The Rings of Power - Game Over

[MacDougall]

ngl

pretty put off this game now, felt really motivated at sod

gl I'm going to chill for a while, won't drop but just care less

y

don't like Osie

osie pretty scummy tbh

[NotAnAxehole]

min one wolf between scotty/naa/osieorb

It is exactly Scotty.

you think scotty has osie eating out of his hand then?

Yes, I think Osie is the type of player who has certain ideas on how to play the game of mafia, and anything that conflicts with those ideas seems scummy to them. They said as much in a post this game (I'm not going back to look for it) - that they tend to scum read certain playstyles - And they also mentioned playstyles that they disliked when they talked about my wolf chat plan of RoP 1.0 that they didn't like - they also mentioned playstyles & terminology they disliked on one other occasion... Their reads are very very very obviously influenced by playstyle.

I think Osie's reads are purely stylistic reads and that's why I think he's agreeing with Scotty's nonsense.

Aside from that, I think Osie is within their town meta (albeit, limited meta data sample - it's a lot of work to compile).

[srceenplay]

BOURBON

Not getting much from me.

Still say star is full of shit.
Moons probably misguided.


Drive home is in about 15 hours.
Be available then.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME Is it not clearing for me to tell you all that it actually takes 1 more for majority, when I could watch people lose their minds at 9 votes not being a majority instead?

I haven't thought about it at all but I already have you cleared so

[NotAnAxehole]

BOURBON

Not getting much from me.

Still say star is full of shit.
Moons probably misguided.


Drive home is in about 15 hours.
Be available then.

LOL

I thought you were going to claim scum and save us all the trouble.

[hollowkatt]

min one wolf between scotty/naa/osieorb

It is exactly Scotty.

you think scotty has osie eating out of his hand then?

Yes, I think Osie is the type of player who has certain ideas on how to play the game of mafia, and anything that conflicts with those ideas seems scummy to them. They said as much in a post this game (I'm not going back to look for it) - that they tend to scum read certain playstyles - And they also mentioned playstyles that they disliked when they talked about my wolf chat plan of RoP 1.0 that they didn't like - they also mentioned playstyles & terminology they disliked on one other occasion... Their reads are very very very obviously influenced by playstyle.

I think Osie's reads are purely stylistic reads and that's why I think he's agreeing with Scotty's nonsense.

Aside from that, I think Osie is within their town meta (albeit, limited meta data sample - it's a lot of work to compile).

I get it though. I tend to wolf read people who mess with the natural order of the game so I'm getting what they're saying. I'm giving you the benefit of doubt for as up front as you're being basically.

[osieorb18]

Ah yeah now I remember.

you tell me

I haven't read anything from over night

There’s like 40 posts and half of them are me, come on HK

creature, dunya, nanook, moonwink are all probably town.

are you happy now?

I think its easier to call all of them scum than town.

I personally agree with this statement, and we were united in our front against HK’s laziness.

Yes, I assumed you would agree with it. The reason he made it though, I think, is because he KNEW you'd agree with it and he KNEW it would unite you two. If he's scum, I feel like he's making this statement to encourage you to continue pushing HK, who would probably be town in this case, not because he actually believes it. Osie was doing something very similar when you started pushing and pressuring me.

FYI (not that it matters that much) the two players that clinched my interest in signing up for this game were dunya and scotty. So if it seems like I'm trying to interact with them a bit more, that can also be a factor.

%%%

Anyways...

Since I realized this (and pretty much confirmed that it works with Urist):

The best way for town to use Ring #13 is to use the condition "No more than one 'a' in the recipient's role name, and the recipient's role name cannot begin with 'K'."

I have interest in having specifically Ring #13 or Ring #7 since I think they work well with my passive.

%%%

so that folks can actually make some arguments for why they think Srceen is actually town.

Did you not see my argument that Srceen was town, did you dismiss it offhand? It didn't come up in your thoughts on either myself or Srceen.

%%%

min one wolf between scotty/naa/osieorb

It is exactly Scotty.

you think scotty has osie eating out of his hand then?

Yes, I think Osie is the type of player who has certain ideas on how to play the game of mafia, and anything that conflicts with those ideas seems scummy to them. They said as much in a post this game (I'm not going back to look for it) - that they tend to scum read certain playstyles - And they also mentioned playstyles that they disliked when they talked about my wolf chat plan of RoP 1.0 that they didn't like - they also mentioned playstyles & terminology they disliked on one other occasion... Their reads are very very very obviously influenced by playstyle.

