Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[BoKnows]

I come from a simpler world, where we lynch red checks & sometimes, tho very very rarely, have a naive sheriff.


All this mech action theorizing & shenaniganizing is too big brain for me.


I'm smooth braining this shiz & voting a red check, for the people.

Me too. This game was sending me straight to toon world last night. Luckily I slept off the toons.

Does that mean you're gonna vote the red check? Or where's your head at?

Nah from my understanding is that Michelle's red check is broken. Gonna up voting in my PoE, unless something cool happens. It's just the mechanics are starting to fly well over my head. They're a above my pay lol.

[BoKnows]

Everyone is F R O Z E N after I drop a sick bit of truth in the thread.

According the mafia wiki the player needs to claim stump in the thread to become the stump.

Since I have never heard of that, and have played in a number of games that have stumps, I'm not putting much stock in that.

Okay.

[Michelle]

I don't trust Esooa's claim.

I wish, if everyone thinks my result is wrong on Alison, to give her the possibility to clear herself.

I understand no one in this game.

Hally pressured me to claim and I tried to avoid the claim as much as I could. But my heart couldn't resist when I saw the wagon on Ted. Everyone thinks she is villager but Hally, the villager who posts 10000000 daily is demotivated and i don't get it.
Alison remembers me of GoC and her wagon is not growing which is concerning.
Esooa plays in a way i never saw her playing, in the negative meaning of this
Falcon choose to chop a villager instead scum (i strongly believe now that Al was scum)
Odd wanted Sloonei dead in a whimsical way.
KZA defends Esooa without reason, being defended by her in the same way.
SPF idk, something is missing from her, but in rhe last game my paranoia towards her could turn very bad

The demotivation thingy is like a virus, is spreading and infected me as well, is there a vaccine against it? A cure?

[Michelle]

It looks like Ben Schmidt should be a trooper from flavor yeah? Someone correct me if im wrong

I will defer to Alison on that one.

I am not a trooper, i think i would know about it

[Long Con]

Okay, but we're going to [VOTE: esooa] aubergine, right?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

It looks like Ben Schmidt should be a trooper from flavor yeah? Someone correct me if im wrong

I will defer to Alison on that one.

I am not a trooper, i think i would know about it

I don't think you would

[Long Con]

It looks like Ben Schmidt should be a trooper from flavor yeah? Someone correct me if im wrong

I will defer to Alison on that one.

I am not a trooper, i think i would know about it

I don't think you would

The first two claimants did.

[Long Con]

What if a kill or two on night 2 was due to an anti-claim mechanic?

[Long Con]

No that makes no sense, sorry. Troopers would be dead, Alison would be dead, who else was claimed?

Maybe there's no anti-claim.

[Long Con]

I could be speaking form the perspective of a guy that hasn't seen a Night in a while though.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

It looks like Ben Schmidt should be a trooper from flavor yeah? Someone correct me if im wrong

I will defer to Alison on that one.

I am not a trooper, i think i would know about it

I don't think you would

The first two claimants did.

They did due to flavor yeah? Don't think they were explicitly told "you are a trooper" or whatever

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Anyways I just want someone with flavor knowledge or Alison to answer, I dont really care about other speculation tbh

[Esooa]

what's up

[Esooa]

Okay, but we're going to [VOTE: esooa] aubergine, right?

sounds fun, let me join you

[Esooa]

has Michelle given her check?

[BoKnows]

has Michelle given her check?

Red check on Alison. But it's funky

[Esooa]

how so?

[BoKnows]

how so?

It was on N2 when Odd busdrove sloonei and Alison. So it would of been a red-check on Sloonei, but we know Sloonei was villager cause of his flip.

[Esooa]

wtf

[Strawhenge]

@Esooa, you've claimed tree stump, essentially. And you claimed you 'started as such'. But you also claimed to be able to doctor Alison. Tree stumps classically don't have any other abilities—not even voting—except that they just can't die.

Even if your doctor role was 1-shot or x-shot, I'm having a lot of trouble believing this claim. Which part of your claims were you lying about, and why?

[Esooa]

so it's just a framer or what?

[Esooa]

@Esooa, you've claimed tree stump, essentially. And you claimed you 'started as such'. But you also claimed to be able to doctor Alison. Tree stumps classically don't have any other abilities—not even voting—except that they just can't die.

