Traitors for Exile

[MacDougall]

Well we only have until Wednesday to figure it out. Who's been the most quiet since the start?

You?


Is this really the best way to find scum tho, just lynch the low posters?

In this game we basically have multiple rogues. That means they can fake hunt. Which means there is no >rand value in volume clearing anyone at all.

[MacDougall]

i feel mostly better lol

i need to read the rules again because I don't remember if we get a chop + exile or what.

112 long time no see. I will try not scum read you this time, not for weak reasons at least

hello there.

don't worry imo. my towniness will shine with the light of a thousand florida lightning bolts.

Yeah ok you are confidently the towniest person on page 6.

I think KZA is also decently townie on page 6.

[MacDougall]

i feel mostly better lol

i need to read the rules again because I don't remember if we get a chop + exile or what.

112 long time no see. I will try not scum read you this time, not for weak reasons at least

hello there.

don't worry imo. my towniness will shine with the light of a thousand florida lightning bolts.

Yeah ok you are confidently the towniest person on page 6.

I think KZA is also decently townie on page 6.

[MacDougall]

Well we only have until Wednesday to figure it out. Who's been the most quiet since the start?

You?


Is this really the best way to find scum tho, just lynch the low posters?

I've been thinking about this and it might not be a bad play to kill whoever seems most afraid to ruffle feathers on D1

we're in a unique mafia environment where NOBODY has TMI so I'm open to hearing other strategies

Independent rand is the rarest of the rands. For those you have meta on your best bet is to just catch them by feeling them as "off". For those you have no meta on, you're essentially at the whim of sheeping someone that does.

This is purist mafia. We have to just lynch the person who seems like they're lying the worst. We're detectives, we have no leads. We grill people.

Hence why I have just been acting like a maniac the entire time.

[MacDougall]

@Gavial real names in the poll and alphabetical for day 2 please friend

[MacDougall]

wait Poison is playing? don't vig me again

uhh that might actually be the correct move here.

I do make the right moves but the games are so wrong. Smh smh.

iktf. i am 100% at reading mac if you discard the games i've misread him.

Did you mistake me for KZA?

[MacDougall]

I think my top bets for baddies here are Wisdom, Poison and Falcon. This is all off page 6 reads lol.

[MacDougall]

That read on made on KZA being billboard actually applies to Falcon way more.

[MacDougall]

Well we only have until Wednesday to figure it out. Who's been the most quiet since the start?

You?


Is this really the best way to find scum tho, just lynch the low posters?

Exactly, we should just find them differently. I heard Traitors would sweat when you look them in the eye.

Where did you hear that?



Do you have anymore tips for catching Traitors? Cuz you should share your knowledge with the class

Well I'm friends with all sorts of people.

Yes,

We would pressure the shit out of few people and record their reaction if they go OMGUS we town read them mostly but if they are being weird we lynch them.

Oh,

We should also say how shitty the shitposter are, not funny at all. We would get impressive results.

I might just actually clear you for this post so forget being in my shit list.

[MacDougall]

Kiiinda like Gira a little bit? Who is familiar with them?

[MacDougall]

Guys, y'all are dumb.

The host has already declared one Traitor for us.

Look at voting poll.

The host says "I work with him"

And we know the famous saying, "If you know the criminal and keep sush about it, you are the equal criminal they are]

The host knows who the criminals are. The traitors. He is the criminal along with them.

But we can spare the host.

So basically he said he works with Murphy. So Murphy is the Traitor.


Ez.

or maybe not, you're officially my first null read

[MacDougall]

Actually I do have the benefit of having seen 3p Poison before, she was actually entirely different there. Very passive, white bread. Keeping her nose clean. So this is probably town Poison.

[MacDougall]

Gira joins 112 in my top town.

