RPG Mafia MAFIA WIN

[Dolby]

I'm actually honored to finally be in one of these but I must admit that I don't know who everyone represents

[Scotty]

Saving Dunya

[VOTE: LinearPoint] aubergine

ngl I want to end the day tied between the two and make wolves make the choice
[VOTE: linearpoint] aubergine

If they’re both v/v they’re picking LP 10 times out of 10

that's my way of saying I don't think they're both v

what's your take on them being v/w?

I think only possible if LP is the w

It's possible dunya is town if LP is a wolf, and in that world the dunya voters are trying to save LP by pushing dunya over which makes them more likely wolves.

if LP is town I think dunya is almost always a wolf. I still think it's possible, maybe even likely that they're both wolves. I do not think they're both town at all.

I’ve seen you think both of them should go over today.

What is your current stance? More likely to hit a wolf in…?

[hollowkatt]

ftr dunya flipped her lid at start of d2 after she got a few votes.

TSP and jack have been hard going for her since then. If dunya flips wolf, I contend that this was a hellbus ploy the whole time for cred

i agree with this. jack and tsp look bad for the dunya push regardless of her alignment.

I have the complete opposite take. If dunya flips wolf jack and tsp look far better than they currently do

[Scotty]

I'm actually honored to finally be in one of these but I must admit that I don't know who everyone represents

You’re the one in the middle

[Scotty]

ftr dunya flipped her lid at start of d2 after she got a few votes.

TSP and jack have been hard going for her since then. If dunya flips wolf, I contend that this was a hellbus ploy the whole time for cred

i agree with this. jack and tsp look bad for the dunya push regardless of her alignment.

I have the complete opposite take. If dunya flips wolf jack and tsp look far better than they currently do

Does my theory not hold up at all tho? The timing would be perfect for the change in behavior

[Dolby]

Saving Dunya

[VOTE: LinearPoint] aubergine

ngl I want to end the day tied between the two and make wolves make the choice
[VOTE: linearpoint] aubergine

If they’re both v/v they’re picking LP 10 times out of 10

that's my way of saying I don't think they're both v

what's your take on them being v/w?

I think only possible if LP is the w

It's possible dunya is town if LP is a wolf, and in that world the dunya voters are trying to save LP by pushing dunya over which makes them more likely wolves.

if LP is town I think dunya is almost always a wolf. I still think it's possible, maybe even likely that they're both wolves. I do not think they're both town at all.

eh if LP is town I'd probably look at the Dunya wagon and assume they're v/v tbh

Dunya's positioning surrounding here, Wilgy, and her EoD1 wagon (pending reread) might be enough for me

also I don't think her posting has been that bad

[LinearPoint]

Saving Dunya

[VOTE: LinearPoint] aubergine

ngl I want to end the day tied between the two and make wolves make the choice
[VOTE: linearpoint] aubergine

If they’re both v/v they’re picking LP 10 times out of 10

that's my way of saying I don't think they're both v

what's your take on them being v/w?

I think only possible if LP is the w

It's possible dunya is town if LP is a wolf, and in that world the dunya voters are trying to save LP by pushing dunya over which makes them more likely wolves.

if LP is town I think dunya is almost always a wolf. I still think it's possible, maybe even likely that they're both wolves. I do not think they're both town at all.

eh if LP is town I'd probably look at the Dunya wagon and assume they're v/v tbh

Dunya's positioning surrounding here, Wilgy, and her EoD1 wagon (pending reread) might be enough for me

also I don't think her posting has been that bad

Yeah that's basically the conclusion I have reached.

[Dolby]

I'm actually honored to finally be in one of these but I must admit that I don't know who everyone represents

You’re the one in the middle

can I get like actual unironic who is what for the corners and Alice?

[Scotty]

I’m a leaf
Watch me naynay in the breeze

[VOTE: LP] aubergine

[Dolby]

I'm actually honored to finally be in one of these but I must admit that I don't know who everyone represents

You’re the one in the middle

can I get like actual unironic who is what for the corners and Alice?

actually I only know myself, marmot, urist, and tsp here and don't know the rest

[Scotty]

This is the most I’ve ever switched votes in a phase, let alone a game.

This must be what it feels like to be a fair weather Mets fan

[Jackofhearts2005]

This game is frustrating me to no end

you're a bad person

You're right, I need to stop partially explaining to people how the sausage is made.

I got another one for your to parse if you’d be so kind:
Monkey Island

I think just more sample sizes would help me figure this put

Ok, I'll do my best to not spoil myself to keep the experience authentic.


