Cindy Kate & Percy Date Night Mafia <3 [ENDGAME]

[MartinGG99]

also good game everyone and thanks for not mischopping me for my horrendous play

[Alison]

It wasn't like you played bad or were obvious scum or anything, a combination of mech and townie play just made it hard for you to escape the POE

[Actvscenei]

Good game! I had so much fun playing on a new site with some new names! Absolutely not my best game (made some critical errors that are #regerts), but I enjoyed it.

Thank you, Dizzy and Marmot! And thank you Guillotine for sending me the sign ups

[MacDougall]

"This won't be the last you'll see of me." he stated.

It never is, is it Mac?

Thats probably the cleanest I've been beaten tbh. Maybe I'm washed.

nah you got townread really hard at the start, it was just messy for you mech wise.

remember when you said "I felt safe and then suddenly I am bottom POE"? that wasn't because you slipped or anything, the POE just shrank to the point it could no longer conceivably hold enough misexes for you to win.

Nutella dying over Made was also very painful. She was our most important role imo.

[Marmot]

"MacDougall ignored her and walked away"

I had to write some last second flavor and you subbed into the game

[Alison]

Lol, I'm joking. I probably deserve it though with "murdering" Hawk and refusing to believe in 2 healers

It sucks we didn't get a sweep but the hawk thing was just bad luck. They got counterclaimed and were roleblocked on a night there was no kill - that was just a storm of bad coincidences lining up to frame them.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@MartinGG99 you were absolutely a part of this win. You were a suspect for most people literally the whole game and are still standing here. That's not just because of Alison's support.

[Alison]

"This won't be the last you'll see of me." he stated.

It never is, is it Mac?

Thats probably the cleanest I've been beaten tbh. Maybe I'm washed.

nah you got townread really hard at the start, it was just messy for you mech wise.

remember when you said "I felt safe and then suddenly I am bottom POE"? that wasn't because you slipped or anything, the POE just shrank to the point it could no longer conceivably hold enough misexes for you to win.

Nutella dying over Made was also very painful. She was our most important role imo.

What did she do?

[Alison]

@MartinGG99 you were absolutely a part of this win. You were a suspect for most people literally the whole game and are still standing here. That's not just because of Alison's support.

I think his analysis about Allcrab was 1) really sensible and 2) fucked him over if he was mafia which made him look really townie which made Mac concede.

[MacDougall]

also good game everyone and thanks for not mischopping me for my horrendous play

You ultimately were the reason I conceded so not that bad Martin.

[Sloonei]

also good game everyone and thanks for not mischopping me for my horrendous play

You were very town. It was just mechanical mysteries that kept you in the poe.

[MacDougall]

"This won't be the last you'll see of me." he stated.

It never is, is it Mac?

Thats probably the cleanest I've been beaten tbh. Maybe I'm washed.

nah you got townread really hard at the start, it was just messy for you mech wise.

remember when you said "I felt safe and then suddenly I am bottom POE"? that wasn't because you slipped or anything, the POE just shrank to the point it could no longer conceivably hold enough misexes for you to win.

Nutella dying over Made was also very painful. She was our most important role imo.

What did she do?

Made our factional kills strong, ninja, janitorised. She had a shot of each iirc.

[Sloonei]

"This won't be the last you'll see of me." he stated.

It never is, is it Mac?

Thats probably the cleanest I've been beaten tbh. Maybe I'm washed.

nah you got townread really hard at the start, it was just messy for you mech wise.

remember when you said "I felt safe and then suddenly I am bottom POE"? that wasn't because you slipped or anything, the POE just shrank to the point it could no longer conceivably hold enough misexes for you to win.

Nutella dying over Made was also very painful. She was our most important role imo.

What did she do?

Made our factional kills strong, ninja, janitorised. She had a shot of each iirc.

so i probably would have died night 1 if she'd survived?

[TonyStarkPrime]

I also had a philosophy of one day at a time. I thought I was doomed yesterday and then suddenly the universe conspires to save me. Strange things happen if you just keep going.

I needed you alive. Probably went a little too far to guarantee it.

[MacDougall]

Good game! I had so much fun playing on a new site with some new names! Absolutely not my best game (made some critical errors that are #regerts), but I enjoyed it.

