Bonk Mafia (TOWN WINS)

[Master Radishes]

So, question to the crowd:

Want to hear from dyson and lomo.
Dyson, what’s the best vaccuum to buy?
Lomo, are you going to slank til you get vigged or are we going to have to lynch you early?

Does Scotty throw a jokey Q at his partner like he does with Dyson here? Or is a wolf more likely to tag on a 'serious' question to a partner, ala the Q towards Lomo?

[Alison]

I'm serious.

[NotAnAxehole]

Iirc my PoE after flip was

Alison
Dyson
Misery
Nanook (only if also with Dyson)

I might be forgetting someone, but I think all of the mafia are in the above list. Maybe Alison / misery are the optimal kills today then, not Dyson.

I think only one person on this list is likely to be mafia and it's the person with the caveat, so

I agree, Nanook probably deliberately left his partner to die despite being active at end of day when he was perfectly justified voting Dyson without directly incriminating anyone. I will vote with you sometime late in the day.

[Alison]

Iirc my PoE after flip was

Alison
Dyson
Misery
Nanook (only if also with Dyson)

I might be forgetting someone, but I think all of the mafia are in the above list. Maybe Alison / misery are the optimal kills today then, not Dyson.

I think only one person on this list is likely to be mafia and it's the person with the caveat, so

I agree, Nanook probably deliberately left his partner to die despite being active at end of day when he was perfectly justified voting Dyson without directly incriminating anyone. I will vote with you sometime late in the day.

Good to know.

[Master Radishes]

Scotty also spends the rest of the phase shading Dyson for kind of 'straightforward' reasons. Could be TMI on a partner, but my instinct is to read it as pushing someone he senses is a potential misexe. Could be wrong on that, but that's how I read it atm.

[Alison]

So, question to the crowd:

Want to hear from dyson and lomo.
Dyson, what’s the best vaccuum to buy?
Lomo, are you going to slank til you get vigged or are we going to have to lynch you early?

Does Scotty throw a jokey Q at his partner like he does with Dyson here? Or is a wolf more likely to tag on a 'serious' question to a partner, ala the Q towards Lomo?

Oh hey, I know the answer to this.

[NotAnAxehole]

So, question to the crowd:

Want to hear from dyson and lomo.
Dyson, what’s the best vaccuum to buy?
Lomo, are you going to slank til you get vigged or are we going to have to lynch you early?

Does Scotty throw a jokey Q at his partner like he does with Dyson here? Or is a wolf more likely to tag on a 'serious' question to a partner, ala the Q towards Lomo?

It's common for some less confident mafia players to throw out a meaningless comment with several names, probably only one of Dyson or Alison is mafia like I was saying.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Voting for JaggedJimmyJay, who had 4 votes not terribly long prior to the deadline, is one means of "saving Scotty", particularly when it at the end it leaves a tie. Scotty wasn't eliminated without the help of chance.

I might even believe that Nanook is the sort of player who'd make a call between the deadline 4-player wagons as mafia instead of sitting on me, but I cannot claim confidence in such a specific meta read. Mafia-aligned players vote like that all the time. This kind of stuff is why I don't care about voting behavior half as much as most people seem to.

If Nanook is town that'll need to be made apparent by Day 2 play.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I'm serious.

I don't think I've ever given a shit about looking bad in that way

Like

I either bus scotty for the cred or I save him, I dont leave it to rand, that's the worst of both worlds

I could've easily justified either choice

[NotAnAxehole]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME so I hear you like game throwing?

[Master Radishes]

So, question to the crowd:

Want to hear from dyson and lomo.
Dyson, what’s the best vaccuum to buy?
Lomo, are you going to slank til you get vigged or are we going to have to lynch you early?

Does Scotty throw a jokey Q at his partner like he does with Dyson here? Or is a wolf more likely to tag on a 'serious' question to a partner, ala the Q towards Lomo?

It's common for some less confident mafia players to throw out a meaningless comment with several names, probably only one of Dyson or Alison is mafia like I was saying.

I agree. But what I'm getting at is that there are two very different type of questions here. Is the wolf more likely to throw a meaningless jokey one at their partner, or a more serious albeit light-touch question instead?

I'd say I rarely see wolves doing the former (e.g. how Scotty questions Dyson) and more commonly the latter (e.g. how Scotty questions Lomo).

Obviously it's not a guarantee either is scum (and I know Alison will disagree, obviously) but my point is more so that I don't think Scotty and Dyson are likely partners, even if based primarily on this single post.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME so I hear you like game throwing?

I think you mean

gamethrowing

[NotAnAxehole]

Anyways,

[VOTE: Alison] aubergine

See y'all tomorrow

[tutuu]

Voting for JaggedJimmyJay, who had 4 votes not terribly long prior to the deadline, is one means of "saving Scotty", particularly when it at the end it leaves a tie. Scotty wasn't eliminated without the help of chance.

I might even believe that Nanook is the sort of player who'd make a call between the deadline 4-player wagons as mafia instead of sitting on me, but I cannot claim confidence in such a specific meta read. Mafia-aligned players vote like that all the time. This kind of stuff is why I don't care about voting behavior half as much as most people seem to.

If Nanook is town that'll need to be made apparent by Day 2 play.

i think deep down inside u kno nanook is town but u wanna scold him for voting u so thats ur punishment

as jesus said turn the other cheek. forgive him fam, he did an oopsie, we all teammates doe ;-;

oh hey im doing ur thing. the ... communication thingie. hell yeah. imma be ur mediator. imma make u both kiss up and hug it out. hug it out bitches, hug it out yeah

[Alison]

I'm serious.

