Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[Michelle]

Ever since my red-check, yeah, I've been defending myself because there was something to defend. And if I didn't engage enough with Esooa and Oddmerta, it's because they've both seemed disinterested in engaging in conversation. Esooa even got cross with me and told me to stop asking her questions, so I did.

I understand that Esooa was convincing in making you stop asking questions. Why are you affraid to be more confrontational and push her more if you have questions for her?

[Strawhenge]

(snip)
Did you Iso a flipped scum to search for interactions with living players?

Not in the same way that Sloonei did, for instance, but with each player I ISO’d, I looked for their interactions with flipped scum.

(snip)
I understand that Esooa was convincing in making you stop asking questions. Why are you affraid to be more confrontational and push her more if you have questions for her?

It’s not that I’m afraid to, it’s that she made it very clear even afterwards that she was not interested in the game anymore.

[Michelle]

(snip)
Did you Iso a flipped scum to search for interactions with living players?

Not in the same way that Sloonei did, for instance, but with each player I ISO’d, I looked for their interactions with flipped scum.

(snip)
I understand that Esooa was convincing in making you stop asking questions. Why are you affraid to be more confrontational and push her more if you have questions for her?

It’s not that I’m afraid to, it’s that she made it very clear even afterwards that she was not interested in the game anymore.

Can you link me your cases please? I am only phone posting today and I can only play
sporadically

[Michelle]

(snip)
Did you Iso a flipped scum to search for interactions with living players?

Not in the same way that Sloonei did, for instance, but with each player I ISO’d, I looked for their interactions with flipped scum.

(snip)
I understand that Esooa was convincing in making you stop asking questions. Why are you affraid to be more confrontational and push her more if you have questions for her?

It’s not that I’m afraid to, it’s that she made it very clear even afterwards that she was not interested in the game anymore.

Can you link me your cases please? I am only phone posting today and I can only play
sporadically

[Michelle]

(snip)
Did you Iso a flipped scum to search for interactions with living players?

Not in the same way that Sloonei did, for instance, but with each player I ISO’d, I looked for their interactions with flipped scum.

(snip)
I understand that Esooa was convincing in making you stop asking questions. Why are you affraid to be more confrontational and push her more if you have questions for her?

It’s not that I’m afraid to, it’s that she made it very clear even afterwards that she was not interested in the game anymore.

Can you link me your cases please? I am only phone posting today and I can only play
sporadically

[Michelle]

Sorry about that, i thought my phone freeze and i pressed post again (and again)

[Esooa]

I'm pretty sure we just lose tonight

[Hally]

I'm pretty sure we just lose tonight

why

[Strawhenge]

(snip)
Can you link me your cases please? I am only phone posting today and I can only play
sporadically

Sure:

• Oddmerta

• fingersplints

• NANOOK

• Long Con

Sadly there are only a few full ISOs, and most of them were on D2 with only Odd on D7. Part of the reason was real-life time constraints. I had to do a lot of phone-posting this game that made more involved cases like these hard to do. Another part of the reason is because a lot of people I trusted were putting up a lot of good cases on people that I fully agreed with.

[Strawhenge]

I'm pretty sure we just lose tonight

I'm pretty sure that if town would lose the game during a night phase, the game would end at the preceding EOD.

[Hally]

I'm pretty sure we just lose tonight

I'm pretty sure that if town would lose the game during a night phase, the game would end at the preceding EOD.

not of there are ways to mechanically stop their kill

[Esooa]

how would we not lose tonight

[Michelle]

You made Isos on 3 villagers and a mafia from the other team.


I said i will tell you what other wolfy things you did.

What the fuck, seriously?

So it's either supertown Hally, supertown Michelle, or unchoppable Esooa?! The fuck kind of choice is that?!

If it's either Hally or Michelle, congratulations on an amazing scum game.

