Everyone's JOATED: Guillo's Roles (Town Wins)

#1951

honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 11:43 am furthermore i feel like the dream thing was gnome and scotty attempting to diminish my credibility in a very insincere way

if anyone wants to join this discussion dont be shy

Scotty/nanook atleast one is a

#1952

lost monkey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 11:36 am Hk lynch was so bad. Nanook probably scum.

hk didn't help his cause with the attitude that he presented. Why do you think that nanook is scum?

#1953

I mean I didn't really think he was likely to be mafia but mac was right, hk probably did have to resolve, and he postcapped himself so there wouldn't even be pressure for mafia to resolve him for us

#1954

nah u all should realize you didnt have to vote him out, he claimed cop he couldve gotten another night check and we could've looked at someone else it was more abt being passive and sheeping imo than anything else

he did not have to be resolved yesterday

#1955

honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:09 pm nah u all should realize you didnt have to vote him out, he claimed cop he couldve gotten another night check and we could've looked at someone else it was more abt being passive and sheeping imo than anything else

he did not have to be resolved yesterday

I mean he couldn't have lol, he vanillaized himself

#1956

Always happy to lynch anyone who claims a red check on town.

#1957

This is why I hate bastard games so much

#1958

Stupid

#1959

I mean sure, we could have treated hk as cleared, but do you think enough people would've bought into for that to be effective? Probably not, yeah? More likely outcome is he doesn't die tonight and gets pushed tomorrow too...and if he doesn't die tomorrow...then he gets pushed again d4...and in all that time he maybe gets one more check on n3, if we assume that mafia don't have a blocker of any kind.

So yeah. Thats why he needed to be resolved, cause if he isn't now then he's just gonna keep getting pushed by people who can't see past "HE CLAIMED A RED ON TOWN THO"

It sucks but sometimes thats the game

#1960

Creature wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:30 pm Always happy to lynch anyone who claims a red check on town.

hope u learn from this that you can consider multiple factors if u attempt to think critically
you can get redchecks on town in non bastard games too w millers and maf roles that frame ppl dont blame the setup blame smooth brain attitude

#1961

There’s no post cap and all I want to do is not post because…that lynch didn’t have to happen.

honey, I’m not being insincere with my response. I sincerely think that you being hung up on falcon’s D1 legacy and basically ignoring any other happenings of D2 is shortsighted.

Could GG be bad? Sure. But I am not basing it on NK processing. That’s just me

#1962

i just got invited to a disco maf game and i have some plans happening this weekend so i cant start as many thoughtful discussions as i'd like to rip

#1963

lost monkey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 11:46 am
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 11:43 am furthermore i feel like the dream thing was gnome and scotty attempting to diminish my credibility in a very insincere way

if anyone wants to join this discussion dont be shy
Scotty/nanook atleast one is a

Why those options

#1964

honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:09 pm nah u all should realize you didnt have to vote him out, he claimed cop he couldve gotten another night check and we could've looked at someone else it was more abt being passive and sheeping imo than anything else

he did not have to be resolved yesterday

No he didn’t, but you suddenly changing to a vanity wagon of GG helped not at all 3 hours before EoD. No one was switching at that point.

I still think Dolby is a hit, especially with those suspect late votes.

Aaaaand GG could be a hit regardless, I’m not gonna put a damper on that. Just the timing was less than ideal.

#1965

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:35 pm I mean sure, we could have treated hk as cleared, but do you think enough people would've bought into for that to be effective? Probably not, yeah? More likely outcome is he doesn't die tonight and gets pushed tomorrow too...and if he doesn't die tomorrow...then he gets pushed again d4...and in all that time he maybe gets one more check on n3, if we assume that mafia don't have a blocker of any kind.

So yeah. Thats why he needed to be resolved, cause if he isn't now then he's just gonna keep getting pushed by people who can't see past "HE CLAIMED A RED ON TOWN THO"

It sucks but sometimes thats the game

I want to nightvote you

#1966

Why are you booing me? I'm right.

#1967

Bastard game leaves countless possibilities for HK’s red check on TSP:
-TSP was framed, like previously said
-HK was targeted to get opposite info ability
-someone’s flavor card gave either of those options credence
-HK’s role was bastard inherently
-etc etc

#1968

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:55 pm Why are you booing me? I'm right.

Nah. You’re trying to take the high road but the bridge is out

#1969

I’m taking the road through the TUNNEL CHOOCHOO

#1970

I mean yeah ideally we could've just left hk alone but realistically he just would've been a distraction and pushed again tomorrow, so

Sometimes you just have to kill someone you don't think is mafia so the game can move on, it sucks but that's the game

#1971

So are we finally gonna yeet Nanook tomorrow? If so I’ll be the conductor for that train!

#1972

Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:50 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:09 pm nah u all should realize you didnt have to vote him out, he claimed cop he couldve gotten another night check and we could've looked at someone else it was more abt being passive and sheeping imo than anything else

he did not have to be resolved yesterday
No he didn’t, but you suddenly changing to a vanity wagon of GG helped not at all 3 hours before EoD. No one was switching at that point.