@Jackofhearts2005 do you have a high post count mafia game I can look at?

viewtopic.php?t=1823

[Urist]

I'm actually honored to finally be in one of these but I must admit that I don't know who everyone represents

You’re the one in the middle

can I get like actual unironic who is what for the corners and Alice?

actually I only know myself, marmot, urist, and tsp here and don't know the rest

hollowkatt, marmot, NAA
dolby, xxxx, dunya
urist, linearpoint, TSP

[LinearPoint]

Yeah honestly the amount of indecisiveness doesn't institute confidence that Duyna is Mafia.

[Scotty]

I'm actually honored to finally be in one of these but I must admit that I don't know who everyone represents

You’re the one in the middle

can I get like actual unironic who is what for the corners and Alice?

actually I only know myself, marmot, urist, and tsp here and don't know the rest

Top right is axe, top left is HK, middle right is Duneya, bottom is Linear

[LinearPoint]

You made a triangle. That ain't a linearpoint.
Though to be fair I'm also 90% sure with my knowledge of math that is impossible.

[Scotty]

You made a triangle. That ain't a linearpoint.
Though to be fair I'm also 90% sure with my knowledge of math that is impossible.

You are a paradox

[Jackofhearts2005]

And Dunya absolutely positively uses ATE as scum while insisting it isn't ATE. It's arguably her go to wolf play. That she doesn't do that as scum is just a silly assertion.

i've asked for confirmation / evidence of this and nobody responded

My bad. But she does.

[Urist]

You made a triangle. That ain't a linearpoint.
Though to be fair I'm also 90% sure with my knowledge of math that is impossible.

what is a point, if not a line we're looking at from the wrong direction?

[Scotty]

Also hi welcome back.

What say you about the thread state? I could be your friend in these dark days

[LinearPoint]

You made a triangle. That ain't a linearpoint.
Though to be fair I'm also 90% sure with my knowledge of math that is impossible.

You are a paradox

You know it.

[Dolby]

You made a triangle. That ain't a linearpoint.
Though to be fair I'm also 90% sure with my knowledge of math that is impossible.

It's a linear equation (y = x +2 plotted on a graph). don't see a point in there

[Scotty]

You made a triangle. That ain't a linearpoint.
Though to be fair I'm also 90% sure with my knowledge of math that is impossible.

what is a point, if not a line we're looking at from the wrong direction?

Interesting

[Urist]

And Dunya absolutely positively uses ATE as scum while insisting it isn't ATE. It's arguably her go to wolf play. That she doesn't do that as scum is just a silly assertion.

i've asked for confirmation / evidence of this and nobody responded

My bad. But she does.

do you have an example of a game where she did this?

[LinearPoint]

Also, I’d like to hear why everybody who has voted LP thinks LP is scummy.

Admittedly, I normally lock LP in as town (or so obvious town, she must die) very quickly (like 2/2 games we’ve played together). I haven’t done that here. But she’s also the popular CW to the player I want yeeted and nobody has said (that I’ve read) a reason to scumread her that is even marginally compelling.

I also wanted to come back to this post actually because this is probably Mafia just due to the fact it is blatantly wrong.
I was horribly scummy as Town in both my other Town games and if I didn't die at night to vigilantes I was going to be lynched.
This is by far my strongest Town game and it feels like I'm doing a much better job of solving. I think today if I die or not a lot of Mafia have outed themselves.

Pretty confident in a Dya, Scotty, TSP, and Jack team.
Maximum one of those is wrong.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Saving Dunya

[VOTE: LinearPoint] aubergine

If Dunya or LP flip wolf I actively would want Wilgy alive

I also think that if Dunya flips town Scotty looks good from EoD1 wagon dynamics surrounding the rising of the Dunya flashwagon. Dunya is probably a reach wagon for wolves if that flash wasn't pure and they'd instead probably would concentrate on just saving Scotty rather than creating Dunya's wagon

I firmly believe Dunya and Lp are aligned

[Jackofhearts2005]

Much as I love Naito, I'm so much more Miz than Naito.

[Dolby]

Saving Dunya

[VOTE: LinearPoint] aubergine

If Dunya or LP flip wolf I actively would want Wilgy alive

I also think that if Dunya flips town Scotty looks good from EoD1 wagon dynamics surrounding the rising of the Dunya flashwagon. Dunya is probably a reach wagon for wolves if that flash wasn't pure and they'd instead probably would concentrate on just saving Scotty rather than creating Dunya's wagon

I firmly believe Dunya and Lp are aligned

I think it's pretty clear that I'm riffing on that I've been voting on Dunya's counter both days

[Dolby]

Also, I’d like to hear why everybody who has voted LP thinks LP is scummy.

Admittedly, I normally lock LP in as town (or so obvious town, she must die) very quickly (like 2/2 games we’ve played together). I haven’t done that here. But she’s also the popular CW to the player I want yeeted and nobody has said (that I’ve read) a reason to scumread her that is even marginally compelling.

