the way her recognition of my vote-signaling came off was a bit nervous. She pointed out that I'd dropped a silent vote on her, but then backtracked a little to say the issue was that I was doing this without responding to the cases that were being presented at the time. It looked to me like a player who was nervous of drawing too much of my direct attention there.
But also, after having just about everyone in the game suspect 112 to some degree, and having so many other people semi-clear themselves mechanically, my piece of Day 1 speculation just isn't carrying the same weight for me as it was 48 hours ago. The POE is dwindling, and 112 is the name closest to the top of the most lists. Sorry if we are wrong, 112, but this feels like the right move at this point.
Why 4? Why Michelle?
even after we saw a silencer flip the previous day?112 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:55 pmhaven't played a game with a silencer in 5+ yrsSloonei wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:53 pm Not that anyone asked, but I'm comfortable voting 112 now after resisting it for a few reasons.
The one that put me over the top was my analysis of the response to my silencing on Day 2. 112 was the first person to point out that I was voting without posting, but she didn't seem to even consider the possibility that I was silenced. A mafia member would presume that, with their silencer dead, there should be no silenced player in the game.
But beyond that, I thought the way her recognition of my vote-signaling came off was a bit nervous. She pointed out that I'd dropped a silent vote on her, but then backtracked a little to say the issue was that I was doing this without responding to the cases that were being presented at the time. It looked to me like a player who was nervous of drawing too much of my direct attention there.
But also, after having just about everyone in the game suspect 112 to some degree, and having so many other people semi-clear themselves mechanically, my piece of Day 1 speculation just isn't carrying the same weight for me as it was 48 hours ago. The POE is dwindling, and 112 is the name closest to the top of the most lists. Sorry if we are wrong, 112, but this feels like the right move at this point.
not what i first think of
i don't read nightfallsSloonei wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:56 pmeven after we saw a silencer flip the previous day?112 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:55 pmhaven't played a game with a silencer in 5+ yrsSloonei wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:53 pm Not that anyone asked, but I'm comfortable voting 112 now after resisting it for a few reasons.
The one that put me over the top was my analysis of the response to my silencing on Day 2. 112 was the first person to point out that I was voting without posting, but she didn't seem to even consider the possibility that I was silenced. A mafia member would presume that, with their silencer dead, there should be no silenced player in the game.
But beyond that, I thought the way her recognition of my vote-signaling came off was a bit nervous. She pointed out that I'd dropped a silent vote on her, but then backtracked a little to say the issue was that I was doing this without responding to the cases that were being presented at the time. It looked to me like a player who was nervous of drawing too much of my direct attention there.
But also, after having just about everyone in the game suspect 112 to some degree, and having so many other people semi-clear themselves mechanically, my piece of Day 1 speculation just isn't carrying the same weight for me as it was 48 hours ago. The POE is dwindling, and 112 is the name closest to the top of the most lists. Sorry if we are wrong, 112, but this feels like the right move at this point.
not what i first think of
lol112 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:57 pmi don't read nightfallsSloonei wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:56 pmeven after we saw a silencer flip the previous day?112 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:55 pmhaven't played a game with a silencer in 5+ yrsSloonei wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:53 pm Not that anyone asked, but I'm comfortable voting 112 now after resisting it for a few reasons.
The one that put me over the top was my analysis of the response to my silencing on Day 2. 112 was the first person to point out that I was voting without posting, but she didn't seem to even consider the possibility that I was silenced. A mafia member would presume that, with their silencer dead, there should be no silenced player in the game.
But beyond that, I thought the way her recognition of my vote-signaling came off was a bit nervous. She pointed out that I'd dropped a silent vote on her, but then backtracked a little to say the issue was that I was doing this without responding to the cases that were being presented at the time. It looked to me like a player who was nervous of drawing too much of my direct attention there.
But also, after having just about everyone in the game suspect 112 to some degree, and having so many other people semi-clear themselves mechanically, my piece of Day 1 speculation just isn't carrying the same weight for me as it was 48 hours ago. The POE is dwindling, and 112 is the name closest to the top of the most lists. Sorry if we are wrong, 112, but this feels like the right move at this point.
not what i first think of
IdkDyslexicon wrote: ↑Wed Feb 24, 2021 6:58 pm I actually have cold feet on 112.
Don't know who else or if there's support for anything else?