I still think Dolby is a hit, especially with those suspect late votes.

Aaaaand GG could be a hit regardless, I’m not gonna put a damper on that. Just the timing was less than ideal.

you realize i didnt change from voting hk to gg? i changed from voting dolby who was afk and being voted by gnome and you who sheeped me so fast and you and gnome became my prime suspects after contextualizing the n1 kill on falcon

i didnt have that great of a reason for voting dolby and i decided people who full claim can self resolve
gnome wasnt afk but wasn't towny

not a vanity wagon

#1973

honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:05 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:50 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:09 pm nah u all should realize you didnt have to vote him out, he claimed cop he couldve gotten another night check and we could've looked at someone else it was more abt being passive and sheeping imo than anything else

he did not have to be resolved yesterday
No he didn’t, but you suddenly changing to a vanity wagon of GG helped not at all 3 hours before EoD. No one was switching at that point.

I still think Dolby is a hit, especially with those suspect late votes.

Aaaaand GG could be a hit regardless, I’m not gonna put a damper on that. Just the timing was less than ideal.
you realize i didnt change from voting hk to gg? i changed from voting dolby who was afk and being voted by gnome and you who sheeped me so fast and you and gnome became my prime suspects after contextualizing the n1 kill on falcon

i didnt have that great of a reason for voting dolby and i decided people who full claim can self resolve
gnome wasnt afk but wasn't towny

not a vanity wagon

Reminder: the vote was HK 6, Dolby 5, GG 0. You switched from Dolby, essentially killing the momentum of that train to…a vanity wagon on GG.

My “sheep” vote had a case attached to it, so hardly sheep honey.

Why does it matter that Dolby was afk for the back half of the day?

#1974

listo95 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:03 pm So are we finally gonna yeet Nanook tomorrow? If so I’ll be the conductor for that train!

I suppose I could ride caboose on that train. Need to do more digging

#1975

I think Mac is 3p

#1976

Nice, HK has a chance of resurrection today! Come on lucky d10!

#1977

Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:17 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:05 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:50 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:09 pm nah u all should realize you didnt have to vote him out, he claimed cop he couldve gotten another night check and we could've looked at someone else it was more abt being passive and sheeping imo than anything else

he did not have to be resolved yesterday
No he didn’t, but you suddenly changing to a vanity wagon of GG helped not at all 3 hours before EoD. No one was switching at that point.

I still think Dolby is a hit, especially with those suspect late votes.

Aaaaand GG could be a hit regardless, I’m not gonna put a damper on that. Just the timing was less than ideal.
you realize i didnt change from voting hk to gg? i changed from voting dolby who was afk and being voted by gnome and you who sheeped me so fast and you and gnome became my prime suspects after contextualizing the n1 kill on falcon

i didnt have that great of a reason for voting dolby and i decided people who full claim can self resolve
gnome wasnt afk but wasn't towny

not a vanity wagon
Reminder: the vote was HK 6, Dolby 5, GG 0. You switched from Dolby, essentially killing the momentum of that train to…a vanity wagon on GG.

My “sheep” vote had a case attached to it, so hardly sheep honey.

Why does it matter that Dolby was afk for the back half of the day?

dolby full claimed! there's no point in voting them out with that hello? didnt see you casing dolby either just sheeping

#1978

honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:43 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:17 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:05 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:50 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:09 pm nah u all should realize you didnt have to vote him out, he claimed cop he couldve gotten another night check and we could've looked at someone else it was more abt being passive and sheeping imo than anything else

he did not have to be resolved yesterday
No he didn’t, but you suddenly changing to a vanity wagon of GG helped not at all 3 hours before EoD. No one was switching at that point.

I still think Dolby is a hit, especially with those suspect late votes.

Aaaaand GG could be a hit regardless, I’m not gonna put a damper on that. Just the timing was less than ideal.
you realize i didnt change from voting hk to gg? i changed from voting dolby who was afk and being voted by gnome and you who sheeped me so fast and you and gnome became my prime suspects after contextualizing the n1 kill on falcon

i didnt have that great of a reason for voting dolby and i decided people who full claim can self resolve
gnome wasnt afk but wasn't towny

not a vanity wagon
Reminder: the vote was HK 6, Dolby 5, GG 0. You switched from Dolby, essentially killing the momentum of that train to…a vanity wagon on GG.

My “sheep” vote had a case attached to it, so hardly sheep honey.

Why does it matter that Dolby was afk for the back half of the day?
dolby full claimed! there's no point in voting them out with that hello? didnt see you casing dolby either just sheeping

You..didn’t see me lay out my points for voting him?

Also, my point is that his full claim was suspect to begin with.

#1979

Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:24 pm I think Mac is 3p

in the setup rules it says there are no 3rd parties so unless u think that's a lie then .. denied

#1980

ATTENTION!

Ok! You may continue!

