Batman: The Animated Series mafia win

[Made]

[Epignosis]

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

Used to have a rule that I don't vote new people on their first visit here.

Used to.

This is not Lime's first visit here. Can you explain your vote?

No.

[Transcend]

Also, Transcend, you're on the discord sometimes right? I don't think we've played together before, right?

i took a self ban on MU for personal reasons, but I overestimated how much time i needed off and i got bored so here i am!

i feel like if i played with you, it was a mash or something, and my effort level in mashes is next to zero. i just meme around until i get ita'd.

[Syn]

if u don't think that epi is a wolf do u think anyone that is or was on the wagon has any wolf equity? ik u tr me and lime but what about ender or syn?

I have Syn in my POE. He has done nothing townie. I am content to give Ender a day pass so long as he is committed to hard sheeping me.

your poe sucks

[Transcend]

u know that's a pretty massive take u have that's def not in consensus with the rest of the thread

if u don't want to elaborate on that vote, it will just make me think that u cannot elaborate on that vote, and that it's just performative.

[Made]

Also, Transcend, you're on the discord sometimes right? I don't think we've played together before, right?

i took a self ban on MU for personal reasons, but I overestimated how much time i needed off and i got bored so here i am!

i feel like if i played with you, it was a mash or something, and my effort level in mashes is next to zero. i just meme around until i get ita'd.

Mash run-ins sounds about right. Go seeing you again!

[Seanzie]

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

Used to have a rule that I don't vote new people on their first visit here.

Used to.

This is not Lime's first visit here. Can you explain your vote?

No.

Thanks for the help.

[Transcend]

Also, Transcend, you're on the discord sometimes right? I don't think we've played together before, right?

i took a self ban on MU for personal reasons, but I overestimated how much time i needed off and i got bored so here i am!

i feel like if i played with you, it was a mash or something, and my effort level in mashes is next to zero. i just meme around until i get ita'd.

Mash run-ins sounds about right. Go seeing you again!

tyty

if i enjoy this game enough i'll probs hang around here until the ban is over, but that's not until march

but so far this community seems pretty nice

[Transcend]

doggo bored

[VOTE: epi] aubergine

l8a sk8a h8as

[Epignosis]

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

Used to have a rule that I don't vote new people on their first visit here.

Used to.

This is not Lime's first visit here. Can you explain your vote?

No.

Thanks for the help.

[Seanzie]

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

Used to have a rule that I don't vote new people on their first visit here.

Used to.

This is not Lime's first visit here. Can you explain your vote?

No.

Thanks for the help.

Do you think @Transcend is mafia and trying to pocket me? why or why not?

[Transcend]

HOT take: made has been kinda towny in his most recent posts

[Epignosis]

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

Used to have a rule that I don't vote new people on their first visit here.

Used to.

This is not Lime's first visit here. Can you explain your vote?

No.

Thanks for the help.

Do you think @Transcend is mafia and trying to pocket me? why or why not?

No, I don't think Transcend is mafia.

Does that mean I get to skip the secondary questions?

[Seanzie]

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

Used to have a rule that I don't vote new people on their first visit here.

Used to.

This is not Lime's first visit here. Can you explain your vote?

No.

Thanks for the help.

Do you think @Transcend is mafia and trying to pocket me? why or why not?

No, I don't think Transcend is mafia.

Does that mean I get to skip the secondary questions?

Do you have any depth of thought?

[Epignosis]

Nope. I'm dumb as shit.

[Alison]

HOT take: made has been kinda towny in his most recent posts

No.

[Transcend]

He could've literally spewed Falcon town too with what he's going for.

Damn, y’all really think I’m so bad as to accidentally spew 4 people town right off the bat? Disrespectful

Okay, so this is hard to call to bad to be wolf because it assumes that I did infact spew Esooa, Seanzie, LC, and Falcon. I don't know if I did that because i'm town. to assume that the 4 are town (which is needed to call, my post TWTBW) feels like a perspective slip.

