The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[RondoDimBuckle]

Rondo... He could be scummy town, but scummy is scummy. I guess I could give him points for persistence under fire. I'd maybe expect him to have gone to water by now but he has been rather dogged.

@RondoDimBuckle can you share with me a mafia alignment game you've played before?

I would if I could. I am resigned to death since you are now town leader

You haven't randed mafia before?

I literally am giving you a chance to show me that you are town right now. What makes you think you are resigned to death? I am capable of reevaluation, more than most tbh.

You shouldn't give up on getting me to townread you as either alignment. I am far from convinced. I just say that I am to bait stronger responses.

Its less about me wanting to be town read and more about me not caring if you town read me or not. I am town, I have people who town read me already and will back me up if they want me to stay alive. Nothing I say or do will change that because its not up to me, other people will save or kill me as they wish and I am ok with that

[MacDougall]

No matter your alignment the way you're reacting here isn't good for your faction man. You just keep responding like a startled cat every time I engage with you.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Actually thats a lie, if I did have one I would probably say I dont and then not share it

Why?

because its not my job to find information for you to use against me and I am a contrarian

[RondoDimBuckle]

No matter your alignment the way you're reacting here isn't good for your faction man. You just keep responding like a startled cat every time I engage with you.

Thats not my view of it. but you have the right to your own opinion

[MacDougall]

Rondo... He could be scummy town, but scummy is scummy. I guess I could give him points for persistence under fire. I'd maybe expect him to have gone to water by now but he has been rather dogged.

@RondoDimBuckle can you share with me a mafia alignment game you've played before?

I would if I could. I am resigned to death since you are now town leader

You haven't randed mafia before?

I literally am giving you a chance to show me that you are town right now. What makes you think you are resigned to death? I am capable of reevaluation, more than most tbh.

You shouldn't give up on getting me to townread you as either alignment. I am far from convinced. I just say that I am to bait stronger responses.

Its less about me wanting to be town read and more about me not caring if you town read me or not. I am town, I have people who town read me already and will back me up if they want me to stay alive. Nothing I say or do will change that because its not up to me, other people will save or kill me as they wish and I am ok with that

But if you are town, I want to town read you, and you are not giving me what I need lol. And you literally just said you were resigned to death because I am town leader, and I am telling you that it really is exactly up to you.

[MacDougall]

Actually thats a lie, if I did have one I would probably say I dont and then not share it

Why?

because its not my job to find information for you to use against me and I am a contrarian

This is a perspective slip right? If you were town you wouldn't view me asking you for a comparative mafia game as trying to find something to use against you.

[RondoDimBuckle]

now we are just going in circles. I am going to go for another ride because this is pointless

[RondoDimBuckle]

Actually thats a lie, if I did have one I would probably say I dont and then not share it

Why?

because its not my job to find information for you to use against me and I am a contrarian

This is a perspective slip right? If you were town you wouldn't view me asking you for a comparative mafia game as trying to find something to use against you.

I can put myself in your perspective town or mafia

[MacDougall]

Re. Epignosis, I think he is town. It's been some time since I've played with him but this is pretty much how he towned in the last dozen or so games he played as town. What tends to happen is that Epi just spikes a wolf right in the head and clears himself and then becomes the overwhelming voice of reason.

[MacDougall]

Actually thats a lie, if I did have one I would probably say I dont and then not share it

Why?

because its not my job to find information for you to use against me and I am a contrarian

This is a perspective slip right? If you were town you wouldn't view me asking you for a comparative mafia game as trying to find something to use against you.

I can put myself in your perspective town or mafia

Okay how do I explain this succinctly.

As town, if someone asks for a comparitive wolf game, one would usually not feel like said information could be used against you.

As mafia, they would.

Hence the perspective slip.

Not much you're saying really makes sense to me. I am not trying to be harsh or mean or anything man. I am just trying to figure your ass out but you keep just spitting wolf tells every which way. My brain and my intuition are at odds because my brain says you are outed mafia but my intuition tells me that your doggedness and terrier like attitude are indicative of a town.

[Scotty]

scotty kinda giving off a big bad vibe like he plotting something!!!!

That’s correct, Pinky

[Scotty]

scotty kinda giving off a big bad vibe like he plotting something!!!!

scotty is from the future. you're just picking up on the differences in culture.

Shhhh shhhhhh quiet,
I don’t wanna have to reveal who gets lynched on day 3

[DrWilgy]

Sig hasn't shown up yet?

Hmmm...

