The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

Submit to the dungeons
Poll runs till Tue Aug 31, 2021 11:00 pm
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


112
1
4%
Voters: DkKoba
DkKoba
2
8%
Voters: sig, falcon45ca
DrWilgy
1
4%
Voters: EnderWiggin
EnderWiggin
1
4%
Voters: 112
Epignosis
1
4%
Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
MacDougall
0
No votes
Voters: None
Made
5
20%
Voters: tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, TonyStarkPrime
MasterRadishes
4
16%
Voters: Scotty, Ruri, Epignosis, Michelle
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
0
No votes
Voters: None
Poison
1
4%
Voters: RondoDimBuckle
RondoDimBuckle
1
4%
Voters: DrWilgy
Ruri
0
No votes
Voters: None
Scotty
0
No votes
Voters: None
sig
0
No votes
Voters: None
Syn/BoKnows
1
4%
Voters: Made
tedxtr (DEAD)
0
No votes
Voters: None
TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes
Voters: None
tutuu
1
4%
Voters: Urist
Urist
0
No votes
Voters: None
No vote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Lynch
0
No votes
Voters: None
Non (Host, mod, Spec, Dead, etc.)
6
24%
Voters: dunya, Lime Coke, sabie12, Justplayingitcool, tedxtr, Syn
Total votes: 25

Vc

did you actually want me to put my vote on radishes or can we have it as read?

The only vote who counts is the poll vote.
What's just itt is not useful

[Made]

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

dw man the wagon will be switched to someone with 0 votes at dl

My wagonomics say that I am still most likely to die. The Issue is if not if i'm the scummist person in thread, that's fixable. the issue is if enough people think i'm "sus enough" by end of day. If they do, I die here, especially if another wagon surpasses me now, and people panic switch tomorrow.

[Made]

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

Whats the case against you?

no clue tbh, but I'm catching up. It seems to be mostly tone tho. I do have some thread associations with scummier players too

[Michelle]

Wagons now, could be w/w

Made
5
20%
Voters: tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, TonyStarkPrime

MasterRadishes
4
16%
Voters: Scotty, Ruri, Epignosis, Michelle

A vanity wagon Rond is voting in the poll while he is posting itt a vote for Mr R

Poison
1
4%
Voters: RondoDimBuckle

[Made]

@michelle have you done that vote count thing as scum yet?

[Scotty]

Wagons now, could be w/w

Made
5
20%
Voters: tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, TonyStarkPrime

MasterRadishes
4
16%
Voters: Scotty, Ruri, Epignosis, Michelle

A vanity wagon Rond is voting in the poll while he is posting itt a vote for Mr R

Poison
1
4%
Voters: RondoDimBuckle

This is a towny post

[Urist]

spicy wagons

[Michelle]

Made if you're town please

[Michelle]

@michelle have you done that vote count thing as scum yet?

Yes, it's not AI

[Made]

Made if you're town please

Have we analysis'd tutuu entrance into thread D2 yet? It looked like a wolf backed into a corner fighting like hell. That was my immediate read, and her pivot on me supports that imo

[Made]

@michelle have you done that vote count thing as scum yet?

Yes, it's not AI

kinda figured it wasn't, just was curious if it's happened yet!

[Made]

Honestly, I think my wagon is a bunch of scum that took the very easy "We vote made here" track. i look like a snack to scum rn imo.

[Made]

Honestly, I think my wagon is a bunch of scum that took the very easy "We vote made here" track. i look like a snack to scum rn imo.

idk if that's true of my current wagon, I think i've gone stale enough where an active scum could of thought to pivot off me to start a counter wagon, but that would be in the minority of actions here

[Michelle]

Made if you're town please

Have we analysis'd tutuu entrance into thread D2 yet? It looked like a wolf backed into a corner fighting like hell. That was my immediate read, and her pivot on me supports that imo

You were so inactive that anyone pushing you is right in doing it.
Tutuu is either just town or she talked her way out from a suspicion from me and Mac with a skill I would only admire if she is wolf. Though, my current read is tutuu town, still admirable

[Made]

Made if you're town please

Have we analysis'd tutuu entrance into thread D2 yet? It looked like a wolf backed into a corner fighting like hell. That was my immediate read, and her pivot on me supports that imo

You were so inactive that anyone pushing you is right in doing it.
Tutuu is either just town or she talked her way out from a suspicion from me and Mac with a skill I would only admire if she is wolf. Though, my current read is tutuu town, still admirable

I mean I see it either way tbh, but I think it's not tinfoil at this point to be sus on her slot, especially if chops town today. Even more so if that town is made.

