AtLA post-game (mafia win)

[sig]

Read Falcon's iso and think he's a bad vote. Everything seems normal, matches my small meta, and it's all people I think are villagers voting him.

You are correct inc.
He seems good, sig on the other hand has to be scum and many people are trying to ignore that fact.

And the reasons arrrrrre?

Well see they’re nonexistent sig

[Guillotine]

Seriously why do those questions sound like an infomercial

Because the writer is not funny.

[Guillotine]

► Show Spoiler

May I be added to this format? As grogu obviously. We can make a grogu tier which is in between wolfy and towny since I don’t know how to do either

[NotAnAxehole]

Read Falcon's iso and think he's a bad vote. Everything seems normal, matches my small meta, and it's all people I think are villagers voting him.

You are correct inc.
He seems good, sig on the other hand has to be scum and many people are trying to ignore that fact.

And the reasons arrrrrre?

Well see they’re nonexistent sig

But not incorrect.

[Guillotine]

tbh I was expecting to have good or stronger reads for reading the past 600-something posts

I didn't. Well, not as many I would like.

going to read random isos

my eyes on grogu though that bastard has tricked me in the past with my attempts to get reliable reads on him and if it weren't for the soup kill I would ask for a check on him

I have tricked you? Pretty sure if I was a wolf it was my team who tricked you. I just loosely follow their plan, which has been to just push and vote me and then get credit for it.

This feels like a trust tell

► Show Spoiler

[NotAnAxehole]

I'm ok with being right for the wrong / bad reasons @sig

[DaughterOfOmega]

Lunch was excellent. My biological dad was very kind and wanted to help me out financially for college.

I want to post an awful reads of list in a few

Glad to hear. What do you want to pursue in college?

Currently pursuing a PHD in chemistry. Fall will be my last semester of my sophomore year

[Guillotine]

I like axe guy posting the guillo thing again and again, its funny. Why are people scum reading him btw?

Well,

Sig is mafia

Guillo is a boomer and a meme.

There are the two votes.

[DaughterOfOmega]

Town: Grogu (obligatory) Naviya, Falcon, Lost Monkey, Luckbox, Macdoug

Mafia: Creature, Seanzie

[NotAnAxehole]

Town: Grogu (obligatory) Naviya, Falcon, Lost Monkey, Luckbox, Macdoug

Mafia: Creature, Seanzie

I like this a lot, but I feel like your mafia are just "the absence of town quality" yet I feel like a player like Sig has been just scummy, not just the absence of being towny.

[DaughterOfOmega]

Town: Grogu (obligatory) Naviya, Falcon, Lost Monkey, Luckbox, Macdoug

Mafia: Creature, Seanzie

I like this a lot, but I feel like your mafia are just "the absence of town quality" yet I feel like a player like Sig has been just scummy, not just the absence of being towny.

I disagree with the premise of your post, but I will give you some advice.

Towns are often more openly scummy than the actual mafia players. Many people play town while ignoring the views other see them as, on the other hand mafia must worry about being seen as scummy. A complete void of either town or mafia usually points to more of a mafia playstyle which is to not draw so much attention.

Though I personally have still missed bits of this game, so I will keep your sig read in mind while I play.

[NotAnAxehole]

Town: Grogu (obligatory) Naviya, Falcon, Lost Monkey, Luckbox, Macdoug

Mafia: Creature, Seanzie

I like this a lot, but I feel like your mafia are just "the absence of town quality" yet I feel like a player like Sig has been just scummy, not just the absence of being towny.

I disagree with the premise of your post, but I will give you some advice.

Towns are often more openly scummy than the actual mafia players. Many people play town while ignoring the views other see them as, on the other hand mafia must worry about being seen as scummy. A complete void of either town or mafia usually points to more of a mafia playstyle which is to not draw so much attention.

Though I personally have still missed bits of this game, so I will keep your sig read in mind while I play.

But that would mean that what you consider "being scummy" isn't scummy. I'm talking about actual scum tells.