I don't think I've ever given a shit about looking bad in that way

Like

I either bus scotty for the cred or I save him, I dont leave it to rand, that's the worst of both worlds

I could've easily justified either choice

This is exactly what you did in Modern Family.

[NotAnAxehole]

Kill order:

Alison
Misery
Nanook

K bye for real now, I'll make an activity post in 24hrs if no hammer.

[Alison]

For those not familiar with the meta: in Modern Family, T&T (scum) was tied with BT (town) in 4-4. Nanook (scum) voted Mana, a smaller wagon also on town, pushing it to 3 votes instead of making a hard call whether to bus T&T or save them. It is quite literally an exact replica of the situation here.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

i think deep down inside u kno nanook is town but u wanna scold him for voting u so thats ur punishment

as jesus said turn the other cheek. forgive him fam, he did an oopsie, we all teammates doe ;-;

oh hey im doing ur thing. the ... communication thingie. hell yeah. imma be ur mediator. imma make u both kiss up and hug it out. hug it out bitches, hug it out yeah

Gun to my head, yes I would call Nanook town.

I'm just not handing the keys over to someone for doing something that mafia constantly do. "Gamethrowing"

[tutuu]

For those not familiar with the meta: in Modern Family, T&T (scum) was tied with BT (town) in 4-4. Nanook (scum) voted Mana, a smaller wagon also on town, pushing it to 3 votes instead of making a hard call whether to bus T&T or save them. It is quite literally an exact replica of the situation here.

hmmm iight bet dass interesting to know. mizery did the exact same here and mizery is an experienced player (idk who they are but they imply so). HMMMMMMMMMMM

@Mizery HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

why u voted for falcon putting him at 3 votes at the last possible second when u knew it wouldnt do anything?

[Alison]

I actually think Mizery's version of it is townie because of the unnecessary vote switch. Super weird thing to fake as a scum who just wants to hide on a vanity wagon. Don't think most wolves think to do it, they just park and watch the rand happen.

[Alison]

Who was Mizery voting before the switch?

[Alison]

Rondo, ok. No worries then. I was slightly concerned that maybe Mizery was parked on a partner that they thought wouldn't go over as a vanity wagon that also offers some distancing cred, but then got worried they would become a real wagon so moved to Falcon to ensure it wouldn't happen.

I think Rondo is town though so this theory isn't a worry for me any more.

[tutuu]

tutuu
radish
jay
rondo

dyson
mizery

axehole
nook
motel
mac
TSP

alison
falcon

also a pocket scum world of some weird shit like dyson + mizery (mizery sees both partners tied at max votes, says fuck this shit)

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Interactions of Scotty and motel room

From Scotty

Spoiler: show

I haven't played with most people here fyi, only Mac, dunya and dyson, maybe scotty in a game like 4 years ago. So I wont be doing much of the meta-read thing.

I don’t even remember playing with you. Do you recall which game? Grandpa doesn’t hVe the memory he used to

I haven't played with most people here fyi, only Mac, dunya and dyson, maybe scotty in a game like 4 years ago. So I wont be doing much of the meta-read thing.

I don’t even remember playing with you. Do you recall which game? Grandpa doesn’t hVe the memory he used to

Monkey Island and Mad Max at least, which was ages ago

omg monkey island!! If I recall I was bad and you were good? When was the last time you were bad?

Scotty seems towny to me at this early stage. Tutuu seemed good too but that jester comment is actually saying nothing now that you point it out.

It was an expression...

"This person to me feels over the top, im not sure how to proceed reading him"

Scotty - "There are no jesters and u know it"

*Me puts arms in air* u got me guys

It just seemed in my reread an attempt to evoke a certain response. Regardless, you pointed out that you didn’t know if you should read him as towny or wolfy, which was a nothing stance like motel said.

Granted, I also don’t know rondo nor do I know how they usually operate D1, but I agree that he’s acting like a jester, or else a broken clown (thanks mac)

I could vote motel room I guess

Tutuu, I know you only have 9 posts left but you wanna wonder twins activate and vote in a bloc today?


I also like how someone (TSP?) said no more mech talk and it just did. Like, why are we not doing any more mech talk? I might be coming around to the whole mass claiming thing

Scotty did well to inject zero enthusiasm into any of his posts -- it's made them more difficult to interpret.

None of these posts means anything to me except the last one. Scotty needed someone to vote for and found momentary comfort with motel room as an option. This is predictable enough given that motel room is a lower-activity player and the classical form of low-hung fruit. That doesn't necessarily make motel room town. I think I lean that direction at this instant.

~~~

From motel room

Spoiler: show

wtf is this theme

My first guess was Bonk's Adventure

but I reckon not.

Scotty seems towny to me at this early stage. Tutuu seemed good too but that jester comment is actually saying nothing now that you point it out.

Motel's slim ISO is not towny IMO



Nice to know that he TR's Scotty tho...

[VOTE: Motel] aubergine

This is the dodgiest out of the votes for me.

Dunya's usually good at reading tone and genuine-ness so I assume she'll get off me, but lets see.

Neither dunya or myself are voting for you. Why are you preoccupied with votes on you, instead of hunting scum?

I am hunting scum ding dong, I only know me at the moment and they way people might opportunistically vote for me.

Isn't dunya still voting for me? I better drop a [VOTE: NO VOTE] aubergine

Do you have reads outside of people who've voted for you?

Yep, my good list atm is
Mizery, scotty, tutuu - maybe\probably Mac - I have tonystarkprime as good for a reason I cant recall

I honestly cant go either way on dunya and lime coke love in.

Potential bads are you rondo dyson and notanaxehole

The theme here is that motel room town read Scotty. Okay sure. I have no idea why, so motel will have to expand on that himself. Otherwise I cannot assess the sincerity of the read and will shrug.