@sig
@sig
@sig

Where ya at buddy?

Being not pleased we have 27 pages on day 1

Sorry buddy.

[Scotty]

[VOTE: sig] aubergine

Hi sig

The order of these emojis…is off. This string of emojis seem..off

[Scotty]

half right... I already did that and he outed himself with the emoji post

Wow!! Yes, mindmeld. That’s what spooked me too!

[Scotty]

MacDougall has revealed himself to be an innocent child.

Wait whaaaat why would you do this? You didn’t need to do this mac

[MacDougall]

MacDougall has revealed himself to be an innocent child.

Wait whaaaat why would you do this? You didn’t need to do this mac

You had to be there.

I was so townread it meant nothing anyway. Always go for the laughs.

[KZA]

I love when Mac uses his role for memes even if it involves vigging me halfway through D1

[Made]

sig
tutuu
Rondo
made

all maf

That sounds like a fun team! Unfortunately, not the real one. Why rondo? Also has sig showed up yet?

[Made]

Did Mac actually flip innocent child?

[112]

kk here finally

[Made]

If Mac is town, this game will prob be v easy

[Scotty]

Holy bananas mac, you’re on fire

Actually thats a lie, if I did have one I would probably say I dont and then not share it

Why?

because its not my job to find information for you to use against me and I am a contrarian

This is a perspective slip right? If you were town you wouldn't view me asking you for a comparative mafia game as trying to find something to use against you.

I can put myself in your perspective town or mafia

Okay how do I explain this succinctly.

As town, if someone asks for a comparitive wolf game, one would usually not feel like said information could be used against you.

As mafia, they would.

Hence the perspective slip.

Not much you're saying really makes sense to me. I am not trying to be harsh or mean or anything man. I am just trying to figure your ass out but you keep just spitting wolf tells every which way. My brain and my intuition are at odds because my brain says you are outed mafia but my intuition tells me that your doggedness and terrier like attitude are indicative of a town.

I’ve been trying to put a finger on who Rondo reminds me of, and I think it’s been there all along- rondo reminds me of me in my early mafia years. Kinda all over the place, wanting to be omnipresent in the thread, and posting spontaneously.

I do feel like that perspective skip is in fact a slip.

The argument should have been, “I don’t want to show my mafia games because that’s too much work” but instead, he does say “it’ll be used against me” which, even if Mac is mafia…which…um…he isn’t…he is inferring mafia mac would be trying to find rondo’s weaknesses and expose him. I mean, who really cares what mac in any alignment uses against his town play. He’d still have to defend whatever dingo poo mac throws his way.

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

Let’s boogie. Feel more inclined to vote here over sig for now

[112]

Scotty is town even though i didn't like his entrance and other ppl are sussing him

[KZA]

OHOHO

[112]

you know who probably is legit wolfing?

MR

[Scotty]

now we are just going in circles. I am going to go for another ride because this is pointless

lol I imagine you responding with this in your every day life to a myriad of situations:
-girlfriend asking you to do the dishes
-mom asking you to put the toilet seat down
-boss asking you to stay after to file paperwork
-waiting on a drink you just ordered at the bar

This is a fun game

[KZA]

you know who probably is legit wolfing?

MR

yeah I'm not okay with his contributions

[112]

now we are just going in circles. I am going to go for another ride because this is pointless

lol I imagine you responding with this in your every day life to a myriad of situations:
-girlfriend asking you to do the dishes
-mom asking you to put the toilet seat down
-boss asking you to stay after to file paperwork
-waiting on a drink you just ordered at the bar

This is a fun game

-trying to escape a labyrinth with the right-turns-only method only to find out it has islands so you go jump in your lambourghini to offload some steam.

[Scotty]

who’s to say that Mac is right about any of his reads anyway?
I mean, he’s just a child

[Scotty]

now we are just going in circles. I am going to go for another ride because this is pointless

lol I imagine you responding with this in your every day life to a myriad of situations:
-girlfriend asking you to do the dishes
-mom asking you to put the toilet seat down
-boss asking you to stay after to file paperwork
-waiting on a drink you just ordered at the bar

This is a fun game

-trying to escape a labyrinth with the right-turns-only method only to find out it has islands so you go jump in your lambourghini to offload some steam.

Omg I thought I was the only one in my life that uses that method. My wife thinks I’m crazy, but it always works. Except in THAT exact scenario. Holy shit

[MacDougall]

who’s to say that Mac is right about any of his reads anyway?
I mean, he’s just a child

I mean... you?

