The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[Scotty]

emotion > logic

scotty town

idk who to vote though

D1 in a nutshell

I don’t like emotion in this game- easily faked. I could be faking right now. My anger isn’t townworthy. Logic can’t be faked and I don’t have a lot of it in day ones

scum can't say logical things?

what? I mean emotion is not a great way to base suspicion…even though that’s literally all we have to go on today before any reveals

[MacDougall]

Threatening to claim is +maf

i think its +town and that ur tunnelin

Scotty wasn't even in Urist's scumlist.

[Scotty]

I could be getting pocketed by tutuu right now as my only defender and it’s making me chuckle because irony

[tedxtr]

fourth time

why did you vote for tutuu

[Urist]

Threatening to claim is +maf

i think its +town and that ur tunnelin

Scotty wasn't in my poe tho

[MacDougall]

Given the initial premise of Ted's read was Scotty and Tutuu seeming partnery it is so ... very ... hard not to read this current Tutuu spurt as selling out to save a drowning teammate.

[tutuu]

emotion > logic

scotty town

idk who to vote though

D1 in a nutshell

I don’t like emotion in this game- easily faked. I could be faking right now. My anger isn’t townworthy. Logic can’t be faked and I don’t have a lot of it in day ones

scum can't say logical things?

what? I mean emotion is not a great way to base suspicion…even though that’s literally all we have to go on today before any reveals

theres no logic in mafia fam, only emotion, imo, but to each their own

[Scotty]

fourth time

why did you vote for tutuu

Just because I’ve already explained my shallow reasoning a few times and you don’t like it doesn’t mean the answer is gonna change

She seemed suspicious. Obviously I didn’t stay there long, which is the crux of why you find me sus

[DrWilgy]

Without sounding too OMGUS, I am suspicious of Ender for his trifling townreads, like he’s picking rare flowers from the botanical garden and bringing them home

[VOTE: Ender] aubergine

I am always suspicious of those that give too many townreads early

the botanical garden here recently had its corpse flower bloom last week

Bruh, those are super cool. Got to see one in Houston like 10 years ago. It fuckin reeked lol.

[KZA]

[VOTE: Syn] aubergine

experimental trip hop vote

[Scotty]

emotion > logic

scotty town

idk who to vote though

D1 in a nutshell

I don’t like emotion in this game- easily faked. I could be faking right now. My anger isn’t townworthy. Logic can’t be faked and I don’t have a lot of it in day ones

scum can't say logical things?

what? I mean emotion is not a great way to base suspicion…even though that’s literally all we have to go on today before any reveals

theres no logic in mafia fam, only emotion, imo, but to each their own

Definitely to each their own, and I will stand by my reasoning that logic begets motivation. Emotion can be spontaneous or manipulative.

[tedxtr]

what post did you vote her for? why did she seem suspicious?

and while you’re at it, if you can quote where you’ve already answered me why you voted for her, that’d be great, since i don’t remember you ever saying why beyond “i just felt like it”

[MacDougall]

emotion > logic

scotty town

idk who to vote though

D1 in a nutshell

I don’t like emotion in this game- easily faked. I could be faking right now. My anger isn’t townworthy. Logic can’t be faked and I don’t have a lot of it in day ones

scum can't say logical things?

what? I mean emotion is not a great way to base suspicion…even though that’s literally all we have to go on today before any reveals

theres no logic in mafia fam, only emotion, imo, but to each their own

I can hear @JaggedJimmyJay's wtf from spec chat.

Also you're just wrong. Stats don't lie. The three players on the site with the highest statistically valid winrates are Alison, Jay and myself. And we use logic. Perhaps you should try it too. The game may be hard to master but the permutations can be controlled after a while.

[Scotty]

what post did you vote her for? why did she seem suspicious?

and while you’re at it, if you can quote where you’ve already answered me why you voted for her, that’d be great, since i don’t remember you ever saying why beyond “i just felt like it”

You’re pissing me off

“I just felt like it” WAS THE ANSWER AND THE POINT I WAS MAKING BECAUSE IT LACKS ANY MORE THAN THAT

[Scotty]

emotion > logic

scotty town

idk who to vote though

D1 in a nutshell

I don’t like emotion in this game- easily faked. I could be faking right now. My anger isn’t townworthy. Logic can’t be faked and I don’t have a lot of it in day ones

scum can't say logical things?

what? I mean emotion is not a great way to base suspicion…even though that’s literally all we have to go on today before any reveals

theres no logic in mafia fam, only emotion, imo, but to each their own

I can hear @JaggedJimmyJay's wtf from spec chat.

