[END] Fight Club Mafia

#501

Hedgeowl wrote:Did they also vote based on his vote for you Bullz? I need to check their posts.

I didn't. I am not convinced Bullz is good, so I wouldn't vote for Kyle based on that.

#502

Oh God I almost forgot

I am not seeing the cases here other than as related to proximity. I am voting Lea again as not only was she in the right place at the right time, but that whole exchange she had with DH felt off to me, and now she I's apparently using it to clear her from association with him.

#503

I forgot to vote but did just now. SVS, I forgot to go back and look at Lea and I should have. I agree that interaction with DH was odd.

#504

thellama73 wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote:Did they also vote based on his vote for you Bullz? I need to check their posts.
I didn't. I am not convinced Bullz is good, so I wouldn't vote for Kyle based on that.

Ah, ok thanks. I found it below.

thellama73 wrote:Super busy today and not much time, but I want to make sure I don't miss the vote.

I'm actually going wildcard and voting for Kyle. He is on unfurl's list and I found his eagerness to participate in the last fight a little unsettling. Just a gut ping.

So your vote was more of a shot in the dark for Kyle and yet Bea followed your instincts on this one? Strange, I think for Bea the most here I think. It will be interesting to see if they are both civ. civ or not? However, not enough to convince me to vote for Kyle.

votes blooper

#505

Hedgeowl wrote: So your vote was more of a shot in the dark for Kyle and yet Bea followed your instincts on this one? Strange,

Bea is very smart. I wish more people would follow my instincts.

#506

Hi Juliets, I have been quiet this game because a) I've been a busy guy lately, not to mention I was just away at the cottage for the long weekend, and b) until recently, the game was very unmafialike and I was doing more listening than speaking, because I didn't really know what to say. I said "pick me for a fight" because fights were the only thing going. Actually, c) I was seriously injured in my fight, and ended up unable to post for a day and night period.

Anyways, ten minutes left to vote... I was diggin' on the case against Vomps until several people practically vouched for him, so I'm not going to thrust him back into the tie-spotlight so soon. I'm going to go with BWT or nijuukyugou... oh wait, nijuu is way out in the lead since I last checked. Nijuu is getting lynched already. Ok, I'll vote Nij.

Also, BR is still asleep (we were up late last night), so I'm just going to get her vote from her and do it. I don't want to see her die. She can post later when she gets up.

#507

thellama73 wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote: So your vote was more of a shot in the dark for Kyle and yet Bea followed your instincts on this one? Strange,
Bea is very smart. I wish more people would follow my instincts.

You both are very smart. However, if your instincts were right about me more often I might follow them too.

my instincts are feeling ok about you so far this game, which is why I was curious. What are your thought on project mayhem recruitment this game compared to your recruitment in American gods? How did you decide to recruit certain people?

#508

Bullzeye wrote:You were the first to vote for me. I didn't have a lynch opponent. It wouldn't have made sense to lynch Nev, no, but I don't think it makes sense to lynch anyone on the logic that they can just replace back in. You're still going to be responsible for the death of a civ even if they can come back in someone else's role that's still one civ down.

You keep calling yourself "a civ" as if it's a subjectively guaranteed thing. Obviously lynching a guaranteed civvie so they can replace another probable civvie would be a bad plan but that isn't what the situation was. You know that.

#509

*votes for blooper cus its not me* :0

#510

Kylemii wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:You were the first to vote for me. I didn't have a lynch opponent. It wouldn't have made sense to lynch Nev, no, but I don't think it makes sense to lynch anyone on the logic that they can just replace back in. You're still going to be responsible for the death of a civ even if they can come back in someone else's role that's still one civ down.
You keep calling yourself "a civ" as if it's a subjectively guaranteed thing. Obviously lynching a guaranteed civvie so they can replace another probable civvie would be a bad plan but that isn't what the situation was. You know that.

I'm not doing that at all. What I am saying is that you literally said it would be fine to lynch me if I'm a civ because I could replace back in. YOU said that even if I was a civ it would be okay for me to die. You said that.