~~~

Conclusion

This is another annoying interaction where I simply have nothing worthy of clearance. We're meant to make judgment calls in this game, and mine would be that motel room is probably town. I cannot claim any confidence in that though and need him to expand before I proceed.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I'm serious.

I don't think I've ever given a shit about looking bad in that way

Like

I either bus scotty for the cred or I save him, I dont leave it to rand, that's the worst of both worlds

I could've easily justified either choice

This is exactly what you did in Modern Family.

I dont think I was even around for eods in modern family was I

[Alison]

If you see both partners tied at max votes, you don't sit on a vanity wagon. You hammer one to get bus cred, and then townread the other for being the counterwagon to flipped scum. Not concerned about Dyson + Mizery at all.

You should probably be rating motel lower than you currently are. Scotty awkwardly attacked Dyson for pointing out that motel's discord stuff is NAI. The slot that first accused motel of being scum with an angleshooty read got killed in the night. Scotty said "I could vote motel I guess" once and then never actually did it. motel is also a candidate for being one of the people too afk to save Scotty. They are my top scum read.

[Alison]

I'm serious.

I don't think I've ever given a shit about looking bad in that way

Like

I either bus scotty for the cred or I save him, I dont leave it to rand, that's the worst of both worlds

I could've easily justified either choice

This is exactly what you did in Modern Family.

I dont think I was even around for eods in modern family was I

Your last post was 6 minutes before EOD and I know it was you because of posting style + the other half of your hydra being afk.

[Alison]

@JaggedJimmyJay You mention that you interpret Scotty as finding comfort in motel as a LHF push - but the fact that he didn't actually vote motel suggests that the push wasn't that comfortable for him after all. Why can't he be partners making a meaningless distancing lip service post that he never intends to follow through on?

[tutuu]

If you see both partners tied at max votes, you don't sit on a vanity wagon. You hammer one to get bus cred, and then townread the other for being the counterwagon to flipped scum. Not concerned about Dyson + Mizery at all.

You should probably be rating motel lower than you currently are. Scotty awkwardly attacked Dyson for pointing out that motel's discord stuff is NAI. The slot that first accused motel of being scum with an angleshooty read got killed in the night. Scotty said "I could vote motel I guess" once and then never actually did it. motel is also a candidate for being one of the people too afk to save Scotty. They are my top scum read.

bet iight sis imma put them lower, i like this post. i highkey think ur scum but if we kill u and u town u can trust that i'll do my best to kill motel

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@JaggedJimmyJay You mention that you interpret Scotty as finding comfort in motel as a LHF push - but the fact that he didn't actually vote motel suggests that the push wasn't that comfortable for him after all. Why can't he be partners making a meaningless distancing lip service post that he never intends to follow through on?

He "can" be that. We're not tasked with resolving "can" though. We must solve "is". "Can" is meaningless in my opinion.

If I ask myself "would Scotty have been glad to join a motel room wagon had one sprung to life without him needing to start it himself?" my first instinct is that the answer is "yes".

I don't clear motel room entirely on this basis, but that's my take.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Interactions of Scotty and lost monkey (Alison)

From Scotty

Spoiler: show

Want to hear from dyson and lomo.
Dyson, what’s the best vaccuum to buy?
Lomo, are you going to slank til you get vigged or are we going to have to lynch you early?

'Hm, I should push a bit to look like I'm doing something/see if I can pressure a potential mischop a bit.'

Want to hear from dyson and lomo.

'Better make sure everyone knows I'm not *too* serious about this though.'

Dyson, what’s the best vaccuum to buy?

'Oh, but I shouldn't be *only* jokey or else people might use that against me too.'

Lomo, are you going to slank til you get vigged or are we going to have to lynch you early?

Are you implying that dyson and lomo are potential mischops?

Like, we’re not chopping like lomo today even if he doesn’t post any more, but I always prefer content over no content. Don’t you?

See, in a previous life I would be voting for lomo right now, as I was wont to do for >80% if my mafia career, voting no/low posters on D1, but last game, someone convinced me that those slots would be resolved eventually and wouldn’t give enough info if they were lynched D1 and happened to be town.

But I don’t like the excuse that you can just skate by on D1. It’s lame

If you like this @Scotty

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

tutuu deliberately overposting knowing we won't chop her if she's unable to defend herself?

Im not under threat of getting chopped this day based off ppls current reads and even if that was my scum plan and i did it, u could then interrogate and chop me the next day

we have a full 26 hours and change till vote lock and if you run out of posts you cant change your vote so at that point its easy to claim tomorrow on no I couldnt change my vote off someone that was cleared in the last 6 hours because I ran out of votes, oh well scummy to be at 60-70+ half way through the day

[VOTE: lime coke ] aubergine

This is the most reasonable thing you’ve said all game

+1

Youll love this

Spoiler: show

nook isn't hard townreading me yet so something is wrong with me

Okay i think this post specifically is towny

Its a very creative post lt to come up with as mafia unless uve seen it before / done it before as town

You can waste at post on this

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

tutuu deliberately overposting knowing we won't chop her if she's unable to defend herself?

