Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[Alison]

I think both of the posts that Esooa quoted are pretty NAI for Jay.

[Esooa]

My read on tutuu's energetic openings -- No read exists, please provide new input.

My read on tutuu's initial reads -- They're fine I guess. Consensus.

My perspective of tutuu -- No gripes, read will develop with more original contribution once she has acclimated. Cannot call town read with any confidence.

And this post is just wut. He wrote 3 sentences that say completely nothing

Would Jay struggle to produce more meaningful content if he was mafia?

I'm not going to level myself into making bad posts is towny, actually

if he makes towny posts I'll reconsider but atm no

[Sloonei]

My read on tutuu's energetic openings -- No read exists, please provide new input.

My read on tutuu's initial reads -- They're fine I guess. Consensus.

My perspective of tutuu -- No gripes, read will develop with more original contribution once she has acclimated. Cannot call town read with any confidence.

And this post is just wut. He wrote 3 sentences that say completely nothing

Would Jay struggle to produce more meaningful content if he was mafia?

I'm not going to level myself into making bad posts is towny, actually

if he makes towny posts I'll reconsider but atm no

i don't know what this means.

jay is town.

[Esooa]

it means Jay has bad posts and I'm not going to take "mafia would make good posts" as a way to disagree with that

[Alison]

I agree that it's a nothingburger but this is just how Jay provides reads early on in the game. I have no reason to call X a civillian, I have no gripe with Y but am looking forward to seeing their progression, etc.

[Sloonei]

it means Jay has bad posts and I'm not going to take "mafia would make good posts" as a way to disagree with that

That is not the point I am trying to make. My question was rhetorical. The answer is No, Jay would not struggle to make "better" posts than that one if he was mafia.

I don't think it will suffice to call it a "bad" post. That is a misread of his intention. He does not "say nothing." He says that tutuu's entrance has not been particularly alignment-indicative. Tutuu had just showed up in a whirlwind of typos, and it was a new topic of conversation. Jay weighed in to say that he had no cause for alarm at her entrance, but that it was also not enough for him to grant a town read on tutuu. That's not nothing. That's not a bad post.

[Esooa]

I'm not going to find the post but his read on tsp early was also scummy imo

[Esooa]

I still think the post is scummy because he uses way too many words in what appears to be an effort to now intricately than normally read tutuu while actually adding nothing of worth. If he had said something like "tutuu is still null atm" or whatever other such thing then okay. But I don't think the nature of the post is simply "tutuus entrance had been NAI"

[Esooa]

more intricately than normal*

[Sloonei]

Spoiler: show

setup spec time: i wonder if this is multiball

I bet mafia-aligned players are more likely to conceive of this by page two than civilians are. How about THAT?

setup spec time: i wonder if this is multiball

I bet mafia-aligned players are more likely to conceive of this by page two than civilians are. How about THAT?

setup spec time: i wonder if this is multiball

why are you on a relatively small mafia team?

well now, aren't you one for jumping to conclusions

TonyStarkPrime, why did I just cringe at one of your posts on page 2 with my actual human face?

As the official Jay Interpreter: none of these posts contain a read on TSP. All three of them are meant to instigate. These are proverbial poo flings.

[Sloonei]

I still think the post is scummy because he uses way too many words in what appears to be an effort to now intricately than normally read tutuu while actually adding nothing of worth. If he had said something like "tutuu is still null atm" or whatever other such thing then okay. But I don't think the nature of the post is simply "tutuus entrance had been NAI"

But Esooa, that would be boring.

[Esooa]

do you not think saying something is more likely done by mafia than town while quoting their posts is the same as scum reading a player

[Sloonei]

do you not think saying something is more likely done by mafia than town while quoting their posts is the same as scum reading a player

Not in that specific context, no. At least not insofar as we can say that JaggedJimmyJay currently believes TunaSharkPiranha to be aligned with the mafia team. There might have been a twinge of suspicion. I believe there was. But he only pushed on it lightly to see if anything would be uncovered. This is a standard JaggedJimmyPlay.

[Oddmerta]

Allison, town read me for no reason please

[Alison]

The real question is if Esooa would push on this point like this as mafia. I think it's within her scum range, not necessarily because she wants to get Jay killed (she can't, not with this case), but because she wants to be seen as tunneled town. I don't really get a strong impression one way or another as to how authentic this push is and think it's a coin flip. I do think her earlier insistency when arguing with SPF was townie. There she felt more like a townie who's bit on a solid lead, with the triumphant brandishing of the post from another game as proof that SPF was lying, and so forth. Here it feels more like she's repeating the party line because she's made up her mind about Jay.

[Alison]

Allison, town read me for no reason please

ok

[Sloonei]

Allison, town read me for no reason please

do you town read alison?

[Oddmerta]

Allison, town read me for no reason please

do you town read alison?

