Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[KZA]

I woke up to see this good news, thanks Odd!

my result on Strawhenge: scum.

I don't want to speculate about what happened, i let you do this.
Cya in the morning

well that's easier than ISOing him for JPIC interactions

[Hally]

So the options I see for failed are

Kill was bus driven into themselves and ruling was that it failed

Or

They tried to hit esooa

I guess there could be something else fucky

Roleblock maybe?

can’t be a roleblock. superkill goes through that

[Hally]

i am actually concerned about nook. i don’t understand why he keeps holstering his shot. if i was a villager in his shoes i’d be expecting to die every night and would want to make sure i get my last shot off but he doesn’t seem worried about it. idgi

I have a vest

you have a vest, a vig and a doc? tf

I got the vest from the thing spf sent me, I didn't start with it

oh right, i forgot about that

alright

[Hally]

2 days later: “i was lying guys, i didn’t get a check”

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I see no reasonable way this is KILO so I'm rolling with the red check

@Michelle if this is fake and you don't say so right now I will 100% shoot you tonight, fair warning

[Hally]

how do we know that odd didn’t busdrive straw with someone since he knew straw was getting peeked?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

So the options I see for failed are

Kill was bus driven into themselves and ruling was that it failed

Or

They tried to hit esooa

I guess there could be something else fucky

Roleblock maybe?

can’t be a roleblock. superkill goes through that

I am very confused then

Idk not worried about it today

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

how do we know that odd didn’t busdrive straw with someone since he knew straw was getting peeked?

We don't

But if he flips green

Its an easy solve lol

[Hally]

how do we know that odd didn’t busdrive straw with someone since he knew straw was getting peeked?

We don't

But if he flips green

Its an easy solve lol

i guess

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Like there's no reasonable world where today is KILO

So

We kill the red check

If straw flips green

Then odd is quasi outed

Which is fine

[Esooa]

why is michelle not dead though

[Hally]

i’m just saying, i know michelle green peeked odd but marmot was a godfather so i expect jpic’s team to also have a godfather for balancing purposes

also we still have splints who told us the troopers weren’t pure

[Oddmerta]

Just got a wolf yesterdsy, no kill last night, why not go for the red check?

[Hally]

why is michelle not dead though

no idea

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We don't need to cross that bridge rn

[Hally]

michelle isn’t dead so that odd could fake a red on straw and get a free mislunch

ez

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Why are you dead is also a fair question

Why isn't spf dead

Why aren't I dead (jk I have a vest)

Theres a lot of people that austensibly should be dead and aren't

[Hally]

i wish i was dead

[Strawhenge]

And now we come to the part of my rolecard that I didn’t want to reveal unless absolutely necessary:

Since Skip the Typewriter Guy is in business with the Gerhardts, I investigate as guilty despite being town.

[Oddmerta]

michelle isn’t dead so that odd could fake a red on straw and get a free mislunch

ez

Did Michelle say she was targetting straw beforehand?

[Strawhenge]

My rolecard seriously sucks.

[Oddmerta]

And now we come to the part of my rolecard that I didn’t want to reveal unless absolutely necessary:

Since Skip the Typewriter Guy is in business with the Gerhardts, I investigate as guilty despite being town.

I believe this

[KZA]

this fkn game

[Hally]

And now we come to the part of my rolecard that I didn’t want to reveal unless absolutely necessary:

Since Skip the Typewriter Guy is in business with the Gerhardts, I investigate as guilty despite being town.

why tf wouldn’t you say that before when you knew you were getting peeked?

[Hally]

you always claim miller first thing to avoid this situation

[Esooa]

why would you not claim that earlier?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

And now we come to the part of my rolecard that I didn’t want to reveal unless absolutely necessary:

Since Skip the Typewriter Guy is in business with the Gerhardts, I investigate as guilty despite being town.