These 2 posts, one after another, showing fake surprise and a weak suspicion on everyone else with no serious stance on someone.
Like everyone can be wolf except you, but you got so far because dead villagers told everyone you are playing in town meta, using an old meta and ignoring that meantime you could change yourself and have a good tone as scum like you had as villager back then.

It's wolfy mindset to accuse everyone else and show yourself as town just because.

[Hally]

how would we not lose tonight

i mean, if it was mechanically guaranteed the game would be over

[Strawhenge]

You made Isos on 3 villagers and a mafia from the other team.


I said i will tell you what other wolfy things you did.

What the fuck, seriously?

So it's either supertown Hally, supertown Michelle, or unchoppable Esooa?! The fuck kind of choice is that?!

If it's either Hally or Michelle, congratulations on an amazing scum game.

These 2 posts, one after another, showing fake surprise and a weak suspicion on everyone else with no serious stance on someone.
Like everyone can be wolf except you, but you got so far because dead villagers told everyone you are playing in town meta, using an old meta and ignoring that meantime you could change yourself and have a good tone as scum like you had as villager back then.

It's wolfy mindset to accuse everyone else and show yourself as town just because.

1. Re: my ISOs, I never said I was correct in my ISOs. It's possible to be town and be wrong about someone.

2. Look at the timestamp of my reactions to last EOD. Those were my immediate reactions to a surprising chop result. I was expressing (real) surprise, because I felt very certain that Odd was scum.

3. I think it's reasonable to not have a serious stance on someone less than ten minutes after EOD when two of the three remaining players other than yourself are people you've trusted up until that point.

4. A wolfy mindset to accuse everyone else but myself? Should I have added, 'But then again, maybe I'm scum'? Have all of your stances included the possibility that you're scum as well?

[Oddmerta]

RIP me lol, thanks for the game. Sorry for being so lazy

[Hally]

did we lose

[Hally]

@novaselinenever

[Hally]

[Esooa]

lol

[Hally]

esooa you can just say you’re the last wolf

[Esooa]

gg I was maf

[Hally]

me too

[Esooa]

oh cool

[Hally]

what happened to nova

[Hally]

[novaselinenever]

My apologies I was stuck without any internet connection, and just got home. I'll start the phase shortly.

[Hally]

nw

[novaselinenever]

This is a true story. The events depicted took place at The Syndicate Forum in April 2021. At the request of the survivors, the names have been changed. Out of respect for the dead, the rest has been told exactly as it occurred.

Someone attempted to super-kill [???], but failed.

Day 10 starts.
You have 46 hours to decide on an elimination.

[Hally]

LOL

[Esooa]

lmfao

[Esooa]

what happened

[Hally]

one of esooa or straw tried to kill me

nerds

[Esooa]

one of esooa or straw tried to kill me

nerds

do you really fucking think I'm not town lol

[Hally]

one of esooa or straw tried to kill me

nerds

do you really fucking think I'm not town lol

i’m just telling you what happened

[Esooa]

well it's straw

[Hally]

@Michelle i assume you tried to check esooa

[Hally]

because if you tried to check me that’s just lol

[Esooa]

@novaselinenever is there hammer enabled today

[Michelle]

I don't have any answer at my check

[Michelle]

Not yet

[Hally]

who did you check

[Michelle]

who did you check

Esooa

I received the peek, she is not villager.
Either she's a harmful 3p, or she's mafia

[Hally]

lol

[Hally]

can she die though

[Hally]

michelle why did esooa try to kill me and not you

[Hally]

i’m so confused by this game

[Hally]

i think she’s probably 3P

what exactly did you get? “mafia” or just “not town”?

[Michelle]

I know i didn't play well this game, but i couldn't play better with the limited amount of time I had.
But i tried

Esooa didn't play the game in a villagery way at all, and no matter who is the last Gerhard mafia between her and Straw, from 2 non town results i want to chop Esooa.
What do you say Hally?

[Michelle]

i think she’s probably 3P

what exactly did you get? “mafia” or just “not town”?

Guilty