Also, why would we ever assume that a wolf wouldn't antagonize their teammates in the way i'm doing right now. Seanzie could be a teammate of mine i'm trying to power thread with, Esooa could be friendly scum in thread banter.

The assumptions y'all making here are sus af

this feels rlly generalized

fwiw i don't actually agree with this certain take on u in that ur scum because u spewed 4 ppl town or whatever

there are other reasons that ppl r voting u of which u haven't addressed, but the fact that you're categorizing everyone under one person's assumption looks kinda

ruff.

it's cuz i'm lazy and i haven't caught up in thread. I saw alison's case, and alison tagged me, so i responded to that.

Is there anything you want me to respond to rn? i'mma go shower real quick, then i'm come back in the thread for like 10 mins max to respond to opening statements and cross examination.

gotta wake up early tomorrow.

yea actually a personal red flag of yours was that u rode along with the "lolsleep" momentum only to quickly shade everyone that was on it. if u had that thought then why would u add onto the momentum if u thought there was something shady about it?

it was train of consciousness. i saw that someone was voting sleep, so i joined in because it was funny. after posting that i realized it was good cover for baddies so i went to look back at it. fwiw, doing this is very within my scum range, but also my town range so

idk this post was kinda towny

why do u disagree w/ me?

[Alison]

I don't see how that post is townie at all. It is NAI at best.

[Transcend]

shrug maybe so

but why is epi being such a contrarian

is this typical behavior of him to be like "hurr durr this dude is scum but im not gonna tell u why"?

[Alison]

Yes.

[Transcend]

cause it all looks performative to me and he doesn't seem v interested in engaging ppl either which looks scummy

[falcon45ca]

shrug maybe so

but why is epi being such a contrarian

is this typical behavior of him to be like "hurr durr this dude is scum but im not gonna tell u why"?

How do you see it as AI, when Made himself says that it's both within his scum and town range...the very definition of NAI?

[fingersplints]

[VOTE: fingersplints] aubergine

Meanie voting for me on my birthday

[Transcend]

shrug maybe so

but why is epi being such a contrarian

is this typical behavior of him to be like "hurr durr this dude is scum but im not gonna tell u why"?

How do you see it as AI, when Made himself says that it's both within his scum and town range...the very definition of NAI?

i think his ~response~ to me was towny. the act itself was supposedly nai, but the way he engaged with me when i expressed my concerns was decent.

i ain't sold on the mans being town but he's doing better than he was before.

anyways apparently epi is in character but i don't think he's towntold as much as others and has some rough progression in my opinion. i'll park my vote here for the night, but at this point the thread feels villagery and probably means that there's at least one scum in the ppl that aren't as present in the thread.

[Transcend]

[VOTE: fingersplints] aubergine

Meanie voting for me on my birthday

HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Transcend]

do u have any other thoughts about the thread so far fingersplints?

[fingersplints]

Just woke up so haven’t read it yet. I always just search for my name first in case there is anything about me to respond to.
And thank you

[fingersplints]

Okay a couple pages in so far.

Tbh I never really understand the “sleep” option. We never had it in my day, so perhaps it’s just because I’m used to only being allowed to vote for people so it feels weird to me. It just feels like giving a pass on a day like that is best for the baddies as it just gives them an extra night and we don’t gain any info that day.

[RondoDimBuckle]

It has come to my attention most honourable Majisters that Syn has though no fault of my own decided it best to nominate myself for the honour of swinging from a tree. This is a most unpleasant course of action that I must in the firmest of terms denounce and in return nominate the less than honourable Syn for the same position.

Do not be dissuaded by my course of action though, as if Syn is willing to renounce their stance so shall I.

Doubtless allies to Syns chair will denounce me in return for the very actions I take to protect myself but I also must admit this was a cunning ruse on my part to (In my limited capacity) see who might join in on either my or Syns actions to gather any invaluable intelligence so we might uncover the traitors in our midst.

Let me in this light bring to attention that a certain Majister Made took advantage of this situation to bring attention away from themselves and focus the light on my actions. Since then certain peoples have been noted to cease any pressure on their actions both formerly and since. Though be it far from a humble servant of the people to draw any conclusions that is for you to decide.

