Cindy Kate & Percy Date Night Mafia <3 [ENDGAME]

[lost monkey]

Waiting with great anticipation for lost monkey's response to Sloonei regarding actions.

If its regarding sloonei, I haven't seen sloonei do anything by the end of N2. Switched vote to nutella after her claim seeing her act scummy the entire day was not good and also i seem to remember he was trying to say in the thread that owner was town. His reads were also not good. So why not? The only reason i have him as town was because of his desperado shot. Didn't yourself tell us on D4 that i need to take a better look at sloonei lol. All crab had far better reads and very much similar to mine, he tried saving bunny, tried lynching act, tried lynching orange and plus i believed his claim. SInce all the powers i had figured town must have them in the game seeing gavial claim.

Not that it matters now, but I think you attributed a lot of things to me that I never did.

I am more concerned with what you protected allcrab last night. We have two confirmed players and several people who are much more clear/at risk of a night kill than he is.

Might remember some stuff wrongly but didnt you vote nutella and then change to made after her claim? and also didnt you say that owner might be town on D2. Allcrab was a better choice for me than you or tangy/tsp is because he can still use his power and which i consider to be a better thing and then tangy/tsp is someone who i have considered as possible poisoner candidate seeing longcon and bunny being poisoned.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

did JJJ kill mafia or protect them for the most part?

Nobody answered you so I will.

I shrugged at nutella and ended up okay with her being chopped. I voted for the Made counterwagon because I was also okay with him being chopped. I would have been okay with the Owner wagon going over too. That set of three wagons was agreeable to me by the time the day ended.

I was a vocal contributor to and perhaps a leader within the thread motion against Owner and Sonnycrush leading to both of their deaths. Also Owner used her mafia role on Gavial and I in an effort to kill one of or both of us.

[Esooa]

did JJJ kill mafia or protect them for the most part?

Nobody answered you so I will.

I shrugged at nutella and ended up okay with her being chopped. I voted for the Made counterwagon because I was also okay with him being chopped. I would have been okay with the Owner wagon going over too. That set of three wagons was agreeable to me by the time the day ended.

I was a vocal contributor to and perhaps a leader within the thread motion against Owner and Sonnycrush leading to both of their deaths. Also Owner used her mafia role on Gavial and I in an effort to kill one of or both of us.

ok

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Tony has barely played since the day phase began. I view that as concerning with regard to poisoner prospects.

[Sloonei]

Might remember some stuff wrongly but didnt you vote nutella and then change to made after her claim? and also didnt you say that owner might be town on D2. Allcrab was a better choice for me than you or tangy/tsp is because he can still use his power and which i consider to be a better thing and then tangy/tsp is someone who i have considered as possible poisoner candidate seeing longcon and bunny being poisoned.

What about protecting jay or seanzie?

Also (this stuff doesn't matter, but): you're remembering the nutella stuff wrong. I was never really involved in the push against her at all until the very end, and at that point she was pushing harder against me than I was against her. I voted for Made, but I don't believe that I was ever voting for nutella at any point, and I don't remember her claiming anything at any point.
RE: Owner, I did say "Owner is town" but that was just so I could get people to argue the point. Day 2 was stagnant. I was trying to get people to talk. I never actually thought that Owner was town.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I would appreciate general perceptions from anyone reading on 1) Esooa since she joined the game and 2) the mason claims she and Nanook share. I've already said my piece.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I'd like for us to close as many theoretical worlds off as possible with the day that remains. If there is already any truth in the consensus (which right now isn't super clear to me outside suspicion of Made or acceptance of Made votes), we'll be much more likely to hold to it if we confirm the falsehoods of anything else.

[Sloonei]

I would appreciate general perceptions from anyone reading on 1) Esooa since she joined the game and 2) the mason claims she and Nanook share. I've already said my piece.