I think Osie's reads are purely stylistic reads and that's why I think he's agreeing with Scotty's nonsense.

Aside from that, I think Osie is within their town meta (albeit, limited meta data sample - it's a lot of work to compile).

Have you ever actually seen me play, even once?

As for the "certain ideas on how to play" comment (as familiar as it annoyingly is), it's not the case. I look for whether or not people seem to believe what they are saying or not as my main analysis tool, check interactions, consider gameflow, and then pretty much everything else I do is mechanical (I prefer hosting to playing 99% of the time).

%%%

And they also mentioned playstyles that they disliked when they talked about my wolf chat plan of RoP 1.0 that they didn't like - they also mentioned playstyles & terminology they disliked on one other occasion... Their reads are very very very obviously influenced by playstyle.

I mentioned personalities I dislike more than anything, to be accurate.

I think Osie's reads are purely stylistic reads and that's why I think he's agreeing with Scotty's nonsense.

Actually, I just pretty firmly have had a strong townread on Scotty throughout the game and have yet to see a real case on him. Similar with Srceenplay, Creature, and Jack. And all four of those players know the rest of the playerbase better than I do, so I'm paying attention to their reads in addition to my own tonal reads, and reconsidering my own tonal reads occasionally if I feel that their reads make more sense.

[NotAnAxehole]

I don't do cases, so you're just going to have to adjust your reads based on flips. I know I'm right.

[osieorb18]

Okay stepping off for the Night.

Note to self: Mass ISO again tomorrow morning.

[MacDougall]

im just gonna vote HK and call this d1 pt 2

[DaughterOfOmega]

Hello

[DaughterOfOmega]

hey guyz here's a dumb tier list:

town
mac
nanook
dunya
creature
scotty
doom

lean town
moonwink
naa
martin
jack

poe
porscha
srceen
andres
marmot
wigly
osieorb

hmu for explanations

if HK is mafia, someone above me in that town list is mafia

ez

[DaughterOfOmega]

night shift baby

[Creature]

Have we decided somewhere already?

[Creature]

im just gonna vote HK and call this d1 pt 2

Another day we fail to hit majority?

[NotAnAxehole]

I'm only voting scotty or Srceenplay and I've got 2 votes. Need 10 to kill.

[Creature]

I'm only voting scotty or Srceenplay and I've got 2 votes. Need 10 to kill.

I won't oppose any of them tbh.

[DrWilgy]

Town for some fun to heads!
Everyone likes guns
And heads


Players
Porscha (ISO)
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME (ISO)
Jackofhearts2005 (ISO)
MartinGG99 (ISO)
MacDougall (ISO)
srceenplay (ISO)
DaughterOfOmega (ISO)
NotAnAxehole (ISO)
Andresvmb (ISO)
Creature (ISO)
hollowkatt (ISO)
Moonwink (ISO)
Marmot (ISO)
DrWilgy (I

DrWilgy I...

[Jackofhearts2005]

Still haven't quite beaten Morrowind but whatever, let's get on this.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Is there anything new on HK or are we just doing what we did yesterday?

[Jackofhearts2005]

I still wanna yeet Moonwink for wanting to yeet anyone at all.

[Jackofhearts2005]

If we were just gonna yeet whoever, we should yeet Wilgy or Porsha, who combine for like 25 total posts over the course of 4 days.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Maj games give me HCRealms ptsd where nearly everyone townreads a player but they vote for him anyway because it's that or go no yeet again.

[Jackofhearts2005]

@MacDougall

Or we can yeet Dunia.

Or someone can try to convince me to yeet HK with words.

[Scotty]

I'm only voting scotty or Srceenplay and I've got 2 votes. Need 10 to kill.

I won't oppose any of them tbh.

Since when do you suspect me?

[Creature]

I still wanna yeet Moonwink for wanting to yeet anyone at all.

They're pretty town for me atp

If we were just gonna yeet whoever, we should yeet Wilgy or Porsha, who combine for like 25 total posts over the course of 4 days.

I think they're fine. I'd probably lynch Andres who has posted only two times all game over them.

Maj games give me HCRealms ptsd where nearly everyone townreads a player but they vote for him anyway because it's that or go no yeet again.

This is why we should be lynching someone halfway the dayphase and not wait until the last hour to try to coordinate a wagon. It's already past the dayphase and doesn't look like we're reaching anywhere.

@MacDougall

Or we can yeet Dunia.

Or someone can try to convince me to yeet HK with words.

idk about dunya. I felt they had a solid D1. Didn't see much from her today.