[NotAnAxehole]

I'm not saying I can't be wrong, it's just I'm not vibing sig scummy, I think upon review of his ISO, he just gave off an actual scum tell.

[hollowkatt]

I'm not saying I can't be wrong, it's just I'm not vibing sig scummy, I think upon review of his ISO, he just gave off an actual scum tell.

what's the tell?

[NotAnAxehole]

I'm not saying I can't be wrong, it's just I'm not vibing sig scummy, I think upon review of his ISO, he just gave off an actual scum tell.

what's the tell?

You read his iso and find the scummiest thing he did, or you can read mine to find a good starting point.

[DaughterOfOmega]

Town: Grogu (obligatory) Naviya, Falcon, Lost Monkey, Luckbox, Macdoug

Mafia: Creature, Seanzie

I like this a lot, but I feel like your mafia are just "the absence of town quality" yet I feel like a player like Sig has been just scummy, not just the absence of being towny.

I disagree with the premise of your post, but I will give you some advice.

Towns are often more openly scummy than the actual mafia players. Many people play town while ignoring the views other see them as, on the other hand mafia must worry about being seen as scummy. A complete void of either town or mafia usually points to more of a mafia playstyle which is to not draw so much attention.

Though I personally have still missed bits of this game, so I will keep your sig read in mind while I play.

But that would mean that what you consider "being scummy" isn't scummy. I'm talking about actual scum tells.

I'm not sure I get what you're saying. Scum tells are often bs. You have to create lists with who you think are potential wolves so you that can create real pressure. If you allow people to sit there in a void less existence, you will have a harder time in mid to end game

[Creature]

Of course I'm trying to not attract attention.

[hollowkatt]

I'm not saying I can't be wrong, it's just I'm not vibing sig scummy, I think upon review of his ISO, he just gave off an actual scum tell.

what's the tell?

You read his iso and find the scummiest thing he did, or you can read mine to find a good starting point.

that would be effort

[NotAnAxehole]

I'm not saying I can't be wrong, it's just I'm not vibing sig scummy, I think upon review of his ISO, he just gave off an actual scum tell.

what's the tell?

You read his iso and find the scummiest thing he did, or you can read mine to find a good starting point.

that would be effort

Path of least resistance seems to be voting Sig and taking my word for it.

[NotAnAxehole]

Town: Grogu (obligatory) Naviya, Falcon, Lost Monkey, Luckbox, Macdoug

Mafia: Creature, Seanzie

I like this a lot, but I feel like your mafia are just "the absence of town quality" yet I feel like a player like Sig has been just scummy, not just the absence of being towny.

I disagree with the premise of your post, but I will give you some advice.

Towns are often more openly scummy than the actual mafia players. Many people play town while ignoring the views other see them as, on the other hand mafia must worry about being seen as scummy. A complete void of either town or mafia usually points to more of a mafia playstyle which is to not draw so much attention.

Though I personally have still missed bits of this game, so I will keep your sig read in mind while I play.

But that would mean that what you consider "being scummy" isn't scummy. I'm talking about actual scum tells.

I'm not sure I get what you're saying. Scum tells are often bs. You have to create lists with who you think are potential wolves so you that can create real pressure. If you allow people to sit there in a void less existence, you will have a harder time in mid to end game

I think we probably fundamentally disagree on a lot of how to play, and that's fine. But I still think Sig could easily fall into the category of scum in how you read the game, so I'm hoping that you vote him.

[Grogu]

Read Falcon's iso and think he's a bad vote. Everything seems normal, matches my small meta, and it's all people I think are villagers voting him.

You are correct inc.
He seems good, sig on the other hand has to be scum and many people are trying to ignore that fact.

And the reasons arrrrrre?

Well see they’re nonexistent sig

I just don’t like your posts, they seem scummy and also like you are acting. This defense of yours is also a very bad one.