She good, da claim good.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

As I consider the poison targets, I find myself wondering something:

Some PerC folks have said they think it's definitely a Syndicate player. I don't really understand why that is the case. Expansion would be neat. I bring this up because the most obvious trend I note in the targets (Alison, Long Con, bad bunny, and Garden Gnome) is that they're players who have given the fewest overall reads outside Alison. The other three can be targeted without singularly implicating anyone, because those players didn't put enough reads into the game to make that possible. The Alison target alone would have to illuminate if any of them can.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I would appreciate general perceptions from anyone reading on 1) Esooa since she joined the game and 2) the mason claims she and Nanook share. I've already said my piece.

She good, da claim good.

How about the Tone Zone

[Alison]

Also Alison it'd be cool to know how you feel about the prospects of a poisoner Martin. You may have said something already.

I've been marinating it in my mind. A poisoner Martin would certainly be able to get a townread from me easier than a scum Martin would. I'm not sure why he would claim poison healer really early and then not poison the claimant. Martin is a poisoner candidate, but not my top one.

[Sloonei]

I would appreciate general perceptions from anyone reading on 1) Esooa since she joined the game and 2) the mason claims she and Nanook share. I've already said my piece.

She good, da claim good.

How about the Tone Zone

eh?

[Alison]

@Alison where do you think you look first for mafia members if both aren't covered by Made and Mac?

Allcrab. Martin if things get really dire. Everyone else is mech cleared: the POE is really small.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

eh?

Tony

[Sloonei]

eh?

Tony

He remains a perfectly viable poisoner candidate. Nothing he's done has changed that.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@lost monkey how do you feel overall about the role you played in the eliminations of nutella, Owner, and Sonnycrush? I ask for a reason, so please take no undue aggression from it.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@Alison where do you think you look first for mafia members if both aren't covered by Made and Mac?

Allcrab. Martin if things get really dire. Everyone else is mech cleared: the POE is really small.

Please walk me through why you consider lost monkey to be mechanically cleared for the town faction.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Mafia-aligned POE per mechanics

Players:

Spoiler: show

Alison
Allcrab
Garden Gnome
Guillosooa
lost monkey
MacDougall
Made
MartinGG99
Nanook
Sloonei
TangyStarkPrime

Eliminate non-suspects via mechanics:

Garden Gnome - poisoned and dying, will resolve anyway
Guillosooa - mason
Nanook - mason
Sloonei - backup desperado that shot orangecrush
TangyStarkPrime - desperado shot by Belzy

Remaining players:

Spoiler: show

Alison
Allcrab
lost monkey
MacDougall
Made
MartinGG99

From a behavioral perspective I can reduce that list more. From a mechanical perspective I don't know that I can. An argument can be made to mechanically clear lost monkey, but I don't think I would go that far. To eliminate lost monkey from this list I would need to consider behavior as well. Outside Made a behavioral argument can be made for all of them to be removed, so I will resist that level of generosity at least right this moment.

[lost monkey]

Might remember some stuff wrongly but didnt you vote nutella and then change to made after her claim? and also didnt you say that owner might be town on D2. Allcrab was a better choice for me than you or tangy/tsp is because he can still use his power and which i consider to be a better thing and then tangy/tsp is someone who i have considered as possible poisoner candidate seeing longcon and bunny being poisoned.

What about protecting jay or seanzie?

Also (this stuff doesn't matter, but): you're remembering the nutella stuff wrong. I was never really involved in the push against her at all until the very end, and at that point she was pushing harder against me than I was against her. I voted for Made, but I don't believe that I was ever voting for nutella at any point, and I don't remember her claiming anything at any point.
RE: Owner, I did say "Owner is town" but that was just so I could get people to argue the point. Day 2 was stagnant. I was trying to get people to talk. I never actually thought that Owner was town.

Nah i remember you voting nutella mid D1 and i saw you taking the vote off nutella and shifting to made after she claimed. You may not remember that but i do because i was lurking at that time. I didnt read much of D2 but i saw that so i assumed you tried convincing owner as town.