HK looks pretty underwhelming and the few times I saw them posting they barely followed up with anything.

[Creature]

I'm only voting scotty or Srceenplay and I've got 2 votes. Need 10 to kill.

I won't oppose any of them tbh.

Since when do you suspect me?

I didn't like how you fell of at the end of day 1. It's almost as if you ran out of gas.

[Scotty]

I'm only voting scotty or Srceenplay and I've got 2 votes. Need 10 to kill.

Could be 11. Also DOOM’s target will be making the Big Decision if we don’t all swarm on one name.

Someone is going down today.

It’s been like 15 hours since I made a point that srceenplay could have scumslipped and no one is talking about it.

Does anyone else see what I see or is it just me?

[Scotty]

I'm only voting scotty or Srceenplay and I've got 2 votes. Need 10 to kill.

I won't oppose any of them tbh.

Since when do you suspect me?

I didn't like how you fell of at the end of day 1. It's almost as if you ran out of gas.

lol what
I was swamped and work and said as much. It’s not my fault that I was the most active person itt for the first 24 hours and half of the players hadn’t even jumped in yet

[Scotty]

I just realized I’m almost at post cap.
DOOM has shortened the day, don’t know when day actually ends. If I’m not engaged with work I’ll try and be around at eod.

HK is a continuation vote and he hasn’t don’t anything today to dissuade me from thinking he’s bad but I also think that srceenplay legit scumslipped. I wouldn’t mind consolidating on either one.

[VOTE: srceenplay] aubergine

[Creature]

I'm only voting scotty or Srceenplay and I've got 2 votes. Need 10 to kill.

Could be 11. Also DOOM’s target will be making the Big Decision if we don’t all swarm on one name.

Someone is going down today.

Oh right. Then maybe we can each vote our top wolfread?

It’s been like 15 hours since I made a point that srceenplay could have scumslipped and no one is talking about it.

Does anyone else see what I see or is it just me?

I think I missed it.

I'm only voting scotty or Srceenplay and I've got 2 votes. Need 10 to kill.

I won't oppose any of them tbh.

Since when do you suspect me?

I didn't like how you fell of at the end of day 1. It's almost as if you ran out of gas.

lol what
I was swamped and work and said as much. It’s not my fault that I was the most active person itt for the first 24 hours and half of the players hadn’t even jumped in yet

Okay.

[Scotty]

Wait wait wait I missed this before:

Bluff?

I don’t doubt you to be a double voter.
I do doubt you raising the lynch count. That’s not how a double voter works.

Plus your post before you say sorry for the day before. “My fault” that would have put us at nine not “10”. So how is it your fault.

Liar liar pants on fire.

Bluff?

I don’t doubt you to be a double voter.
I do doubt you raising the lynch count. That’s not how a double voter works.

Plus your post before you say sorry for the day before. “My fault” that would have put us at nine not “10”. So how is it your fault.

Liar liar pants on fire.

So you think he is town, but just seeing seeds of chaos?

Nope. Put him in the flip pile too

Both of these reads can’t exist on the same logical plane. If you believe him to be the double voter, how can he possibly be scum? That’s a town role.

[Creature]

I thought wolves had safeclaims. Still looks bad anyways.

[dunya]

If we were just gonna yeet whoever, we should yeet Wilgy or Porsha, who combine for like 25 total posts over the course of 4 days.

Bad.

Porscha's post count is low but content volume high.

Wilgy self resolved and I hate this post.

[dunya]

@Scotty

What about my defence from MacDougalls tunnelling felt town to you?

In his words, I seemed to be trolling him.

I'm not bothered by suspicion against me, is that a town tell for me?

[dunya]

[VOTE: srceenplay] aubergine

[dunya]

I just realized I’m almost at post cap.
DOOM has shortened the day, don’t know when day actually ends. If I’m not engaged with work I’ll try and be around at eod.

HK is a continuation vote and he hasn’t don’t anything today to dissuade me from thinking he’s bad but I also think that srceenplay legit scumslipped. I wouldn’t mind consolidating on either one.

[VOTE: srceenplay] aubergine

It's possible for me that HK is just frozen here cos he has posted nothing to convince me he's town this day phase and has ignored my question.

[dunya]

I'm happy with a HK or srceen yeet today, preference on srceen. But I will help get HK over if needed.

[dunya]

I know I'm flip flopping on HK a lot.

So scummmmy.

[hollowkatt]

I just realized I’m almost at post cap.
DOOM has shortened the day, don’t know when day actually ends. If I’m not engaged with work I’ll try and be around at eod.

