Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[Sloonei]

why is fingersplints a suspect? i don’t understand that. her posts seem completely fine to me

Just glancing at the thread after getting in from work. Have not read anything.

Fingersplints is in the “Not a townread” mold rather than the “scum read” mold.

why isn’t she a town read?

Her style has not leant itself to being overtly anything. She’s been active enough to avoid being a low poster, but has not done anything that has rocked the boat in any way either.

that seems like more a playstyle thing than an alignment thing, no? is she usually one to rock the boat as a villager?

I am not saying it is not a playstyle thing. Again, she's in the POE because she’s not a firm townread, not because she is actively suspicious.

[KZA]

Does anyone seriously townread JPIC?

[Sloonei]

Does anyone seriously townread JPIC?

Gun to my head, yes. I don’t think he’s Team Marmot, at least. But that’s not a slot I’m comfortable reading right now.

[Hally]

Why was nanook not an option after Michelle wiped ted off the board?

I would have voted for al_sama if I was here and being forced to choose between him and TSP. LC was partially right about me: I never suspected TSP that hard. If anything, I wish, I’d done more to stick up for him.

i feel you on wishing i’d stuck up for tony more. i never really understood what was so wolfy about him

nook wasn’t an option because he claims he can clear himself. voting him out when he wasn’t around to claim would have been bad

[Hally]

Does anyone seriously townread JPIC?

not really. i don’t remember anything he’s posted

[KZA]

If LC town I think JPIC wolf based on some earlier nudging

But i shouldn't pre flip that hard lol

[Sloonei]

Does @Long Con still suspect me after tony flipped town?

[Hally]

i agree jpic is not on marmot’s team but i think he could pretty easily be on the other one. nothing he’s posted feels difficult for a wolf to post at all

[Sloonei]

i agree jpic is not on marmot’s team but i think he could pretty easily be on the other one. nothing he’s posted feels difficult for a wolf to post at all

Yeah.

[Sloonei]

If I am choosing a “cleared” player we gave a pass to too easily, it’s falcon.

[Hally]

If I am choosing a “cleared” player we gave a pass to too easily, it’s falcon.

mhm

[KZA]

I'm gonna be done season 2 probably tomorrow so I can slide in as flavour person with TSP dead

[Esooa]

kza is a strong town read for me

[Hally]

kza is a strong town read for me

why?

[Oddmerta]

@Michelle next time don't mess around, if you have mech on a hugely scumread player say so. Don't wait the whole 48 hours

TonyStarkPrime next time don't mess around, if you're so largely scumread don't get all prideful and not claim. You weren't going to be the NK ever, even if you were what are the chances we get two wolves off of you? Also now we don't have your RB and vote silence.

[Oddmerta]

@Alison @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME clear yourselves immediately

[Hally]

i think tony didn’t claim because if he had claimed his real role we probably would have assumed it was a wolf role lol

[KZA]

Alison
Hally
Ted
Michelle
Odd
Esooa

Sloonei
SPF
Straw

Falcon
BK
Finger
LC

Nanook

JPIC
Al Sama

[KZA]

Why am I town reading the entire game gmmfjrkdmxnfm

[Esooa]

does anyone remember why I town read alison day 1

I don't remember if it was a good read or not

[Oddmerta]

i think tony didn’t claim because if he had claimed his real role we probably would have assumed it was a wolf role lol

He specifically lied and said he couldn't claim, anyway enough about that

[Oddmerta]

I don't trust Michelle anymore after that stunt but we have to roll with it because if either her or Ted flip red they are done

[Hally]

does anyone remember why I town read alison day 1

I don't remember if it was a good read or not

you can iso yourself and see

[Sloonei]

I don't trust Michelle anymore after that stunt but we have to roll with it because if either her or Ted flip red they are done

What do you mean when you say you don’t trust her?

[Oddmerta]

I just realized that I hard inted this game by forgetting to submit night actions again. Mea maxima culpa. Oh well.

No

[Oddmerta]

I don't trust Michelle anymore after that stunt but we have to roll with it because if either her or Ted flip red they are done

What do you mean when you say you don’t trust her?

I mean chocolate tastes like fish, what the hell do you think I mean?

[Hally]

i think michelle and alison are pretty obvious villagers

[Oddmerta]

Al, falcon, jpic, LC and Sloonei. Any towns here?

[Hally]

Al, falcon, jpic, LC and Sloonei. Any towns here?

please stop with this sloonei thing

[Oddmerta]

@BoKnows what can you do?

[Sloonei]

I don't trust Michelle anymore after that stunt but we have to roll with it because if either her or Ted flip red they are done

What do you mean when you say you don’t trust her?

I mean chocolate tastes like fish, what the hell do you think I mean?

I have no idea what you mean, because it is unclear. Hence the question. An answer would be nice.

[Oddmerta]

Al, falcon, jpic, LC and Sloonei. Any towns here?

please stop with this sloonei thing

Why? Do you have mech that clears him?