Im not under threat of getting chopped this day based off ppls current reads and even if that was my scum plan and i did it, u could then interrogate and chop me the next day

we have a full 26 hours and change till vote lock and if you run out of posts you cant change your vote so at that point its easy to claim tomorrow on no I couldnt change my vote off someone that was cleared in the last 6 hours because I ran out of votes, oh well scummy to be at 60-70+ half way through the day

[VOTE: lime coke ] aubergine

But not reply to this

:think:
[VOTE: f4lcon ] aubergine

[VOTE: lost monkey ] aubergine

y r u playing voting roulette
Do you actually find tutuu sus for this or are you just spitballing

Exactly what I said

My interpretation, and I'd imagine dunya's given her commentary, is that it was sarcasm (and I found that sarcasm suspicious). So you're saying then that you were then and remain now on board with voting out low posters. Correct? Just for the sake of total clarity.

Yep, I agreed with tutuu with my Poe at the time being lomo/dyson/falcon.

As of now-
I’d still be down with dyson, because that slot is either super newby wolf or just an awkward town. If I had my fritters, they’d be the lynch today but that looks unlikely.
Falcon is not even most sus to me right now, hence me switching to dunya, but I can still see it.

Green: I was once correctly suspected as mafia in a game long ago for treating one lurker (town) with marshmallows and kindness and a different lurker (my mafia teammate) like an absolute doofus (hi MR, this was the S2 finale). That's a highly specific example and may not apply to Scotty, but the distinction here is nonetheless stark.

Orange: People who care about "rule of three" -- there ya go.

From lost monkey (Alison)

Nothing.

~~~

Conclusion

Yes, Alison can be mafia. Maybe someday I'll clear someone. Credit to Scotty for making this exercise so dull.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Interactions of Scotty and Dyson sphere

From Scotty

Spoiler: show

Aight so Lime Coke and Rondo are mafia. The third is probably Dyson Sphere.

I could see dyson since I forgot he was a person even playing this game, but why Lime? He’s not pinging me this game yet. Seems jiggy wit it

Want to hear from dyson and lomo.
Dyson, what’s the best vaccuum to buy?
Lomo, are you going to slank til you get vigged or are we going to have to lynch you early?

'Hm, I should push a bit to look like I'm doing something/see if I can pressure a potential mischop a bit.'

Want to hear from dyson and lomo.

'Better make sure everyone knows I'm not *too* serious about this though.'

Dyson, what’s the best vaccuum to buy?

'Oh, but I shouldn't be *only* jokey or else people might use that against me too.'

Lomo, are you going to slank til you get vigged or are we going to have to lynch you early?

Are you implying that dyson and lomo are potential mischops?

Like, we’re not chopping like lomo today even if he doesn’t post any more, but I always prefer content over no content. Don’t you?

Who took the bonk?

What's a bonk?


Are you maf?

No idea. Something to do with Discord?

Nope, town. What about you?

when the vote board isnt in alphabetical order smh

motel room said something really shady about how he doesn't know what bonking is and that maybe it's a discord thing?????????? how would someone come to that conclusion all on their own? to bonk is to hit or strike soemthing, so where did discord come into play for this bold assumption?

bonking is indeed a discord thing, @Justplayingitcool (who isn't in this game) is our resident discord bonker.

motel room has teammates who told him what's up and tmid it all over the thread.

Alright, the way I read that, motel room just didn't know that "bonk! Go to horny jail!" was a meme, and then guessed that it might be a meme that is popular on discord. I wouldn't read maf for feigning ignorance on that. It's easy to forget that not everyone knows memes.
I knew bonk was a meme, because I've seen it outside of discord. But I'm not surprised it's popular on discord too.

Sorry, it took me a while to catch up on the entire thread and this was the only thing of substance I could contribute right now. I'll see if I can post some more.

well this post is scummy. Too explanatory

it's true, dyson is a true euro unlike MR who is a north american living in europe...i mean asia. shit. this is getting confusing.

@Dyson sphere who are your suspects atm?

I also would like dyson to contribute more thoughts

So, I guess if I go by post count, my scum reads are @NotAnAxehole @lost monkey and @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

Dyson, just curious- how many games of mafia have you played?

Dyson, just curious- how many games of mafia have you played?

I don't remember the exact number.

That is the vaguest answer you could have said omg

What do you find suspicious about the low post count?

I literally don’t know what to make of dyson. He is…actually a vaccuum.

My favorite is falcon needling him, then immediately voting for Mizery. Very easy to touch and back off for cred if dyson is bad

I stand by my falcon vote

Exactly what I said

My interpretation, and I'd imagine dunya's given her commentary, is that it was sarcasm (and I found that sarcasm suspicious). So you're saying then that you were then and remain now on board with voting out low posters. Correct? Just for the sake of total clarity.

Yep, I agreed with tutuu with my Poe at the time being lomo/dyson/falcon.

As of now-
I’d still be down with dyson, because that slot is either super newby wolf or just an awkward town. If I had my fritters, they’d be the lynch today but that looks unlikely.
Falcon is not even most sus to me right now, hence me switching to dunya, but I can still see it.

[VOTE: dyson] aubergine

Buehler

Green: More often than not when mafia say this, it's literal. Scotty probably did forget about Dyson, which would be a good sign. Grain of salt that if you wish.

Orange: If this is worth bringing up for Alison, it's also worth bringing up for Dyson. My instincts tell me this is better for Dyson between the two of them. Temper that since it's one little thing.

You'll note a general trend in these posts: Scotty is directly attentive to Dyson throughout the day, and often in a negative capacity (either with direct accusations or neutral reminders that he's lurking). There's a clear progression from start to end culminating in a vote that doubles as "save myself" and "vote out this scummy low-poster". I think that all speaks to Dyson's credit.

From Dyson sphere

Spoiler: show

Lol, Scotty is funniest poster. True so far, before I arrived

There's one new post on this side of the interaction, and it's just a statement of truth. Scotty has one of our coveted Funniest Poster Socky Awards to his name for a reason.

