Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[JaggedJimmyJay]

since fallout 2 jess and I have played two t/t games together, which is where I pulled the previous quotes from

Okay, thank you. That I did not realize. I will revisit that exchange and see to what extent I care. At the least it helps me to understand your gripe.

[Strawhenge]

Cool beans, thanks. How do you feel about Sloonei's concerns about Alison?

I think he brought up what seems like a valid point, but at least part of it is based on Alison's meta. It definitely makes me read Sloonei as being carefully vigilant as well.

[Strawhenge]

Sloonei is town.

In turn, why so sure here?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I'll expand on my read of Sloonei so it's more useful to folks than just blank JJJ/Sloonei meta.

His initial suspicions of Alison reflect to me the very sort of civilian mindset that I associate with Sloonei. He is not one to accept off-hand shenanigans like those that can exist in a first-post claim, and his reservations closely enough parallel some of my initial thoughts that I think it rings honestly. I don't think he has been overly adamant or pushy about the read (which I wouldn't like). He said his piece, he exchanged some words with Alison, and arrived at an eventual meh before turning his attention to other matters, such as disinterest in Tony suspicions. I doubt he is entirely finished with Alison, but he is allowing it to stew in his brain while he does other stuff. It's all a progression of play that I recognize uniquely in Sloonei.

This is still a "Day 0 read", so I will continue to interpret Sloonei moving forward. But for now he gets my stamp of approval.

[Sloonei]

If this Day 0 poll remains logjammed, which I tend to anticipate with one east-American and one European left to vote, then I suggest one of the 8pm folks move to 6pm. I think it's less reasonable to ask Europeans to be awake at 1am or later than it is to ask west-Americans to be around at 3pm. I acknowledge it'd also be 8am for the poor folks on the Australian east coast.

Fine.

[Oddmerta]

I'll expand on my read of Sloonei so it's more useful to folks than just blank JJJ/Sloonei meta.

His initial suspicions of Alison reflect to me the very sort of civilian mindset that I associate with Sloonei. He is not one to accept off-hand shenanigans like those that can exist in a first-post claim, and his reservations closely enough parallel some of my initial thoughts that I think it rings honestly. I don't think he has been overly adamant or pushy about the read (which I wouldn't like). He said his piece, he exchanged some words with Alison, and arrived at an eventual meh before turning his attention to other matters, such as disinterest in Tony suspicions. I doubt he is entirely finished with Alison, but he is allowing it to stew in his brain while he does other stuff. It's all a progression of play that I recognize uniquely in Sloonei.

This is still a "Day 0 read", so I will continue to interpret Sloonei moving forward. But for now he gets my stamp of approval.

Yeah, you're compromised. I am taking over Sloonei watch

[Sloonei]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

[Sloonei]

Am I a sucker for thinking that Esooa's frustration with the responses she's receiving are indicative of a good clean townsperson?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Yeah, you're compromised. I am taking over Sloonei watch

You got specific Sloonei beefs?

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Did he say that

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Oh yeah he wants to beat the champ k

[Sloonei]

Yeah, you're compromised. I am taking over Sloonei watch

You got specific Sloonei beefs?

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Did he say that

I want Sloonei to be scum because I'm town and I want to beat the world champion

[Oddmerta]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

[Sloonei]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Am I a sucker for thinking that Esooa's frustration with the responses she's receiving are indicative of a good clean townsperson?

I'm at least willing to drop the SPF-specific gripe I raised earlier. I just looked back at their exchange with the new context in tow, and I can understand where Esooa is coming from. I don't think it impacts my own view of SPF really, but the accusation can be a genuine one.

Beyond that, I need more data. I'm colored by the bias inherent to my own posture in her ISO.

[Oddmerta]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

[Justplayingitcool]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

Why?

[Sloonei]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

[Justplayingitcool]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

[Oddmerta]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

He made a post, I didn't like it. That's all I need

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@Justplayingitcool you're being treated by some as a stronger mafia read than most Days 0 will facilitate. How do you feel about that? How do you feel about the players involved with that?