#1981

These Pixar movies are getting weird

#1982

honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:46 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:24 pm I think Mac is 3p
in the setup rules it says there are no 3rd parties so unless u think that's a lie then .. denied

Ah good call. Missed that
He may just be pingpong slapadap town then

The rules also say any talking during night, even if unlocked, isn’t allowed. So I fully expect us all to die tonight lol

#1983

Someone talk to me about things so I don’t just keep talking to myself in a vacuum.

I mean I do it enough in real life to not want to emulate it here

#1984

I suppose those must be the living players, right?

1. lost monkey
2. MacDougall
5. Lime Coke
6. Flea the Magician
7. NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
8. Alison
10. EnderWiggin
11. TripleHaven
12. Dolby
13. Scotty
14. Garden Gnome
15. honey
16. Creature
18. listo95
21. osieorb18

#1985

honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:05 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:50 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 12:09 pm nah u all should realize you didnt have to vote him out, he claimed cop he couldve gotten another night check and we could've looked at someone else it was more abt being passive and sheeping imo than anything else

he did not have to be resolved yesterday
No he didn’t, but you suddenly changing to a vanity wagon of GG helped not at all 3 hours before EoD. No one was switching at that point.

I still think Dolby is a hit, especially with those suspect late votes.

Aaaaand GG could be a hit regardless, I’m not gonna put a damper on that. Just the timing was less than ideal.
you realize i didnt change from voting hk to gg? i changed from voting dolby who was afk and being voted by gnome and you who sheeped me so fast and you and gnome became my prime suspects after contextualizing the n1 kill on falcon

i didnt have that great of a reason for voting dolby and i decided people who full claim can self resolve
gnome wasnt afk but wasn't towny

not a vanity wagon

your vote on me, when you knew that I wasn't going to be the chop, was very much not towny. Your reasons for voting me were outright scummy. I'd vote you now, if I could. If I actually were scum, I'd be tempted to NK you. But I'm town, so you're safe from me.

#1986

I am actually annoyed that HK just capped and sacrificed himself, even if he has the slightest chance of coming back as a confirmed town. Even if the dude had a red check that was wrong it was irresponsible as hell to just waste the cop role.

#1987

So I think we just don't trust any more checks from now onward

#1988

Back to oldschool wolfhunting if game hasn't ended yet

#1989

Mmm another possibility is HK WAS wolf, and a teammate had an ability to janitor their flip either last night or during the day yesterday. And he purposefully tried to get killed with a fake red check. I find this less likely but who the duck knows.

If that was the case, Dolby is town. I don’t think so tho

#1990

Meh, I think Dolby will have to go. listo can go too.

#1991

lost monkey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 11:40 am After seeing what happened last game, I find it weird that creature voted hk.

No, last game was a clear example of why fake red checks are unacceptable.

#1992

Getting back into wolfreading EnderWiggin too.

#1993

I’m guessing Alison is still kidnapped. Here’s hoping she can be saved automatically and doesn’t have to be Hack Bauer’d

#1994

Creature wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 2:02 pm I suppose those must be the living players, right?

1. lost monkey
2. MacDougall
5. Lime Coke
6. Flea the Magician
7. NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
8. Alison
10. EnderWiggin
11. TripleHaven
12. Dolby
13. Scotty
14. Garden Gnome
15. honey
16. Creature
18. listo95
21. osieorb18

I believe lost monkey, Lime Cock, Fear the Magician, Scotty and honey are all town. Oh, and Alison too.

#1995

Creature wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 2:10 pm Getting back into wolfreading EnderWiggin too.

I’m still hung up on Michelle scumreading Ender on D1. Will look more into it again because Ender’s d2 was garbage

#1996

Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 2:12 pm
Creature wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 2:10 pm Getting back into wolfreading EnderWiggin too.
I’m still hung up on Michelle scumreading Ender on D1. Will look more into it again because Ender’s d2 was garbage

For me something seemed wrong about Ender D1, but then didn't want to lynch someone who hit their posting limit.

#1997

@Creature

Why Listo and Ender?

#1998

Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:52 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:46 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:24 pm I think Mac is 3p
in the setup rules it says there are no 3rd parties so unless u think that's a lie then .. denied
Ah good call. Missed that
He may just be pingpong slapadap town then

The rules also say any talking during night, even if unlocked, isn’t allowed. So I fully expect us all to die tonight lol

oh i didnt see that rule

#1999

Lime Coke wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 2:13 pm @Creature

Why Listo and Ender?

Both have been pretty UTR just playing side characters.

#2000

honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 2:13 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:52 pm
honey wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:46 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Sat Jul 17, 2021 1:24 pm I think Mac is 3p
in the setup rules it says there are no 3rd parties so unless u think that's a lie then .. denied
Ah good call. Missed that
He may just be pingpong slapadap town then

The rules also say any talking during night, even if unlocked, isn’t allowed. So I fully expect us all to die tonight lol
oh i didnt see that rule

**dies and flips as town**

Day 6 Elimination (Hammer Enabled)