And re: my innactivity

i posted more than a bunch of people and even then, I telegraphed that i'm slanking this game. I think there's enough here where at the very least i'm not a priority-- at least not yet.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Made if you're town please

Have we analysis'd tutuu entrance into thread D2 yet? It looked like a wolf backed into a corner fighting like hell. That was my immediate read, and her pivot on me supports that imo

You were so inactive that anyone pushing you is right in doing it.
Tutuu is either just town or she talked her way out from a suspicion from me and Mac with a skill I would only admire if she is wolf. Though, my current read is tutuu town, still admirable

I mean I see it either way tbh, but I think it's not tinfoil at this point to be sus on her slot, especially if chops town today. Even more so if that town is made.

And re: my innactivity

i posted more than a bunch of people and even then, I telegraphed that i'm slanking this game. I think there's enough here where at the very least i'm not a priority-- at least not yet.

bo + syn

[Made]

Made if you're town please

Have we analysis'd tutuu entrance into thread D2 yet? It looked like a wolf backed into a corner fighting like hell. That was my immediate read, and her pivot on me supports that imo

You were so inactive that anyone pushing you is right in doing it.
Tutuu is either just town or she talked her way out from a suspicion from me and Mac with a skill I would only admire if she is wolf. Though, my current read is tutuu town, still admirable

I mean I see it either way tbh, but I think it's not tinfoil at this point to be sus on her slot, especially if chops town today. Even more so if that town is made.

And re: my innactivity

i posted more than a bunch of people and even then, I telegraphed that i'm slanking this game. I think there's enough here where at the very least i'm not a priority-- at least not yet.

bo + syn

yeah ik. but still

[MacDougall]

made find the mafia

[Poison]

honestly I confirm koba's claim but cannot confirm the alignment. At first i was hesitant to talk about getting RBed when Michelle asked because i was considering isoing them first, in case i found them towny i wouldn't have confirmed RBed, but since they have claimed i can talk about it ig. I think i was targeted by Scum!RB rather than Town!RB because Town!RB would have way more people to RB than me, and even though Koba said why they did it, i still find it hard to believe t!RB being this reckless imo. So yeah I can confirm RB Koba, not their alignment

please explain without acronyms do someone who doesnt know forum mafia

Sorry about that, I see tutuu already replied but yeah it's basically Roleblock = RB T!Koba = Town Koba, S!koba = Scum koba

[Poison]

Spoiler: show

Hot take: mac is mafia-aligned innocent child

Is that a thing?

Okay so during the night phase I’ve reached the conclusion that Axe was 100% targeted by mafia.

The more I consider roles and set up I just can’t see being burned as a civ thing. This does matter though since if it’s mafia we have to dissect why it could be them. And how much KP is still floating.

Poison is probably a vote deal if @Michelle wants to share that would be great. And I have to assume based off lore the other vig is a Witcher. Also probably have a jack of all trade floating around. Both of which would be civ in my view.


It could still be epi, but I’d not say we should clear or even consider it a civ move for epi to kill him.

For Mac, I’ve reached the conclusion you are a civ, but I do think you’re reads are a bit off and we just shouldn’t blindly sheep like some did last phase.

@sig explain the @bold please

i think that there is a high number of mafia in:

nanook

poison

michelle

master radish

koba

falcon

these 6 names avoided getting into scraps yesterday. they were laying low, they were just playing it cool. i think that people who's hands are clean during the day get bloody during the night. when the town is devouring itself it makes sense for you to chill out and let it happen

everyone else i can recall getting into some kind of confrontantion, and i also townread all of the people who were part of said confrontations, so that's how im pieceing the two ends together

would be great if you added a line or two about these players individually.

i’ve never played a game without role flips, i wonder if there’s an optimal way to organize stuff

should have just joined rej's game on AB. it's pain.

