The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[tutuu]

Who was the most obvious kill N2? Who did you all expect to see dead at SOD3?

you and/or scotty. there is no consensus towncore that doesn't rely on mech. it's a bit disorganized

[Michelle]

Michelle is obvious town right?

i think so, i've never seen her scum, i don't know how much should i be scared of it. poison (iirc) townreads michelle and they have experience with each other, mac townread michelle, koba flip flopped between having michelle as top town and having michelle as top scumread

her role ability, from a standard game design perspective makes more sense as town than as scum too. unless scum have multiple abilities in the same role. (her role ability is undisclosed, we cautious around anti claim)

Michelle is widely seen as a polarized player. Her scum game is not super mega blindingly obvious, but it has clear issues with tonal awkwardness, struggling to post, and TMI, especially on her partners (she ends up voting them a lot and is a chronic busser D1 even when it's unecessary). Mac has a good read on Michelle and I will sheep him there as well as the three points I listed.

I will put this in my sig when the game ends.

Thanks for your thoughts Alison

[Michelle]

[VOTE: Made ] aubergine

I have to sleep, see you in the morning

Made said close to Eod that if me/Dkkoba are villagers he don't know what to do in this game, or something similar, i say this from the top of my head.

[Alison]

Who was the most obvious kill N2? Who did you all expect to see dead at SOD3?

you and/or scotty. there is no consensus towncore that doesn't rely on mech. it's a bit disorganized

ok. Then maybe Mac or Scotty suddenly developed a read that made the mafia fear them and that's why they stopped doc dodging.

[Alison]

Eh or maybe they doc dodged Mac assuming doctor would protect Mac, and then they shot at my slot N2 thinking doctor is nonconsecutive, but doctor 500 IQ'd them.

[Alison]

[VOTE: Made] aubergine

[Alison]

I skimmed falcon's iso and I think he looks fine tonally.

[TonyStarkPrime]

@TonyStarkPrime Hardclaim if you have a green on sig.

There shouldn't be this much confusion about how serious people's mech claims are on D3.

I do of course I do smh I’m tsp I’m not stupid

[Alison]

I'm literally just here to say Mac that was a dumb move to make

NOBODY ELSE CLAIM

there is obviously some sort of soup role given what Jay said in the rules like seriously. We gonna have a repeat of last game where mafia soups everyone and wins.

It was worth it cuz of the meme tbh.

I mean, he says its for the memes but is there a world where a wolf has a role where he can fake claim inno child with a mod backup? :think: Its ballsy but I still think Mac is inno town till someone else has the same thought as me, this is tinfoil for day 3 or something

Rondo is now permanently POE'd for this post.

[Alison]

Wilgy is probably outed scum because dyachei and DkKoba got mischopped over him. In what world does that happen if Wilgy is town?

[Alison]

I gutread Ender town. So townlean but I don't actually have strong evidence to support it. Just a tonal thing from an ISO skim.

Let me know if you have evidence on Ender's alignment either way because Day 3 is a little late to be making tonal gutreads. But I am not reading 100 pages so.

[Alison]

It's my girlfriend's birthday so not gonna be around that much for the rest of the day. Peace.

@Made Ping me with your defense.

[DrWilgy]

Michelle is obvious town right?

I think so

[DrWilgy]

I'm literally just here to say Mac that was a dumb move to make

NOBODY ELSE CLAIM

there is obviously some sort of soup role given what Jay said in the rules like seriously. We gonna have a repeat of last game where mafia soups everyone and wins.

It was worth it cuz of the meme tbh.

I mean, he says its for the memes but is there a world where a wolf has a role where he can fake claim inno child with a mod backup? :think: Its ballsy but I still think Mac is inno town till someone else has the same thought as me, this is tinfoil for day 3 or something

Rondo is now permanently POE'd for this post.

Bad take. Rondo is town.

[DrWilgy]

Wilgy is probably outed scum because dyachei and DkKoba got mischopped over him. In what world does that happen if Wilgy is town?

Wat?

[DrWilgy]

What if it's just BoSyn after all

yea if BoSyn and Made are both town i just don't know what's life

This

[RondoDimBuckle]

Michelle is obvious town right?

Disagree with premise that a wolf cant be poisoned and stick to their guns till they flip

[RondoDimBuckle]

I'm literally just here to say Mac that was a dumb move to make

NOBODY ELSE CLAIM

there is obviously some sort of soup role given what Jay said in the rules like seriously. We gonna have a repeat of last game where mafia soups everyone and wins.