Either way the Wind Slayers will be informed of how matters progress and if needs be more overt actions might be taken. Though for now I find myself priorly engaged and shall have to continue to subject myself to the snails pace that is courier mail. I shall continue to read over the missives provided and if any definitive conclusion can be reached, rest assured they will be shared and justice administered most swift. - Rondo Dim Buckle

[fingersplints]

Are we actually allowed to claim flavor?

I believe so, but given how roles were randed, I don't really see it as beneficial or detrimental in any way. Either way, since it is a closed setup, I'll be keeping my cards close for now.

I agree with this. I don’t see the point of mass claiming Day 1, and don’t feel the need to share at this point.

And I also can see this point:

Essoa claims Joker, I'm Scarecrow, Made is Talia al Guhl...

Where are you going with this?

I've already theorized that the Town is Batman's Rogue Gallery and Maf are from the Bat Family....so that's where I'm going with it

The OP explains the rand, how there are fakeclaims, and characters are in no way tied to alignment.

You're doing busywork to look busy.

[Transcend]

It has come to my attention most honourable Majisters that Syn has though no fault of my own decided it best to nominate myself for the honour of swinging from a tree. This is a most unpleasant course of action that I must in the firmest of terms denounce and in return nominate the less than honourable Syn for the same position.

Do not be dissuaded by my course of action though, as if Syn is willing to renounce their stance so shall I.

Doubtless allies to Syns chair will denounce me in return for the very actions I take to protect myself but I also must admit this was a cunning ruse on my part to (In my limited capacity) see who might join in on either my or Syns actions to gather any invaluable intelligence so we might uncover the traitors in our midst.

Let me in this light bring to attention that a certain Majister Made took advantage of this situation to bring attention away from themselves and focus the light on my actions. Since then certain peoples have been noted to cease any pressure on their actions both formerly and since. Though be it far from a humble servant of the people to draw any conclusions that is for you to decide.

Either way the Wind Slayers will be informed of how matters progress and if needs be more overt actions might be taken. Though for now I find myself priorly engaged and shall have to continue to subject myself to the snails pace that is courier mail. I shall continue to read over the missives provided and if any definitive conclusion can be reached, rest assured they will be shared and justice administered most swift. - Rondo Dim Buckle

U should go on a blind date w my friend

I think she's a perfect match for u

Her name is Vig Bullet.

[Esooa]

hi (sorry for scumminess)

[fingersplints]

bradley ur vote is probably valid but doggy thinks that falcon is likely town

(there's my tmi read of the game enjoy)

Who is “Bradley”?
And “doggy” is Transcend?

[fingersplints]

This is fun, the number of people willing to poke a fight with me here makes me think I'm onto something. Probably not everything, but something.

You have 25 posts and this is the beginning of a Mafia game on a very vocal site. Don't please yourself on that basis.

25 out of ~250. Even if you think I am possibly a wolf, I don't see the point of this post, discouraging me from scumhunting?

Either way, since you're being stubborn, I will ISO Made and let you know my thoughts (even though I've already given some) so you can FINALLY talk about Falcon (whom you've been defending - on purpose? Inadvertently? who knows? Nook.)...

Have you played with Epignosis before?

[fingersplints]

if we hammer I'm probably not going to play this game any molre because that would be really stupid

This. Why are people trying to rush the day?
Day 1 at that.

[Esooa]

I'm Batman.

Cool.



[VOTE: Epi] aubergine

Syn suggesting sleep before we have any info over the lack of info we might gather has me somewhat concerned

11 v 4 is rough.

Wtf that's def imba

I think we should sleep. Need more info.

A sound strategy I must say. By sleeping, we have a 0% chance of accidentally misyeeting a villager.

[VOTE: sleep] aubergine

Accidentally misyeet? Do we ever intentionally misyeet a villager?


