Kylemii wrote: ↑Thu May 13, 2021 12:30 am
DaisyCloud wrote: ↑Thu May 13, 2021 12:16 ameither way

you can not know who is what unless u r mafia or u r the host. or spectator and granted spoilers. that is it. or wait you could be cop and was granted 1 random peak. but no nite 0 so doubt.
how else would you know? u say it isn't random.
this is where the disparity is coming in. when you say this, it means that you legitimately think that my "these 5 players are 100% mafia lock it in, gg" list was meant to legitimately come off as a real list. you haven't explained why doing that would benefit me as mafia. you also haven't adequately explained how it's TMI or what the TMI would be unless you believe that it was a genuine attempt at locking in the mafia.
the only way you can be telling the truth about your mental process here in this scenario is if you believe that i'm just a straight up insultingly bad player.
dude, what?
u said it wasn't random. imma act like this ain't your 2nd mafia game and that other game we done played wasn't your 1st. see reads list can be fake. reads lists can be random. read lists can be real and has some sort of backing for it. a basses. read lists can be wrong. they can be right. they can be partially correct.
people do maintain their initial reads for a huge chunk of the game and almost never waiver.
regardless mafia or town could easily do any of these scenarios.
could a reads list ever be a slip? yes
could a reads list give unfos after a flip? yes
does the fact you made a list mean you are scum? not neccesarily nai
does the fact made one early in game make u suss? not neccesarily. nai
does the fact that im on there and I didn't even post yet make u scum? nai but a bit sus, scratch of the head. like why
does the fact that you made it and it wasn't random make u sus? nai but like how could you sus peeps enough like that to make a list
does the fact that you wanted to make a list for reactions make y scum? nai but like why those specific peeps
does the fact that you pre-planned all this and regardless gonna post a list make u sus? should say nai but like it's me so sus
how does any of this play into your alignment? depends. before you harped on this u seemed okayish.
idk.what else u want from me. I legit don't know why u want to continue this. get your read on me already. it's not that hard. unless you're wolf and u think that this is funny.