Clue: The Movie [Day 10]

#851

Matahari wrote:
Mister Rearranger wrote:SVS was The Motorist?! I miswrote her in my notes holy shit.

My entire reason I thought I could trust Epi all of a sudden was based on a stupid mistake I made.
Any possibility that you could say who you thought SVS was?

The telegrammer.

Sorry for my frustration last night. I've had a stressful week. Probably should have waited to vote instead of needing everyone else to join me on Bass action if I want to survive. Banking a 50/50 shot on him either being Boddy or the Chief is a lot to ask of people. But if he is the Chief, he's already outlived his usefulness anyways. I assure any other civs out there, I have not (entirely, lol).

#852

I made a slaphazard s.s., which leaves me with 3 ? marks, assuming certain players have been truthful. MR is a ?, Bass is an assumption of honesty. I should go ahead and vote, but I'm going to wait a bit longer.

#853

Boogs was here, but he didn't comment or vote ?????

#854

Matahari wrote:I made a slaphazard s.s., which leaves me with 3 ? marks, assuming certain players have been truthful. MR is a ?, Bass is an assumption of honesty. I should go ahead and vote, but I'm going to wait a bit longer.

Well that's unfortunate and I guess I'm out of the loop when it comes to why everyone seems to be making that assumption with Bass.

#855

I hope everyone else keeps in mind that Bass has not brought up a solution to why SVS was lynched instead of Nijii that jives with my understanding of the game so far. Nobody really has, but if he really switched the following day's lynch (MP to Nijii), then I have a very big unsolved mystery when it comes to SVS's death.

#856

Well while I wait to die please enjoy this .gif and others if I feel so inclined:

#857

I'm voting MR now, so I don't forget tonight. I'm sorry if its a wrong choice, but based on what I'm seeing in the game, its a better choice than my other questionable players.

linki

#858

#859

Matahari wrote:So, Wadsworth gets to kill every night now? Or was my count off?

MP is not the role I thought he was, because he's a male role (I had forgotten that). Back to the drawing board.

What role did you think? And what conclusion did you reach from your insta-spreadsheet?

Also really amused that nobody revisited your Wadsworth observation. The "there won't be a kill the night a dead baddie would kill" theory was something I disagreed with vocally and early on. If it's not true, it completely invalidates the way some players have been narrowing down their suspects.

#860

Mister Rearranger wrote:
Matahari wrote:So, Wadsworth gets to kill every night now? Or was my count off?

MP is not the role I thought he was, because he's a male role (I had forgotten that). Back to the drawing board.
What role did you think? And what conclusion did you reach from your insta-spreadsheet?

Also really amused that nobody revisited your Wadsworth observation. The "there won't be a kill the night a dead baddie would kill" theory was something I disagreed with vocally and early on. If it's not true, it completely invalidates the way some players have been narrowing down their suspects.

At first, I thought he was the cook, until it was revealed that he was a male role.

#861

I don't remember him ever hinting at that so I'm curious what led you to speculate on it?

#862

After his save during the lynch where Blooper had more votes, he did some explaining- during some of his posts he basically pointed out that he was not the chief, so I assumed he was the cook and had put more votes on someone. Later after finding out he was a male role, I reread him (starting with that lynch) and realized he said some other things too, that pointed to him being someone else. I'm making assumptions, I guess, because its very hard to know anything with 100% confidence.

#863

I thought I hinted too blatantly at my role.

Maybe I didn't after all.

#864

Let me ask you something, when Bass indicated that he had actually changed the outcome of one of the lynches, did you have reason to doubt him?

#865

Matahari wrote:Let me ask you something, when Bass indicated that he had actually changed the outcome of one of the lynches, did you have reason to doubt him?

Are you asking me or MR?

#866

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Matahari wrote:Let me ask you something, when Bass indicated that he had actually changed the outcome of one of the lynches, did you have reason to doubt him?
Are you asking me or MR?

whoops, ya, thought I was talking to MR. Yeah, that question was for MR

#867

Matahari wrote:After his save during the lynch where Blooper had more votes, he did some explaining- during some of his posts he basically pointed out that he was not the chief, so I assumed he was the cook and had put more votes on someone. Later after finding out he was a male role, I reread him (starting with that lynch) and realized he said some other things too, that pointed to him being someone else. I'm making assumptions, I guess, because its very hard to know anything with 100% confidence.

So he would have had to put the additional votes on Nijii, not vote at all (when he could have saved himself), and potentially bank on a coin-flip saving his life?

There were not 2 swapped lynches. I'm pretty sure I know how the other one happened.

Well, Bass mentioned he switched the lynch from me to Blooper, so the one on D2 where Blooper had 4 votes and S~V~S had 2 was the other "switch" I was referring to.

At least I was PRETTY sure why that one happened. I suppose I could be wrong.

He'd be sure-er than that if he was hinting at the Cook. So I hope he wasn't hinting at the Cook.

linki: If you're asking me that, the answer is no. My reason to doubt him comes from 2 mis-lynches, a survival, and 2 rezzes not adding up, with 2 unrevealed roles being dead and knowing that one role 100% did not change the outcome of either mis-lynch.

#868

Not to mention, the Cook can only use the +2 votes once a game, using it on Nijii when he had no way of knowing ahead of time that she would be within 2 votes of him and that he'd be in danger would be wasteful and some pretty impressive luck.

#869

Guys, I hate to do this, but when my family came in from Dallas this weekend, they apparently brought with them a super mystery illness with which I am sorely afflicted and I have to go to bed right this second. I will catch up on the thread and get the lynch post up first thing in the morning, provided I survive that long.

Sorry sorry sorry! I hate being an irresponsible host.

#870

Your health is more important to our country than your games. Please get well.

