Bird Mafia [TOWN VICTORY]

[Alison]

I dislike LoMo's latest posting.

[Herm]

If Falcon is scum they jumped the gun with that villager claim for reasons?

I agree with this but weren't you scumreading falcon?

His behavior was scummy.

[Duskfall]

Alison is town, glav slot is town

Weaker Ender is town
Weaker again Nanook is town

Kza has decent scum equity

[Timsup2nothin]

If Falcon is scum they jumped the gun with that villager claim for reasons?

I agree with this but weren't you scumreading falcon?

His behavior was scummy.

is this a four word reply meaning "yes"?

[Duskfall]

I think I like wiml latest posting but I wanna see him do a specific think to get a town read

[Duskfall]

I found herm towny earlier but I gave that read lightly early and since then they've been a bit underwhelming and probably don't deserve it to stay

[Alison]

I haven't been impressed with KZA's posting. orangecrush completely dipped from the game thread.

My POE is something like: Herm, LoMo, KZA, orangecrush

Which is 3 slankers but I'm not getting bad vibes from the active posters so I think that's okay

Still skeeved out by a couple of nook's posts but his later days will be more telling probably. Wurzel shielded by Wiml and Creature shielded by nook for now so I'm excluding them for the moment, will circle back around to them later.

[Wiml]

If Falcon is scum they jumped the gun with that villager claim for reasons?

I agree with this but weren't you scumreading falcon?

His behavior was scummy.

Yeah but didn't falcon claim VT before you started initially scumreading him? What changed?

I'm concerned you did a 180 on that slot as soon as Gavial subbed out.

[Wiml]

Falcon, I have a question for you having read only 5% of the game so far.

What kind of scum are you?

I am a Villager, and I can do nothing at night.



Why do you feel the need to point out you've only read 5% of the game?

[Herm]

If Falcon is scum they jumped the gun with that villager claim for reasons?

I agree with this but weren't you scumreading falcon?

His behavior was scummy.

is this a four word reply meaning "yes"?

Yes

[Herm]

Falcon, I have a question for you having read only 5% of the game so far.

What kind of scum are you?

I am a Villager, and I can do nothing at night.



Why do you feel the need to point out you've only read 5% of the game?

I like to throw silly stuff out there when I play.

It has nothing to do with strategy.

I opened the game, introduced myself to the game, then I caught up!

[Herm]

I was interested playing with new people.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I was interested playing with new people.

Theres your first mistake

[KZA]

protip Alison can't read me so if she's town I'm lock town

[Alison]

protip Alison can't read me so if she's town I'm lock town

this is really untrue

[Wiml]

Falcon, I have a question for you having read only 5% of the game so far.

What kind of scum are you?

I am a Villager, and I can do nothing at night.



Why do you feel the need to point out you've only read 5% of the game?

I like to throw silly stuff out there when I play.

It has nothing to do with strategy.

I opened the game, introduced myself to the game, then I caught up!

I wasn't suggesting what you were saying was scummy (it is but that's not the point)!

I'm saying that falcon claimed VT very early. Then you scumread him for reasons that felt like you were just sheeping Gavial with half-hearted reasons of your own. Then Gavial subbed out. Now you're defending him because of something he did before you initially started scumreading him.

That progression really pinged me and that's why I'm trying to ask what changed for you!

[Herm]

I was interested playing with new people.

Theres your first mistake

Lol.

Well, it started fun at least

[Alison]

also that was a beetlejuice and you've been caught as scum through exactly that tell before

[Wiml]

Also I want to point put that me just naked quoting Herm's post had them immediately jump to the conclusion that I was calling it wolfy.

[falcon45ca]

protip Alison can't read me so if she's town I'm lock town

this is really untrue

Which part?

[Herm]

I trusted Gavial more than I trusted my own reads.

I'm not the most confident player lol.

[Wiml]

I trusted Gavial more than I trusted my own reads.

I'm not the most confident player lol.

So, to make sure I'm interpreting this correctly, did you townread falcon's VT claim from the start but decide to sheep Gavial's scumread there and once Gavial subbed out you stopped sheeping him?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I was interested playing with new people.

Theres your first mistake

Lol.

Well, it started fun at least

What can we do to salvage your enjoyment

[Herm]

I'm outside walking/listening to music right now.

Gonna get those miles plugged in before work tomorrow!

[falcon45ca]

Herm/LoMo/Ender


GG, Town wins

[hollowkatt]

I was interested playing with new people.

Theres your first mistake

if you hadn't said that I would have

[Herm]

I was interested playing with new people.

Theres your first mistake

Lol.

Well, it started fun at least

What can we do to salvage your enjoyment

No more personal drama, enjoy yourself and have fun is all I ask for lol.

[Herm]

Herm/LoMo/Ender


GG, Town wins

Well you're at least 33% wrong lol.

Why us three?

[KZA]

also that was a beetlejuice and you've been caught as scum through exactly that tell before

are you talking about Philo?

I was caught long before that

[Wiml]

Wait Herm you changed your read on falcon way earlier why didn't you just say that?

[Wiml]

I was quizzing you on something you didn't even do!

[Herm]

I trusted Gavial more than I trusted my own reads.