Yes I do

[Oddmerta]

Long Con has pinged me as not town

[Esooa]

The real question is if Esooa would push on this point like this as mafia. I think it's within her scum range, not necessarily because she wants to get Jay killed (she can't, not with this case), but because she wants to be seen as tunneled town. I don't really get a strong impression one way or another as to how authentic this push is and think it's a coin flip. I do think her earlier insistency when arguing with SPF was townie. There she felt more like a townie who's bit on a solid lead, with the triumphant brandishing of the post from another game as proof that SPF was lying, and so forth. Here it feels more like she's repeating the party line because she's made up her mind about Jay.

I'm town and I'm not tunneled. I don't actually care about the jjj read past saying like, he's who I would kill if I had to right now

I asked Jess about the read to get more from her cause I generally like trying to solve jess

I argued about it with sloonei cause he was being annoying by being quoting my posts and going basically "no lol"

until he said more later though not anything to the extent of why jjj is actually town, just why he's not exactly mafia.

though I decided I'd rather just drop the conversation than try to figure it out

[Oddmerta]

I want Sloonei to be scum because I'm town and I want to beat the world champion

[Esooa]

I want Sloonei to be scum because I'm town and I want to beat the world champion

lmao

[MacDougall]

I think both of the posts that Esooa quoted are pretty NAI for Jay.

No they are both AI. Just town indicative.

[tutuu]

@novaselinenever

novaselinenever

falcon45ca
tedxtr
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Oddmerta
Sloonei
Esooa
Strawhenge
JaggedJimmyJay
staypositivefriend
KZA
MacDougall
Dom
Marmot
TonyStarkPrime
Long Con
fingersplints
tutuu
Justplayingitcool
Michelle
Alison
BoKnows
AL_sama

[tutuu]

^^^^ CHRONOLOGICAL ISOS

hosts PLS pay ATTENTION

backwards are ur ownnnn fault its not hard to make chronological isos

[MacDougall]

Falcon still prob town
Ted can die
Oddmerta townie
Sloonei town for now
Esooa town probably
Strawhenge seemed town enough

[MacDougall]

Jay and SPF town
KZA can die

[MacDougall]

TSP is probably town but I hope not
Marmot and LC both need to be set fire to

[Esooa]

Falcon still prob town
Ted can die
Oddmerta townie
Sloonei town for now
Esooa town probably
Strawhenge seemed town enough

why am I town

[MacDougall]

Tutuu is fine
JPIC is not
Alison I'm kinda scumreading.
El Sama and Boknows can also both die.

[MacDougall]

Falcon still prob town
Ted can die
Oddmerta townie
Sloonei town for now
Esooa town probably
Strawhenge seemed town enough

why am I town

No.

[MacDougall]

I retract the Esooa read. I think she would just accept and revel in me townreading her usually as town.

That's specifically a her thing.

[tedxtr]

Ted can die

[tutuu]

^^^^ CHRONOLOGICAL ISOS

hosts PLS pay ATTENTION

backwards are ur ownnnn fault its not hard to make chronological isos

Just so theres no misunderstanding - i meant hosts who put backwards isos, i didnt mean this as "hurry up with the isos next time pls!"

[Esooa]

I retract the Esooa read. I think she would just accept and revel in me townreading her usually as town.

That's specifically a her thing.

the fuck lmao

[tedxtr]

hi tutuu why are you mean to our host

[Esooa]

tutuu what's your read on me

[Esooa]

I'm going to solve every player through nothing but their reads on me

mac is going to read this as me justifying asking him why

[tutuu]

Too many typos means the typos are intentional. Intentional typos means tutuu is trying to pocket us with her cutesy half-clueless half-tryhard act like she does as scum every time. The difference is that it's genuine when she's town and inauthentic when she's scum.

I was on phone and it was 4:46 am and i was very excited! im on laptop rn. i think i made similar tons of typos in my first game here in which i was also stuck on phone - space invaders

[tutuu]

hi im gay =)

angle shooting @ mods

LMAO

[Justplayingitcool]

Tutuu is fine
JPIC is not
Alison I'm kinda scumreading.
El Sama and Boknows can also both die.

why am I not fine

[tutuu]

setup spec time: i wonder if this is multiball

I bet mafia-aligned players are more likely to conceive of this by page two than civilians are. How about THAT?

Im town and i thought the same (as tony)

Why?

[tutuu]

Falcon and Alison think JPIC is W.
JJJ and Alison think Mac is V.
Mac and Alison think Falcon is V.

I am townreading all of Falcon/JJJ/Mac. If you'd like to pocket me for free, now is your chance. Limited time offer only, expires at the end of D0.

How do I say this. I actually am scumreading JPIC also. I didn't out that read because I didn't want to.

I believe you. How are you feeling this game Mac?

I have no feelings that directly pertain to this game. My general feelings towards life, myself and the time that I am bound to waste are negative though.