Also you're just wrong. Stats don't lie. The three players on the site with the highest statistically valid winrates are Alison, Jay and myself. And we use logic. Perhaps you should try it too. The game may be hard to master but the permutations can be controlled after a while.

this

[tedxtr]

tutuu got fooled by about 4 “emotional reads” before, interesting line she’s taking here

and before she’ll ask me to name them, the first example i can come up with is jpic in whatever game that was when we both said he was repressing that villager heat in his replies

[Scotty]

You’re hung up on my progression and I’m telling you my progression is shit

[DrWilgy]

i think its very likely we will chop town d1 and id like to urge yall to not be too hard on ourselves, we got alot of slankers, game has 24 players but feels like 14 players or less, we are doing the best we can, and thats alright

No

[MacDougall]

Aight Scotty...

Syn, Sig, Made, Falcon are all also sus. What you think?

[tutuu]

MacDougall
RondoDimBuckle
EnderWiggin
Urist
tedxtr
Scotty
KZA
TonyStarkPrime

112
Michelle
Epignosis
DrWilgy

Master Radishes
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
sig
Made
Poison
falcon45ca
Ruri
DkKoba
Syn

NotAnAxehole
Creature

[tutuu]

emotion > logic

scotty town

idk who to vote though

D1 in a nutshell

I don’t like emotion in this game- easily faked. I could be faking right now. My anger isn’t townworthy. Logic can’t be faked and I don’t have a lot of it in day ones

scum can't say logical things?

what? I mean emotion is not a great way to base suspicion…even though that’s literally all we have to go on today before any reveals

theres no logic in mafia fam, only emotion, imo, but to each their own

I can hear @JaggedJimmyJay's wtf from spec chat.

Also you're just wrong. Stats don't lie. The three players on the site with the highest statistically valid winrates are Alison, Jay and myself. And we use logic. Perhaps you should try it too. The game may be hard to master but the permutations can be controlled after a while.

i just opened the master sheet and it said ur winrate is below 50%. where can i see the stats for 2020 and 2021 only?

[DrWilgy]

Finished reading your iso @Syn.

Talk to me about EnderWiggin more plz.

[MacDougall]

Also on the subject of winrates... Alison and Jay use pure logic and ignore emotion and both have higher winrates than me and I tend to read emotion and ignore logic on occasion probably to the detriment of my results honestly. Case in point Alison would just go on burying Rondo today whereas I'm re-evaluating. Maybe I'm right this time but I think in most cases she would be.

[Urist]

Given the initial premise of Ted's read was Scotty and Tutuu seeming partnery it is so ... very ... hard not to read this current Tutuu spurt as selling out to save a drowning teammate.

Tutuu was on syn before switching to axehole right? I think that if tutuu/scotty were paired, tutuu wouldn't have made that switch.
To me tutuu's behaviour reads more like her trying to earn towncred by defending townscotty. If tutuu were town i think she'd be voting for syn atm.

[tutuu]

Given the initial premise of Ted's read was Scotty and Tutuu seeming partnery it is so ... very ... hard not to read this current Tutuu spurt as selling out to save a drowning teammate.

Tutuu was on syn before switching to axehole right? I think that if tutuu/scotty were paired, tutuu wouldn't have made that switch.
To me tutuu's behaviour reads more like her trying to earn towncred by defending townscotty. If tutuu were town i think she'd be voting for syn atm.

i dont have a scumread im happy to vote for atm, and syn is funny and i like his presence, his and axehole's contributions feel on a similar level, so if i had to pick one to die id choose axehole coz hes voting me

[MacDougall]

emotion > logic

scotty town

idk who to vote though

D1 in a nutshell

I don’t like emotion in this game- easily faked. I could be faking right now. My anger isn’t townworthy. Logic can’t be faked and I don’t have a lot of it in day ones

scum can't say logical things?

what? I mean emotion is not a great way to base suspicion…even though that’s literally all we have to go on today before any reveals

theres no logic in mafia fam, only emotion, imo, but to each their own

I can hear @JaggedJimmyJay's wtf from spec chat.

Also you're just wrong. Stats don't lie. The three players on the site with the highest statistically valid winrates are Alison, Jay and myself. And we use logic. Perhaps you should try it too. The game may be hard to master but the permutations can be controlled after a while.

i just opened the master sheet and it said ur winrate is below 50%. where can i see the stats for 2020 and 2021 only?

You say it like being under 50% is a bad thing but look how many people with more than 30 games have a winrate higher than mine. Over 50 it's literally one, Jay.

Also I have significantly more games than both of them tbh.

On this site a winrate over 40% is admirable. On average rng you will lose more than you win because of the majority/minority affect and wolves winning more often here than towns.

[DrWilgy]

Also on the subject of winrates... Alison and Jay use pure logic and ignore emotion and both have higher winrates than me and I tend to read emotion and ignore logic on occasion probably to the detriment of my results honestly. Case in point Alison would just go on burying Rondo today whereas I'm re-evaluating. Maybe I'm right this time but I think in most cases she would be.

I feel validation in my desire to slam Rondo now. Ty papi.