[KZA]

Creature is probably just mafia

Basically posting absolutely nothing like in the last game I played with him

[KZA]

Falcon wagon is a good idea, hes lacking the punch I'd expect him from typically

Not calling him lock wolf but well see how he responds

[KZA]

[VOTE: Creature] aubergine

[Dana]

Hey @Creature

Long time, no see.

Hey new players. I’m Jack. I’m unyeetable. I’ll troll and pretend not to hunt (or actually not hunt) until I see something shiny, which is hopefully a wolf.

I don't like the vibes of this post very much at all

why?

It just felt kinda off to me a lil bit. I don't think I've ever played with Jack before so idk if this is normal for them but it just gave me some bad vibes. Idk if I can explain it super well but specifically the "I'm unyeetable" part made me go :/ like was that a joke... Or a challenge?

[Luckbox Inc]

[VOTE: Creature] aubergine
for KZA

[Felicis]

Seriously why do those questions sound like an infomercial

Because the writer is not funny.

Are you an entitled brat?

Are you buried in instant gratification?

Are you selfish?

Are you an unempathetic little prick?

Please help me a man is holding me hostage and making me type only in memes. Please. This is not a meme, I'm not trying to be funny. I need you to help me get out of here. My address is 422- OH MY GOD WHAT ARE YOU DOING N-

Still catching up but wanted to say this^^ is the best post in the game so far lmao

[Grogu]

► Show Spoiler

May I be added to this format? As grogu obviously. We can make a grogu tier which is in between wolfy and towny since I don’t know how to do either

New tier: innocent child, not townie nor scummy. Just a good kid!
May I present to you…

[Grogu]

tbh I was expecting to have good or stronger reads for reading the past 600-something posts

I didn't. Well, not as many I would like.

going to read random isos

my eyes on grogu though that bastard has tricked me in the past with my attempts to get reliable reads on him and if it weren't for the soup kill I would ask for a check on him

I have tricked you? Pretty sure if I was a wolf it was my team who tricked you. I just loosely follow their plan, which has been to just push and vote me and then get credit for it.

This feels like a trust tell

► Show Spoiler

Lol. The sweetest nut

[NotAnAxehole]

Here is my mafia core at this stage of the game:

Sig
TSP
Felicis
ButterscotchSundae
KZA
Justinrs2

Second tier:

Dana
Creature (relies on KZA being wrong)
Guillotine (Also more or less relies on KZA and justinrs2 being wrong)

I think there's quite a lot to see on a re-read

[Grogu]

Lunch was excellent. My biological dad was very kind and wanted to help me out financially for college.

I want to post an awful reads of list in a few

Glad to hear. What do you want to pursue in college?

Currently pursuing a PHD in chemistry. Fall will be my last semester of my sophomore year

Nice. Wish I was that smart

[NotAnAxehole]

Specifically, I get the vibe that Justin/Falcon is not T/T So idk, maybe falcon can sub into Justin's slot now that I've had a look at it.

[Grogu]

Specifically, I get the vibe that Justin/Falcon is not T/T So idk, maybe falcon can sub into Justin's slot now that I've had a look at it.

Justin more likely than falco

[NotAnAxehole]

idk if anyone is vibing with this, but reading the game without considering anything Sig has posted still leads me to believe that they're mafia.

[Luckbox Inc]

Here is my mafia core at this stage of the game:

Sig
TSP
Felicis
ButterscotchSundae
KZA
Justinrs2

Second tier:

Dana
Creature (relies on KZA being wrong)
Guillotine (Also more or less relies on KZA and justinrs2 being wrong)

I think there's quite a lot to see on a re-read

Why Felicis, Kza and Justin?
I've got reasons to think all of them are good-- mostly tone stuff

[NotAnAxehole]

Here is my mafia core at this stage of the game:

Sig
TSP
Felicis
ButterscotchSundae
KZA
Justinrs2

Second tier:

Dana
Creature (relies on KZA being wrong)
Guillotine (Also more or less relies on KZA and justinrs2 being wrong)

I think there's quite a lot to see on a re-read

Why Felicis, Kza and Justin?
I've got reasons to think all of them are good-- mostly tone stuff

If your only beef is with picks 3,5,6 then I think we can say that... For day 1, we're in agreement. But yeah, Justin I actually just explained 2 seconds ago...