It was worth it cuz of the meme tbh.

I mean, he says its for the memes but is there a world where a wolf has a role where he can fake claim inno child with a mod backup? :think: Its ballsy but I still think Mac is inno town till someone else has the same thought as me, this is tinfoil for day 3 or something

Rondo is now permanently POE'd for this post.

if you read later I was being dumb and ender explains it

Votes start of day

Spoiler: show

112
0
No votes
Voters: None
Alison
0
No votes
Voters: None
BoKnows
0
No votes
Voters: None
DrWilgy
0
No votes
Voters: None
EnderWiggin
0
No votes
Voters: None
Epignosis
1
9%
Voters: Urist
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
Made
3
27%
Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Scotty
MasterRadishes
0
No votes
Voters: None
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
0
No votes
Voters: None
Poison
0
No votes
Voters: None
RondoDimBuckle
0
No votes
Voters: None
Ruri
0
No votes
Voters: None
Scotty
0
No votes
Voters: None
sig
0
No votes
Voters: None
TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes
Voters: None
tutuu
0
No votes
Voters: None
Urist
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Vote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Lynch
0
No votes

[RondoDimBuckle]

I gutread Ender town. So townlean but I don't actually have strong evidence to support it. Just a tonal thing from an ISO skim.

Let me know if you have evidence on Ender's alignment either way because Day 3 is a little late to be making tonal gutreads. But I am not reading 100 pages so.

oh no, I wont fight you on it but there be dragons

[falcon45ca]

I'm literally just here to say Mac that was a dumb move to make

NOBODY ELSE CLAIM

there is obviously some sort of soup role given what Jay said in the rules like seriously. We gonna have a repeat of last game where mafia soups everyone and wins.

It was worth it cuz of the meme tbh.

I mean, he says its for the memes but is there a world where a wolf has a role where he can fake claim inno child with a mod backup? :think: Its ballsy but I still think Mac is inno town till someone else has the same thought as me, this is tinfoil for day 3 or something

Rondo is now permanently POE'd for this post.

Bad take. Rondo is town.

Why is Rondo town? I don't understand why you've got such confidence on his slot

[falcon45ca]

The no kill is nice but I am currently doubting everything I think I know.

Spicy. What new ideas inspire you?


Cuz this kind of attitude isn't what I normally expect from towny MR...you mention BK, any other takes?

[Made]

Okay, so yesterday was literally worst-case scenario in terms of flips. Michelle should have died, I should have died. This is awful

[Made]

Okay, so I softed my role enough times this game so I'll just say it straight, I can't die. My role is that I can't died. I can't be vigged, I can't be nk, I can't be voted out. My plan, my hope was that me dying yesterday would set up thread where Michelle has flipped, so no question mark there, I flip so no question mark here, and DK could be solved based on how my wagon was handled. Basically voting me is a slightly worse No yeet

I think the fact that tutuu is voting me here is horseshit considering she said that I'm scum if DK is scum.

also Hi Alison

[falcon45ca]

Okay, so yesterday was literally worst-case scenario in terms of flips. Michelle should have died, I should have died. This is awful

You think you should've died...why didn't you vote yourself then?


Why aren't you happy nobody died last night? Seems a bit odd if ya ask me

[Made]

OH THANK GOD Alison replaced Mac. If I had to solve for her in this cluster, my head would explode

[Made]

Okay, so yesterday was literally worst-case scenario in terms of flips. Michelle should have died, I should have died. This is awful

You think you should've died...why didn't you vote yourself then?


Why aren't you happy nobody died last night? Seems a bit odd if ya ask me

you can't self vote this game, and I didn't see that no one died until I sent that. too busy being annoyed about the fact that I'm alive

[Made]

Okay, so yesterday was literally worst-case scenario in terms of flips. Michelle should have died, I should have died. This is awful

You think you should've died...why didn't you vote yourself then?


Why aren't you happy nobody died last night? Seems a bit odd if ya ask me

Also, when I left thread with a minute left, I was dying, the Nook and someone else voted to save me

[falcon45ca]

Okay, so I softed my role enough times this game so I'll just say it straight, I can't die. My role is that I can't died. I can't be vigged, I can't be nk, I can't be voted out. My plan, my hope was that me dying yesterday would set up thread where Michelle has flipped, so no question mark there, I flip so no question mark here, and DK could be solved based on how my wagon was handled. Basically voting me is a slightly worse No yeet

I think the fact that tutuu is voting me here is horseshit considering she said that I'm scum if DK is scum.

also Hi Alison

What? You're immortal!