Did sean claim tracker? I had him as town but I preferred to save because i believed his claim. I still dont trust jay lol, after the whole trying to save nutella and trying to off made made be wary of him. If made is scum then i might believe he could be town otherwise still don't trust him.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I didn't try to save nutella. I did vote for Made, and I will tend to absorb most of the tried to save nutella presumption from that wagon because I am the loudest player on it, but I made just about zero effort to keep nutella alive. I was fine with her being eliminated, and I think that's visible in my posts if one just takes a look. Indeed when I actively promoted a non-nutella wagon around EOD it was for Owner.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Also, if Made is mafia and we facilitated three separate mafia wagons at the end of Day 1, I will swell with insufferable ego.

[lost monkey]

As I consider the poison targets, I find myself wondering something:

Some PerC folks have said they think it's definitely a Syndicate player. I don't really understand why that is the case. Expansion would be neat. I bring this up because the most obvious trend I note in the targets (Alison, Long Con, bad bunny, and Garden Gnome) is that they're players who have given the fewest overall reads outside Alison. The other three can be targeted without singularly implicating anyone, because those players didn't put enough reads into the game to make that possible. The Alison target alone would have to illuminate if any of them can.

I think the poisoner can either win with town or scum from the looks of the poison. Except for the D1 poison, it may be that person was undecided or that person thought alison was scum. If the person thought alison was scum, that would mean bunny and guillo, one is town prosec and other is town mason. Long, bunny were people who thought you could be scum and gnome was just there. All of them were in your poe and the only person who blindly trusted you was tangy. Most of the perc people didnt agree with your read on bunny and probably would not have allowed the lynch to happen.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

As I consider the poison targets, I find myself wondering something:

Some PerC folks have said they think it's definitely a Syndicate player. I don't really understand why that is the case. Expansion would be neat. I bring this up because the most obvious trend I note in the targets (Alison, Long Con, bad bunny, and Garden Gnome) is that they're players who have given the fewest overall reads outside Alison. The other three can be targeted without singularly implicating anyone, because those players didn't put enough reads into the game to make that possible. The Alison target alone would have to illuminate if any of them can.

I think the poisoner can either win with town or scum from the looks of the poison. Except for the D1 poison, it may be that person was undecided or that person thought alison was scum. If the person thought alison was scum, that would mean bunny and guillo, one is town prosec and other is town mason. Long, bunny were people who thought you could be scum and gnome was just there. All of them were in your poe and the only person who blindly trusted you was tangy. Most of the perc people didnt agree with your read on bunny and probably would not have allowed the lynch to happen.

Is this an argument for why the poisoner is from The Syndicate or for why the poisoner is JaggedJimmyJay? Or something else? I'm struggling to follow.

[lost monkey]

I didn't try to save nutella. I did vote for Made, and I will tend to absorb most of the tried to save nutella presumption from that wagon because I am the loudest player on it, but I made just about zero effort to keep nutella alive. I was fine with her being eliminated, and I think that's visible in my posts if one just takes a look. Indeed when I actively promoted a non-nutella wagon around EOD it was for Owner.

You would have probably lynched me if given the chance on D1. You tried telling nutella was town thing but too many people didnt agree with you and then you changed to a i dont care with nutella getting lynched thing. I dont wanna wifom over you but ill wait for the made lynch to happen before i talk more. If she is actually scum then its fine if not you will be my scum read.

[lost monkey]

As I consider the poison targets, I find myself wondering something:

Some PerC folks have said they think it's definitely a Syndicate player. I don't really understand why that is the case. Expansion would be neat. I bring this up because the most obvious trend I note in the targets (Alison, Long Con, bad bunny, and Garden Gnome) is that they're players who have given the fewest overall reads outside Alison. The other three can be targeted without singularly implicating anyone, because those players didn't put enough reads into the game to make that possible. The Alison target alone would have to illuminate if any of them can.