#511

DAY 6

Who deserves to die?

Poll ended at Wed Aug 06, 2014 10:57:11 am

bea
0
No votes

birdwithteeth11
1
Keterman (3) 4%

Black Rock
0
No votes

Boogs
1
Boomslang (13) 4%

Boomslang
0
No votes

Bullzeye
2
Dom (2), unfurl (6) 8%

Canucklehead
0
No votes

DisgruntledPorcupine 2.0
0
No votes

Dom
0
No votes

Elohcin
1
Black Rock (24) 4%

Hedgeowl
0
No votes

juliets
0
No votes

Keterman
0
No votes

Kylemii
3
thellama73 (5), bea (12), Bullzeye (18) 12%

Leamiteo
1
S~V~S (20) 4%

Long Con
1
Boogs (8) 4%

Metalmarsh89 2.0
1
Metalmarsh89 (17) 4%

Mister Rearranger
0
No votes

nijuukyugou
7
Russtifinko (10), timmer (14), Canucklehead (19), juliets (21), Hedgeowl (22), Long Con (23), Kylemii (25) 28%

Russtifinko
1
DisgruntledPorcupine (15) 4%

S~V~S
0
No votes

Sorsha
0
No votes

Spacedaisy
0
No votes

thellama73
0
No votes

timmer
1
Vompatti (16) 4%

unfurl
0
No votes

Vompatti
2
Sorsha (9), nijuukyugou (11) 8%

Everyone!!!! (host, mod, injured, dead)
3
MovingPictures07 (1), Epignosis (4), DharmaHelper (7) 12%

Total votes : 25

#512

Hedgeowl wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote: So your vote was more of a shot in the dark for Kyle and yet Bea followed your instincts on this one? Strange,
Bea is very smart. I wish more people would follow my instincts.

You both are very smart. However, if your instincts were right about me more often I might follow them too. my instincts are feeling ok about you so far this game, which is why I was curious. What are your thought on project mayhem recruitment this game compared to your recruitment in American gods? How did you decide to recruit certain people?

I had a (sort of) role checker on my team in AG, so I recruited people whose powers I thought would be useful. Sometimes I would recruit people who were trying to get me lynched. I am wondering whether project mayhem is still recruiting nightly. I feel like that makes them too powerful, since unless we lynch one every day, they are destined to grow in numbers and inevitably win. But then again, we have the policemen as well.

The main thing that has stuck out to me is how clueless we all seem to be this game. Usually there is a bit more consensus on lynches than this. We are really scattered this game.

#513

I'd say that five people missed the vote... lemme go see who.

BWT
Elohcin
Leamiteo
Mister Rearranger
Spacedaisy

Yikes guys... yikes.

#514

Day 6: Ninja Blooper's Game Over

nijuukyugou has been lynched. She was an unrecruited Civilian.

Hedgeowl has won the fight. Boomslang has not been seriously injured.

It is now Night 6. You have 24 hours to send in your PMs and select new fighters.

#515

Now I'm not going to kill those who missed the vote this time... but I have something else in mind. Consider this just your one warning.

#516

oh no! That couldnt be worse! I feel awful.

#517

Blooper was an honest cop. RIP, and thanks for your service, nijuukyugou.

#518

Oops!!!! Sorry about that guys. LMAO. I have no idea why I typed cop. She was not a cop. I fixed the post. She was an unrecruited Civilian.

Had a brain moment there.

#519

Long Con wrote: Blooper was an honest cop. RIP, and thanks for your service, nijuukyugou.

Never mind, must have been a Host mistake... and I saw it!

Blooper was a regular Civ. Unrecruited, though. Not as bad, but still... not good.

#520

So who wants to fight that hasn't won one yet?

#521

I got seriously injured last time. Not sure I want to fight again.