Yeah uh

Thats the kind of thing you have to claim a LOT earlier for me to believe it lol

[Hally]

michelle isn’t dead so that odd could fake a red on straw and get a free mislunch

ez

Did Michelle say she was targetting straw beforehand?

yes

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Like, for example, d1

Or, you know, when I told mich to peek you

[Oddmerta]

Typewriters are real

[Strawhenge]

I’ve never been a Miller before, and haven’t ever been in a game with one, that I recall.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Not after you've been red checked, sorry

[Hally]

seriously, what miller KNOWS they’re getting peeked and doesn’t claim?

c’mon

[staypositivefriend]

why can't today be KILO? we have 22 players in this game and only 4 flipped confirmed scum - there are multiple wolves/3ps alive even in the best case scenario

i dont really believe strawhenge's sudden addition to his rolecard - i think he would have said that immediately when he made his full claim instead of deciding to arbitrarily hide it

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

why can't today be KILO? we have 22 players in this game and only 4 flipped confirmed scum - there are multiple wolves/3ps alive even in the best case scenario

i dont really believe strawhenge's sudden addition to his rolecard - i think he would have said that immediately when he made his full claim instead of deciding to arbitrarily hide it

I don't believe there are four mafia remaining

[Hally]

I’ve never been a Miller before, and haven’t ever been in a game with one, that I recall.

but what did you expect would happen when mich got a red check on you? did you think we would just believe you if you claimed after the fact?

[Hally]

even if you’ve never seen a miller before, i feel it’s logical to assume you wouldn’t be believed unless you were upfront and didn’t wait until after you were peeked?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I have an incredibly hard time understanding not claiming that part WHEN YOURE ABOUT TO BE CHECKED, in what world do you see that and think "yeah ill just let them know tomorrow" ????

[staypositivefriend]

if strawhenge is a wolf and he knew he was being investigated, it raises the question of why he waited the full 24 hours to fakeclaim miller instead of claiming it immediately

but i would need an in-depth explanation of the thought process behind hiding his miller claim for me to buy it - im considering his claim as outing for now

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Eh tbf he probably didn't see he was getting checked ahead of time

Still have a tough time believing it tho

[Michelle]

I see no reasonable way this is KILO so I'm rolling with the red check

@Michelle if this is fake and you don't say so right now I will 100% shoot you tonight, fair warning

Hardclaim, this is the info i received.

[Esooa]

why can't today be KILO? we have 22 players in this game and only 4 flipped confirmed scum - there are multiple wolves/3ps alive even in the best case scenario

i dont really believe strawhenge's sudden addition to his rolecard - i think he would have said that immediately when he made his full claim instead of deciding to arbitrarily hide it

I don't believe there are four mafia remaining

remember for numbers I'm not considered for lylo

[Hally]

Eh tbf he probably didn't see he was getting checked ahead of time

Still have a tough time believing it tho

how would he not see? you told michelle itt to check him

[Strawhenge]

I don’t really have any explanation other than just being inexperienced with the role. I know it looks bad. You guys do whatever you have to do, I guess.

But you DID get a typewriter, Hally. What scum card would read, ‘Oh, by the way, other than killing people, you can give them a typewriter.’

[Hally]

straw, what benefit was there iyo to hiding that you were w miller? what were you hoping to get from that?

[Michelle]

I just won a game few days ago where i claimed miller in my first post.
I was a true miller, and this is the correct play when you are allowed to claim

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Eh tbf he probably didn't see he was getting checked ahead of time

Still have a tough time believing it tho

how would he not see? you told michelle itt to check him

He wasn't in thread between then and day starting, its reasonable he might not have seen

[Hally]

I don’t really have any explanation other than just being inexperienced with the role. I know it looks bad. You guys do whatever you have to do, I guess.

But you DID get a typewriter, Hally. What scum card would read, ‘Oh, by the way, other than killing people, you can give them a typewriter.’

yeah, i’m thinking about that too

[Oddmerta]

Well this means I aint scumdriving Strawhenge into or out of checks

[Michelle]

Eh tbf he probably didn't see he was getting checked ahead of time

Still have a tough time believing it tho

how would he not see? you told michelle itt to check him

And I accepted it