Thank you, Dizzy and Marmot! And thank you Guillotine for sending me the sign ups

You played great btw. We had a rolecop on you for a couple of days so we knew you were win thief lol.

[MacDougall]

I also had a philosophy of one day at a time. I thought I was doomed yesterday and then suddenly the universe conspires to save me. Strange things happen if you just keep going.

I needed you alive. Probably went a little too far to guarantee it.

Definitely lmao.

[Sloonei]

Thank you to all the PerC folks for hopping over here to play with us. It was great playing with all of you.

sorry i was unable to town read you, @hawkataine.

[TonyStarkPrime]

I thought about outing a green on you but I dunno if that would have done it

[MacDougall]

It never is, is it Mac?

Thats probably the cleanest I've been beaten tbh. Maybe I'm washed.

nah you got townread really hard at the start, it was just messy for you mech wise.

remember when you said "I felt safe and then suddenly I am bottom POE"? that wasn't because you slipped or anything, the POE just shrank to the point it could no longer conceivably hold enough misexes for you to win.

Nutella dying over Made was also very painful. She was our most important role imo.

What did she do?

Made our factional kills strong, ninja, janitorised. She had a shot of each iirc.

so i probably would have died night 1 if she'd survived?

If we still chose you as the target yes. Nutella being alive may have changed our target though.

[MartinGG99]

I'm fine , but I appreciate the support ^-^.

I just like to pretend I'm stupid and responsible sometimes for it so I don't feel so bad the next or fist time I actually screw up bad.

Part of the reason why I write "AKA That One Idiot" in my signature to help me remind myself of that.

If I don't occasionally think that we all make mistakes then I tend to take things hard and am vulnerable to just over-doing it.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@Gavial if you don't handle the cupid date like a champ, I'm dead a month ago. I owe it all to you, mate.

[MacDougall]

I thought about outing a green on you but I dunno if that would have done it

You were that confident I was mafia?

[Hally]

gg everyone! this was a blast to watch and it made me really happy to see two beloved communities playing together

thanks marmot and dizzy for making it happen

[MacDougall]

Thanks to @nutella @orangecrush @Sonny @Owner of a Lonely Heart and @Made for being a fun team. Hard outs. I didn't mean for you to die Nut I swear.

[Alison]

Made our factional kills strong, ninja, janitorised. She had a shot of each iirc.

ouch

[TonyStarkPrime]

I thought about outing a green on you but I dunno if that would have done it

You were that confident I was mafia?

I was decently sure but also you’re the only one I could trust to cooperate within some bounds.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I love the cupid role and might steal it for anti-town independents spoiler alert

[TonyStarkPrime]

I also had to do something mechy before town started thinking about your claim

[Alison]

I thought about outing a green on you but I dunno if that would have done it

You were that confident I was mafia?

I was decently sure but also you’re the only one I could trust to cooperate within some bounds.

why not me

I'm a very cooperative person

[Marmot]

I love the cupid role and might steal it for anti-town independents spoiler alert

Yeah, I'm definitely going to reuse that one in either the same or similar capacity.

[TonyStarkPrime]

I thought about outing a green on you but I dunno if that would have done it

You were that confident I was mafia?

I was decently sure but also you’re the only one I could trust to cooperate within some bounds.

why not me

I'm a very cooperative person

I put a green on you, town chops Mac, I lose

[Alison]

JJJ and Mac have both stuck their necks out too much and been too loud to be 3P poisoner. They'd draw an NK. Sloonei is confirmed backup. Seanzie seems to have gotten a red check on Owner somehow and I don't see how he'd get that if he was 3P poisoner. Maybe he has a rolecop to go with it or something, idk, but he wouldn't be my first guess.

I'm going to go eat now but I'll marinate on poisoner solves.

It's just Tangy. Murphy's Law is real.

sadge

[MacDougall]

JJJ and Mac have both stuck their necks out too much and been too loud to be 3P poisoner. They'd draw an NK. Sloonei is confirmed backup. Seanzie seems to have gotten a red check on Owner somehow and I don't see how he'd get that if he was 3P poisoner. Maybe he has a rolecop to go with it or something, idk, but he wouldn't be my first guess.

I'm going to go eat now but I'll marinate on poisoner solves.