I think the poisoner can either win with town or scum from the looks of the poison. Except for the D1 poison, it may be that person was undecided or that person thought alison was scum. If the person thought alison was scum, that would mean bunny and guillo, one is town prosec and other is town mason. Long, bunny were people who thought you could be scum and gnome was just there. All of them were in your poe and the only person who blindly trusted you was tangy. Most of the perc people didnt agree with your read on bunny and probably would not have allowed the lynch to happen.

Is this an argument for why the poisoner is from The Syndicate or for why the poisoner is JaggedJimmyJay? Or something else? I'm struggling to follow.

Why the poisoner is from synd.

[lost monkey]

@lost monkey how do you feel overall about the role you played in the eliminations of nutella, Owner, and Sonnycrush? I ask for a reason, so please take no undue aggression from it.

I was the first one to call out nutella about being fake in the thread, sheeping your reads. Mac and nanook pushed after that and then alison went full on nutella is scum. I thought sonny was town till orange started posting. Didn't mind him getting shot but i didn't push too hard since everyone was already talking about it. By the end of D1, with the nutella save, i already figured out owner was scum, plus when i came into the thread it was already mid D2 and i didn't need to do anything since the lynch was going how i wanted it to be.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Why the poisoner is from synd.

Are you suggesting it's TangyStarkPrime then? The way you worded that post has me thoroughly confused by your meaning, which is likely more my fault than yours. I see that "most PerC people thought bunny was town", and sure that would seem to be true -- why does that preclude them from poisoning bunny? What about the targets being in my POE is indicative of the Syndicate players in general?

[lost monkey]

Heads up btw since i have used all the one shots i have had, me and allcrab do not have the same roles. I am the JOAT. So yeah there could be a possibility that martin may be scum.

Could you, like, elaborate on the "possibility"?

Play wise i have you as possible town lean but i don't see how town has the same two role, having the same ability in the same faction.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@Alison what does a mafia-aligned Martin look like, and how does this version of Martin differ from that?

[lost monkey]

Why the poisoner is from synd.

Are you suggesting it's TangyStarkPrime then? The way you worded that post has me thoroughly confused by your meaning, which is likely more my fault than yours. I see that "most PerC people thought bunny was town", and sure that would seem to be true -- why does that preclude them from poisoning bunny? What about the targets being in my POE is indicative of the Syndicate players in general?

The only two people who could be poisoner is right now me and allcrab and it would be better to have bunny alive than dead for us. Unless you are considering guillo as poisoner?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Why the poisoner is from synd.

Are you suggesting it's TangyStarkPrime then? The way you worded that post has me thoroughly confused by your meaning, which is likely more my fault than yours. I see that "most PerC people thought bunny was town", and sure that would seem to be true -- why does that preclude them from poisoning bunny? What about the targets being in my POE is indicative of the Syndicate players in general?

The only two people who could be poisoner is right now me and allcrab and it would be better to have bunny alive than dead for us. Unless you are considering guillo as poisoner?

I'd considered Guillosooa before, though the corroboration of the mason claims relieves that. Allcrab is a prime poison suspect, albeit not the "top" suspect -- for me that's probably Martin. "I wouldn't poison bunny because I like bunny" is a little hard to take seriously, but I don't know the guy.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

My primary poisoner POE would be Martin, TangyStarkPrime, and Allcrab. So from that perspective, sure -- 2/3 are Syndicate.

I could consider Mac too simply for his lack of a claim. Behaviorally-speaking I dunno about that.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

If the poisoner is town or town-friendly, they need to just claim. Throw your nerves aside and get it out there. Forcing us to waste time hunting for you is detrimental to your own win condition if you can win with us. The longer this drags out the more likely you are to get shot by mafia or chopped by happenstance.

If anyone reading this that isn't a poisoner feels an immediate urge to interject with particular words, please just don't. Let it go. I know.

[MartinGG99]

@MartinGG99 same question to you as the one directly above.

I would look to evaluating Allcrab + someone-else outside of that group for mafia compatibility.