@MacDougall we are contacting you concerning your car's extended warranty

This is the second funniest thing in this thread.

Re Made: LMFAO

Poison the verb not the noun. I was thinking it would add votes to Michelle instead of flat out kill her given the KP we've already seen.

Fair, sometimes I get confused

[Poison]

Replied to the notifications I'm gonna come back after class

[Poison]

Did 112 post today? I see they are voting but I don't remember anything from them

[Poison]

Can we flip rondo tomorrow?

No he was towny af D1, although idk bout D2 rondo yet gotta talk to him

[Poison]

Learning tutuu’s alignment will resolve a lot of things. For many people. If she’s town, which a skim of her iso tells me (as I’m often nodding along with many of her reads), then there are a bevy of people trying to take her down. If she flips town, her reads are probably pretty spot on.
Her point about poison blowing up after being rolebocked last night is one that I agree with: it looks performative. In the ensuing back and forth that follows between the two, poison seems to do more poo slinging than defending. Maybe That is their defense. I dunno. But I give no brownie points to poison because of it.

Umm we don't lynch a player who can flip villager as info lynch, so voting tutuu seems exaggerated fmpov
You dislike Poison's reaction but what if it's genuine?

Re: Scotty @Scotty explain poo slinging, and explain why do I need to defend myself and what made you think I'm defending myself?

As for my reaction, it is more like a me thing rather than alignment indicative. You probably doubt my personality over my playstyle imo. Your suspicion on me aren't strong fmpov, they only hang on my first post as you said before, which was a good morning and probably saying I'm happy to play with tutuu again. If it feels performative to you, you should look back to my previous games or ask my homies how I usually talk [Michelle, and Ted, rip ted] . Of course I can copy my town game as a scum but in that way everyone can be Scum.

If you have some real concerns for me, something that you want me to address to and help you read me right then do put your case forward. If you are going to scum read me because of the things you mentioned then help yourself and scum read me, cause honestly I haven't learned the art of explaining my speech yet.

[Poison]

Anyways I see 112 posting.

I'll be back later

[RondoDimBuckle]

Can we flip rondo tomorrow?

No he was towny af D1, although idk bout D2 rondo yet gotta talk to him

yay

[Urist]

I've been considering this for a while and didn't think it would be necessary, bit I'm realizing that we're going to be in lylo sooner rather than later so I should get my role confirmed asap.

I am going to claim now. Last night, I targeted tutuu. I have an ability that seems anti-town at first but I think you'll come to understand how pro-town this claim is at EoD.

Anyway, my action is that every night I must target another player. The following day, that player will require two extra votes to eliminate. Unfortunately, I misread this at first and thought it would cause the person to require two fewer votes, instead of two more. That's why I targeted tutuu. Silly me!

But this isn't a terrible thing. I think we can confirm my role now. All we have to do is make sure that tutuu has exactly one more vote than the runner-up at EoD. Should be easy. Then the runner-up will be eliminated and tutuu will survive and my role will be proven.

There's nothing to lose so I say we get crackin'! How 'bout y'all?

[RondoDimBuckle]

I've been considering this for a while and didn't think it would be necessary, bit I'm realizing that we're going to be in lylo sooner rather than later so I should get my role confirmed asap.

I am going to claim now. Last night, I targeted tutuu. I have an ability that seems anti-town at first but I think you'll come to understand how pro-town this claim is at EoD.

Anyway, my action is that every night I must target another player. The following day, that player will require two extra votes to eliminate. Unfortunately, I misread this at first and thought it would cause the person to require two fewer votes, instead of two more. That's why I targeted tutuu. Silly me!

But this isn't a terrible thing. I think we can confirm my role now. All we have to do is make sure that tutuu has exactly one more vote than the runner-up at EoD. Should be easy. Then the runner-up will be eliminated and tutuu will survive and my role will be proven.