HK is a continuation vote and he hasn’t don’t anything today to dissuade me from thinking he’s bad but I also think that srceenplay legit scumslipped. I wouldn’t mind consolidating on either one.

[VOTE: srceenplay] aubergine

It's possible for me that HK is just frozen here cos he has posted nothing to convince me he's town this day phase and has ignored my question.

you asked me a question?

[Jackofhearts2005]

I still wanna yeet Moonwink for wanting to yeet anyone at all.

They're pretty town for me atp

If we were just gonna yeet whoever, we should yeet Wilgy or Porsha, who combine for like 25 total posts over the course of 4 days.

I think they're fine. I'd probably lynch Andres who has posted only two times all game over them.

Maj games give me HCRealms ptsd where nearly everyone townreads a player but they vote for him anyway because it's that or go no yeet again.

This is why we should be lynching someone halfway the dayphase and not wait until the last hour to try to coordinate a wagon. It's already past the dayphase and doesn't look like we're reaching anywhere.

@MacDougall

Or we can yeet Dunia.

Or someone can try to convince me to yeet HK with words.

idk about dunya. I felt they had a solid D1. Didn't see much from her today.

HK looks pretty underwhelming and the few times I saw them posting they barely followed up with anything.

I honestly forgot Andres was in the game at all.

[Jackofhearts2005]

If we were just gonna yeet whoever, we should yeet Wilgy or Porsha, who combine for like 25 total posts over the course of 4 days.

Bad.

Porscha's post count is low but content volume high.

Wilgy self resolved and I hate this post.

Fucking when did that happen?

[Scotty]

@Scotty

What about my defence from MacDougalls tunnelling felt town to you?

In his words, I seemed to be trolling him.

I'm not bothered by suspicion against me, is that a town tell for me?

Instead of listing everything, ima just list your progression that i tonally liked:
-you were very casual with mac ribbing you for not responding to him explaining your mac/osie not w/w read
-you started getting annoyed with him
-but still loved him
-then didn’t
-continued to town read him for it, kept a level head

And:
I’m not convinced mac is good, and I don’t think y’all would be teamed.

Can it be faked? Yeah, dawg. You aren’t a top town for me yet.

I'm happy with a HK or srceen yeet today, preference on srceen. But I will help get HK over if needed.

So do you think srceen scumslipped? Or is this just a continuation from what moon was saying about his wishy washiness?

[Jackofhearts2005]

I hate how most of my suspects are voting Screen.

I’m kinda entirely serious about cleaning out the three low posters.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Like I don’t wanna work with my suspects. I wanna toss them into the sun.

[Scotty]

I hate how most of my suspects are voting Screen.

I’m kinda entirely serious about cleaning out the three low posters.

tbh I don’t think that helps the game state right now. There’s no real vig in this game, so they’ll hVw to be resolved at some time, but I don’t think now’s the time

Regardless of those you don’t trust voting for srceen- which is a lazy reason- do you personally find srceen scummy?

[hollowkatt]

@dunya I looked through your ISO and didn't see you tagging me or asking me anything. Were you thinking of Scotty?

[srceenplay]

On my way home.

See I’m popular. Eh.

Not understanding what you are seeing wrong with my post @Scotty

[Creature]

I still wanna yeet Moonwink for wanting to yeet anyone at all.

They're pretty town for me atp

If we were just gonna yeet whoever, we should yeet Wilgy or Porsha, who combine for like 25 total posts over the course of 4 days.

I think they're fine. I'd probably lynch Andres who has posted only two times all game over them.

Maj games give me HCRealms ptsd where nearly everyone townreads a player but they vote for him anyway because it's that or go no yeet again.

This is why we should be lynching someone halfway the dayphase and not wait until the last hour to try to coordinate a wagon. It's already past the dayphase and doesn't look like we're reaching anywhere.

@MacDougall

Or we can yeet Dunia.

Or someone can try to convince me to yeet HK with words.

idk about dunya. I felt they had a solid D1. Didn't see much from her today.

HK looks pretty underwhelming and the few times I saw them posting they barely followed up with anything.

I honestly forgot Andres was in the game at all.

I also keep forgetting his existence. If my calculations are right, his next post will be february 28th and it will be something like this:

"uwu got prodded again. sorry been too busy. will catch up tonight"

[Creature]

I hate how most of my suspects are voting Screen.

I’m kinda entirely serious about cleaning out the three low posters.

Starting to think the same tbh

[VOTE: Andresmvp] aubergine