[Scotty]

now we are just going in circles. I am going to go for another ride because this is pointless

lol I imagine you responding with this in your every day life to a myriad of situations:
-girlfriend asking you to do the dishes
-mom asking you to put the toilet seat down
-boss asking you to stay after to file paperwork
-waiting on a drink you just ordered at the bar

This is a fun game

-trying to escape a labyrinth with the right-turns-only method only to find out it has islands so you go jump in your lambourghini to offload some steam.

Omg I thought I was the only one in my life that uses that method. My wife thinks I’m crazy, but it always works. Except in THAT exact scenario. Holy shit

EBWOP not the lambo part…the..the other part

[MacDougall]

you know who probably is legit wolfing?

MR

He is certainly not outside his scum range. If anything he isn't actually towny enough to be in it yet.

[Scotty]

who’s to say that Mac is right about any of his reads anyway?
I mean, he’s just a child

I mean... you?

Smartest kid I know

[Scotty]

ok I’m tired, i change my mind- mac coming out is good for the thread.

Let’s finish D1 out strong. Hoo-ah

[112]

now we are just going in circles. I am going to go for another ride because this is pointless

lol I imagine you responding with this in your every day life to a myriad of situations:
-girlfriend asking you to do the dishes
-mom asking you to put the toilet seat down
-boss asking you to stay after to file paperwork
-waiting on a drink you just ordered at the bar

This is a fun game

-trying to escape a labyrinth with the right-turns-only method only to find out it has islands so you go jump in your lambourghini to offload some steam.

Omg I thought I was the only one in my life that uses that method. My wife thinks I’m crazy, but it always works. Except in THAT exact scenario. Holy shit

:stonks:

[MacDougall]

ok I’m tired, i change my mind- mac coming out is good for the thread.

Let’s finish D1 out strong. Hoo-ah

Given I was so townread the mafia were probably always killing me n1 anyway confirming it is good for the gamestate yes because it at least provides something to base things of of.

Like iso me and read how ppl dealt with me.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Spoiler: show

Actually thats a lie, if I did have one I would probably say I dont and then not share it

Why?

because its not my job to find information for you to use against me and I am a contrarian

This is a perspective slip right? If you were town you wouldn't view me asking you for a comparative mafia game as trying to find something to use against you.

I can put myself in your perspective town or mafia

Okay how do I explain this succinctly.

As town, if someone asks for a comparitive wolf game, one would usually not feel like said information could be used against you.

As mafia, they would.

Hence the perspective slip.

Not much you're saying really makes sense to me. I am not trying to be harsh or mean or anything man. I am just trying to figure your ass out but you keep just spitting wolf tells every which way. My brain and my intuition are at odds because my brain says you are outed mafia but my intuition tells me that your doggedness and terrier like attitude are indicative of a town.

Its because when it comes down to it your intuition is right and your brain is wrong.

Someone has to be the second wagon today.

Spoiler: show

Holy bananas mac, you’re on fire

Actually thats a lie, if I did have one I would probably say I dont and then not share it

Why?

because its not my job to find information for you to use against me and I am a contrarian

This is a perspective slip right? If you were town you wouldn't view me asking you for a comparative mafia game as trying to find something to use against you.

I can put myself in your perspective town or mafia

Okay how do I explain this succinctly.

As town, if someone asks for a comparitive wolf game, one would usually not feel like said information could be used against you.

As mafia, they would.

Hence the perspective slip.

Not much you're saying really makes sense to me. I am not trying to be harsh or mean or anything man. I am just trying to figure your ass out but you keep just spitting wolf tells every which way. My brain and my intuition are at odds because my brain says you are outed mafia but my intuition tells me that your doggedness and terrier like attitude are indicative of a town.

I’ve been trying to put a finger on who Rondo reminds me of, and I think it’s been there all along- rondo reminds me of me in my early mafia years. Kinda all over the place, wanting to be omnipresent in the thread, and posting spontaneously.

I do feel like that perspective skip is in fact a slip.

The argument should have been, “I don’t want to show my mafia games because that’s too much work” but instead, he does say “it’ll be used against me” which, even if Mac is mafia…which…um…he isn’t…he is inferring mafia mac would be trying to find rondo’s weaknesses and expose him. I mean, who really cares what mac in any alignment uses against his town play. He’d still have to defend whatever dingo poo mac throws his way.