[Creature]

Creature is probably just mafia

Basically posting absolutely nothing like in the last game I played with him

No, I have to make notes of a 1-hour long video.

[Creature]

If ypu lynch me, you'll just get a dead villager and dead info to work tomorrow with two or three less villagers.

[NotAnAxehole]

If ypu lynch me, you'll just get a dead villager and dead info to work tomorrow with two or three less villagers.

I mostly believe this.

[NotAnAxehole]

@MacDougall come vibe with me, I need you to convince your kind to vote with me.

[Luckbox Inc]

If ypu lynch me, you'll just get a dead villager and dead info to work tomorrow with two or three less villagers.

I mostly believe this.

not really any reason to. This is completely within Creature's wolf range.

[NotAnAxehole]

If ypu lynch me, you'll just get a dead villager and dead info to work tomorrow with two or three less villagers.

I mostly believe this.

not really any reason to. This is completely within Creature's wolf range.

Also yes.

[Felicis]

Fuckkkkkkkkk okay I'm home I'm caught up, I don't have tons to say except that I'm still feeling p cool about Ender's posts, they just feel like trying to solve as opposed to getting town to out information; I noticed guillo no longer thinks I'm a yiff wolf; axe thinks I'm maybe a wolf and also has sights set on Sig.

Sounds like Day 1

[NotAnAxehole]

Fuckkkkkkkkk okay I'm home I'm caught up, I don't have tons to say except that I'm still feeling p cool about Ender's posts, they just feel like trying to solve as opposed to getting town to out information; I noticed guillo no longer thinks I'm a yiff wolf; axe thinks I'm maybe a wolf and also has sights set on Sig.

Sounds like Day 1

Vote Sig and I might take you out of my scum list.

[Creature]

If ypu lynch me, you'll just get a dead villager and dead info to work tomorrow with two or three less villagers.

I mostly believe this.

not really any reason to. This is completely within Creature's wolf range.

Yes, but that still raises a good point that lynching me is suboptimal because, from outside my pov, I either flip wolf with close to zero interactions or I flip town and the rest of town get practically no info because it was a semi-MIA lynch.

[NotAnAxehole]

If ypu lynch me, you'll just get a dead villager and dead info to work tomorrow with two or three less villagers.

I mostly believe this.

not really any reason to. This is completely within Creature's wolf range.

Yes, but that still raises a good point that lynching me is suboptimal because, from outside my pov, I either flip wolf with close to zero interactions or I flip town and the rest of town get practically no info because it was a semi-MIA lynch.

I've created an associative by defending you here, which they'll take as TMI when you flip town.

[Luckbox Inc]

If ypu lynch me, you'll just get a dead villager and dead info to work tomorrow with two or three less villagers.

I mostly believe this.

not really any reason to. This is completely within Creature's wolf range.

Yes, but that still raises a good point that lynching me is suboptimal because, from outside my pov, I either flip wolf with close to zero interactions or I flip town and the rest of town get practically no info because it was a semi-MIA lynch.

I don't disagree.
Did you have a plan for when you might leave your wolf range?

[Jackofhearts2005]

And now I'm gonna crash and come back.

Thank you for participating Justin.

I kinda want Jackofhearts today, but will think it over when I'm awake.

Thanks but I’m married.

[Guillotine]

If ypu lynch me, you'll just get a dead villager and dead info to work tomorrow with two or three less villagers.

I mostly believe this.

not really any reason to. This is completely within Creature's wolf range.

Yes, but that still raises a good point that lynching me is suboptimal because, from outside my pov, I either flip wolf with close to zero interactions or I flip town and the rest of town get practically no info because it was a semi-MIA lynch.

I've created an associative by defending you here, which they'll take as TMI when you flip town.

[Jackofhearts2005]

@NotAnAxehole

Use this one.