Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[Hally]

i wonder if she’ll be a wolf

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Idk guys I'm pretty nervous

[Hally]

i couldn’t bring myself to bus her. hope it doesn’t out me

[Hally]

“team marmot has been eliminated”

[Hally]

the suspense is killing me

[staypositivefriend]

fingersplints was the last mafia in the game and we've all won. gg!

[Hally]

wow that was hard. gg y’all

[Hally]

@novaselinenever hi

[BoKnows]

hi

[Hally]

hi

[BoKnows]

'Cause I'm hopeful, yes, I am
Hopeful for today
Take this music and use it
Let it take you away
And be hopeful, hopeful
And He'll make a way
I know it ain't easy but that's okay
Just be hopeful

[novaselinenever]

@fingersplints [Mike Milligan] has been eliminated.

"She was a true gloom, my mother. We used to eat in the dark. For a laugh, I wrote on her tombstone, "Here lies Barbara Milligan, happy till the end." Me, on the other hand, I'm an optimist."
Mike Milligan

[Passive] - Mike is immune to any kind of tampering. His vote will always count for 1, and his actions will always find their targets. If someone tries to tamper with his role, he will learn their identity but not the effect of their actions. If they target him the second time, he will discover the effects used on him and their flavor name.

[Active] - Each night, Mike may target a player and redirect their actions to a secondary player of his choice. He may not target the same player twice in a row.

[Active - Simone] - Redacted.

Wincon - Eliminate all threats to the Kansas City Mafia

The Kansas City Mafia has been eliminated.

Night 5 starts.
You have 22 hours to submit your actions (if any).

[Hally]

my redirector theory came true

[Hally]

now we have to find a whole new mafia team

i love this game

[Strawhenge]

Welp, no cake for me.

[Hally]

i think we should kill kza or odd because i think splints was telling the truth that there’s a wolf in the troopers

[Strawhenge]

Can I at least have a cupcake if JPIC also flips red?

[BoKnows]

shocking

[Strawhenge]

[VOTE: strawhenge] aubergine

You're not catching me with that wagon bomb, man

Wait, what? Wagon bomb?

[Michelle]

[spoiler

You sure about this plan?
Poll ended at Mon Apr 19, 2021 1:00 am


Alison
0
No votes
Voters: None
BoKnows
0
No votes
Voters: None
Esooa
0
No votes
Voters: None
fingersplints
8
42%
Voters: Michelle, Justplayingitcool, KZA, staypositivefriend, Alison, Esooa, BoKnows, Strawhenge
Hally
0
No votes
Voters: None
Justplayingitcool
2
11%
Voters: fingersplints, Oddmerta
KZA
0
No votes
Voters: None
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
0
No votes
Voters: None
Oddmerta
0
No votes
Voters: None
staypositivefriend
0
No votes
Voters: None
Strawhenge
1
5%
Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Unvote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Elimination
1
5%
Voters: Hally
Well, it's creative (Host/Dead/Non)
7
37%
Voters: Marmot, JaggedJimmyJay, Sloonei, MacDougall, nutella, novaselinenever, dunya
Total votes: 19
[/spoiler]
VC

Now i get why everyone was voting Fingers without complaints, she was the last of her team.
Sadly, we stil have probably one full scum team

[Strawhenge]

i think we should kill kza or odd because i think splints was telling the truth that there’s a wolf in the troopers

If the Kansas City Mafia are eliminated, how would she know who’s on the other team?

[Michelle]

Sorry, i failed to put it in spoiler

[Alison]

weh

I don't want to have to decide between kza and odd

I'm leaning towards kza slightly but splint also said there was a wolf between odd and SPF

[Alison]

i should prolly re-eval odd

and we probably do have to exe in the troopers

[Alison]

the upside is that wolf in the troopers strongly suggests I'm town so yay

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

[VOTE: strawhenge] aubergine

You're not catching me with that wagon bomb, man

Wait, what? Wagon bomb?

It was a meme

[KZA]

As you can see I was not teamed with fingersplints.

[BoKnows]

As you can see I was not teamed with fingersplints.

[Michelle]

1. Falcon -- [Barton Brixby] -- Eliminated D4
2. Tedextr -- [???] -- Killed N2 peeked not guilty
3. Nanook
4. Odd Peeked not guilty*
5. Sloonei - [Ronald Reagan] -- Killed N2
6. Esooa
7. Strawhenge
8. JaggedJimmyJay - [Constance] -- Killed N1
9. Staypositivefriend
10. KZA
11. MacDougall - [Peggy] -- Killed N1
12. Dom - Gavial -- [The Kitchen Brothers] -- Eliminated D3
13. Marmot - [Joe Bulo] -- Eliminated D1
14. TSP -- [Irma Mundt] -- Eliminated D2
15. Long Con - - [Hank Larsson] -- Killed N4
16. Fingersplints lasr kansas mafia
17. Tutuu -- Hally
18. JPIC
19. Michelle
20. Alison
21. BoKnows
22.Al Sama -- [???] -- Killed N2

* What if the other mafia has a redirector as well and they kept me alive only to out a green on Odd?

