The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[Alison]

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Scotty and epi are both mafia imo

Why Scotty?

His posts reek of mafia

u think that scum dayvig epi shot ted with split second timing right at the moment he claimed he's desperado shooting scotty? that would be cool af if it happened NGL

No I do not

[tutuu]

ooooh bet

made u aint immortal fam u shoulda said so heheh :P

u dead af, u just get to chat

iight, i buy it tbh.

[Alison]

Some dick roleblocked me

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

:think:

[VOTE: Urist ] aubergine

You forgot to vote in the poll.

[tutuu]

[VOTE: urist] aubergine

[tutuu]

have we not had a single wolf wagon all game literrally lmaoooooo

[Urist]

Some dick roleblocked me

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

Yes i'm playing 11d chess and claimed being rb'd after carrying the kill
Plus town has a second rb for some reason good thinking scotty

Point 1) is worthless to me. If you kept quiet about it the real roleblocker would immediately out you. Your only hope is to do what a townie would do and claim it. Therefore you would claim rb'd as either mafia or town.

Point 2) is eh. Could be a jailkeeper. Could be a JOAT with a single roleblock. Could be some weird mech shit. We have someone claiming to be literally unkillable, why can't we have 2 roleblockers?

So technically all i know is that my action was not successful. I'm assuming blocked for no real reason tbh since it is role madness and maybe the person I targeted was just actionimmune.

If I were mafia carrying the kill then I would have no reason to claim; the kill could have been prevented in any number of ways and there would be no reason to draw attention to myself.

[Alison]

Actually one thing that gives credibility to Made's role was that he misrepresented it as immortality when it was very clearly a tree stump. And he didn't know what tree stumps were.

It's weird for Made as mafia to make up a fake claim about being a tree stump and misrep it as immortality; it's more likely that JPIC knew about tree stumps, made a tree stump role, and gave it to Made who misnomered it.

It could be that Made changed his story after backlash but I don't think that's likely. It looked like a genuine misunderstanding. And I don't think a mafia tree stump is likely because it creates perverse incentives (optimal play is to spam the thread and lolcat all game and nobody wants that shit).

[Alison]

Are blocks loud this game? Did Poison get an explicit message saying she was blocked or did her action just quietly fail?

[Urist]

Are blocks loud this game? Did Poison get an explicit message saying she was blocked or did her action just quietly fail?

Everyone is told whether their action is successful regardless of what type of action it is.

[Alison]

Some dick roleblocked me

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

Yes i'm playing 11d chess and claimed being rb'd after carrying the kill
Plus town has a second rb for some reason good thinking scotty

Point 1) is worthless to me. If you kept quiet about it the real roleblocker would immediately out you. Your only hope is to do what a townie would do and claim it. Therefore you would claim rb'd as either mafia or town.

Point 2) is eh. Could be a jailkeeper. Could be a JOAT with a single roleblock. Could be some weird mech shit. We have someone claiming to be literally unkillable, why can't we have 2 roleblockers?

So technically all i know is that my action was not successful. I'm assuming blocked for no real reason tbh since it is role madness and maybe the person I targeted was just actionimmune.

If I were mafia carrying the kill then I would have no reason to claim; the kill could have been prevented in any number of ways and there would be no reason to draw attention to myself.

There is 0 chance a roleblocker who got a block off doesn't claim in this situation lol. And then you get turbo'd if you kept mum about the rb.

Who did your target with your ability?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Tree stump is considerably different from being immortal and much more believable yeah

Be clear when claiming guys

[tutuu]

Are blocks loud this game? Did Poison get an explicit message saying she was blocked or did her action just quietly fail?

they are SUPER loud

actually dont remember for @Poison

but koba received feedback that their roleblock was successful. (successfuly blocked an action? im assuming? as opposed to koba not being roleblocked? not sure if it was elaborated)

[tutuu]

Are blocks loud this game? Did Poison get an explicit message saying she was blocked or did her action just quietly fail?

Everyone is told whether their action is successful regardless of what type of action it is.

oh interesting

[Urist]

I'm just gonna claim because i stopped giving a fuck a long time ago. I'm a straightup doctor and I protected ted n1 and scotty n2. If someone else could have prevented the kill they should claim now bc they are probably the reason.

[tutuu]

rondo feels like mafia to me. can we kill him?