Even if your doctor role was 1-shot or x-shot, I'm having a lot of trouble believing this claim. Which part of your claims were you lying about, and why?

I don't really care what you think about it

[BoKnows]

so it's just a framer or what?

huh what is that?

[Strawhenge]

@Esooa, you've claimed tree stump, essentially. And you claimed you 'started as such'. But you also claimed to be able to doctor Alison. Tree stumps classically don't have any other abilities—not even voting—except that they just can't die.

Even if your doctor role was 1-shot or x-shot, I'm having a lot of trouble believing this claim. Which part of your claims were you lying about, and why?

I don't really care what you think about it

Well then, let's test it.

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

If you're town and want to win, stop us from wagoning an actual tree stump.

[Esooa]

so it's just a framer or what?

huh what is that?

a role which the person they target at night will show up as red on checks

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

so it's just a framer or what?

Or odd was blocked

[Long Con]

so it's just a framer or what?

Or odd was blocked

Or is on Alison's team.

[Esooa]

so it's just a framer or what?

Or odd was blocked

ah, maybe

is there any real reason to think Alison is mafia otherwise

who else can be mafia

[Esooa]

@Esooa, you've claimed tree stump, essentially. And you claimed you 'started as such'. But you also claimed to be able to doctor Alison. Tree stumps classically don't have any other abilities—not even voting—except that they just can't die.

Even if your doctor role was 1-shot or x-shot, I'm having a lot of trouble believing this claim. Which part of your claims were you lying about, and why?

I don't really care what you think about it

Well then, let's test it.

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

If you're town and want to win, stop us from wagoning an actual tree stump.

I encourage it. My vote is on myself, see?

[Michelle]

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

so it's just a framer or what?

Or odd was blocked

ah, maybe

is there any real reason to think Alison is mafia otherwise

who else can be mafia

I think there might be, yeah

At least I don't think her claim can be true

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

Who steals from people without knowing their names?
Poll runs till Fri Apr 16, 2021 1:00 am
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


Alison
2
11%
Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, falcon45ca
BoKnows
0
No votes
Voters: None
Esooa
4
21%
Voters: Esooa, Strawhenge, Michelle, Long Con
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
fingersplints
1
5%
Voters: Hally
Hally
0
No votes
Voters: None
Justplayingitcool
0
No votes
Voters: None
KZA
1
5%
Voters: staypositivefriend
Long Con
0
No votes
Voters: None
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
0
No votes
Voters: None
Oddmerta
0
No votes
Voters: None
staypositivefriend
0
No votes
Voters: None
Strawhenge
1
5%
Voters: Oddmerta
Unvote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Elimination
1
5%
Voters: BoKnows
Now that's just lazy (Host/Dead/Non)
9
47%
Voters: TonyStarkPrime, MacDougall, novaselinenever, JaggedJimmyJay, nutella, Sloonei, Marmot, Made, Gavial
Total votes: 19

vc

[falcon45ca]

how so?

It was on N2 when Odd busdrove sloonei and Alison. So it would of been a red-check on Sloonei, but we know Sloonei was villager cause of his flip.

Wait, so this whole thing is contingent on Odd & Alison telling the truth? Odd, who was cleared by Alison...is there another clear on Odd I'm unaware?

[Strawhenge]

@Esooa, you've claimed tree stump, essentially. And you claimed you 'started as such'. But you also claimed to be able to doctor Alison. Tree stumps classically don't have any other abilities—not even voting—except that they just can't die.

Even if your doctor role was 1-shot or x-shot, I'm having a lot of trouble believing this claim. Which part of your claims were you lying about, and why?

I don't really care what you think about it

Well then, let's test it.

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

If you're town and want to win, stop us from wagoning an actual tree stump.

I encourage it. My vote is on myself, see?

Then you don't want town to win.

[Long Con]

@Esooa, you've claimed tree stump, essentially. And you claimed you 'started as such'. But you also claimed to be able to doctor Alison. Tree stumps classically don't have any other abilities—not even voting—except that they just can't die.

Even if your doctor role was 1-shot or x-shot, I'm having a lot of trouble believing this claim. Which part of your claims were you lying about, and why?

