RPG Mafia MAFIA WIN

[hollowkatt]

what does me being a trash goblin have to do with your alignment

[dunya]

Who is chicken?

we're all chickens

[Urist]

dunya is mafia

[Syn]

Hello to specifically dya and nobody else.

I've never played with dya!

Well, actually, I have, but I don't want to talk about that game.

[Syn]

dunya is mafia

I am apathetic to this read but I will be watching with great interest.

[Syn]

dunya is mafia

I am apathetic to this read but I will be watching with great interest.

So I can be opportunistic, see.

[Urist]

dunya is mafia

I am apathetic to this read but I will be watching with great interest.

So I can be opportunistic, see.

Carpe diem bro

[Syn]

I'm waiting to see if Dunia will do her blush tell as wolf.

[Syn]

Guys, is she blushing?

[Scotty]

[VOTE: Scotty] aubergine

this seems like a fun place to push

Scotty why aren't you a wolf?

I’ve been domesticated over many millennia and I’m probably a better friend than a cat ever will be, you…feline

correct on an evolutionary scale. But I meant this game specifically.

this line of questioning is coming off as opportunistic.

Like, how am I supposed to answer this? You don’t label a “white” rock as an “absence of black” rock.

Why are you town?

[Scotty]

Dayachi has some work to do if she’s gonna be NK’d tonight

I also look at the top posters, and I think it unlikely that the top 3 in posters are all town. I’d say 1 are not in: HK, Syn, chicken. One of HK or Syn. I’d lean HK however

This is another instance of someone jumping onto a train very late. Why are postcount reads being made twelve hours into D1? Why are multiple people trying to make that read?

What train did I jump on exactly? I’m the only conductor of this train and the train isn’t a train. It’s a tricycle

[dunya]

dunya is mafia

slander.

disgusting

[Syn]

can someone summarize the scotty case?

His first post was to make a lazy other-game progression read on HK.

Since then he's supported LinearPoint's case on me and HK (which amounts to "They posted a lot and there is a difference check between them"), but then 180'd on that when other people discredited LP. (First instance of "jumping onto the train late.")

Then he quoted Dunia's reads list, which is actually contrary to his own (Dunia has HK as top town), but he says it matches his. Half an hour later he posts his updated reads, which are again, not like Dunia's.

Then he jumps late onto the train again and pushes the "top posters are wolfy" (HK and me) lazy case, after, again, other people already have.

Then he tries to say HK has TMI that I'm town (circling back around to his initial wolf read on HK).

oh ffs you’re all goblins. Don’t D1 me again please. I’m over it. Kill me D2 at least

oh ffs you’re all goblins. Don’t D1 me again please. I’m over it. Kill me D2 at least

Do you have a wolf read besides "one of HK or Syn"?

[VOTE: Scotty] aubergine

this seems like a fun place to push

Scotty why aren't you a wolf?

I’ve been domesticated over many millennia and I’m probably a better friend than a cat ever will be, you…feline

correct on an evolutionary scale. But I meant this game specifically.

this line of questioning is coming off as opportunistic.

Like, how am I supposed to answer this? You don’t label a “white” rock as an “absence of black” rock.

Why are you town?

[Scotty]

Dayachi has some work to do if she’s gonna be NK’d tonight

I also look at the top posters, and I think it unlikely that the top 3 in posters are all town. I’d say 1 are not in: HK, Syn, chicken. One of HK or Syn. I’d lean HK however

This is another instance of someone jumping onto a train very late. Why are postcount reads being made twelve hours into D1? Why are multiple people trying to make that read?

This happened in Highway Heist (as Scotty should remember) and all such targets were town.

Wilgy was hard-core POE'd like 8 hours into the say simply because he hadn't posted when everyone else had like 50+ posts

what’s wrong with just…expanding my POE then?

[dunya]

i think scotty is town and very unlike how he played in lotr mafia. but that's just me.

[dunya]

hi @Creature sorry about the wolf rand again

[Urist]

dunya is mafia

slander.

disgusting

Am i wrong?

[Syn]

Okay, maybe Urist is onto something.

[Scotty]

Dayachi has some work to do if she’s gonna be NK’d tonight

I also look at the top posters, and I think it unlikely that the top 3 in posters are all town. I’d say 1 are not in: HK, Syn, chicken. One of HK or Syn. I’d lean HK however

dw, I'll still kill them N1.

Dyachei is very well-educated, if you're town it would be gamethrowing to kill her regardless of her alignment.

them*

i think dya is town and marmot is town too.

i kinda wanna take back my town read on LPP (rask)

Yeah i'm sorry dya but i'm probably going to make that mistake about a dozen more times. I'm trying to remember but i'm perpetually distracted while posting. Please don't think i'm doing it to be a dick.

all i ask is that people try. I didnt think you were trying to be a dick tbh

Apologies! I’m guilty of that, and hadn’t consciously seen it used.

[Syn]

Sounds like a problem for D2 though.