[AL_sama]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

I wonder what that might be hmm

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Maybe Oddmerta got exactly what he wanted by opposing civilian Sloonei.

[Oddmerta]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

The not reading pages part is what gave you away.

[Sloonei]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

He made a post, I didn't like it. That's all I need

What did you not like about it? What was contained in the words that made you look at them and think to yourself, "This person is a member of the mafia faction in Fargo Mafia"?

[Justplayingitcool]

@Justplayingitcool you're being treated by some as a stronger mafia read than most Days 0 will facilitate. How do you feel about that? How do you feel about the players involved with that?

I would feel better knowing the reason as to why I am scum read. The only understandable read came from Falcon even though my post was literally a copypasta.

[Justplayingitcool]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

The not reading pages part is what gave you away.

It's day 0

[Sloonei]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

I believe the argument is that you're not a beaming ball of town energy. You've been more passive than active, maybe, or have not taken enough action to assert yourself in the game so far.

This is not my read, it's just my interpretation of what others have said about you.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@Justplayingitcool you're being treated by some as a stronger mafia read than most Days 0 will facilitate. How do you feel about that? How do you feel about the players involved with that?

I would feel better knowing the reason as to why I am scum read. The only understandable read came from Falcon even though my post was literally a copypasta.

My own read on you is nothing confident either way. I'd vote for you in the absence of something more interesting. But I can take a stab at some gripes:

- Your entry to game could come across as timid.
- You haven't done much of anything outside goofing.
- You treat suspicions of you as surprising despite doing little outside goofing.

How about them apples?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Am I a sucker for thinking that Esooa's frustration with the responses she's receiving are indicative of a good clean townsperson?

Yes

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Sloonei and I make the same post within a minute. Good luck mafia.

[Justplayingitcool]

please note that oddmerta does not actually suspect me, he just "wants" me to be mafia.

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

I believe the argument is that you're not a beaming ball of town energy. You've been more passive than active, maybe, or have not taken enough action to assert yourself in the game so far.

This is not my read, it's just my interpretation of what others have said about you.

That discussion took place while I was asleep! The game opened at 11pm!!

I apologise for having a normal sleeping schedule

[Oddmerta]

Hello folks. I voted for 8pm!

This post, we can all clearly see that he voted for 8pm. Why feel the need to tell us this at all?

[Justplayingitcool]

@Justplayingitcool you're being treated by some as a stronger mafia read than most Days 0 will facilitate. How do you feel about that? How do you feel about the players involved with that?

I would feel better knowing the reason as to why I am scum read. The only understandable read came from Falcon even though my post was literally a copypasta.

My own read on you is nothing confident either way. I'd vote for you in the absence of something more interesting. But I can take a stab at some gripes:

- Your entry to game could come across as timid.
- You haven't done much of anything outside goofing.
- You treat suspicions of you as surprising despite doing little outside goofing.

How about them apples?

- Again, it's a copypasta.
- I goof regardless of alignment
- it's surprising because I hadn't heard a reason for the read

[Sloonei]

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

I believe the argument is that you're not a beaming ball of town energy. You've been more passive than active, maybe, or have not taken enough action to assert yourself in the game so far.

This is not my read, it's just my interpretation of what others have said about you.

That discussion took place while I was asleep! The game opened at 11pm!!

I apologise for having a normal sleeping schedule

You are playing a mafia game and think it's permissible to have a decent sleep schedule?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Sloonei and I make the same post within a minute. Good luck mafia.

Last time I read two people town for this it was hally and spf and spf was mafia playing out of her mind

[Sloonei]

@Justplayingitcool you're being treated by some as a stronger mafia read than most Days 0 will facilitate. How do you feel about that? How do you feel about the players involved with that?

I would feel better knowing the reason as to why I am scum read. The only understandable read came from Falcon even though my post was literally a copypasta.

My own read on you is nothing confident either way. I'd vote for you in the absence of something more interesting. But I can take a stab at some gripes:

- Your entry to game could come across as timid.
- You haven't done much of anything outside goofing.
- You treat suspicions of you as surprising despite doing little outside goofing.