It's just Tangy. Murphy's Law is real.

sadge

Hah yeh.

[Alison]

Come to think of it if Sloonei hadn't been backup and picked up desperado we would never have gotten there on TSP because we would have thought desperado dies to only town.

[Allcrab]

gg wp

thx for the carry.

[MacDougall]

Come to think of it if Sloonei hadn't been backup and picked up desperado we would never have gotten there on TSP because we would have thought desperado dies to only town.

Yeah game was townsided on mech thats why we lost. You all sucked etc.

[nutella]

ggs

[Sloonei]

so what does a prosecutor do?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

GGs

[MartinGG99]

Assessing the Made wagon requires answering one core question first: what is Made's alignment? At face value I think his nutella vote is bussing-compatible. The only reason to doubt that is that his wagon swelled all the way to 7 votes. That might be the more important factor.

It actually reached 8 votes and a tie for like a millisecond, unless my eyes deceived me or there was a poll glitch. I didn't have the presence of mind to screen cap it before it returned to 8-7. This was within seconds of the poll closing. Someone needs to own up to that.

@JaggedJimmyJay, I still owe you something.

That was me. I had a split-second urge to get rid of made but then decided against it because I felt any chop would help solve there. Coincidentally, all the wagons were mafia lol.

I debated spilling the beans about it and asked the hosts if me getting chopped prevents my heal on d2. It wouldn't prevent it, but I decided against sharing it since I figured it would only do harm.

[Garden Gnome]

@Garden Gnome

[Sloonei]

man. this game really started with three mafia wagons on day 1.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

so what does a prosecutor do?

1-shot hammer vote

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Assessing the Made wagon requires answering one core question first: what is Made's alignment? At face value I think his nutella vote is bussing-compatible. The only reason to doubt that is that his wagon swelled all the way to 7 votes. That might be the more important factor.

It actually reached 8 votes and a tie for like a millisecond, unless my eyes deceived me or there was a poll glitch. I didn't have the presence of mind to screen cap it before it returned to 8-7. This was within seconds of the poll closing. Someone needs to own up to that.

@JaggedJimmyJay, I still owe you something.

That was me. I had a split-second urge to get rid of made but then decided against it because I felt any chop would help solve there. Coincidentally, all the wagons were mafia lol.

I debated spilling the beans about it and asked the hosts if me getting chopped prevents my heal on d2. It wouldn't prevent it, but I decided against sharing it since I figured it would only do harm.

Mystery solved.

You were probably wise to just not admit it, particularly when everyone forgot it happened. Especially after Made died it would have looked fishy.

[Garden Gnome]

also good game everyone and thanks for not mischopping me for my horrendous play

I was in the bath when the game ended, listening to cool jazz and thinking that I was just a distraction to town solving the game. I was going to vote myself and tell town to go forward without me. But the melodrama wasn't necessary.

Congratulations, town!

And well played, mafia! You fought hard!

Oh, and why was I healed from the poison? That was a very bizarre turn of events!

[Marmot]

so what does a prosecutor do?

You are a Town 1-Shot Prosecutor. You win when all threats to the town faction are eliminated. Once in the game, you may target another player at night. During the following day, that player will be flipped immediately if they reach a majority of votes before the final 2 hours of the day. If this does happen, that player will flip, the poll will reset, and the day will continue as normal. This event will be announced to the thread at the start of that day.

It's sort of a duplicate of a role that juliets had in a recent game on MU.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I hope I didn't irritate anyone inordinately in this game. I try to contain the competitor within me, and usually I do a better job than I did in this one. There were moments where I may have been too much, and if so I apologize.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

lost monkey still had a vigilante shot.

[Marmot]

Congratulations to JJJ for acheiving the fourth highest post count by a player in a game and also, the highest post count by a winning player.

Despite the loss, MacDougall did achieve the second highest post total ever by a mafia player.


This game itself is also the fifth-highest ever in terms of post count.

[Sloonei]

Congratulations to JJJ for acheiving the fourth highest post count by a player in a game and also, the highest post count by a winning player.

Despite the loss, MacDougall did achieve the second highest post total ever by a mafia player.


This game itself is also the fifth-highest ever in terms of post count.

I did not update the Official list to include Fargo. I forget where it should be, but I noticed it was missing.