[MacDougall]

current standing

Not Chopping:
KZA - yes this is KZA

MacDougall - cop, wants me to die as is tradition
Marmot - My gut is on a hot streak reading Marmot off his openers so I'll trust it again
falcon45ca - Good ol Falc
112 - I enjoy the brazen FoS of Sparkles and think the thought process has looked good. I'm not really concerned about being called stilted by them it happens to me a decent amount as town
MissSparkles - High posting, asking decent questions, doesn't seem to care about creating friction with other players

WimI - Kinda mixed thoughts here. Is posting a lot, but has seemed kind of, idk friendly/agreeing with a lot of people which could be at traitor attempting to integrate quickly. This could just be playstyle thing too. I'll wait and see if they get a little pointier. I do like their mech plan from early. Either way I'm probably not going here today.

Currently Willing to Chop:
KGMurphy
Long Con
Gira
Creature
Poison
Wisdom
cat
Auwt

these are lower content slots to this point so I'll just wait and see who posts themselves in to towniness

You like their mech plan? Which plan was that?

[Poison]

Whazzzaqppp

[MacDougall]

kaz and i interact a lot and maybe i'm just not used to seeing him post a lot without saying something ironic or half-serious

but something really does feel off about him even when i try to ignore the non-mafia-playing kaz and focus on the mafia-playing one

I will respect this read and not defend KZA despite feeling conflicted.

[MacDougall]

Whazzzaqppp

Oi m8

[MacDougall]

Falcon, Wisdom, Cat, Auwt?

[Poison]

Actually I do have the benefit of having seen 3p Poison before, she was actually entirely different there. Very passive, white bread. Keeping her nose clean. So this is probably town Poison.

You have seen all shades of poison!!!

[MacDougall]

@Wisdom articulate your sus on Creature?

@Poison do you have any good town reads?

[MacDougall]

Actually I do have the benefit of having seen 3p Poison before, she was actually entirely different there. Very passive, white bread. Keeping her nose clean. So this is probably town Poison.

You have seen all shades of poison!!!

Yeah but 3p rands are rare and I actually saw you rand one. That's cool.

[MacDougall]

Hmmm actually I might have a plan here.

[MacDougall]

Ugh this is gonna take me hours. But I am also a psychopath.

[Poison]

@Wisdom articulate your sus on Creature?

@Poison do you have any good town reads?

Not really, I happened to interact only with you and miss sparkle and you seemed chill and towny and funny amd Miss got pissed at nothing so I'm kinda iffy about the latter.

[Poison]

Ugh this is gonna take me hours. But I am also a psychopath.

We have 36 mins. Lessgo!

[MacDougall]

@Wisdom articulate your sus on Creature?

@Poison do you have any good town reads?

Not really, I happened to interact only with you and miss sparkle and you seemed chill and towny and funny amd Miss got pissed at nothing so I'm kinda iffy about the latter.

So by not really, what you mean is yes? ie. Me?

[MacDougall]

Ugh this is gonna take me hours. But I am also a psychopath.

We have 36 mins. Lessgo!

Oh fuck what a dogshit EOD time lol.

[Poison]

Well yes to both.

Honestly, I haven't really got the time to read the entire thread but upto where I read I thought creature's concern about a few stuffs were somewhat mindmelds.

I didn't enjoy the first two pages of turtle/sparkle seemed rather agenda yyy and marmot seems different than the last game where he was scum.

[MacDougall]

Poison do you intend to vote?

[Poison]

Poison do you intend to vote?

I'm planning to vote sparkle, but that vote ain't lynching her so it would be a waste. I'll rather iso the top wagons quickly.

[Wiml]

Well yes to both.

Honestly, I haven't really got the time to read the entire thread but upto where I read I thought creature's concern about a few stuffs were somewhat mindmelds.

I didn't enjoy the first two pages of turtle/sparkle seemed rather agenda yyy and marmot seems different than the last game where he was scum.

Are you referring to the mechanics stuff with this? (Or at least wrt the mention of me). What wolf agenda would I be pushing by trying to mech optimise the game in our favour (given, as a reminder, that the wolves don't know their teammates)?