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

Let’s boogie. Feel more inclined to vote here over sig for now

Its not a perspective slip if I chose to word it that way, In macs view he wants to find a wolf, in the world I am a wolf asking me to find information for him is ridiculous because wolf me wouldnt do it. It just happens to coincide with the fact that town me wouldnt do it either.

Secondarily. I entered this whole forum with a role play post. I have been role playing for almost 20 years at this point. Do you really think I would perspective slip as wolf?

Scotty seems opportunistically trying to push me, its easy to follow inno child and when everything goes wrong say "but Mac told me to do it"

Spoiler: show

now we are just going in circles. I am going to go for another ride because this is pointless

lol I imagine you responding with this in your every day life to a myriad of situations:
-girlfriend asking you to do the dishes
-mom asking you to put the toilet seat down
-boss asking you to stay after to file paperwork
-waiting on a drink you just ordered at the bar

This is a fun game

This is an internet forum I am not beholden to you to choose to stay if I dont want to :think:

If Mac is just running in circles asking me the same questions in different ways I am going to leave and come back when there are other people to interact with. Asked and answered.

[MacDougall]

scotty kinda giving off a big bad vibe like he plotting something!!!!

This feels like a real thought tbh.

[MacDougall]

sig
tutuu
Rondo
made

all maf

That sounds like a fun team! Unfortunately, not the real one. Why rondo? Also has sig showed up yet?

You know you could check that. Also I've explained at length my issues with Rondo. Just read the last few pages.

Did Mac actually flip innocent child?

If Mac is town, this game will prob be v easy

Not if people don't try. I will only be here for one phase. We need to play this day 1 well. We need to corner some wolves. We need to start building some actual wagons here. I am not super confident in the platform yet. There are too many votes scattered around, too much going on. We need to start to focus our energy. I'd like to see 3 wagons emerge sooner rather than later. Force the wolves to start making choices that aren't hanging back on vanity wagons etc.

[MacDougall]

Syn 100% Scum

[VOTE: Syn ] aubergine

Are you still feeling this way @RondoDimBuckle?

[RondoDimBuckle]

sig
tutuu
Rondo
made

all maf

That sounds like a fun team! Unfortunately, not the real one. Why rondo? Also has sig showed up yet?

I claim no equity with made

[RondoDimBuckle]

Syn 100% Scum

[VOTE: Syn ] aubergine

Are you still feeling this way @RondoDimBuckle?

You played with me in Batman, do you think in a format where I can move whenever I want what I say in chat matters? Look at my vote right now

[MacDougall]

Syn 100% Scum

[VOTE: Syn ] aubergine

Are you still feeling this way @RondoDimBuckle?

You played with me in Batman, do you think in a format where I can move whenever I want what I say in chat matters? Look at my vote right now

Dude I am just asking you because I am sus of Syn. Why do you keep overreacting to every question I ask. It's so tiring and annoying. Please stop doing it.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Syn 100% Scum

[VOTE: Syn ] aubergine

Are you still feeling this way @RondoDimBuckle?

You played with me in Batman, do you think in a format where I can move whenever I want what I say in chat matters? Look at my vote right now

Dude I am just asking you because I am sus of Syn. Why do you keep overreacting to every question I ask. It's so tiring and annoying. Please stop doing it.

ok fine, ill read syns iso and give you a response

[MacDougall]

I think Syn is my top scumread here tbh.

His ISO is mostly just rubbish. He has these limpdick pushes on people but nothing of substance and his targets are consistently the same people that the thread seems to be pushing, but only the ones that have town equity. I don't like anything about his game here. Syn might be a troll as every alignment but when he's a town troll his play and reads are usually good. I'm not seeing anything redeemable about his play here.

[Made]

Just got back to thread after a day out of doing irl things, ill read the actual rondo stuff in a bit, but the “town doesn’t think meta can be used against” argument is interesting

[MacDougall]

you know who probably is legit wolfing?

MR

112 is worrying me but I am not going to solve them before I die.

Points for: They seem to have genuine suspicion of MR that has been present since MR's entrance to the game. Initally the sus seemed minor but it appears with this post that 112's perspective on MR shifted in the time since they last commented on MR. This is quite towny as you can see the progression from minor to not so minor is there.

Points against: There is nothing in 112's ISO that is outside their range when they are on. They have thrown a few reads that I didn't like out. I can't confidently town read them.

I'd have them as an every so slight reserved town lean. Ie. keep them honest. If 112 is mafia here they are in their better mafia form, which means that 112 has probably already thrown out some sus on teammates and set themselves up to go relatively deep.

[Made]

[VOTE: syn] aubergine