I also wanted to come back to this post actually because this is probably Mafia just due to the fact it is blatantly wrong.
I was horribly scummy as Town in both my other Town games and if I didn't die at night to vigilantes I was going to be lynched.
This is by far my strongest Town game and it feels like I'm doing a much better job of solving. I think today if I die or not a lot of Mafia have outed themselves.

Pretty confident in a Dya, Scotty, TSP, and Jack team.
Maximum one of those is wrong.

I mean

Jack's right?

The one other game that I played with you I townlocked you early

Hard against Scotty w also fyi

[LinearPoint]

I'm shocked anyone town read me in either of those games lol.

[Jackofhearts2005]

ftr dunya flipped her lid at start of d2 after she got a few votes.

TSP and jack have been hard going for her since then. If dunya flips wolf, I contend that this was a hellbus ploy the whole time for cred

i agree with this. jack and tsp look bad for the dunya push regardless of her alignment.

Help me bus my teammate, Dunya.

[Dolby]

I'm shocked anyone town read me in either of those games lol.

you were the most obvious town in TF2 by far

[Jackofhearts2005]

@Scotty @hollowkatt

Quit dipping your toes in and then running out of the pool like it's too freaking cold. Dunya's going today with or without you.

You both said it yourself. She needs to be resolved regardless of alignment and her flip helps solve the rest of the game.

Even if LP is a wolf, she could be a wolf with freaking anybody and the game doesn't advance at all.

[LinearPoint]

Actualyl I might amend the Mafia list I made.
Sig is such a wildcard they could be Mafia.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Also, I’d like to hear why everybody who has voted LP thinks LP is scummy.

Admittedly, I normally lock LP in as town (or so obvious town, she must die) very quickly (like 2/2 games we’ve played together). I haven’t done that here. But she’s also the popular CW to the player I want yeeted and nobody has said (that I’ve read) a reason to scumread her that is even marginally compelling.

I also wanted to come back to this post actually because this is probably Mafia just due to the fact it is blatantly wrong.
I was horribly scummy as Town in both my other Town games and if I didn't die at night to vigilantes I was going to be lynched.
This is by far my strongest Town game and it feels like I'm doing a much better job of solving. I think today if I die or not a lot of Mafia have outed themselves.

Pretty confident in a Dya, Scotty, TSP, and Jack team.
Maximum one of those is wrong.

I hope you are a wolf because you're no help at all.

[LinearPoint]

@Scotty @hollowkatt

Quit dipping your toes in and then running out of the pool like it's too freaking cold. Dunya's going today with or without you.

You both said it yourself. She needs to be resolved regardless of alignment and her flip helps solve the rest of the game.

Even if LP is a wolf, she could be a wolf with freaking anybody and the game doesn't advance at all.

I think ironically the only person to Town read me this game is Duyna.
Even funnier is that me and Duyna both created the two wagons and now neither of us want either of them.
So I guess if anybody it'd be Duyna, but I'm not Mafia so I feel she is Town.

[Dolby]

Actualyl I might amend the Mafia list I made.
Sig is such a wildcard they could be Mafia.

take on Wilgy?

Why are the rest of us town?

[LinearPoint]

Also, I’d like to hear why everybody who has voted LP thinks LP is scummy.

Admittedly, I normally lock LP in as town (or so obvious town, she must die) very quickly (like 2/2 games we’ve played together). I haven’t done that here. But she’s also the popular CW to the player I want yeeted and nobody has said (that I’ve read) a reason to scumread her that is even marginally compelling.

I also wanted to come back to this post actually because this is probably Mafia just due to the fact it is blatantly wrong.
I was horribly scummy as Town in both my other Town games and if I didn't die at night to vigilantes I was going to be lynched.
This is by far my strongest Town game and it feels like I'm doing a much better job of solving. I think today if I die or not a lot of Mafia have outed themselves.

Pretty confident in a Dya, Scotty, TSP, and Jack team.
Maximum one of those is wrong.

I hope you are a wolf because you're no help at all.

It'll be even funnier when I flip and show that I didn't even pick a useful role like Warrior.

[LinearPoint]

Actualyl I might amend the Mafia list I made.
Sig is such a wildcard they could be Mafia.

take on Wilgy?

Why are the rest of us town?

I mean Jack, TSP, and Scotty all have played this day pertty scummy.
They've been doing their best to switch wagons at opportune times to keep the vote counts even.
I really cannot see them being Town. Maybe 1, (Jack most likely to not be Mafia of those 3)
Dya is also played the exact same as GoC which she was Mafia.
Wilgy has always been mislynch bait so no.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Saving Dunya

[VOTE: LinearPoint] aubergine

ngl I want to end the day tied between the two and make wolves make the choice
[VOTE: linearpoint] aubergine

If they’re both v/v they’re picking LP 10 times out of 10

that's my way of saying I don't think they're both v

what's your take on them being v/w?