#871

Mister Rearranger wrote:Not to mention, the Cook can only use the +2 votes once a game, using it on Nijii when he had no way of knowing ahead of time that she would be within 2 votes of him and that he'd be in danger would be wasteful and some pretty impressive luck.

The way the role description sounds to me, the cook has to send in a name the night before. Maybe I'm not comprehending it properly?

#872

Feel better!

Matahari wrote:
Mister Rearranger wrote:Not to mention, the Cook can only use the +2 votes once a game, using it on Nijii when he had no way of knowing ahead of time that she would be within 2 votes of him and that he'd be in danger would be wasteful and some pretty impressive luck.
The way the role description sounds to me, the cook has to send in a name the night before. Maybe I'm not comprehending it properly?

Correct. But how would he even think that Nijii would wind up with Bass's vote and he'd wind up with a cluster on him.

This goes in conjunction with the other thing I mentioned: If he's using up that one-time +2, game-changing kinda vote manipulation, don't you think he'd want to be around to see it play out and vote if need be?

I would.

#873

This goes in conjunction with the other thing I mentioned: If he's using up that one-time +2, game-changing kinda vote manipulation, don't you think he'd want to be around to see it play out and vote if need be?

Are we talking about you or MP, or who? You've lost me somewhere. Are we talking about me thinking temporarily that MP was the cook? Are you trying to get me to re-look at my assumptions on who is who?

You must spell things out for me, because I am slow on the uptake-

#874

Matahari wrote:
This goes in conjunction with the other thing I mentioned: If he's using up that one-time +2, game-changing kinda vote manipulation, don't you think he'd want to be around to see it play out and vote if need be?
Are we talking about you or MP, or who? You've lost me somewhere. Are we talking about me thinking temporarily that MP was the cook? Are you trying to get me to re-look at my assumptions on who is who?

You must spell things out for me, because I am slow on the uptake-

I was talking about you thinking temporarily that MP was the cook. Sorry.

Moot point now. If everyone voted we could have ended this ahead of time. I have no means to survive this lynch that I know of. But I'ma enjoy my time left here because I was really getting into this game.

#875

I'm here! I spent the whole weekend at my family's place in the woods without internet! Aaaack

#876

^wb and seeya next game! lol

#877

Mister Rearranger wrote:^wb and seeya next game! lol

Wait, am I dead?

#878

Mongoose wrote:
Mister Rearranger wrote:^wb and seeya next game! lol
Wait, am I dead?

No no not at all!

I will be shortly, but you're fine.

#879

Mongoose wrote:
Mister Rearranger wrote:^wb and seeya next game! lol
Wait, am I dead?

#880

MR, I feel terrible about you going regardless, but I REALLY hope you're not civ.

#881

This is how I've felt all game:

#882

Love the .gifs from this movie. Haha.

#883

I thought the poll ended at 12 pm? Wtf? I was going to vote this morning before work to make sure I didn't forget. This time thing has been throwing me off all game with the poll constantly being random.

#884

Lynch

Poll ended at Mon Oct 06, 2014 12:01:36 am

Bass the clever
1
Mister Rearranger (5)
13%

Boogs
0
No votes

Epignosis
0
No votes

Vompatti
0
No votes

Matahari
0
No votes

Mister Rearranger
5
Epignosis (2), MovingPictures07 (3), Vompatti (4), Matahari (7), Mongoose (8)
63%

Mongoose
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
0
No votes

Someone else
2
zeek (1), Hedgeowl (6)
25%

Total votes : 8

#885

I didn't do it!

Well, yeah, actually, you kind of did. All of you did.

MIster Rearranger has been lynched. He was The Cook.
You have 24 hours to send in your night actions.

#886

That...was not at all what I was expecting to happen.

I am sorry MR.

#887

Son of a bitch. Guess we should have just went with Bass. I'm so sorry, MR.

#888

Rip MR. I would have voted Bass again for what its worth.

#889

I'm sorry MR, I'm going to reread what you've posted throughout the game, but what comes to mind immediately, is that you were trying to tell us that the cook had nothing to do with the switched lynch, the one that Bass didn't have anything to do with.

#890

G'bye everybody!

#891

Mister Rearranger wrote:

G'bye everybody!

My favorite line in the movie!

#892

RIP MR. I know people are looking at my as boddy but I'm not him I told you guys everything and I don't know what else to do. but I know if I get lynched it will be one more civ you guys will loss.

#893

I am recreating my spreadsheet from scratch.

Question about Boddy targets:

SVS was Boddy's target on Night 1. Correct?

MP was targeted by Boddy on Night 4. Correct?

That means Boddy HAD to have voted on Day 4, correct?

#894

I really think we should vote Bass again. I only voted for Mr. because I felt like it. This is an emotional moment for all of us.

#895

Vompatti wrote:I really think we should vote Bass again. I only voted for Mr. because I felt like it. This is an emotional moment for all of us.

gawd you're so goofy

I think a Vomps vote would be a safe vote.

#896

Matahari wrote:
Vompatti wrote:I really think we should vote Bass again. I only voted for Mr. because I felt like it. This is an emotional moment for all of us.
gawd you're so goofy

I think a Vomps vote would be a safe vote.

I wouldn't mind that tbh.

#897

Epignosis wrote:I am recreating my spreadsheet from scratch.

Question about Boddy targets:

SVS was Boddy's target on Night 1. Correct?

MP was targeted by Boddy on Night 4. Correct?

That means Boddy HAD to have voted on Day 4, correct?

That seeems right to me.

#898

This is my spreadsheet. I have nothing to hide.

#899

Thats a great spread sheet.

#900

IT's much cute, too BAD it's incconrect.

Who is not supatown?