~~~

Conclusion

This is the closest I have come so far to feeling like someone actually isn't Scotty's teammate beyond the vaguest kind of educated guess. I have at least some confidence in saying so.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I'm serious.

I don't think I've ever given a shit about looking bad in that way

Like

I either bus scotty for the cred or I save him, I dont leave it to rand, that's the worst of both worlds

I could've easily justified either choice

This is exactly what you did in Modern Family.

I dont think I was even around for eods in modern family was I

Your last post was 6 minutes before EOD and I know it was you because of posting style + the other half of your hydra being afk.

Was i TRing both slots?

And yeah 90% or more of our posts that game were from me. Jules had rl stuff come up

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Interactions of Scotty and Mizery

From Scotty

Spoiler: show

lol tutuu out here throwing around townreads on everyone like a Mardi Gras bead queen on Fat Tuesday.

Between that mizery/tutuu interaction tho, I think mizery looks super town. I appreciate the humble attitude about not wanting to be read town for asking mech questions.

I don’t know how tutuu usually plays, but if they’re wolf, they’re trying to D1 power wolf, and power wolves make my head hurt

Does scotty's entrance look like it could be a pocket attempt on me or am I making that up

I entered before you, goober

Also you’re probs the closest townread I have, and I don’t give town reads early often because I suck at tone reads and D1s are the bane of my existence

So yea, sure, jump in my cargo shorts

I literally don’t know what to make of dyson. He is…actually a vaccuum.

My favorite is falcon needling him, then immediately voting for Mizery. Very easy to touch and back off for cred if dyson is bad

I stand by my falcon vote

On the flip, the only player that has even come close to pocketing me is tutuu, and I don’t even think that qualifies because I picked her First
Tutuu’s posts have had a pretty logical through line, and I’ve agreed with her today. So either we’re both wrong, right or I’m just a patsy. I choose life, senator.

I think mizery is still pretty town based on like I said, their interaction with tutuu early on.

Mac was on my radar as a possible mindgame mafia, and I guess he still could be the mafia provider, but ima let that play out. If he isn’t the town provider, that’ll sort itself out sooner than later

TSP Lean town- has some mindmelding with some others lien they’re in some sort of secret organization. I don’t remember what his scum game looks like, but he appears to have a firm grasp of the mech stuff. Probably NAI but I lean town

The clear trend here is a strong town read by Scotty on Mizery. The second post in this series is the one that speaks loudest to me. Mizery noted a possible pocketing attempt, which on its own doesn't necessarily dissociate the two. But Scotty's response to that probably does. He is both trying to combat Mizery's fear with joviality (calling them "goober") and assuage their concerns with an e a r n e s t - e x p l a n a t i o n. Good look for Mizery.