[Urist]

Killing top posters is protown

[tutuu]

I'm just gonna claim because i stopped giving a fuck a long time ago. I'm a straightup doctor and I protected ted n1 and scotty n2. If someone else could have prevented the kill they should claim now bc they are probably the reason.

so your action failed on scotty...

so like ... scotty was communed?

or like. a person targeted scotty, stopping all actions that targeted him. mayhaps?

[Urist]

But i'm just going to stay on epi or tutuu forever until either they're dead or i am

[tutuu]

[VOTE: rondo] aubergine

[Alison]

I'm just gonna claim because i stopped giving a fuck a long time ago. I'm a straightup doctor and I protected ted n1 and scotty n2. If someone else could have prevented the kill they should claim now bc they are probably the reason.

Interesting claim.

Kind of believable because it restricts your options even more. Claiming doctor means you can't turn around and say "hey, the doctor must have protected the mafia NK, the roleblock on me wasn't why there was no kill".

But it does open up the question, if you are town doctor why was there no kill? Roleblocker was on you; you didn't heal anyone because you were roleblocked. I doubt there are that many ways for town to stop the NK.

[Made]

Show me the receipts of you softing your role as well as you setting up town to get maximum information from your "exe".

Spoiler: show

@Made from ur last 10 games here do u remember how many times were u mischopped D1-D2?

If the number is high i think its adequate to give him a d1 pass guys, its a big game with a lot of scum, its not cool to keep mischopping the same guy, it feels rude and made is a very chill dude, if it was anyone else in his shoes they'd be showing off their temper i think

(Thats only if the number is high like 6+. If the number is low disregard this post and carry on)

ehh, i don't remember. I'm cool being chopped early tho, it's a rushhh.

The day is ending Saturday tho right? I might be afk most of tomorrow

So I talked it over with JPIC last night, and we decided that in the interest of chill vibes, I will be immortal this game. All attempts to remove me from this game will be met with looks of disapproval.

i think made is a lot more under the radar than i remember him being when i rolled scum against him.

I have a pocket slanky town meta I pull out every once and a while. This is one of those times. I don't think i'm needed yet, so no point in cluttering thread

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

by finding and pushing mafia while you're alive

silly mac, I worked it out with Jpic, I'm immortal again this game

made wont talk abt me because they are trying to fake spew me as scum

I kinda read this thought as town tho tbh. Not cuz it's particularly towny, but it's pretty fun to imagine coming up with this thought as scum

i don't even know why made has votes tbh

Then vote koba didnt u sr them

If town let you live d3 they deserve to lose

I am unkillable, unlynchable, immune to poison dayvig arson and even unmodkillable.

lol same

me on the way to the gallows

Gotcha. And @TonyStarkPrime

what are you thoughts on me over Dk?

also @RondoDimBuckle while we're vibing waiting for the flip. Where are you at on me?

Made promises to push Epi tomorrow
Hell even I promise to push Epi tomorrow if we chop Koba

it's a bad idea for thread state, trust me

when is nightfall? busy for like 30 mins and then should have time to be in the thread for a while

7 min

jynx

@RondoDimBuckle answer my question nerd :P

why are you voting me?

Made, any last words I guess?

I'm going into a meeting so no time to review proper, but it's been great playing with you all. I don't think this game is lost. I recently quoted all of my most recent takes. Do with them what you will.

And beyond all else...

read all that, have the context that John's Major's character doesn't really "die" and imagine how GANGSTER my flip would of been @Alison


@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME ur the worst (but also, not actually, but also who was the other person who changed their vote last second???)

[Alison]

But i'm just going to stay on epi or tutuu forever until either they're dead or i am

I am not voting Epi unless there is a dayvig counterclaim.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Some dick roleblocked me

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

:think:

[VOTE: Urist ] aubergine

You forgot to vote in the poll.

thanks, busy day

[Alison]

@Made Is the character you're referring to the guy in the gifs? Which character is it? I want to look through the wiki and see if it matches up.

[Urist]

But i'm just going to stay on epi or tutuu forever until either they're dead or i am

I am not voting Epi unless there is a dayvig counterclaim.

So you think that the evil witch hunter flavoured dayvig is a town vig when town has a separate dayvig
Alright

[Alison]

Some dick roleblocked me

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

:think:

[VOTE: Urist ] aubergine

You forgot to vote in the poll.

thanks, busy day

I see you are now voting me.

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

Urist and Made might both be town. Let's vote Rondo off.