There's nothing to lose so I say we get crackin'! How 'bout y'all?

this sounds weird enough to be true but its also too precarious to leave open to wolves who opportunistically murder someone? I dunno maybe I am being paranoid. I am willing to give it a go if the town leaders approve

[Michelle]

I've been considering this for a while and didn't think it would be necessary, bit I'm realizing that we're going to be in lylo sooner rather than later so I should get my role confirmed asap.

I am going to claim now. Last night, I targeted tutuu. I have an ability that seems anti-town at first but I think you'll come to understand how pro-town this claim is at EoD.

Anyway, my action is that every night I must target another player. The following day, that player will require two extra votes to eliminate. Unfortunately, I misread this at first and thought it would cause the person to require two fewer votes, instead of two more. That's why I targeted tutuu. Silly me!

But this isn't a terrible thing. I think we can confirm my role now. All we have to do is make sure that tutuu has exactly one more vote than the runner-up at EoD. Should be easy. Then the runner-up will be eliminated and tutuu will survive and my role will be proven.

There's nothing to lose so I say we get crackin'! How 'bout y'all?

this sounds weird enough to be true but its also too precarious to leave open to wolves who opportunistically murder someone? I dunno maybe I am being paranoid. I am willing to give it a go if the town leaders approve

What if wolves have a double voter or some role to switch wagons? I would not risk tutuu's life like this

[Michelle]

kinda mad cuz i read the dya slot as town but i was busy with cute boy and my phone was dead during EoD so

Wait what

their predecessor was very towny in mindset from what i remember i just was not able to really parse it LMFAO

it was just unconventional

Dkkoba complained i didn't read their posts. So i will Iso them in my free time

Anything until this post above is NAI and extremely easy to post as wolf.

This post imo is a slip, they mentioned the predecesor posts of Dya's slot and Creature didn't post a word.
Later in the game when questioned thwyt took it jokey and say 0 is tonwy or something like that (i will not search now for that post)
I don't think town would try to obtain towny points based on a flip and i see DkKoba read for Dya's slot as TMI and a clear proof they are a wolf.

I will call it proof No. 1

[MacDougall]

Yeah I agree. I have been intending to wagon Koba since that post and have mostly just been letting things play out. Koba is clearly outed mafia and should definitely be lolcatting but given that they chose not to then that's all the better for spew.

Sucks to be you @DkKoba.

[Ruri]

Host Communication: Please can I ask you all not to discuss other users potential rule breaks in the thread. If you feel like someone has broken a rule, please DM me instead. Thank you.

@112
@Epignosis
@Syn
@Poison
@Master Radishes
@Ruri
@falcon45ca
@sig
@EnderWiggin
@RondoDimBuckle
@tutuu
@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
@Made
@Scotty
@Urist
@DkKoba
@MacDougall
@Michelle
@DrWilgy
@TonyStarkPrime

Shock.

[Ruri]

@Ruri why are you voting me?

Oh, you noticed. I'm voting in POE. Tell me about yourself.

[Ruri]

I've been considering this for a while and didn't think it would be necessary, bit I'm realizing that we're going to be in lylo sooner rather than later so I should get my role confirmed asap.

I am going to claim now. Last night, I targeted tutuu. I have an ability that seems anti-town at first but I think you'll come to understand how pro-town this claim is at EoD.

Anyway, my action is that every night I must target another player. The following day, that player will require two extra votes to eliminate. Unfortunately, I misread this at first and thought it would cause the person to require two fewer votes, instead of two more. That's why I targeted tutuu. Silly me!

But this isn't a terrible thing. I think we can confirm my role now. All we have to do is make sure that tutuu has exactly one more vote than the runner-up at EoD. Should be easy. Then the runner-up will be eliminated and tutuu will survive and my role will be proven.

There's nothing to lose so I say we get crackin'! How 'bout y'all?

I assume this means you sussed Tutuu? And, if your role is proven, I don't think it will tell us much about your alignment. But will table this for now.

[Ruri]

kinda mad cuz i read the dya slot as town but i was busy with cute boy and my phone was dead during EoD so

Wait what

their predecessor was very towny in mindset from what i remember i just was not able to really parse it LMFAO

it was just unconventional

Dkkoba complained i didn't read their posts. So i will Iso them in my free time

Anything until this post above is NAI and extremely easy to post as wolf.