[dunya]

@ urist - w
@ Dolby - w
@ DrWilgy - w
@ Le petit poussin - w
@ LinearPoint - w

havent posted yet or made one nai post:
@ Jackofhearts2005 - ?
@ sig - ?
@ TonyStarkPrime - ?
@ Creature - ?

i feel very good about these town reads:
@ dyachei - t
@ hollowkatt -t
@ MacDougall - t
@ Marmot- t
@ NotAnAxehole- t
@ Scotty - t
@ syn - t

only one in wolf reads i could go back on is urist atm, but yolo. that poopoo head has caused me e m o t i o n a l damage. ;p

[dunya]

dunya is mafia

slander.

disgusting

Am i wrong?

slander usually means you're wrong. ;p

[dunya]

Okay, maybe Urist is onto something.

[dunya]

Sounds like a problem for D2 though.

[Urist]

Sounds like a problem for D2 though.

@MacDougall

[NotAnAxehole]

Also, Scotty is mafia until he does his town tell multiple times. There's something that he does repeatedly & reliably as town that he NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER has done repeatedly as mafia based on my analysis of his games. So I'm waiting for the trust tell, I'm good with killing him up until that point.

Also am I following right that your read comes from the guilty baseline and I have to work to ingratiate myself to a town level?

Is that how you always make your reads in games?

It depends on the read. If someone has a town tell, then they are guilty until proven town, if someone has a mafia tell, then they are town until proven mafia. This is just, common sense as to how town tells & mafia tells work - the absence of the tell means your baseline is the opposite.

[Marmot]

@Marmot what do you think of dunia's current use of exclamations and gifs in response to scumreads?

[Syn]

Sounds like a problem for D2 though.

@MacDougall

I wanna tag people too.

@NotAnAxehole

[NotAnAxehole]

Also, Scotty is mafia until he does his town tell multiple times. There's something that he does repeatedly & reliably as town that he NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER has done repeatedly as mafia based on my analysis of his games. So I'm waiting for the trust tell, I'm good with killing him up until that point.

Your meta of me falls apart the moment you think you have a meta on me.

You’re a three-headed lemonisnicket until you flip to prove otherwise because I just made it up

I think this is a common misconception that mafia players who read content have. I don't make content/interpretation reads.

[dunya]

@Marmot what do you think of dunia's current use of exclamations and gifs in response to scumreads?

oh my.

oh my, the towncore has fallen.

[Syn]

Sounds like a problem for D2 though.

Please let me set you and Scotty up for the D1-2 punch.

[NotAnAxehole]

DAMN YOU, URIST.

Yo Urist outplaying you and it's not even D1. Smh.

I'm gonna town read this and there is absolutely nothing anyone can do about it.

I know why you're dropping this read on him and I think your reasoning is wrong.

The read is correct though.

what's your read on urist?

I don't have one.

[Scotty]

can someone summarize the scotty case?

His first post was to make a lazy other-game progression read on HK.

Since then he's supported LinearPoint's case on me and HK (which amounts to "They posted a lot and there is a difference check between them"), but then 180'd on that when other people discredited LP. (First instance of "jumping onto the train late.")

Then he quoted Dunia's reads list, which is actually contrary to his own (Dunia has HK as top town), but he says it matches his. Half an hour later he posts his updated reads, which are again, not like Dunia's.

Then he jumps late onto the train again and pushes the "top posters are wolfy" (HK and me) lazy case, after, again, other people already have.

Then he tries to say HK has TMI that I'm town (circling back around to his initial wolf read on HK).

After just being HK’s scum mate, I see it entirely relevant to compare his first posts as a parallel to that game.

Your second point of jumping on a train. I actually have no idea what you’re talking about. This whole “case” has no supporting evidence and is a lazy tunnel. I think you are bad.

The yellow highlighted is the most egregiously disingenuous. Those reads were not contrary to my own. Check my reads right before that. I’m being gaslit.

Ironically, I’m Feeling better already with HK, who has put in more work this day 1 than he did all of D1 of Rings, when he seemed lazy, pulled back and on the defensive the whole time.

[Marmot]

@Marmot what do you think of dunia's current use of exclamations and gifs in response to scumreads?

oh my.

oh my, the towncore has fallen.

Excuse me?

[dunya]

@NotAnAxehole

[dunya]

Sounds like a problem for D2 though.

Please let me set you and Scotty up for the D1-2 punch.

i'm down to be mischopped d1 if people wanna read me based on gif usage ;p

[dunya]

@Marmot what do you think of dunia's current use of exclamations and gifs in response to scumreads?

oh my.

oh my, the towncore has fallen.

Excuse me?

you, syn, dya were my towncore.

[Urist]

DAMN YOU, URIST.

Yo Urist outplaying you and it's not even D1. Smh.

I'm gonna town read this and there is absolutely nothing anyone can do about it.

I know why you're dropping this read on him and I think your reasoning is wrong.

The read is correct though.

what's your read on urist?

I don't have one.

