It seems pretty evident to me what both LT and BWT's alliances are. BWT's responses trying to paint LT as bad or her vote as Skeletorified, as well as his flip floppyness that strikes me as insincere, and his buddying up to me (like Daisy did) only confirm to me that there is no way BWT is civvie this game. I would be very surprised if he flipped civvie at this point, especially as he has been off the mark for much of the game. I think he would be an excellent lynch candidate today.
I am also wondering what is going with DH. I've been thinking about why he would survive the Slime Pit and be apparently insanified and so upset. Has anyone considered that he may have been compromised? I know being insanified is frustrating, but for some reason I think there may be more to it.
Linki with LT: These are more great examples, thanks for providing these. There is a distinct difference between sinister and sincere 'flip flopping', if you will, and these only confirm further that BWT stinks of baddie. I was hoping I could re-read his posts and a few others' (as well as some or all of the thread) myself but naturally have not yet had time to. This weekend will be full of studying and continuing to play catch up (partially because work is busier all of a sudden), but I hopefully will be able to find and highlight some fishiness from any other players as well.
LittleTiger wrote:I have already said why I think Timmer is Zodac - twice now.
Both baddie teams clearly voted to lynch him.
As for your thought that it is Horde pushing him as being a Horde - entirely possible.
In fact, I would be very interested to hear what BWT thinks about that possibility.
That makes sense, I agree. I just was wondering if you had more reason than that.
blindfaeth wrote:RIPIYWG llama, Vomp, daisy. Like LT, i was leaning civ on llama and suspicious of daisy.
Plus, the fact that Man-E-Faces has the ability to role-check players makes me think that daisy probably was bad. Otherwise, I imagine he would not have NKed her, because it is very dangerous for him (votes on him quadruple), and instead continued to role-check players.
Vomp was def in a grey area for me, I think he's very difficult to read- but if I had to guess, I think he was good. His behavior seemed pretty consistent w/ the recent Sgt. Pepper game we finished not too long ago on this website.
orsonkidd wrote:did i miss the vote? i thought it wasn't over til like nine?
I agree that the evil lynn thing might be explained by the player being moss man, who can't be lynched and that the post read more like that than being modok (sp)
The problem is, Timmer didn't just survive the lynch - someone else got lynched instead of him. Who knows, maybe Timmer didn't switch it himself and somebody else did. But assuming Timmer did it, he couldn't be Teela or He-Man or She-Ra or Moss Man - because they can't make someone else die in their place. At least, that's what I gather. The consensus seems to be he is likely one of the roles with secrets, question is, which one.
MP, why do you trust me?

I trust you because your intentions have continuously read very genuine to me all game. Given the circumstances of Day 1, it's also pretty clear you are very unlikely SM. You could be on The Horde, but my gut doesn't think you are.
blindfaeth wrote:MovingPictures07 wrote:Wow, lots of death. RIPIYWG to all three. I guess that means we won't know about thellama or Daisy after all. I was leaning civvie on Vompatti, so that's a shame.
And, yeah, it seems DH wasn't lynched. Weird.
The more I think about it the more this post bothers me MP. Man-e-faces has a role check ability and he is a civvie. Why wouldn't daisy be bad?
It's very possible that Man-E-Faces checked Daisy and then killed her. In fact that's probably right. I was thinking that Man-E-Faces tried killing her based off of what was in the thread only, especially since it has only been 3 nights so far. So if Man-E-Faces did check her, that would mean he must have rolechecked her AND killed her with both the 60 and 40% chances working.