[Esooa]

i think michelle and alison are pretty obvious villagers

I agree just wanted to make sure on my alison

[Hally]

Al, falcon, jpic, LC and Sloonei. Any towns here?

please stop with this sloonei thing

Why? Do you have mech that clears him?

why is he a wolf? other than “i want him to be so i can catch the champ” or whatever silliness you’ve been on about

[Oddmerta]

Al, falcon, jpic, LC and Sloonei. Any towns here?

please stop with this sloonei thing

Why? Do you have mech that clears him?

why is he a wolf? other than “i want him to be so i can catch the champ” or whatever silliness you’ve been on about

He isn't helping the town win con, he has tmi, he keeps latching on to the joke statement I made as a means to discredit any suspicion I have on him

[Hally]

Al, falcon, jpic, LC and Sloonei. Any towns here?

please stop with this sloonei thing

Why? Do you have mech that clears him?

why is he a wolf? other than “i want him to be so i can catch the champ” or whatever silliness you’ve been on about

He isn't helping the town win con, he has tmi, he keeps latching on to the joke statement I made as a means to discredit any suspicion I have on him

please illustrate how he has tmi and knowingly isn’t helping the town wincon using his posts

[staypositivefriend]

"he isn't helping the town win condition" is the most vague reasoning for a wolfread that i've seen in any mafia game i've played ever

i think that sloonei is a villager, but i am open to entertaining tinfoil/skepticism about him. i have not seen any tinfoil against him that is not coaxed in overly vague and generic language

[Esooa]

sloonei told me in wolf chat "lol this sucker is dead on right but no one will listen to him cause I have too much clout"

is that good enough hally

[Hally]

"he isn't helping the town win condition" is the most vague reasoning for a wolfread that i've seen in any mafia game i've played ever

i think that sloonei is a villager, but i am open to entertaining tinfoil/skepticism about him. i have not seen any tinfoil against him that is not coaxed in overly vague and generic language

it’s vague because he made it up. he’s arbitrarily decided to wolf read sloonei since the start of the game because he wants to beat the champ. he has yet to provide any coherent or concrete reason why sloonei is a wolf

[Oddmerta]

Why did he go off wagon today?

[staypositivefriend]

"he isn't helping the town win condition" is the most vague reasoning for a wolfread that i've seen in any mafia game i've played ever

i think that sloonei is a villager, but i am open to entertaining tinfoil/skepticism about him. i have not seen any tinfoil against him that is not coaxed in overly vague and generic language

it’s vague because he made it up. he’s arbitrarily decided to wolf read sloonei since the start of the game because he wants to beat the champ. he has yet to provide any coherent or concrete reason why sloonei is a wolf

i agree that this seems to be his motivation - do you believe that oddmerta would approach sloonei in such a way if he was a villager? is oddmerta the type of villager to "make things up"?

i don't know the answer, but i'm asking you because if your description of oddmerta's push on sloonei is accurate, then i find it difficult to imagine him doing that from a villager mindset

[Esooa]

I just tried making a post wolf reading sloonei and when I clicked send post I was logged out

the system is built against us

now that slooneis name has been removed from the banner maybe us proles finally have a chance to take him down

[staypositivefriend]

my strongest townreads are alison, michelle, hally, and sloonei. i believe that there is one wolf in that list of names maximum. BoKnows and Strawhenge and Esooa are on the tier directly below that.

i think there may be a wolf in that list of names, but i believe it primarily contains villagers

[Hally]

Why did he go off wagon today?

he was on ted’s wagon. then he went to work. then michelle claimed a surprise green check on ted and blew up that wagon and sloonei wasn’t around to change his vote

[staypositivefriend]

Why did he go off wagon today?

this seems like a question that could be answered pretty plainly by reading the thread. is that your strongest argument in favor of sloonei being a wolf?

[Hally]

"he isn't helping the town win condition" is the most vague reasoning for a wolfread that i've seen in any mafia game i've played ever

i think that sloonei is a villager, but i am open to entertaining tinfoil/skepticism about him. i have not seen any tinfoil against him that is not coaxed in overly vague and generic language

it’s vague because he made it up. he’s arbitrarily decided to wolf read sloonei since the start of the game because he wants to beat the champ. he has yet to provide any coherent or concrete reason why sloonei is a wolf

i agree that this seems to be his motivation - do you believe that oddmerta would approach sloonei in such a way if he was a villager? is oddmerta the type of villager to "make things up"?

i don't know the answer, but i'm asking you because if your description of oddmerta's push on sloonei is accurate, then i find it difficult to imagine him doing that from a villager mindset

honestly? odd seems like exactly the kind of player to make up a wolf read as a villager purely for ego reasons and delude himself into believing it. he could also be a wolf doing it. it’s hard to say

[Sloonei]

Why did he go off wagon today?

If I wasn’t an admin I’d be saying bad words right now.

[Hally]

I just tried making a post wolf reading sloonei and when I clicked send post I was logged out

the system is built against us

now that slooneis name has been removed from the banner maybe us proles finally have a chance to take him down

insert joke about the MU elite here except for the syndicate

[Hally]

odd, let’s be real. you just arbitrarily decided to wolf read sloonei and are trying to come up with reasons to justify it after the fact. please stop insulting our intelligence

do you have any wolf reads you can actually substantiate?

[Oddmerta]

"he isn't helping the town win condition" is the most vague reasoning for a wolfread that i've seen in any mafia game i've played ever

i think that sloonei is a villager, but i am open to entertaining tinfoil/skepticism about him. i have not seen any tinfoil against him that is not coaxed in overly vague and generic language

it’s vague because he made it up. he’s arbitrarily decided to wolf read sloonei since the start of the game because he wants to beat the champ. he has yet to provide any coherent or concrete reason why sloonei is a wolf

i agree that this seems to be his motivation - do you believe that oddmerta would approach sloonei in such a way if he was a villager? is oddmerta the type of villager to "make things up"?

i don't know the answer, but i'm asking you because if your description of oddmerta's push on sloonei is accurate, then i find it difficult to imagine him doing that from a villager mindset

honestly? odd seems like exactly the kind of player to make up a wolf read as a villager purely for ego reasons and delude himself into believing it. he could also be a wolf doing it. it’s hard to say

Don't insult me