[VOTE: Transcend] aubergine

@Alison do you think wolf falcon makes sort of antagonistic reads about 3 people almost immediately? My answer is no

[fingersplints]

shrug maybe so

but why is epi being such a contrarian

is this typical behavior of him to be like "hurr durr this dude is scum but im not gonna tell u why"?

Absolutely normal for Epi

[Esooa]

Syn suggesting sleep before we have any info over the lack of info we might gather has me somewhat concerned

You're doing my #1 scum tell over and over. You're down bad. Can you come back from this?

This is really aggressive as town and as scum. No clue which is more likely

kind of a weird post tbh

[Esooa]

If we want to be spicy, i think one of the “lol sleep”ers is scum. Gth it’s Sean

I don't really think this post is scummy at all

[Esooa]

Spoiler: show

My number 1, maybe level 1, thing that I manage to find mafia members out is how certain players will question things that are have nothing to do with the game, or will take posts that are more likely jokes, seriously and possibly push players for it.

I'm Batman.

Cool.



[VOTE: Epi] aubergine

I think we should sleep. Need more info.

Hmmmmmm

Syn suggesting sleep before we have any info over the lack of info we might gather has me somewhat concerned

11 v 4 is rough.

Wtf that's def imba

I think we should sleep. Need more info.

A sound strategy I must say. By sleeping, we have a 0% chance of accidentally misyeeting a villager.

[VOTE: sleep] aubergine

Accidentally misyeet? Do we ever intentionally misyeet a villager?


[VOTE: Transcend] aubergine

FUCK EPICMAFIA PLAYERS! I'LL SEE YOU IN 30 DAYS!

► Show Spoiler

Hi Esooa!

who are you

Blue Kang

very important announcement

Spoiler: show

BLUEKANG IS 100% CONFIRMED TOWN IF ANYONE EVEN VOTES HIM ONE TIME I WILL PULL OUT AN EVEN WORSE FONT TEXT YOU'LL WISH YOU NEVER SAW

TLDR, got Cliff's notes?

These are 5 posts that are Falcon taking a post that's a joke and questioning it or is wondering if the individual is scummy for that specific post.

Skimming, but what I’m basically get is we hammer sleep here right?
[VOTE: sleep] aubergine

good luck have fun nerds <3333

It's the kind of cold, calculating strategy I'd expect from HARDAC, but you're a living breathing human...aren't you?

This is the 1 post that might be a joke but could be serious/snarky? No idea.


But yeah. That's my main reasoning to scumread Falcon at the start of the game.

I was vague about the reasoning at first to see what Falcon would do. He actually continued to do it with Esooa and Made's posts, so I wasn't entirely sure if he knew and continued to do it to throw me off, or if he was mafia and was oblivious which lead to him continuing on. Judging by the way he responded to me saying my read was serious, he was oblivious.

I'm not sure if it's in Lime's wheelhouse to case someone this early into the game, tbh. I think it's town at least

[Esooa]

If we want to be spicy, i think one of the “lol sleep”ers is scum. Gth it’s Sean

That's my thoughts as well

If y'all can't tell that Esooa is scum, idk what to tell you.

I dislike this post. It's not pushing me--I'm not there. It's not trying to argue his position. Seems to be really superfluous such that I don't know why a towny would make it. Though I suppose they could

At this point though I'd expect Sean to have at least mention the post he gutread as scummy. I'm not sure why you wouldn't

[Esooa]

Spoiler: show

My number 1, maybe level 1, thing that I manage to find mafia members out is how certain players will question things that are have nothing to do with the game, or will take posts that are more likely jokes, seriously and possibly push players for it.

I'm Batman.

Cool.



[VOTE: Epi] aubergine

I think we should sleep. Need more info.

Hmmmmmm

Syn suggesting sleep before we have any info over the lack of info we might gather has me somewhat concerned

11 v 4 is rough.

Wtf that's def imba

I think we should sleep. Need more info.

A sound strategy I must say. By sleeping, we have a 0% chance of accidentally misyeeting a villager.

[VOTE: sleep] aubergine

Accidentally misyeet? Do we ever intentionally misyeet a villager?