#522

Bullzeye wrote:
Kylemii wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:You were the first to vote for me. I didn't have a lynch opponent. It wouldn't have made sense to lynch Nev, no, but I don't think it makes sense to lynch anyone on the logic that they can just replace back in. You're still going to be responsible for the death of a civ even if they can come back in someone else's role that's still one civ down.
You keep calling yourself "a civ" as if it's a subjectively guaranteed thing. Obviously lynching a guaranteed civvie so they can replace another probable civvie would be a bad plan but that isn't what the situation was. You know that.
I'm not doing that at all. What I am saying is that you literally said it would be fine to lynch me if I'm a civ because I could replace back in. YOU said that even if I was a civ it would be okay for me to die. You said that.

What? No.

I said it would be less of a risk because of that. I didn't say that that it would be good to run around lynching anyone just to replace in for inactive players.

There is a huge difference between those two ideas.

#523

Holy bandwagon in a sort of last hour!

Long Con wrote: Also, BR is still asleep (we were up late last night), so I'm just going to get her vote from her and do it. I don't want to see her die. She can post later when she gets up.

Is allowed that people can vote for others?, sorry, if I sound too serious but that feels unfair imo, even you too are realated, I dont think it will be allowed for other players

#524

unfurl wrote:Holy bandwagon in a sort of last hour!

Long Con wrote: Also, BR is still asleep (we were up late last night), so I'm just going to get her vote from her and do it. I don't want to see her die. She can post later when she gets up.
Is allowed that people can vote for others?, sorry, if I sound too serious but that feels unfair imo, even you too are realated, I dont think it will be allowed for other players

She was just using me as an extension of her hand on the mouse. It was her vote, made by her.

#525

Long Con wrote:
unfurl wrote:Holy bandwagon in a sort of last hour!

Long Con wrote: Also, BR is still asleep (we were up late last night), so I'm just going to get her vote from her and do it. I don't want to see her die. She can post later when she gets up.
Is allowed that people can vote for others?, sorry, if I sound too serious but that feels unfair imo, even you too are realated, I dont think it will be allowed for other players
She was just using me as an extension of her hand on the mouse. It was her vote, made by her.

Isn't that illegal BTSC?

#526

thellama73 wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote: So your vote was more of a shot in the dark for Kyle and yet Bea followed your instincts on this one? Strange,
Bea is very smart. I wish more people would follow my instincts.

You know what, I was tempted to vote for Kyle, there is something about his going back with bullz, I can see both of them of possible being tyler as both were together with DH
but both of them can not be him or recruits for the matter, cause I dont think that back in forth bewteen them sounds fake atm

---

I dont think Vomp is tyler,
I dont know if roles where randomized or hand out, but vomp being tyler is something I think is less likely
but maybe because is less likely in my mind is possible

haha, but I do lean less likely

---

Juliets,
LC being very quiet is something that has been a inside concern of mine, he responded of being busy and whatnot
more so cause he did started with DH also in the same place, but LC is not a shy baddie, my impression of him, is that he is more outspoken when he is bad,
so I had not really bring him up, but I´ve been watchin him

---

Also a thought I had
I know I have been thinking and said that is very likely tyler is superpowerfull and can beat anyones really bad

Has anyone thought that what if tyler fought already and losed in purpose?

so everyone will be there is not way tyler will lose a fight
I think it will be very smart move for tyler to lose their first fight, is something that it been floating in my head

I cant wait to see how wrong or right I have been

---

Linky
ok LC
and is not something that I outrageous by, probably feels more honest that you mention it, cause you could had not say anything, and not one would had know

#527

I totally missed the vote :/ I really thought it was pm, not am. I have been sick for five days and am still fighting this cold. I have not been totally with it. I am going to vote for myself again b/c I have not fought STILL and I am getting pretty bored.

I will vote myself and boogs again. He hasn't fought either, right?!

#528

Okay, never mind...I guess you can only vote one person this time. I am so confused. I voted for myself.

#529

Elohcin wrote:I totally missed the vote :/ I really thought it was pm, not am. I have been sick for five days and am still fighting this cold. I have not been totally with it. I am going to vote for myself again b/c I have not fought STILL and I am getting pretty bored. I will vote myself and boogs again. He hasn't fought either, right?!

Boogs has fought and won, but since you haven't and obviously want to I will give you my vote!