I think only possible if LP is the w

It's possible dunya is town if LP is a wolf, and in that world the dunya voters are trying to save LP by pushing dunya over which makes them more likely wolves.

if LP is town I think dunya is almost always a wolf. I still think it's possible, maybe even likely that they're both wolves. I do not think they're both town at all.

Once again, yes, TSP and I chose to attempt to yeet notoriously LHF player....Dunya. To defend a teammate, LP, who nobody townreads on her own merits and who doesn't seem to gaf about the game.

Come the fuck on.

[Dolby]

Also, I’d like to hear why everybody who has voted LP thinks LP is scummy.

Admittedly, I normally lock LP in as town (or so obvious town, she must die) very quickly (like 2/2 games we’ve played together). I haven’t done that here. But she’s also the popular CW to the player I want yeeted and nobody has said (that I’ve read) a reason to scumread her that is even marginally compelling.

I also wanted to come back to this post actually because this is probably Mafia just due to the fact it is blatantly wrong.
I was horribly scummy as Town in both my other Town games and if I didn't die at night to vigilantes I was going to be lynched.
This is by far my strongest Town game and it feels like I'm doing a much better job of solving. I think today if I die or not a lot of Mafia have outed themselves.

Pretty confident in a Dya, Scotty, TSP, and Jack team.
Maximum one of those is wrong.

I hope you are a wolf because you're no help at all.

It'll be even funnier when I flip and show that I didn't even pick a useful role like Warrior.

LP, were you Druid level 2 last night

[LinearPoint]

Also, I’d like to hear why everybody who has voted LP thinks LP is scummy.

Admittedly, I normally lock LP in as town (or so obvious town, she must die) very quickly (like 2/2 games we’ve played together). I haven’t done that here. But she’s also the popular CW to the player I want yeeted and nobody has said (that I’ve read) a reason to scumread her that is even marginally compelling.

I also wanted to come back to this post actually because this is probably Mafia just due to the fact it is blatantly wrong.
I was horribly scummy as Town in both my other Town games and if I didn't die at night to vigilantes I was going to be lynched.
This is by far my strongest Town game and it feels like I'm doing a much better job of solving. I think today if I die or not a lot of Mafia have outed themselves.

Pretty confident in a Dya, Scotty, TSP, and Jack team.
Maximum one of those is wrong.

I hope you are a wolf because you're no help at all.

It'll be even funnier when I flip and show that I didn't even pick a useful role like Warrior.

LP, were you Druid level 2 last night

I'll get back to you day 3

[Jackofhearts2005]

Actualyl I might amend the Mafia list I made.
Sig is such a wildcard they could be Mafia.

take on Wilgy?

Why are the rest of us town?

I mean Jack, TSP, and Scotty all have played this day pertty scummy.
They've been doing their best to switch wagons at opportune times to keep the vote counts even.
I really cannot see them being Town. Maybe 1, (Jack most likely to not be Mafia of those 3)
Dya is also played the exact same as GoC which she was Mafia.
Wilgy has always been mislynch bait so no.

I've literally been voting Dunya the entire day and I'm super townie.

[LinearPoint]

Actualyl I might amend the Mafia list I made.
Sig is such a wildcard they could be Mafia.

take on Wilgy?

Why are the rest of us town?

I mean Jack, TSP, and Scotty all have played this day pertty scummy.
They've been doing their best to switch wagons at opportune times to keep the vote counts even.
I really cannot see them being Town. Maybe 1, (Jack most likely to not be Mafia of those 3)
Dya is also played the exact same as GoC which she was Mafia.
Wilgy has always been mislynch bait so no.

I've literally been voting Dunya the entire day and I'm super townie.

I could have sworn you were one of the 3 I kept see switching.
Maybve not.

[Dolby]

Jack I think you're getting unreasonably sus bc of the rigidity of the scum list and your inclusion on it

Speaking as someone who wants Lp dead

[Jackofhearts2005]

Scotty and Urist showing TMI with w!Dunya by trying to associate two obvious townies with her and also terrified of her going over, refusing to vote her for any length of time.

Scummy scummy scummy.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Jack I think you're getting unreasonably sus bc of the rigidity of the scum list and your inclusion on it

Speaking as someone who wants Lp dead

Since when is rigidity a bad thing?

[Dolby]

LP going for the claim that outs results tomorrow after heavily implying warrior class invest on D1 is TWTBAW but I don't want to believe it

[LinearPoint]

Scotty and Urist showing TMI with w!Dunya by trying to associate two obvious townies with her and also terrified of her going over, refusing to vote her for any length of time.

Scummy scummy scummy.

You know what I can find common ground in lynching Scotty for his wolfy D1 and D2.

Plus I'm fairly confident this day will end in a mislynch unless we get another better wagon going.

[Urist]

i switched my vote to TSP because i think he has a better chance of going over.
i do think that marmot has more wolf % in him though