[Michelle]

the upside is that wolf in the troopers strongly suggests I'm town so yay

No, why do you have this conslusion?

[Michelle]

In this moment no one has a pass for killing a wolf

[Esooa]

hally is always town imo

Michelle is probably always town

I think NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME is always town (my phone always corrects it to that I have no clue why but it's funny)

bk I... think is always town but I'm gonna reread him and uh, kza

that's a fine starting point

[Esooa]

oh strawhenge is very towny imo

[Hally]

i think we should kill kza or odd because i think splints was telling the truth that there’s a wolf in the troopers

If the Kansas City Mafia are eliminated, how would she know who’s on the other team?

because of her role

[Esooa]

figuring out jpic is important for wagon comp imo

not necessarily lynching but it is important

[Hally]

weh

I don't want to have to decide between kza and odd

I'm leaning towards kza slightly but splint also said there was a wolf between odd and SPF

i don’t think she did

[Alison]

the upside is that wolf in the troopers strongly suggests I'm town so yay

No, why do you have this conslusion?

you think my ability is that I can order my own scum teammates around?

doesn't it make way more sense for there to be a scum in the troopers that town me can force to move around

[Alison]

weh

I don't want to have to decide between kza and odd

I'm leaning towards kza slightly but splint also said there was a wolf between odd and SPF

i don’t think she did

you said you think it's between odd and SPF and she said you're on the right track right?

[Hally]

weh

I don't want to have to decide between kza and odd

I'm leaning towards kza slightly but splint also said there was a wolf between odd and SPF

i don’t think she did

you said you think it's between odd and SPF and she said you're on the right track right?

yes, but that could mean “you’re right to cast doubt on a trooper but not that one” etc

[staypositivefriend]

how does fingersplints role imply that she would know who the wolves are? am i blind?

it seems like her role would be more useful for finding town investigative roles

[KZA]

Splints redacted ability almost certainly gave her info on what the other team was doing

[staypositivefriend]

Splints redacted ability almost certainly gave her info on what the other team was doing

that's possible, but it seems dangerous to me to assume that fingersplints specifically knew who any individual wolves were. she might have gotten information about what they were doing, or who they were visiting, etc, but it's basically gambling to assume that she actually knew the name of specific wolves

her perspective in this game probably did make it easier to find wolves on the opposing team, though. i'm taking everything she said with a light grain of salt

[Hally]

how does fingersplints role imply that she would know who the wolves are? am i blind?

it seems like her role would be more useful for finding town investigative roles

a couple of possibilities

1) she learns who was tampering with her on any given night and sees it doesn’t match up with what the person was claiming they did itt

2) her redacted ability gave her info

she also claimed she knew who killed ted because she redirected them there

[staypositivefriend]

how does fingersplints role imply that she would know who the wolves are? am i blind?

it seems like her role would be more useful for finding town investigative roles

a couple of possibilities

1) she learns who was tampering with her on any given night and sees it doesn’t match up with what the person was claiming they did itt

2) her redacted ability gave her info

she also claimed she knew who killed ted because she redirected them there

yeah, i suppose there is a good chance that she knew a wolf or two just based on mechanical shenanigans. i'm personally not going to read into her lines much at all though

[Hally]

i doubt she was lying about knowing stuff and i’m probably going to follow what she said because i have no better ideas

[staypositivefriend]

having one wolf team completely eliminated from this game is actually pretty nice - it feels like i can start my POE over totally from scratch

i'm going to lock clear hally for the moment (i am working off of the assumption that macdougall's partner was explicitly confirmed to be a villager as well - i should probably double check that and i would appreciate it if anyone corrected me if i'm wrong)

i'm going to clear clear nanook too (not impossible for him to be a wolf but i think he's been absurdly villagery and i'm fine losing to him at the moment)

i'm also going to lock clear michelle for the time being (if she made up the fake alison red check and then retracted it in the way that she did as a wolf then she's on another level. i'm not considering it right now)

that leaves: oddmerta, esooa, strawhenge, KZA, JPIC, BoKnows, alison

now we're getting somewhere!i if my lock villagers are actually villagers, then it's probably safe to assume that there are at least 3 wolves in that pool of names

if i go further, then i would take strawhenge, esooa, and BoKnows off of that list. there could be a wolf in that list of 3 names, but it's one wolf maximum unless my reads are cracked

so there are hopefully 2/3 wolves in something like oddmerta/KZA/JPIC/alison

[Hally]

jpic
kza
odd
spf

kill these people

[KZA]

Kill JPIC then accept I'm town when he flips red thanks

[staypositivefriend]

dont kill me. the rest of the people on that list can die though

[staypositivefriend]

Kill JPIC then accept I'm town when he flips red thanks

why is JPIC mafia