From Mizery

Nothing new.

~~~

Conclusion

I'd like it if I had a little more to talk about. Nonetheless I think Mizery looks pretty town here.

[falcon45ca]

Town:
Tutuu
Mizery
Radish
Scotty
Axehole
Lime
Uhhh music symbol guy

Gut town:
TSP
Dunya
Island. Motel?

Null:
Mac
Nook

Gut scum:
Monkey
Dyson
Falcon

tutuu
radish
jay
rondo

dyson
mizery

axehole
nook
motel
mac
TSP

alison
falcon

also a pocket scum world of some weird shit like dyson + mizery (mizery sees both partners tied at max votes, says fuck this shit)

Why did NAA & motel move from town to null?


TBH, I'm not seeing much in the way of read progression here...your town is still by and large your town, and your scum is still by and large your scum. This is over 12 pages of gameplay.

[Mizery]

why u voted for falcon putting him at 3 votes at the last possible second when u knew it wouldnt do anything?

My other option in staying put was another vanity wagon. I didn't have any strong feelings on either person because all I remember for people casing scotty was "his iso is eh" and I didn't feel like that was...strong? at least coming from someone who...isn't me. lmao. I don't remember who the second person was. people are saying dyson? if it was dyson then I didn't wanna go there because...I don't know. I just didn't feel like it.

tldr no thoughts head empty on the top two wagons i suppose

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Interactions of Scotty and tutuu

Scotty replied to literally every single tutuu post. I'm not doing this entire analysis. Here's one post that speaks to me:

Spoiler: show

If you like this @Scotty

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

tutuu deliberately overposting knowing we won't chop her if she's unable to defend herself?

Im not under threat of getting chopped this day based off ppls current reads and even if that was my scum plan and i did it, u could then interrogate and chop me the next day

we have a full 26 hours and change till vote lock and if you run out of posts you cant change your vote so at that point its easy to claim tomorrow on no I couldnt change my vote off someone that was cleared in the last 6 hours because I ran out of votes, oh well scummy to be at 60-70+ half way through the day

[VOTE: lime coke ] aubergine

This is the most reasonable thing you’ve said all game

+1

Youll love this

Spoiler: show

nook isn't hard townreading me yet so something is wrong with me

Okay i think this post specifically is towny

Its a very creative post lt to come up with as mafia unless uve seen it before / done it before as town

You can waste at post on this

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

tutuu deliberately overposting knowing we won't chop her if she's unable to defend herself?

Im not under threat of getting chopped this day based off ppls current reads and even if that was my scum plan and i did it, u could then interrogate and chop me the next day

we have a full 26 hours and change till vote lock and if you run out of posts you cant change your vote so at that point its easy to claim tomorrow on no I couldnt change my vote off someone that was cleared in the last 6 hours because I ran out of votes, oh well scummy to be at 60-70+ half way through the day

[VOTE: lime coke ] aubergine

But not reply to this

:think:
[VOTE: f4lcon ] aubergine

[VOTE: lost monkey ] aubergine

y r u playing voting roulette
Do you actually find tutuu sus for this or are you just spitballing

TMI. tutuu is probably town.

[tutuu]

Why did NAA & motel move from town to null?

because we chopped a wolf and i reevaluated everyone based off eod1 wagons

TBH, I'm not seeing much in the way of read progression here...your town is still by and large your town, and your scum is still by and large your scum. This is over 12 pages of gameplay.

silence, wolf.

axehole went from town to upper poe
dyson went from lower poe to townread

THIS ISNT EVEN MY FINAL READSLIST LMAOOO WHAT IS U DOINGGGG FAM

i had a big ass post, my last post on day 1 with a big ass readslit that was diff.....

[RondoDimBuckle]

I have a really busy next couple of days, I wont have time to keep up. I am happy to vote Tutuu, Nanook and TSP for my own various reasons

[VOTE: Rondo Dim Buckle ] aubergine

[Mizery]

Omg scotty was the person I said was trying to pocket me lmao

[falcon45ca]

Why did NAA & motel move from town to null?

because we chopped a wolf and i reevaluated everyone based off eod1 wagons

TBH, I'm not seeing much in the way of read progression here...your town is still by and large your town, and your scum is still by and large your scum. This is over 12 pages of gameplay.

silence, wolf.

axehole went from town to upper poe
dyson went from lower poe to townread

THIS ISNT EVEN MY FINAL READSLIST LMAOOO WHAT IS U DOINGGGG FAM

i had a big ass post, my last post on day 1 with a big ass readslit that was diff.....

Just for a moment, with the same veracity that you TR Scotty, imagine that I'm town. How does your list look in that light?


I promise you, I am town. Lock. It. In.

[falcon45ca]

I have a really busy next couple of days, I wont have time to keep up. I am happy to vote Tutuu, Nanook and TSP for my own various reasons

[VOTE: Rondo Dim Buckle ] aubergine

Then vote one of them plz

[tutuu]

[VOTE: Vooooote.....] aubergine



[VOTE: FALCONNNNNNNNNNNNNN] aubergine

[tutuu]

Why did NAA & motel move from town to null?

because we chopped a wolf and i reevaluated everyone based off eod1 wagons

TBH, I'm not seeing much in the way of read progression here...your town is still by and large your town, and your scum is still by and large your scum. This is over 12 pages of gameplay.

silence, wolf.

axehole went from town to upper poe
dyson went from lower poe to townread

THIS ISNT EVEN MY FINAL READSLIST LMAOOO WHAT IS U DOINGGGG FAM

i had a big ass post, my last post on day 1 with a big ass readslit that was diff.....

Just for a moment, with the same veracity that you TR Scotty, imagine that I'm town. How does your list look in that light?


I promise you, I am town. Lock. It. In.

nice fanfic bro didn't read LOL!!!

[falcon45ca]

[VOTE: Vooooote.....] aubergine



[VOTE: FALCONNNNNNNNNNNNNN] aubergine

Lotta theatre here, no?

You already were voting me btw.

[Mizery]

In a world where I was actually paying attention yesterday I might have voted scotty
lmao

[falcon45ca]

Why did NAA & motel move from town to null?