[MacDougall]

Okay Wiml is a fucking town billboard in this game.

[MacDougall]

Speak of the devil.

[Wiml]

Poison do you intend to vote?

I'm planning to vote sparkle, but that vote ain't lynching her so it would be a waste. I'll rather iso the top wagons quickly.

I'm confused about your progression here. What makes you think that Sparkles' anger at Mac was wolf indicative? Especially to the degree of flipping your read on her?

[Poison]

KZA does not sound like pressured at all tho. The iso ain't really giving me much woof vibe.

[MacDougall]

I am sorry Poison but you are actually obvious traitor. I only just read your ISO lol. You've been like doing literally nothing pro town this entire game.

[Wiml]

Okay Wiml is a fucking town billboard in this game.

Do I want to ask what this means???

[MacDougall]

@Wiml can you quickly ISO her. What I can see is pure obvious not town.

[Poison]

Poison do you intend to vote?

I'm planning to vote sparkle, but that vote ain't lynching her so it would be a waste. I'll rather iso the top wagons quickly.

I'm confused about your progression here. What makes you think that Sparkles' anger at Mac was wolf indicative? Especially to the degree of flipping your read on her?

Can you point out my flipping post? Appreciated.

ISO me, I think I have talked about her quite a lot.

[MacDougall]

Okay Wiml is a fucking town billboard in this game.

Do I want to ask what this means???

Your ISO is just dramatically obvious town and your agenda to solve the game for town is transparent. You are a BILLBOARD that has town written on it lol.

[Poison]

I am sorry Poison but you are actually obvious traitor. I only just read your ISO lol. You've been like doing literally nothing pro town this entire game.

I am not a Traitor.

[MacDougall]

Kinda struggling to get reads when everybody here seems to lack TMI.

What I think this actually means is that you are struggling to come up with viable fake reasons to town read people lol.

[MacDougall]

I am sorry Poison but you are actually obvious traitor. I only just read your ISO lol. You've been like doing literally nothing pro town this entire game.

I am not a Traitor.

You aren't dying so you have time to show me that you want town to win this game I guess.

[MacDougall]

Kinda struggling to get reads when everybody here seems to lack TMI.

What I think this actually means is that you are struggling to come up with viable fake reasons to traitor read people lol.

FTFM

[KZA]

tough bounce

[MacDougall]

Creature ISO was listless but he eventually made some reads, albeit nothing spicy or really helpful. I am particularly jarred by the point where he sheeped KZA's entire readslist and was just like "this is all good" but hadn't made a single read of his own until then. One would think that if you had enough of a perspective on literally every person in the game by that stage it'd have come through at least one. ie. I think the post talking about the KZA wall is just bullshit.

[MacDougall]

tough bounce

Self pres and I'd probably vote to save you at this point.

[Poison]

Well yes to both.

Honestly, I haven't really got the time to read the entire thread but upto where I read I thought creature's concern about a few stuffs were somewhat mindmelds.

I didn't enjoy the first two pages of turtle/sparkle seemed rather agenda yyy and marmot seems different than the last game where he was scum.

Are you referring to the mechanics stuff with this? (Or at least wrt the mention of me). What wolf agenda would I be pushing by trying to mech optimise the game in our favour (given, as a reminder, that the wolves don't know their teammates)?

1. It sounded like the thread control was in your hand, you / sparkle.
2. Both of you talked about exile mostly.
3. The way it all happened you two would have a greater chance to actually go into exile.
4. Scum wins when they are in exile.
5. When you read the whole conversation as a whole it seems like at least one of you pushed it forward than natural terms

[KZA]

Cat voting for me was kind of flimsy and I feel like they just started that wagon in hopes of self pres since they were leading the votes by like a 4-1 count at that point

[MacDougall]

I think Sparkles is town specifically because at the very start of the game she immediately made a plan to exile the cop and it shows bravado.