Like Highlander immortal, or is it more like Interview with a Vampire immortal?

[Made]

Okay, so I softed my role enough times this game so I'll just say it straight, I can't die. My role is that I can't died. I can't be vigged, I can't be nk, I can't be voted out. My plan, my hope was that me dying yesterday would set up thread where Michelle has flipped, so no question mark there, I flip so no question mark here, and DK could be solved based on how my wagon was handled. Basically voting me is a slightly worse No yeet

I think the fact that tutuu is voting me here is horseshit considering she said that I'm scum if DK is scum.

also Hi Alison

What? You're immortal!


Like Highlander immortal, or is it more like Interview with a Vampire immortal?

Marvel's the watcher immortal

[Made]

while scum is in discord figuring out what to do with this information, i'mma just go head and

[VOTE: Tutuu] aubergine

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Okay, so I softed my role enough times this game so I'll just say it straight, I can't die. My role is that I can't died. I can't be vigged, I can't be nk, I can't be voted out. My plan, my hope was that me dying yesterday would set up thread where Michelle has flipped, so no question mark there, I flip so no question mark here, and DK could be solved based on how my wagon was handled. Basically voting me is a slightly worse No yeet

I think the fact that tutuu is voting me here is horseshit considering she said that I'm scum if DK is scum.

also Hi Alison

Character claim

[Made]

Okay, so I softed my role enough times this game so I'll just say it straight, I can't die. My role is that I can't died. I can't be vigged, I can't be nk, I can't be voted out. My plan, my hope was that me dying yesterday would set up thread where Michelle has flipped, so no question mark there, I flip so no question mark here, and DK could be solved based on how my wagon was handled. Basically voting me is a slightly worse No yeet

I think the fact that tutuu is voting me here is horseshit considering she said that I'm scum if DK is scum.

also Hi Alison

Character claim

no

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I wish you'd said this yesterday I would've just stayed put to test it

[Made]

Do you even know the Witcher like that?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean I don't really believe you and I think we should always test it

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Do you even know the Witcher like that?

I know a bit

[Made]

I wish you'd said this yesterday I would've just stayed put to test it

It's why I did all the fun Kang stuff yesterday. you ruined the payout

[Made]

payoff, but w/e

[Made]

I also couldn't in good conscious try to get myself chopped more hardly in case Dk was actually Scum

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean you could've prevented a wasted day by just saying it yesterday lol, and I don't really understand what the point of not saying it then but saying it now is

[Made]

GTH, Michelle was healed by scum. No way town saves her here

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Id probably save her tbh

[Made]

I mean you could've prevented a wasted day by just saying it yesterday lol, and I don't really understand what the point of not saying it then but saying it now is

you could have not changed your vote :P. There's no point arguing that bit now imo

[Made]

I'm not playing optimal rn, I'm a bit tilted. But knowing yesterday was 2 v 2 means we're off, and I don't really know how to proceed. Is there a world where town uses a potion to save on Michelle?

[Made]

Town v Town, not 2 v 2. My brain is mush,

[Scotty]

GTH, Michelle was healed by scum. No way town saves her here

Id probably save her tbh

Case and point

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean you could've prevented a wasted day by just saying it yesterday lol, and I don't really understand what the point of not saying it then but saying it now is

you could have not changed your vote :P. There's no point arguing that bit now imo

Thats not really a valid argument, I had no way of knowing you'd claim this lol

[Scotty]

[VOTE: Bo] aubergine

Because why not

[Scotty]

There are some deep manipulators out there and it’s gonna take some digging to find you in your little mole holes

And unfortunately because there’s like 5-6 of you, you’re all free to scum read each other for evidence later and we’ll be none the wiser. Might have to take this day by day

[Made]

I mean you could've prevented a wasted day by just saying it yesterday lol, and I don't really understand what the point of not saying it then but saying it now is

you could have not changed your vote :P. There's no point arguing that bit now imo

Thats not really a valid argument, I had no way of knowing you'd claim this lol

it's not. I had no way to know you'd switch votes either though is all i'm saying