because we chopped a wolf and i reevaluated everyone based off eod1 wagons

TBH, I'm not seeing much in the way of read progression here...your town is still by and large your town, and your scum is still by and large your scum. This is over 12 pages of gameplay.

silence, wolf.

axehole went from town to upper poe
dyson went from lower poe to townread

THIS ISNT EVEN MY FINAL READSLIST LMAOOO WHAT IS U DOINGGGG FAM

i had a big ass post, my last post on day 1 with a big ass readslit that was diff.....

Just for a moment, with the same veracity that you TR Scotty, imagine that I'm town. How does your list look in that light?


I promise you, I am town. Lock. It. In.

nice fanfic bro didn't read LOL!!!

That's fine, you don't have to. I mean, why read posts, right?


Your read on me is as accurate as your read on Scotty. I'm done wasting my time on you.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Interactions of Scotty and RondoDimBuckle

From Scotty

Spoiler: show

It is supposed to be a gif of the whole of Shrek

https://preview.redd.it/4vwc2telggr21.g ... d71e9f339b

Also anyone above 11 posts I am suspicious of since we have 48 hours to post and it seems like its anti town to lock yourself out of responses.

Also since I HAVE to declare who I am voting for I will say I am voting for one of:
dunya
Master Radishes
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
TonyStarkPrime
Lime Coke
lost monkey
RondoDimBuckle
falcon45ca
Scotty
motel room
NotAnAxehole
tutuu
Dyson sphere
Mizery
MacDougall

That is all

wtf is this

1. both givers holstered. we mass claim. mafia kills our town PR tonight. IF we play it right on the next day we get a conf town (the mafia target) + we have a safe sane ability to use/leash. but there is potential for outplay by maf coz i think it relies on us not being dumb

i hope town pr giver gave shot n0 coz i think thats better

2. both givers gave shot. we mass claim. we have 2 confirmed town immediately (assuming no cc), we have a safe leash on sane PR. thats best case scenario, so much good stuff

3. town pr gave shot, scum pr holstered. dass reasonable i think, i dont think they can fuck with us too hard. we still get our peek tomorrow i think

4. town pr holstered, scum pr gave shot. this is uh bad. we get a peek but mafia can kill it tonight. we dont learn shit.

i think that if the town PR gave their shot on N0, they should say so and lead the mass claim, because good stuff will follow. if town PR didnt give their shot on N0 we should stay quiet coz its bad. what yall think of my genius plan?

I agree with this.

I am a contrarian and disagree with this


[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

But actually I dont agree with this, the fact that a wolf can get a town role means your whole theory is hoping a wolf isnt picked. Sure the % chance of picking a town at random is high but not guaranteed. This seems like a way to get a wolf deep lime and tutuu w/w? :think:

lol I agree with what rondo is saying here, but lol this seems a little too kneejerk accusatory

Yea, ima tie it up

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

Will reassess tomorrow but I don’t like rondo’s entrance

Rondo hella reactionary though. Can’t shake this feeling, hackles standing up.

But I suck at D1 so maybe I should just pull a Mac and sheep the consensus town

Yea, ima tie it up

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

Will reassess tomorrow but I don’t like rondo’s entrance

I agree rondos entrance sucked. Lets get him out.

[VOTE: Rondo ] aubergine

Rondo hella reactionary though. Can’t shake this feeling, hackles standing up.

But I suck at D1 so maybe I should just pull a Mac and sheep the consensus town

Nah he's just mafia. You're doing well.

Interesting, I dont quite agree with a blatant declaration without any proof to back it up


[VOTE: TonyStarkPrime] aubergine

Note that if you turn out to be bad, this is your teammate just for this random vote.

Scotty seems towny to me at this early stage. Tutuu seemed good too but that jester comment is actually saying nothing now that you point it out.

It was an expression...

"This person to me feels over the top, im not sure how to proceed reading him"

Scotty - "There are no jesters and u know it"

*Me puts arms in air* u got me guys

It just seemed in my reread an attempt to evoke a certain response. Regardless, you pointed out that you didn’t know if you should read him as towny or wolfy, which was a nothing stance like motel said.

Granted, I also don’t know rondo nor do I know how they usually operate D1, but I agree that he’s acting like a jester, or else a broken clown (thanks mac)

I'm finding Rondo's wacky vote gimmick to be towny. I don't see mafia making themselves this noticeable doing something like that.

I don’t know his meta, but I agree

And between you and dunya as the wonder twins, I view you as more town than she.

[VOTE: falcon] aubergine

I'm finding Rondo's wacky vote gimmick to be towny. I don't see mafia making themselves this noticeable doing something like that.

And yet on the flip side, rondo only started voting on the carousel after being roundhouse kicked for making some weird logical leaps in the beginning, so maybe this is just defensive maneuvering

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

tutuu deliberately overposting knowing we won't chop her if she's unable to defend herself?

Im not under threat of getting chopped this day based off ppls current reads and even if that was my scum plan and i did it, u could then interrogate and chop me the next day

we have a full 26 hours and change till vote lock and if you run out of posts you cant change your vote so at that point its easy to claim tomorrow on no I couldnt change my vote off someone that was cleared in the last 6 hours because I ran out of votes, oh well scummy to be at 60-70+ half way through the day

[VOTE: lime coke ] aubergine

This is the most reasonable thing you’ve said all game

+1

If you like this @Scotty

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

tutuu deliberately overposting knowing we won't chop her if she's unable to defend herself?

Im not under threat of getting chopped this day based off ppls current reads and even if that was my scum plan and i did it, u could then interrogate and chop me the next day