[VOTE: Transcend] aubergine

FUCK EPICMAFIA PLAYERS! I'LL SEE YOU IN 30 DAYS!

► Show Spoiler

Hi Esooa!

who are you

Blue Kang

very important announcement

Spoiler: show

BLUEKANG IS 100% CONFIRMED TOWN IF ANYONE EVEN VOTES HIM ONE TIME I WILL PULL OUT AN EVEN WORSE FONT TEXT YOU'LL WISH YOU NEVER SAW

TLDR, got Cliff's notes?

These are 5 posts that are Falcon taking a post that's a joke and questioning it or is wondering if the individual is scummy for that specific post.

Skimming, but what I’m basically get is we hammer sleep here right?
[VOTE: sleep] aubergine

good luck have fun nerds <3333

It's the kind of cold, calculating strategy I'd expect from HARDAC, but you're a living breathing human...aren't you?

This is the 1 post that might be a joke but could be serious/snarky? No idea.


But yeah. That's my main reasoning to scumread Falcon at the start of the game.

I was vague about the reasoning at first to see what Falcon would do. He actually continued to do it with Esooa and Made's posts, so I wasn't entirely sure if he knew and continued to do it to throw me off, or if he was mafia and was oblivious which lead to him continuing on. Judging by the way he responded to me saying my read was serious, he was oblivious.

Sure, I can get behind this. Falcon can go in the bad pile.

Doesn't Seanzie know Falcon? Why does someone who knows Falcon consider this scummy? I don't

[Esooa]

LC prolly town.


Sean & Epi prolly wolves

this is a pretty towny post

[Esooa]

Consider that Sean isn't voting for me, which I'd think he'd do proper quick as town if he really thought I was scum

I'm pretty fuckin confident this guys town

[Esooa]

Essoa claims Joker, I'm Scarecrow, Made is Talia al Guhl...

Where are you going with this?

I've already theorized that the Town is Batman's Rogue Gallery and Maf are from the Bat Family....so that's where I'm going with it

The OP explains the rand, how there are fakeclaims, and characters are in no way tied to alignment.

You're doing busywork to look busy.

this post is so ridiculous

[Esooa]

Essoa claims Joker, I'm Scarecrow, Made is Talia al Guhl...

Where are you going with this?

I've already theorized that the Town is Batman's Rogue Gallery and Maf are from the Bat Family....so that's where I'm going with it

The OP explains the rand, how there are fakeclaims, and characters are in no way tied to alignment.

You're doing busywork to look busy.

I’m gonna pretend you’re town and Esooa is trying to pocket me instead of the other way around.

I don't really understand this post at all. It doesn't ping me though

[Esooa]

Essoa claims Joker, I'm Scarecrow, Made is Talia al Guhl...

Where are you going with this?

I've already theorized that the Town is Batman's Rogue Gallery and Maf are from the Bat Family....so that's where I'm going with it

The OP explains the rand, how there are fakeclaims, and characters are in no way tied to alignment.

You're doing busywork to look busy.

I’m gonna pretend you’re town and Esooa is trying to pocket me instead of the other way around.

Why?

Gut read of the situation. I’m mindmelding with Sean rn. Could be pocketing, but tinfoil is baddddd

this one is kinda bad tbf

[Esooa]

Let’s do this [VOTE: Falcon] aubergine

Strange that you're voting me instead of the one you claim is trying to pocket you, no?

Nah. It’s a framework. In it ur the obvious scum, esooa is sus for distracting me from you and Sean and ride or die homie. Could be entirely wrong, but that’s the frame work rn. If ur town, essoa look better and Sean looks worst

I have no clue what this is supposed to mean, lol. I think I know what he's getting at, but.. what?

[Esooa]

Pls sheep doggy

Doggy very good :3

this is probably town

[Esooa]

Seanzie isn't this dense. I've read that over and over, and there's a measure of avoidance there. [VOTE: Sneazie] aubergine

I don't really know about how Seanzie normally is, tbh, but I think this is a pretty valid conclusion. I think this is a towny post though