[DrWilgy]

Oh god now I'm worried about my wr

[DrWilgy]

Oh god now I'm worried about my wr

[Urist]

Given the initial premise of Ted's read was Scotty and Tutuu seeming partnery it is so ... very ... hard not to read this current Tutuu spurt as selling out to save a drowning teammate.

Tutuu was on syn before switching to axehole right? I think that if tutuu/scotty were paired, tutuu wouldn't have made that switch.
To me tutuu's behaviour reads more like her trying to earn towncred by defending townscotty. If tutuu were town i think she'd be voting for syn atm.

i dont have a scumread im happy to vote for atm, and syn is funny and i like his presence, his and axehole's contributions feel on a similar level, so if i had to pick one to die id choose axehole coz hes voting me

You're not choosing axehole to die tho bc you're the only vote there. You're just choosing syn (a scumread) to not die and thereby putting scotty (a townread) more in the lead.

[DrWilgy]

Agh no, double post. Imma noob.

[Urist]

Also on the subject of winrates... Alison and Jay use pure logic and ignore emotion and both have higher winrates than me and I tend to read emotion and ignore logic on occasion probably to the detriment of my results honestly. Case in point Alison would just go on burying Rondo today whereas I'm re-evaluating. Maybe I'm right this time but I think in most cases she would be.

Counterpoint: i also use logic and have the worst town winrate of anyone

[tutuu]

Given the initial premise of Ted's read was Scotty and Tutuu seeming partnery it is so ... very ... hard not to read this current Tutuu spurt as selling out to save a drowning teammate.

Tutuu was on syn before switching to axehole right? I think that if tutuu/scotty were paired, tutuu wouldn't have made that switch.
To me tutuu's behaviour reads more like her trying to earn towncred by defending townscotty. If tutuu were town i think she'd be voting for syn atm.

i dont have a scumread im happy to vote for atm, and syn is funny and i like his presence, his and axehole's contributions feel on a similar level, so if i had to pick one to die id choose axehole coz hes voting me

You're not choosing axehole to die tho bc you're the only vote there. You're just choosing syn (a scumread) to not die and thereby putting scotty (a townread) more in the lead.

nah, eod is 6 hours away and ill be there. im opening the idea for a new wagon, im not married to it

[Justplayingitcool]

@dyachei has replaced @Creature. Please do not discuss subs.

[Scotty]

Aight Scotty...

Syn, Sig, Made, Falcon are all also sus. What you think?

I don’t remember falcon posting-
dog is sus as I mentioned before for that entrance
Syn I’ve said couod go either way, unless they’ve done anything more of note it could be memewolfing
Made I think I’m back in the town basket I guess

[tedxtr]

the n1 kill

[MacDougall]

Also on the subject of winrates... Alison and Jay use pure logic and ignore emotion and both have higher winrates than me and I tend to read emotion and ignore logic on occasion probably to the detriment of my results honestly. Case in point Alison would just go on burying Rondo today whereas I'm re-evaluating. Maybe I'm right this time but I think in most cases she would be.

Counterpoint: i also use logic and have the worst town winrate of anyone

well logic can be both good and bad depending on the exponent lol

also you probably haven't played enough games here to really have true values

[tutuu]

@dyachei has replaced @Creature. Please do not discuss subs.

looks like mac will survive 1 extra night

[DrWilgy]

Syn/Tutuu

Or

Urist/Ender?

Does Rondo fit into either of these?

I'm not able to see the lines like I used to.

[MacDougall]

the n1 kill

lol if it happens again in a game where I'm mod confirmed

[MacDougall]

Syn/Tutuu

Or

Urist/Ender?

Does Rondo fit into either of these?

I'm not able to see the lines like I used to.

urist is exceedingly obvious town just from his recent outburst tbh

[Scotty]

Just based on this page I’d say tutuu/syn is not a stretch

[KZA]

the 3 schools of mafia emotion logic and memes

[tutuu]

the 3 schools of mafia emotion logic and memes

calculatedly making the move to self-vote and ate is in the center of the venn diagram

[DrWilgy]

Logic and rational thinking in a game of numbers is the correct way to play.

Emotional tact can be quantified and rationalized.

You nerds are arguing the same shit.

[Scotty]

Logic and rational thinking in a game of numbers is the correct way to play.

Emotional tact can be quantified and rationalized.

You nerds are arguing the same shit.

Get back to surgery, Doctor. The patients need you

[DrWilgy]

Just based on this page I’d say tutuu/syn is not a stretch

Don't sheep me bro

[Scotty]

Why is ender/rondo/mr voting me? I’m not back reading right niw

[MacDougall]

Why is ender/rondo/mr voting me? I’m not back reading right niw

sheeping me after I agreed with ted

[Scotty]

[VOTE: tutuu] aubergine

@tedxtr
Just felt like it