This post imo is a slip, they mentioned the predecesor posts of Dya's slot and Creature didn't post a word.
Later in the game when questioned thwyt took it jokey and say 0 is tonwy or something like that (i will not search now for that post)
I don't think town would try to obtain towny points based on a flip and i see DkKoba read for Dya's slot as TMI and a clear proof they are a wolf.

I will call it proof No. 1

Nice catch. Though, did Creature really not post at all? Unless I'm confused due to the heavy mentions of Creature in POE on D1.

[MacDougall]

Creature made 0 posts.

[MacDougall]

Urist is town. We don't need to resolve Tutuu to prove it.

[MacDougall]

Made has had a chance to do something, anything towny. Hasn't done so.

[Ruri]

Ah, looks like Syn got replaced.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Ah, looks like Syn got replaced.

I blame neutrinos

[MacDougall]

Yes and his replacement has done nothing at all towny and can die.

[Ruri]

so like are MR's reads good or bad everyone?

#1425
You tell me.

[Ruri]

Yes and his replacement has done nothing at all towny and can die.

Well, I checked the ISO and yes it looks lackluster.

[Michelle]

last night i targeted poison bc i was too lazy to reread and mac said they were a 3p read and i hate all 3p so i went on it LMFAO

scotty/sig still on my scumdar

They claimed RBer later. Probably a claim close to their real role and they can say it is a way of claiming safe if they are villager to avoid a soup kill. Whether a soup kill exists or not, we don't really know it because 'Role/flavour claiming is allowed but it may not be in your best interests' doesn't imply an anticlaim mechanic that big, but mafia can have a claim vigi for eg.

My problem with sheeping Mac on a 3rd read is that a villager would always RB a mafia read as the best mechanical play @MacDougall please confirm me that a player with 5 years game experience would chases mafia and not 3rds in N1.
Choosing from Mac's reads exactly the 3rd part read is not only antitown, it's what mafia would do because they fear the most 3rds abilities who can cause a lot of harm to the wolves.

The LMFAO is added artificially to make the post appealing and coming like from an unstressed player, but i feel it fake and added to hide the awkward target of someone who should not be targeted by a town out of common sense.

The line of scum reads is performative and pushes Scotty who we know now is villager.

Dkkoba is mafia because from all Mac's reads they targeted the 3rd part read and made the post like an excuse. The last line is added to show themselves as solvy but is in fact a hidden push for Scotty. Idk what does for Sig but this is a concern after Dkkoba will flip.

That would be the proof number 2

[Ruri]

Voting Koba.

[Ruri]

Koba/Radishes/Made? They're all kinda slankerish. Maybe add Syn/Bo into it.

[Michelle]

when people try to pretend to scumread me off 1-2 posts because they slip via reasoning that is clearly reubutted in my ISO >>>>>>>>>>

After i started to suspect them and also receiving heat from other players (tutuu, Sig) Dkkoba posts this.

'try to pretend to scumread me' is an offensive defence, implying everyone who SR them is wrong and all.
Now starts the long fight we had and who has a time out proposed by me.

I will not continue to comment on their Iso, as the evidence I have posted so far is enough to expose Dkkoba as a wolf and I have a limited life in this game, so I will try to obtain more reads.

[Michelle]

Koba/Radishes/Made? They're all kinda slankerish. Maybe add Syn/Bo into it.

Looks easy, but yes, probably. One deep wolf can be

I should be able to read Bo if he posts.

[Ruri]

Deepwolf options aren't much.

Scotty and Mac are conf!town.
Michelle should be self-resolving.
Tutuu was suggesting they be voted off instead of desperado'd.
Rondo is currently a top-poster, and still new to forum mafia, I think. So that could mean they're likely too new to be wolfing at this point.

[Michelle]

Wiki helps
'Witcher, a translation of the word vedmak, a "male witch" in Slavic mythology'

Pay attention, that could be dangerous!

ur not wrong lol. to answer you question, I am town this game, yes. if scum are witches, i am not a witch

Made's start is pocket-y and my impression is he wants to derp clear himself by this post.
Intentionally derps attempts are not towny from what i know