#530

RIP ninja blooper

Does fighting involve any physical activity or is it just random chance whether you lose or win?

#531

Hate to see you get bored Elohcin. I'll vote for you to fight too!

#532

Id be good with Eloh fighting... rip nijuu, sorry

#533

Juliets
Do you want to fight? I voted for you previous night, and I will vote for you again, if you want to

#534

I trust Long Con to not cheat if he's going to help BR vote. However, it's prob not a good thing to do... what if lc logs on and sees that br has four waiting msgs or something. .. it might get his brain turning even if he wouldn't read them. Again, I trust lc and br, but next time man, you might need to wake her and tell her to vote herself

#535

Ugh, I am so sorry, everyone, I have totally been out of it. I've been under the weather since Monday, trying to prepare for moving, and all of that stuff.

I meant to make the poll have two votes each like last time, I guess this one will just have one. We'll get back to two next poll.

#536

timmer wrote:I trust Long Con to not cheat if he's going to help BR vote. However, it's prob not a good thing to do... what if lc logs on and sees that br has four waiting msgs or something. .. it might get his brain turning even if he wouldn't read them. Again, I trust lc and br, but next time man, you might need to wake her and tell her to vote herself

I did not have 4 waiting messages

I was awake. I opened my eyes and saw him at the computer, looked at the clock and said "Holy shit, I have to vote. Click on it for me." I did not think of it as a big deal. The I turned over and went to sleep again. It's really my sisters fault. She wanted to play games and drink last night. She made me drink too much and stay up till 4am. I am turning 35 at the end of the month so 4am is too hard for me. I shall never let her talk me into that again.

If people think it was unfair I will take a punishment. It was not illegal BTSC, and never even told him why I was voting that way.

Now for the reason I voted that way. I was not caught up in the thread and I could not read this morning. I voted for a quieter person that had no votes. I wasn't comfortable voting for anyone who had votes because I had no idea why people were voting that way.

#537

I WANT TO HIT SOMEONE! Vote for me to fight, you turds!

#538

timmer wrote:I trust Long Con to not cheat if he's going to help BR vote. However, it's prob not a good thing to do... what if lc logs on and sees that br has four waiting msgs or something. .. it might get his brain turning even if he wouldn't read them. Again, I trust lc and br, but next time man, you might need to wake her and tell her to vote herself

When you're married and use the same computer, you learn to work around each other in a Mafia game. It's just something we always have to deal with, and we generally ignore each other for most of the game to make things easier, and to ensure that any suspicion of trust either of us garner is strictly for in-game behaviour.

#539

unfurl wrote:Juliets
Do you want to fight? I voted for you previous night, and I will vote for you again, if you want to

unfurl, I really don't want to fight. I know i haven't fought and that may lead some people to vote for me but I would really rather not. I will likely vote elochin since she hasnt fought and wants to fight and since we only have one vote this time that will be my only choice.

#540

Ok JC, I forgot to ask previously, and voted for you, but I thought to better ask this time

I will vote for Elo as she was the first one to ask nicely

#541

Canucklehead wrote:I WANT TO HIT SOMEONE! Vote for me to fight, you turds!

Voting canuck cus of this very incredibly persuasive argument.

#542

Black Rock wrote:
I did not have 4 waiting messages

Like I said, I trust you guys.

#543

Elohcin hasn't fought yet. She gets my vote.

#544

elochin gets my vote as well

#545

Voting Elo

#546

INH, aren't you dead?

#547

I love you, kylemii. I will never vote for you again as long as I live ever.

#548

Bullzeye wrote:INH, aren't you dead?

thellama73 wrote:General Announcement: Please check to make sure you are still alive before posting on topic in the thread. Thanks very much.

#549

insertnamehere wrote:Voting Elo

Bullzeye wrote:INH, aren't you dead?

This is my favourite thing that has ever happened in a game of Mafia.

#550

Canucklehead wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:Voting Elo

Bullzeye wrote:INH, aren't you dead?
This is my favourite thing that has ever happened in a game of Mafia.

It has happened in two (2) games in a row.