Re-reading start of D2 for game flow, I think Urist looks scummiest probably, mostly due to
1. Urist starts the day saying that Gav might not be mafia based on NK.
2. When srceenplay says that NAA's change in votes at EOD1 looks bad for NAA, Urist sheeps that and agrees.
3. When srceenplay insinuates that Gav is still mafia, Urist decides to go back to scumreading Gav (#595 - Urist - scumteam is gavial/axehole/fingersplints) (this scum team is kinda wack, I gotta say)
4.
Urist wrote: ↑Thu Dec 02, 2021 7:16 pm
If Gavial were mafia I'd expect someone pushing him to be killed. And if not someone pushing him, probably not the person saying "yeah I think he's a PR" before he's even claimed PR.
I think this misrepresents LP's position on D1. She was one of the biggest pushers on Gav on D1, and her tinfoil hedge was that she thought he could be PR. I even asked her D1 why she was voting Gav despite thinking he could be a PR. She only changed her vote at the very last minute.
If srceenplay and Urist are both scum, Urist just continually sheeping srceenplay at SOD2 is kinda a weird wolf strat.
===
Comparing srceenplay and Urist's response to my question of "why do you think Gav is scum", I think Urist's is worse though srceenplay's is weak also.
Within this question, I'm not really looking for right or wrong answers that align with my own take on Gav.
- Urist's scumread on Gav is
(a) meta read: Gav is not doing his half-baked conspiracy theory thing that he does as town
(b) says Gav is obv wolf
TBH couldn't find much else on Urist's scumread. I think there's a distinct lack in pointing to specific things this game that he's doing that are scummy. Reads that aren't comprehensive tend to be scum indicative.
srceenplay's scumread on Gav is that Gav felt like he was flailing D1 and talks about his thought process D1, which is better.
I think I just find it weird that Gav's behavior checks a lot of the boxes of "conventional townie behavior" and all of that is ignored, especially if you are doing a semi-surface level read. I can understand LP's scumread on Gav since things were substantiated. But if you are just talking general behavior, I think 9 times out of 10, most people would townread Gav for being (1) solvie, (2) proactive, (3) scumhunting.