LOL i was waiting for this, ty

[Scotty]

Dolby will never be lynched D1, now that I think of it.

[VOTE: Syn] aubergine

This is an omgus vote because I can’t realistically believe that a town Syn is pushing me so hard on actual fake news, and I hate to use that term.

[Syn]

can someone summarize the scotty case?

His first post was to make a lazy other-game progression read on HK.

Since then he's supported LinearPoint's case on me and HK (which amounts to "They posted a lot and there is a difference check between them"), but then 180'd on that when other people discredited LP. (First instance of "jumping onto the train late.")

Then he quoted Dunia's reads list, which is actually contrary to his own (Dunia has HK as top town), but he says it matches his. Half an hour later he posts his updated reads, which are again, not like Dunia's.

Then he jumps late onto the train again and pushes the "top posters are wolfy" (HK and me) lazy case, after, again, other people already have.

Then he tries to say HK has TMI that I'm town (circling back around to his initial wolf read on HK).

After just being HK’s scum mate, I see it entirely relevant to compare his first posts as a parallel to that game.

Your second point of jumping on a train. I actually have no idea what you’re talking about. This whole “case” has no supporting evidence and is a lazy tunnel. I think you are bad.

The yellow highlighted is the most egregiously disingenuous. Those reads were not contrary to my own. Check my reads right before that. I’m being gaslit.

Ironically, I’m Feeling better already with HK, who has put in more work this day 1 than he did all of D1 of Rings, when he seemed lazy, pulled back and on the defensive the whole time.

Everything in this reply is inaccurate. Since your very first post in this game, you've been tunneling HK and flipping on reads after seeing how the wind is blowing.

[Marmot]

@Marmot what do you think of dunia's current use of exclamations and gifs in response to scumreads?

oh my.

oh my, the towncore has fallen.

Excuse me?

you, syn, dya were my towncore.

And?

[Scotty]

oh ffs you’re all goblins. Don’t D1 me again please. I’m over it. Kill me D2 at least

Do you have a wolf read besides "one of HK or Syn"?

Why don’t you check my post history instead of this sound bite journalism

[NotAnAxehole]

I'm down to kill Scotty D1 if he doesn't town tell before EoD.

[Syn]

Dolby will never be lynched D1, now that I think of it.

[VOTE: Syn] aubergine

This is an omgus vote because I can’t realistically believe that a town Syn is pushing me so hard on actual fake news, and I hate to use that term.

How can you not believe town!Syn would do that? You've never seen Syn before. Syn could do anything. Syn is a wild card.

[dunya]

Dolby will never be lynched D1, now that I think of it.

why? a lot of us think he was opportunistic at best, and pretty wolfy earlier today?

[dunya]

@Marmot what do you think of dunia's current use of exclamations and gifs in response to scumreads?

oh my.

oh my, the towncore has fallen.

Excuse me?

you, syn, dya were my towncore.

And?

and two of them wanna flip on me?

is something wrong here? did i offend you?

[Le petit poussin]

@ urist - w
@ Dolby - w
@ DrWilgy - w
@ Le petit poussin - w
@ LinearPoint - w

havent posted yet or made one nai post:
@ Jackofhearts2005 - ?
@ sig - ?
@ TonyStarkPrime - ?
@ Creature - ?

i feel very good about these town reads:
@ dyachei - t
@ hollowkatt -t
@ MacDougall - t
@ Marmot- t
@ NotAnAxehole- t
@ Scotty - t
@ syn - t

only one in wolf reads i could go back on is urist atm, but yolo. that poopoo head has caused me e m o t i o n a l damage. ;p

You went from misrepresenting me to including me with all the folks I ve been sussing up to this point.

[VOTE: dunia] aubergine

Speaking about disgust

[Syn]

oh ffs you’re all goblins. Don’t D1 me again please. I’m over it. Kill me D2 at least

Do you have a wolf read besides "one of HK or Syn"?

Why don’t you check my post history instead of this sound bite journalism

I did. You did a "serious vote" on Dolby because he supported the case on you but wasn't putting his vote on your wagon, but that's about it.

Your other "wolf read" was LP, which connects to my case on you where you supported LP until she was discredited by others, and then you suddenly decided she was "much too serious."

[dunya]

Dolby will never be lynched D1, now that I think of it.

[VOTE: Syn] aubergine

This is an omgus vote because I can’t realistically believe that a town Syn is pushing me so hard on actual fake news, and I hate to use that term.

How can you not believe town!Syn would do that? You've never seen Syn before. Syn could do anything. Syn is a wild card.

if anything, scotty's frustration with you as the only one quoting and building a case on him atm cements him as town to me tbh.

[Marmot]

@Marmot what do you think of dunia's current use of exclamations and gifs in response to scumreads?

oh my.

oh my, the towncore has fallen.

Excuse me?

you, syn, dya were my towncore.

And?

and two of them wanna flip on me?

is something wrong here? did i offend you?

Are they your towncore? I'm confused. I can't tell if this is a scumread of any of those three people listed or what it was trying to say.