JJJ + Sloon + LoMo I view as very unlikely non-town. TSP, of course, was desperado'ed. And then there are the Masons

In that "if" world where neither Made or Mac are mafia, I might even be forced to consider Alison as mafia in connection to Allcrab. Though I would very much dislike it coming to that (given what happened last time when I let paranoia linger) and probably re-evaluate the masons in comparison to Allcrab + Alison. Regardless, I think such a situation would be a problematic situation for me.

As it currently stands for me I don't think that outcome is very likely. I haven't really looked into it either.

[Alison]

@Alison what does a mafia-aligned Martin look like, and how does this version of Martin differ from that?

no clue tbh

[Alison]

I just read Martin's posts and feel like he's town

[MartinGG99]

My primary poisoner POE would be Martin, TangyStarkPrime, and Allcrab. So from that perspective, sure -- 2/3 are Syndicate.

Is TSP there for more-so for what TSP has done, or for what Tangy had done?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

My primary poisoner POE would be Martin, TangyStarkPrime, and Allcrab. So from that perspective, sure -- 2/3 are Syndicate.

Is TSP there for more-so for what TSP has done, or for what Tangy had done?

Both.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@MartinGG99, gun to your head, who is the poisoner?

[MartinGG99]

@MartinGG99, gun to your head, who is the poisoner?

Allcrab.

[MartinGG99]

My current world solve has Mac + Made as mafia and Allcrab as the most likely poisoner.

I'm not really bothered by people thinking I'm the poisoner given the circumstances. For all intents and purposes I don't have any sort of past-experience as 3P to know the differences between me as town and me as 3P so I can't really argue about it.

[MacDougall]

Okay consider this.

This game has since day 1 been a fantastic thread state where the mafia have essentially been dismantled day after day tracing all the way back to day 1.

I have nearing on 900 posts.

At what point have I actually wolfsided?

I hate making arguments like this but I am a powerwolf. I rarely choose to bus. I like to take the path of least resistance as wolf. I like to just destroy the town.

If the mafia are Nutella, Owner, Sonny/OC, Made +1, how does the second highest poster and probably second largest contributor to the threadstate profile as a viable fifth? It makes no sense. I would argue that I have been townier on play than everyone in this game bar Jay. Think about that. I have been TOWNIER than EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU, and you are putting me as second to last in the POE?

There is nothing that makes sense about me being mafia in this gamestate. The game would not be in this state with a 900 posting MacDougall wolfing. Everyone who has seen me wolf knows this. I am not mafia. We will probably lose if I die honestly. It usually happens. The feeling of being dead in DVC but seeing my townies bring it home is a feeling I rarely if ever feel.

[MacDougall]

If your list of POE is

Alison
Allcrab
lost monkey
MacDougall
Made
MartinGG99

I 100% should be considered the towniest person in this list, not the second wolfiest.

[Esooa]

Mac I already know what you're saying and I did after like 2 hours. See I am not your enemy I stick up for you when you need it

[TonyStarkPrime]

Oh I didn’t see that. @TonyStarkPrime please verify whether or not that’s a finale meme and also who’d you target N4

finale meme

@TonyStarkPrime did you target Gnome with anything last night? If so you don't need to tell me what it was, I just need a yes or no.

No

someone asked tsp a question and he made like 10 posts that mean nothign to anytihng and don't say anything and it tilted me off the fucking planet. I'm just going to not read them anymore

How did I possibly not answer the question

[TonyStarkPrime]

This is the best at answering questions that I’ve ever done

[MacDougall]

Mac I already know what you're saying and I did after like 2 hours. See I am not your enemy I stick up for you when you need it

When have I ever implied you were my enemy?

[Esooa]

Mac I already know what you're saying and I did after like 2 hours. See I am not your enemy I stick up for you when you need it

When have I ever implied you were my enemy?

I see you as my enemy tbh

[MacDougall]

Mac I already know what you're saying and I did after like 2 hours. See I am not your enemy I stick up for you when you need it

When have I ever implied you were my enemy?

I see you as my enemy tbh

Wow. How anime of you.

[Esooa]

tbh by enemy I just mean you say I tunnel you and shit always