I'm not the most confident player lol.

So, to make sure I'm interpreting this correctly, did you townread falcon's VT claim from the start but decide to sheep Gavial's scumread there and once Gavial subbed out you stopped sheeping him?

Pretty much. Made me question his reads and confidence in his reads.

[Wiml]

I trusted Gavial more than I trusted my own reads.

I'm not the most confident player lol.

So, to make sure I'm interpreting this correctly, did you townread falcon's VT claim from the start but decide to sheep Gavial's scumread there and once Gavial subbed out you stopped sheeping him?

Pretty much. Made me question his reads and confidence in his reads.

Didn't you change your falcon read wY before Gavial subbed out though? That's what I just noticed and apologised for.

[Herm]

Wait Herm you changed your read on falcon way earlier why didn't you just say that?

I probably forgot that I did.

[Alison]

protip Alison can't read me so if she's town I'm lock town

this is really untrue

Which part?

it is untrue that I can't read KZA and it is also untrue that if someone who can't read you says you're scum that means you're lock town

[falcon45ca]

Herm/LoMo/Ender


GG, Town wins

Well you're at least 33% wrong lol.

Why us three?

My heightened bird sense told me so

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I was interested playing with new people.

Theres your first mistake

Lol.

Well, it started fun at least

What can we do to salvage your enjoyment

No more personal drama, enjoy yourself and have fun is all I ask for lol.

Thats always my goal! Just follow my lead and skip over the drama, makes the thread way easier to read

[Herm]

I trusted Gavial more than I trusted my own reads.

I'm not the most confident player lol.

So, to make sure I'm interpreting this correctly, did you townread falcon's VT claim from the start but decide to sheep Gavial's scumread there and once Gavial subbed out you stopped sheeping him?

Pretty much. Made me question his reads and confidence in his reads.

Didn't you change your falcon read wY before Gavial subbed out though? That's what I just noticed and apologised for.

If I changed my mind before the sub out it was probably because of the claim?

[falcon45ca]

protip Alison can't read me so if she's town I'm lock town

this is really untrue

Which part?

it is untrue that I can't read KZA and it is also untrue that if someone who can't read you says you're scum that means you're lock town

I agree

[Herm]

I was interested playing with new people.

Theres your first mistake

Lol.

Well, it started fun at least

What can we do to salvage your enjoyment

No more personal drama, enjoy yourself and have fun is all I ask for lol.

Thats always my goal! Just follow my lead and skip over the drama, makes the thread way easier to read

[falcon45ca]

I trusted Gavial more than I trusted my own reads.

I'm not the most confident player lol.

So, to make sure I'm interpreting this correctly, did you townread falcon's VT claim from the start but decide to sheep Gavial's scumread there and once Gavial subbed out you stopped sheeping him?

Pretty much. Made me question his reads and confidence in his reads.

Didn't you change your falcon read wY before Gavial subbed out though? That's what I just noticed and apologised for.

If I changed my mind before the sub out it was probably because of the claim?

That doesn't make sense, cuz you sussed me after the claim.

[Herm]

Herm/LoMo/Ender


GG, Town wins

Well you're at least 33% wrong lol.

Why us three?

My heightened bird sense told me so

My bird sense think it's Wurzel.

[Wiml]

I trusted Gavial more than I trusted my own reads.

I'm not the most confident player lol.

So, to make sure I'm interpreting this correctly, did you townread falcon's VT claim from the start but decide to sheep Gavial's scumread there and once Gavial subbed out you stopped sheeping him?

Pretty much. Made me question his reads and confidence in his reads.

Didn't you change your falcon read wY before Gavial subbed out though? That's what I just noticed and apologised for.

If I changed my mind before the sub out it was probably because of the claim?

That doesn't make sense, cuz you sussed me after the claim.

This!!!

[KZA]

protip Alison can't read me so if she's town I'm lock town

imagine taking this post seriously

[Herm]

I trusted Gavial more than I trusted my own reads.

I'm not the most confident player lol.

So, to make sure I'm interpreting this correctly, did you townread falcon's VT claim from the start but decide to sheep Gavial's scumread there and once Gavial subbed out you stopped sheeping him?

Pretty much. Made me question his reads and confidence in his reads.

Didn't you change your falcon read wY before Gavial subbed out though? That's what I just noticed and apologised for.

If I changed my mind before the sub out it was probably because of the claim?

That doesn't make sense, cuz you sussed me after the claim.

I believed you, then Gavial who was my strongest town read at the time, was convinced that you/HK were partners bc of meta reasons/+ argued that Villager claim was fake.

Then I backed off on that read a bit.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Kinda think seth was mafia, kinda think ender and/or falcon are most likely partners

[Herm]

I find it hard to have a definite consistent thought pattern, since I play a bit emotionally lol.

[Alison]

Kinda think seth was mafia, kinda think ender and/or falcon are most likely partners

elaborate on the seth being mafia bit?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Kinda think seth was mafia, kinda think ender and/or falcon are most likely partners

elaborate on the seth being mafia bit?

I read the first half or so of his iso and I think its scummy

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I also didn't love his replacements 3 posts so far tbh