I don't really care what you think about it

Well then, let's test it.

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

If you're town and want to win, stop us from wagoning an actual tree stump.

I encourage it. My vote is on myself, see?

[Long Con]

Are you new to mafia, Esooa?

[Michelle]

Esooa what reason would you have to gamethrowing as villager?

[Long Con]

how so?

It was on N2 when Odd busdrove sloonei and Alison. So it would of been a red-check on Sloonei, but we know Sloonei was villager cause of his flip.

Wait, so this whole thing is contingent on Odd & Alison telling the truth? Odd, who was cleared by Alison...is there another clear on Odd I'm unaware?

Nope!

[falcon45ca]

so it's just a framer or what?

Or odd was blocked

Or is on Alison's team.

Doesn't this make the most sense?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Esooa isn't new and she isn't gamethrowing

[Long Con]

Esooa what reason would you have to gamethrowing as villager?

(except make it a 'She')

[Long Con]

so it's just a framer or what?

Or odd was blocked

Or is on Alison's team.

Doesn't this make the most sense?

I don't mind it at all, would vote there.

Esooa isn't new and she isn't gamethrowing

[falcon45ca]

how so?

It was on N2 when Odd busdrove sloonei and Alison. So it would of been a red-check on Sloonei, but we know Sloonei was villager cause of his flip.

Wait, so this whole thing is contingent on Odd & Alison telling the truth? Odd, who was cleared by Alison...is there another clear on Odd I'm unaware?

Nope!

Oh FFS, lynch the red check then. Holy hell, I thought we actually had PROOF, not 2 players just saying their cleared by each other.

[Long Con]

so it's just a framer or what?

Or odd was blocked

Or is on Alison's team.

Doesn't this make the most sense?

But I'm really not likely to move my vote from Esooa at this point.

[Long Con]

how so?

It was on N2 when Odd busdrove sloonei and Alison. So it would of been a red-check on Sloonei, but we know Sloonei was villager cause of his flip.

Wait, so this whole thing is contingent on Odd & Alison telling the truth? Odd, who was cleared by Alison...is there another clear on Odd I'm unaware?

Nope!

Oh FFS, lynch the red check then. Holy hell, I thought we actually had PROOF, not 2 players just saying their cleared by each other.

I think if Michelle were a lying wolf, she would have come up with something easier to swallow than an Alison red check, right?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Sighs

I'm reasonably sure esooa lied about her protection thing to keep mich alive

@Esooa correct me if im wrong

[Esooa]

@Esooa, you've claimed tree stump, essentially. And you claimed you 'started as such'. But you also claimed to be able to doctor Alison. Tree stumps classically don't have any other abilities—not even voting—except that they just can't die.

Even if your doctor role was 1-shot or x-shot, I'm having a lot of trouble believing this claim. Which part of your claims were you lying about, and why?

I don't really care what you think about it

Well then, let's test it.

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

If you're town and want to win, stop us from wagoning an actual tree stump.

I encourage it. My vote is on myself, see?

Then you don't want town to win.

I think it sounds funny for people to try to lynch me when I can't be lynched

And if you wanna I don't really care. I'm not gonna die

[Esooa]

Are you new to mafia, Esooa?

first game actaully

[falcon45ca]

how so?

It was on N2 when Odd busdrove sloonei and Alison. So it would of been a red-check on Sloonei, but we know Sloonei was villager cause of his flip.

Wait, so this whole thing is contingent on Odd & Alison telling the truth? Odd, who was cleared by Alison...is there another clear on Odd I'm unaware?

Nope!

Oh FFS, lynch the red check then. Holy hell, I thought we actually had PROOF, not 2 players just saying their cleared by each other.

I think if Michelle were a lying wolf, she would have come up with something easier to swallow than an Alison red check, right?

No doubt, that's a hard push.

[BoKnows]

so it's just a framer or what?

Or odd was blocked

Or is on Alison's team.

Doesn't this make the most sense?

I was thinking that. But, wouldn't that make Alison's claim an incredibly fragile house of cards? We take one piece away and the whole thing comes crashing down. I can't see Alison doing that as a wolf, way too risky. We can't forget that KZA claimed to be a trooper too.