[Made]

@Made Is the character you're referring to the guy in the gifs? Which character is it? I want to look through the wiki and see if it matches up.

Actually spoilers probably

Spoiler: show

https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom. ... ho_Remains

[Alison]

But i'm just going to stay on epi or tutuu forever until either they're dead or i am

I am not voting Epi unless there is a dayvig counterclaim.

So you think that the evil witch hunter flavoured dayvig is a town vig when town has a separate dayvig
Alright

I can buy that there's a dayvig and a desperado in the same game yes.

I also don't think scum dayvig Epi blasts Axe D1 and then claims/softs it.

[RondoDimBuckle]

But i'm just going to stay on epi or tutuu forever until either they're dead or i am

rondo feels like mafia to me. can we kill him?

I'm just gonna claim because i stopped giving a fuck a long time ago. I'm a straightup doctor and I protected ted n1 and scotty n2. If someone else could have prevented the kill they should claim now bc they are probably the reason.

[VOTE: tutuu ] aubergine

[tutuu]

i have a confident guess at made's character (if he's town) but is it wise to say it out loud?

[Made]

I could see rondo here too
[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Show me the receipts of you softing your role as well as you setting up town to get maximum information from your "exe".

Spoiler: show

@Made from ur last 10 games here do u remember how many times were u mischopped D1-D2?

If the number is high i think its adequate to give him a d1 pass guys, its a big game with a lot of scum, its not cool to keep mischopping the same guy, it feels rude and made is a very chill dude, if it was anyone else in his shoes they'd be showing off their temper i think

(Thats only if the number is high like 6+. If the number is low disregard this post and carry on)

ehh, i don't remember. I'm cool being chopped early tho, it's a rushhh.

The day is ending Saturday tho right? I might be afk most of tomorrow

So I talked it over with JPIC last night, and we decided that in the interest of chill vibes, I will be immortal this game. All attempts to remove me from this game will be met with looks of disapproval.

i think made is a lot more under the radar than i remember him being when i rolled scum against him.

I have a pocket slanky town meta I pull out every once and a while. This is one of those times. I don't think i'm needed yet, so no point in cluttering thread

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

by finding and pushing mafia while you're alive

silly mac, I worked it out with Jpic, I'm immortal again this game

made wont talk abt me because they are trying to fake spew me as scum

I kinda read this thought as town tho tbh. Not cuz it's particularly towny, but it's pretty fun to imagine coming up with this thought as scum

i don't even know why made has votes tbh

Then vote koba didnt u sr them

If town let you live d3 they deserve to lose

I am unkillable, unlynchable, immune to poison dayvig arson and even unmodkillable.

lol same

me on the way to the gallows

Gotcha. And @TonyStarkPrime

what are you thoughts on me over Dk?

also @RondoDimBuckle while we're vibing waiting for the flip. Where are you at on me?

Made promises to push Epi tomorrow
Hell even I promise to push Epi tomorrow if we chop Koba

it's a bad idea for thread state, trust me

when is nightfall? busy for like 30 mins and then should have time to be in the thread for a while

7 min

jynx

@RondoDimBuckle answer my question nerd :P

why are you voting me?

Made, any last words I guess?

I'm going into a meeting so no time to review proper, but it's been great playing with you all. I don't think this game is lost. I recently quoted all of my most recent takes. Do with them what you will.

And beyond all else...

read all that, have the context that John's Major's character doesn't really "die" and imagine how GANGSTER my flip would of been @Alison


@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME ur the worst (but also, not actually, but also who was the other person who changed their vote last second???)

Dunno

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

[VOTE: epi] aubergine

[tutuu]

Show me the receipts of you softing your role as well as you setting up town to get maximum information from your "exe".

Spoiler: show

@Made from ur last 10 games here do u remember how many times were u mischopped D1-D2?

If the number is high i think its adequate to give him a d1 pass guys, its a big game with a lot of scum, its not cool to keep mischopping the same guy, it feels rude and made is a very chill dude, if it was anyone else in his shoes they'd be showing off their temper i think

(Thats only if the number is high like 6+. If the number is low disregard this post and carry on)

ehh, i don't remember. I'm cool being chopped early tho, it's a rushhh.

The day is ending Saturday tho right? I might be afk most of tomorrow

So I talked it over with JPIC last night, and we decided that in the interest of chill vibes, I will be immortal this game. All attempts to remove me from this game will be met with looks of disapproval.

i think made is a lot more under the radar than i remember him being when i rolled scum against him.