Huggieeeee maccie goattttt

Huggieeeee tooootie goatttt

hihihihihhihihihiih <3 <3 <3 <3 <3

[tutuu]

tutuu outed a pretty strong scumread on JPIC. What do you all think of that?

I think it's a bus.

lol

[Justplayingitcool]

tutuu outed a pretty strong scumread on JPIC. What do you all think of that?

I think it's a bus.

lol

What's your pretty strong scum read on me?

[tutuu]

tutuu outed a pretty strong scumread on JPIC. What do you all think of that?

I think it's a bus.

I'm not generally a fan of reads based on post volume, but doing so doesn't make my scumdar beep. Does tutuu bus a lot in other games?

tutuu is scum for other reasons. I'm discussing whether her read on JPIC is authentic or not.

1. It does seem like a reach at surface level, so it might lose some authenticity points.

2. What are the other reasons tutuu is scum?

what is reaching here?

[tutuu]

So far all of the arguments for TSP being mafia have sounded like farts to my ears.

i agree idk why do ppl have beef with him

i dont see any post of tsp as scummy or wrong or suspicious, its tsp playing like good old tsp

[tutuu]

HELLOOOOOOOOOO HOW ARE YOU GUYS I HAVENT PLAYED MAFIA IN SO LONG IM SO EXCITED I COULDNT WAIT TILL TRH GAELME ISNOVER IM ACTUALY FEELING SO FRESH LIKE I JUST DTSRTED PPLAYIBG MAFIA AGAIN AND THERES SO MUCH MEMORIES

IM AT MY GRANDMAS VILLAGE AND IN THIS VERY ROOM I STARTED PLAYING MAFIA A FEW YEARS AGO. ALSO I HAVE NO WIFI AND I HAVE TO USE MOBILE DATA THANKFULLY MY PLAN GIVES ME 20 GB EVERY MONTH. ALSO ON MY FITDT SYNDICATE GAME I WAS IN MY OTHER GTNADMAS VILLAGE AND I ALSO HAD TO USE MOBILE DATA AND ITS SOOO NOSTALGIC SO REFTEHSING

u are the grandma

SHUT UPPPPPPPP NERDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Esooa has stated three suspicions that all look rather baked to me, and for similar reasons: doubling down on something unworthy of a stubborn view. This applies to her treatment of KZA, SPF, and myself -- primarily the former two since those have already involved direct interaction. The spoiler contains some of the receipts; I'm not going to spam them all in there though.

Griping with KZA about "not sure it's real" vs. "not sure it's legitimate" -- I'm not sure that's real.

Griping with SPF about taking a reserved approach to reading her after one or two games in which she made incorrect town reads -- at the least I don't think that's reasonable.

Griping with me for various level one beefs e.g. "showiness" or "made a post without a clear read in it". Refusing to view me through a "would make better posts if he was mafia" lens after meeting resistance to that read even though one of her gripes with me was that I did basically the same thing with Tony (didn't immediately assume he wouldn't make a post that is on the surface suspicious or that it's not worth poking him over on page one) It all feels a bit like activity inflation more than it feels like an effort to solve.

Spoiler: show

k Sloonei is town

Falcon's case on him I'm having trouble believing is real tbh

weirdchamp post

weak FOS Mafooa

if you were wanting to actually figure stuff out between them I have no clue why you say you have trouble believing it's real, rather than you're not sure of the legitimacy of it.

saying you're not sure if it's real = assumption the person is making it up, i.e. mafia

Not sure of it's legitimacy = not sure if their case holds water without assumption on their alignment

in fallout mafia you stated an early town read on me without problem

What's the difference?

you were mafia, though. i've learned that the best way to read you is to keep a microscope on your progressions & the specific angles that you push, and the game hasn't gone on for long enough for me to have any meaningful opinions about you. even so, you have my GTH read on you

I feel like you're faking paranoia/skepticism cause you're not sure how you should go about reading me as mafia

But okay

she just townread you when you were a wolf. Do you not think that this would have any impact?

this was last month,

"i like esooa's p#214 (and gimmick in general) both because her gimmick is funny and because she's doing something unique and out-of-character without caring about how it's going to make other people perceive her. my meta on esooa is that she tends to carve herself into her own corners of the game as town and isn't afraid to do stuff that goes against the mindset of ~wanting~ to be townread - i think that esooa adopting her gimmick for as long as she did is something that bodes well for. i also kind of liked esooa hiveminding w/me about one of rex's posts being towny on p#241. i'm not going to pretend to know how to read esooa, but i get generally good vibes from her slot so far"

as the 305th post

After Jess town read me, while I was wolf, two games in a row

I don't think that is why she isn't giving a read on me

setup spec time: i wonder if this is multiball

I bet mafia-aligned players are more likely to conceive of this by page two than civilians are. How about THAT?

probably, but are mafia more likely to say it than town? no

[Justplayingitcool]

tutuu did you break the caps lock button