How about them apples?

- Again, it's a copypasta.
- I goof regardless of alignment
- it's surprising because I hadn't heard a reason for the read

I believe I saw somebody suggest that you have been quicker to integrate yourself into the game as town in their recent experience with you. I believe the GoC was cited.

[tutuu]

@tutuu is it just me seeing things or you're indeed kinda acting pumped up??

i am (or more specifically was) pumped up yes!!!! that wasnt an act!!!

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Sloonei and I make the same post within a minute. Good luck mafia.

Last time I read two people town for this it was hally and spf and spf was mafia playing out of her mind

Those two have certainly forged a unique niche in the mindmeld universe. I have very rarely experienced something like that. Maybe it happened on a smaller scale with Alison in Bread Mafia.

[Justplayingitcool]

@Justplayingitcool you're being treated by some as a stronger mafia read than most Days 0 will facilitate. How do you feel about that? How do you feel about the players involved with that?

I would feel better knowing the reason as to why I am scum read. The only understandable read came from Falcon even though my post was literally a copypasta.

My own read on you is nothing confident either way. I'd vote for you in the absence of something more interesting. But I can take a stab at some gripes:

- Your entry to game could come across as timid.
- You haven't done much of anything outside goofing.
- You treat suspicions of you as surprising despite doing little outside goofing.

How about them apples?

- Again, it's a copypasta.
- I goof regardless of alignment
- it's surprising because I hadn't heard a reason for the read

I believe I saw somebody suggest that you have been quicker to integrate yourself into the game as town in their recent experience with you. I believe the GoC was cited.

Again, I was asleep. I was suspected at times quite a bit in day 1 during GoC

[Oddmerta]

Maybe I got exactly what I wanted

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

The not reading pages part is what gave you away.

It's day 0

Is it Day 0? Man I thought this was Day 7. I retract my scumread because I know how truly unimportant Day 0 is.

[Justplayingitcool]

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

The not reading pages part is what gave you away.

It's day 0

Is it Day 0? Man I thought this was Day 7. I retract my scumread because I know how truly unimportant Day 0 is.

Your patronising tone is noted

[JaggedJimmyJay]

JPIC, this is one of those situations where I suspect self-defense has little capacity to do anything but make things worse. If you're a townboy, I suggest you backburner all that and find some mafiers. It's the absence of mafier-finding primarily contributing to your position.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Sloonei and I make the same post within a minute. Good luck mafia.

Last time I read two people town for this it was hally and spf and spf was mafia playing out of her mind

Those two have certainly forged a unique niche in the mindmeld universe. I have very rarely experienced something like that. Maybe it happened on a smaller scale with Alison in Bread Mafia.

I platonically ship them

Idk what the word for that is

Like I ship them but not into a romance, rather into a mafia playing machine

[tutuu]

Am I a sucker for thinking that Esooa's frustration with the responses she's receiving are indicative of a good clean townsperson?

Yes

No

[AL_sama]

Hello folks. I voted for 8pm!

This post, we can all clearly see that he voted for 8pm. Why feel the need to tell us this at all?

it could very well mean something or nothing at all

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

You got any other reads to go along with this one?

There's the less obvious Long Con and the super obvious JPIC

These are both reads I have seen others express in the thread. I have some understanding of why JPIC is a suspect for people. I have no understanding of the LC case. Care to enlighten me?

You know more than me.

admittedly I haven't read the last 10 pages but literally, nobody has provided a reason as to why they scum read me when I've queried the read.

The not reading pages part is what gave you away.

It's day 0

Is it Day 0? Man I thought this was Day 7. I retract my scumread because I know how truly unimportant Day 0 is.

Scummy thing to say

[tutuu]

odd town

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Am I a sucker for thinking that Esooa's frustration with the responses she's receiving are indicative of a good clean townsperson?

Yes

No

Ok

[Oddmerta]

Anyway Sloonei is now lock scum for me, I can feel it in my bones

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Tutu out here disagreeing with every read as I make it, smh

Maybe I'll just sheep her