I have a pocket slanky town meta I pull out every once and a while. This is one of those times. I don't think i'm needed yet, so no point in cluttering thread

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

by finding and pushing mafia while you're alive

silly mac, I worked it out with Jpic, I'm immortal again this game

made wont talk abt me because they are trying to fake spew me as scum

I kinda read this thought as town tho tbh. Not cuz it's particularly towny, but it's pretty fun to imagine coming up with this thought as scum

i don't even know why made has votes tbh

Then vote koba didnt u sr them

If town let you live d3 they deserve to lose

I am unkillable, unlynchable, immune to poison dayvig arson and even unmodkillable.

lol same

me on the way to the gallows

Gotcha. And @TonyStarkPrime

what are you thoughts on me over Dk?

also @RondoDimBuckle while we're vibing waiting for the flip. Where are you at on me?

Made promises to push Epi tomorrow
Hell even I promise to push Epi tomorrow if we chop Koba

it's a bad idea for thread state, trust me

when is nightfall? busy for like 30 mins and then should have time to be in the thread for a while

7 min

jynx

@RondoDimBuckle answer my question nerd :P

why are you voting me?

Made, any last words I guess?

I'm going into a meeting so no time to review proper, but it's been great playing with you all. I don't think this game is lost. I recently quoted all of my most recent takes. Do with them what you will.

And beyond all else...

read all that, have the context that John's Major's character doesn't really "die" and imagine how GANGSTER my flip would of been @Alison


@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME ur the worst (but also, not actually, but also who was the other person who changed their vote last second???)

twas urist

[RondoDimBuckle]

Some dick roleblocked me

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

:think:

[VOTE: Urist ] aubergine

You forgot to vote in the poll.

thanks, busy day

I see you are now voting me.

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

Urist and Made might both be town. Let's vote Rondo off.

I was joking jeez

[RondoDimBuckle]

Alison read through my ISO. I have been sheeping mac's vote since he claimed why would I want to off you?

[EnderWiggin]

My first thought is they messed up on a soup kill

There's usually a cost to failing a soup kill so no.

Why would you go to this?

[Alison]

So I read the receipts. Posting gifs of some random Marvel character to prepare a fake soft of tree stump in a Witcher themed game is something I don't think Made would do as scum. The softs were also persistent and obvious enough that I don't think it was him just grabbing some vague BS and claiming it was a soft. The "let me die so we can solve the game off my flip" approach is something I have seen him do as town as well.

I believe Made's tree stump claim and since I think tree stump is usually town this means Made is probably town and we should look at the wagons with the knowledge that koba/Made were both town.

tutuu's progression on Made is kinda sketchy given that. She is happy to sheep me on him at first but then suddenly expresses cold feet and says Made is town before he clarifies he is tree stump. Could be TMI/wanting to distance herself from the wagon while happily sheeping me for a free misexe at first.

Urist is more likely town since his doc claim seems unlikely to come from mafia because it limits his options and I think it will be obvious he isn't a doc sooner or later if he is lying. Going to the effort of drumming up a CFD seems weird when the wagons are T/T as well especially since you know you will take heat off it. Nanook's posting today has been a little townie and he has the unnecessary CFD to his credit I suppose.

[Made]

This doesn't help my case, but as scum I would definitely misconstrue being immortal for being a treestump. I enjoy claiming immortality and doing so is NAI

[Alison]

Alison read through my ISO. I have been sheeping mac's vote since he claimed why would I want to off you?

I am voting you because you have been using your memes/jokes as an excuse to behave in blatantly disruptive and anti-town ways. You are acting like a jester and since I don't think you are actually a jester the next most likely possibility is that you are mafia trying to ride TWTBAW reads by acting like a jester.

[Made]

So I read the receipts. Posting gifs of some random Marvel character to prepare a fake soft of tree stump in a Witcher themed game is something I don't think Made would do as scum. The softs were also persistent and obvious enough that I don't think it was him just grabbing some vague BS and claiming it was a soft. The "let me die so we can solve the game off my flip" approach is something I have seen him do as town as well.