we have a full 26 hours and change till vote lock and if you run out of posts you cant change your vote so at that point its easy to claim tomorrow on no I couldnt change my vote off someone that was cleared in the last 6 hours because I ran out of votes, oh well scummy to be at 60-70+ half way through the day

[VOTE: lime coke ] aubergine

This is the most reasonable thing you’ve said all game

+1

Youll love this

Spoiler: show

nook isn't hard townreading me yet so something is wrong with me

Okay i think this post specifically is towny

Its a very creative post lt to come up with as mafia unless uve seen it before / done it before as town

You can waste at post on this

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

tutuu deliberately overposting knowing we won't chop her if she's unable to defend herself?

Im not under threat of getting chopped this day based off ppls current reads and even if that was my scum plan and i did it, u could then interrogate and chop me the next day

we have a full 26 hours and change till vote lock and if you run out of posts you cant change your vote so at that point its easy to claim tomorrow on no I couldnt change my vote off someone that was cleared in the last 6 hours because I ran out of votes, oh well scummy to be at 60-70+ half way through the day

[VOTE: lime coke ] aubergine

But not reply to this

:think:
[VOTE: f4lcon ] aubergine

[VOTE: lost monkey ] aubergine

y r u playing voting roulette
Do you actually find tutuu sus for this or are you just spitballing

If we follow the thread here, I think it's pretty telling. Scotty started harshly anti-Rondo, and shat in his Corn Flakes over various minutiae. Rondo was a very easy player to go after because of his voting behavior (to his credit, there's value in that), and Scotty took the bait. Then eventually when it became apparent that a Rondo chop was not likely to materialize, he conceded the "I agree" town read initiated by my predecessor Lime Coke.

Good looks for Rondo.

From RondoDimBuckle

Spoiler: show

Rondo hella reactionary though. Can’t shake this feeling, hackles standing up.

But I suck at D1 so maybe I should just pull a Mac and sheep the consensus town

Nah he's just mafia. You're doing well.

Interesting, I dont quite agree with a blatant declaration without any proof to back it up


[VOTE: TonyStarkPrime] aubergine

Note that if you turn out to be bad, this is your teammate just for this random vote.

it was a random vote and you trying to tie him up as my team mate might just be an excuse for you to sus him later? TMI?


Is there Scotty + MacDougall equity?


[VOTE: motel] aubergine

LC
MR
axehole
rondo
TSP
scotty
mac
probably nook

my town reads as of 6.40pm on august 11

I'm finding Rondo's wacky vote gimmick to be towny. I don't see mafia making themselves this noticeable doing something like that.

I don’t know his meta, but I agree

And between you and dunya as the wonder twins, I view you as more town than she.

[VOTE: falcon] aubergine

No, stop, please, I want to be suspicious. Good night Dunya, you are rip before dawn

[VOTE: Scotty ] aubergine

y r u playing voting roulette
Do you actually find tutuu sus for this or are you just spitballing

all content is good content for tomorrow

Spoiler: show

LC
MR
axehole
rondo
TSP
scotty
mac
probably nook

my town reads as of 6.40pm on august 11

What I get for taking forever to post.

Dunya
LC
MR
Tutuu
Mac
Axe
TSP
Scotty
Rondo
Nanook (?)

So 10 people (With 1 question mark) on that list.

lol
Let’s just lynch low posters then eh?

► Show Spoiler

Town:
Tutuu
Mizery
Radish
Scotty
Axehole
Lime
Uhhh music symbol guy

Gut town:
TSP
Dunya
Island. Motel?

Null:
Mac
Nook

Gut scum:
Monkey
Dyson
Falcon

lol you and I are seemingly aligned with those bottom 3 scumreads

I'm finding Rondo's wacky vote gimmick to be towny. I don't see mafia making themselves this noticeable doing something like that.

I don’t know his meta, but I agree

And between you and dunya as the wonder twins, I view you as more town than she.

[VOTE: falcon] aubergine

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

tutuu deliberately overposting knowing we won't chop her if she's unable to defend herself?

As mac pointed out: if she is mafia, I just don’t wanna have to deal with it.

[VOTE: Scotty] aubergine

@dunya not that I am defending Scotty, what happens in the world he flips green?

If the jjj slot is scum then im going to eat my hat

Because i dont want to live in a world where someone subs out of a game as a part of an elaborate AtE

I dunno I am going to wait for Dunya to weigh in on things and Nanook, he did come out swinging but that could be to save his bacon. Compelling points though.

[VOTE: Dunya is on scotty so thats where I am actually sitting, just to be clear I am voting for scotty, all the best love and kisses - Rondo ] aubergine

rondo
falcon
scotty

i dont think all three of them are mafia, but i am 100% sure mafia lies within those three.

don't like the whole reaction of scotty, i dunno why jay moved off him for silly reasons, but undermining my genuine case on him the way he did is defo something wolves have done with me before just cos i can't articulate my suspicions in big shiny cases like most ccan

falcon feels like the mischop if thread activity is anything to go by.

if falcon is town, it could mean rondo and scotty are both w. or one of them still is. if falcon is mafia, then rondo is likely town based on voting patterns i think.

I dont like this setting up of an excuse when scotty is mischop to turn on me

dunya -tinfoil
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME -tinfoil
NotAnAxehole

TonyStarkPrime

Dyson sphere
Master Radishes
motel room
Mizery
MacDougall


lost monkey
Lime Coke / JJJ - mostly from LC

Scotty
falcon45ca
tutuu


This is mostly gut reading off first day interactions.

[VOTE: scotty ] aubergine

Not a lot of consequence to add from this side. The tinfoil on dunya at the end looks authentic enough, and it was contingent upon a Scotty town flip. So okay sure.

~~~

Conclusion

Rondo was the only Scotty voter I thought was a plausible enough busser to investigate. So I did. I think he looks more town than not.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

That's fine, you don't have to. I mean, why read posts, right?


Your read on me is as accurate as your read on Scotty. I'm done wasting my time on you.

[VOTE: falcon45ca] aubergine

Then waste it on me. Your posts today are bad.

[tutuu]

Lotta theatre here, no?

You already were voting me btw.