Scotty wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 5:50 pm
Ill keep pondering this, but If dyson is telling truth, we’ve solved the game, because there’s no point of a wolf dyson listing those names, because it only buys him so much time before we realize he’s lying.
Confirmed Town:
-Dyson
-Scotty
-Rondo
-Ilario
Presumed town:
-jack
-Ender
POE:
-Gavial
-falcon
-TSP
It's D3 and we have 4 confirmed town? What's the criteria?
Dyson claims to have an ability that lets him target 3 players on N2 and the host confirms if all or town or nah. He targeted the other members of the “confirmed town” list and got back all were town.
Dyson isn’t confirmed town. The other 3 are confirmed town upon a Dyson townflip.
Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 5:50 pm
Literally, that’s one of the two way the power works so I don’t see how it can be a real power that Martin didn’t foresee possibly returning this result.
Well, the odds are actually not fantastic to return a positive except just by picking the top town names. Say dyson had picked anyone in the POE, returned negative, the ability is shit because plausible deniability in all 3 of the targets. Renders the role almost useless. Finding all 3 town is helpful for clearing.
I mean, it’s still really powerful.
Target 3 towncore = confirmed towncore or confirmed deepwolf
Target 2 towncore and 1 poe = basically a check on the poe person
The ability is only shit if you target 3 sus players and get back that they aren’t all town. Even if you do that, there’s a slim chance of getting back they’re all town, which is also really powerful.
Or that there could be a mole in the towncore. Still would risk a couple mislynches
Yeah but suppose you target like Scotty, Lime, Falcon and get there’s a wolf.
Yeet Falcon and he flips town.
Now that’s mechanical confirmation that at least one of 2 towncore members is a wolf, which is pretty good. You were gonna flip Falcon anyway.
Btw, these yeet orders that end with Ender….unless I did math wrong, we’ve got too many yeets because F3 is Jack/Ender/??? Assuming of course that there aren’t 2 wolves in Jack/Ender/???
I made them with the idea that I get yeeted at f3.
We can only trust the truth. Everything else is a lie.
Scotty wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 5:50 pm
Ill keep pondering this, but If dyson is telling truth, we’ve solved the game, because there’s no point of a wolf dyson listing those names, because it only buys him so much time before we realize he’s lying.
Confirmed Town:
-Dyson
-Scotty
-Rondo
-Ilario
Presumed town:
-jack
-Ender
POE:
-Gavial
-falcon
-TSP
Yeh. Suppose Dyson is telling the truth and no further kills are blocked.
That’s final 3 of Jack/Ender/Tony (maybe not Tony).
That’s not like an impossible scenario for the wolves but it is one where the wolves have to kill a mechanically confirmed player 3 nights in a row.
For Dyson to be telling the truth, I’ve been pocketed by a wolf who specifically isn’t Ilario, Scotty or Rondo and Martin put that ability in this game. Looking at 2 of Falcon, Gavil, Tony, Ender. And Falcon is kinda antialigned with Tony and Gavil.
For Dyson to be lying, Dyson just has to be lying.
Scotty wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 5:50 pm
Ill keep pondering this, but If dyson is telling truth, we’ve solved the game, because there’s no point of a wolf dyson listing those names, because it only buys him so much time before we realize he’s lying.
Confirmed Town:
-Dyson
-Scotty
-Rondo
-Ilario
Presumed town:
-jack
-Ender
POE:
-Gavial
-falcon
-TSP
It's D3 and we have 4 confirmed town? What's the criteria?
Dyson claims to have an ability that lets him target 3 players on N2 and the host confirms if all or town or nah. He targeted the other members of the “confirmed town” list and got back all were town.
Dyson isn’t confirmed town. The other 3 are confirmed town upon a Dyson townflip.
Then we flip Dyson. Otherwise it's never going to be resolved
I have reason to believe Falcon is town.
Vote Dyson for Alignment Confirmation or TSP.
I’m still quite busy so on times where I can’t respond that much you can expect an image as your answer (and I might just randomly post a picture here and there.)
Gavial wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 7:29 pm
I have reason to believe Falcon is town.
Vote Dyson for Alignment Confirmation or TSP.
I’m still quite busy so on times where I can’t respond that much you can expect an image as your answer (and I might just randomly post a picture here and there.)
Scotty wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 7:02 pm
Tsp/falcon team
Is my guess
No Falcon is Town.
I think it’s Jack and TSP.
So jack was the killer then in your mind?
Hot take
I believe as such yes.
I can see it either way because Jack would be the correct kill to make for scum but at the same time Jack would most likely be the one killing because he’s least likely to be targeted by RB. (Although if that’s the case he didn’t consider the fact Jailkeeper can exist lol.)
Gavial wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 8:00 pm
After Dyson flips. If he flips Green then chances are Scum will kill 1 of the 3 players confirmed, probably Scotty.
This leaves us with the remaining:
Myself (Which I am town)
Falcon (Town)
Ender (High probability at being Town)
Lime Coke (CW to Sean)
TSP (Went from Town to Scum for me very quickly when Nanook flipped Green)
Jack (I think he voted Sean for credit and since Sean was dead either way)
Gavial wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 8:00 pm
After Dyson flips. If he flips Green then chances are Scum will kill 1 of the 3 players confirmed, probably Scotty.
This leaves us with the remaining:
Myself (Which I am town)
Falcon (Town)
Ender (High probability at being Town)
Lime Coke (CW to Sean)
TSP (Went from Town to Scum for me very quickly when Nanook flipped Green)
Jack (I think he voted Sean for credit and since Sean was dead either way)
so you're saying Day 1 (which was between Lime and Sean as a vote) Sean picked to keep LC alive? Is it possible he has a power that was less important than seans? You are saying we had w/w trains day 1 and Jack chose the lesser of two evils?
Gavial wrote: ↑Tue Aug 31, 2021 8:00 pm
After Dyson flips. If he flips Green then chances are Scum will kill 1 of the 3 players confirmed, probably Scotty.
This leaves us with the remaining:
Myself (Which I am town)
Falcon (Town)
Ender (High probability at being Town)
Lime Coke (CW to Sean)
TSP (Went from Town to Scum for me very quickly when Nanook flipped Green)
Jack (I think he voted Sean for credit and since Sean was dead either way)