I believe Made's tree stump claim and since I think tree stump is usually town this means Made is probably town and we should look at the wagons with the knowledge that koba/Made were both town.

tutuu's progression on Made is kinda sketchy given that. She is happy to sheep me on him at first but then suddenly expresses cold feet and says Made is town before he clarifies he is tree stump. Could be TMI/wanting to distance herself from the wagon while happily sheeping me for a free misexe at first.

Urist is more likely town since his doc claim seems unlikely to come from mafia because it limits his options and I think it will be obvious he isn't a doc sooner or later if he is lying. Going to the effort of drumming up a CFD seems weird when the wagons are T/T as well especially since you know you will take heat off it. Nanook's posting today has been a little townie and he has the unnecessary CFD to his credit I suppose.

scum claims doctors to fish for a counterclaim. It's not unheard of, Michelle has done the same exact thing in Spiderman.

[RondoDimBuckle]

TWTBAW?

[Alison]

My first thought is they messed up on a soup kill

There's usually a cost to failing a soup kill so no.

Why would you go to this?

A cost such as not having an NK for that night, perhaps?

[tutuu]

So I read the receipts. Posting gifs of some random Marvel character to prepare a fake soft of tree stump in a Witcher themed game is something I don't think Made would do as scum. The softs were also persistent and obvious enough that I don't think it was him just grabbing some vague BS and claiming it was a soft. The "let me die so we can solve the game off my flip" approach is something I have seen him do as town as well.

I believe Made's tree stump claim and since I think tree stump is usually town this means Made is probably town and we should look at the wagons with the knowledge that koba/Made were both town.

tutuu's progression on Made is kinda sketchy given that. She is happy to sheep me on him at first but then suddenly expresses cold feet and says Made is town before he clarifies he is tree stump. Could be TMI/wanting to distance herself from the wagon while happily sheeping me for a free misexe at first.

Urist is more likely town since his doc claim seems unlikely to come from mafia because it limits his options and I think it will be obvious he isn't a doc sooner or later if he is lying. Going to the effort of drumming up a CFD seems weird when the wagons are T/T as well especially since you know you will take heat off it. Nanook's posting today has been a little townie and he has the unnecessary CFD to his credit I suppose.

i agree with all of that

(i expressed cold feet coz i believe all wild stuff. made claiming immortal was too wild for me so im like iight bet u gotta be town. but i understand)

im at like ....

rondo, ender. falcon? radish? 112? poison? for mafia candidates

[RondoDimBuckle]

Eh I am in too many games anyway. Dying today is a blessing

[Alison]

So I read the receipts. Posting gifs of some random Marvel character to prepare a fake soft of tree stump in a Witcher themed game is something I don't think Made would do as scum. The softs were also persistent and obvious enough that I don't think it was him just grabbing some vague BS and claiming it was a soft. The "let me die so we can solve the game off my flip" approach is something I have seen him do as town as well.

I believe Made's tree stump claim and since I think tree stump is usually town this means Made is probably town and we should look at the wagons with the knowledge that koba/Made were both town.

tutuu's progression on Made is kinda sketchy given that. She is happy to sheep me on him at first but then suddenly expresses cold feet and says Made is town before he clarifies he is tree stump. Could be TMI/wanting to distance herself from the wagon while happily sheeping me for a free misexe at first.

Urist is more likely town since his doc claim seems unlikely to come from mafia because it limits his options and I think it will be obvious he isn't a doc sooner or later if he is lying. Going to the effort of drumming up a CFD seems weird when the wagons are T/T as well especially since you know you will take heat off it. Nanook's posting today has been a little townie and he has the unnecessary CFD to his credit I suppose.

scum claims doctors to fish for a counterclaim. It's not unheard of, Michelle has done the same exact thing in Spiderman.

Actually you're right maybe Urist has just given up and decided to claim Doctor to draw out a PR claim.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Some dick roleblocked me

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

:think:

[VOTE: Urist ] aubergine

You forgot to vote in the poll.

thanks, busy day

I see you are now voting me.

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

Urist and Made might both be town. Let's vote Rondo off.

you forgot to vote in poll

[tutuu]

Some dick roleblocked me

[VOTE: Urist] aubergine

:think:

[VOTE: Urist ] aubergine

You forgot to vote in the poll.

thanks, busy day

I see you are now voting me.

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

Urist and Made might both be town. Let's vote Rondo off.

you forgot to vote in poll

LOL

[Alison]

I am probably clearing Urist too fast.

I do think being insistent on wanting Epi dead and repeating it even after he's "outed" is kinda townie.