Mafia Misplay Mafia

[DrWilgy]

is mac having bad reads indicative of being a wolf? i've only played with godread town mac

you think he has bad reads rn? why?

have u seen his past few posts? i dont think the list of names he gave ends the game lol

im town so what he's suggesting is the other 3 names are the entire wolf team

I don't have to be exactly right for my reads to be not shitty ... one dimensional wolf mindset

I don't think It's Lily after this exchange.

[Porscha]

I have no wolf reads

that must mean it is us who are the wolves

Does Mac open wolf with Esooa?

He also had a post exactly like this one with neon

[DrWilgy]

Kinda weird how both of them have been angry at Santy. Maybe we have run up two wolves and they're just salty.

Odd shade.

[Porscha]

hmm, how do i prove that i'm not paired with santy so that sabi can reevaluate their poe....

you pretty much can't after santy turned into a vest made out of kevlar for you and you said thank you very much sir

Oof. If Snow-thing is not a wolf-thing, this post is bad-bad.

I think it's a pretty accurate representation of this entire day

What is accurate?

What Porscha says? Porscha's posts being bad-bad? The whole day-day?

Porscha

Jack If you read the start of day with the snow witch hunt and santy coming in almost single handedly dissolving it by haaaarrddd shielding snow... and snow just says thanks to him

[Lilypetal]

Damn esooa neon wolves...hate to see it...proof is undeniable

[Porscha]

Snow's iso doesn't have a smoking gun but Mac is in the middle of her read list and none of their interactions look impossible to fake.

I'm now voting for Snow for a few reasons.

1) They are the most likely Mac teammate I see after having read everybody in my POE. I'd like the wagons to be between Snow and myself over say...Nanook and myself or Santy and myself.

2) They a voting me anyway so there's no downside.

Yeah I'm down to party on snow wagon

[hollowkatt]

I miss queek

the good thing about breaking character is now maybe this jack wagon goes away.
I'll die for jack tbat's a good trade

Sorry im not allowed to talk to you

I thought we just couldn't talk about us, but that we could talk about others.
I think you town read Jack right? If I missed something I'm sorry.

If you do town read him and he does flip and he is town do you think his wagon is wolf driven or just town wilding?

[DrWilgy]

Done with Mac's day 1.

Noticable things:
Porscha Mac was very fluffy.

Neon received an unwarranted TR early. I do think that this is bait though.

Mac pretty much avoided all HK discussion.

[Porscha]

Damn esooa neon wolves...hate to see it...proof is undeniable

Lol
I think...
Mac made one obvious fake distance and one real distance post between the 2 of them. Both times they were painfully awkward... so awkward in fact, he had to be aware of it. I think the posts were pointedly tactical in being made.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I miss queek

the good thing about breaking character is now maybe this jack wagon goes away.
I'll die for jack tbat's a good trade

Sorry im not allowed to talk to you

I thought we just couldn't talk about us, but that we could talk about others.
I think you town read Jack right? If I missed something I'm sorry.

If you do town read him and he does flip and he is town do you think his wagon is wolf driven or just town wilding?

Hes in my poe

[Porscha]

Done with Mac's day 1.

Noticable things:
Porscha Mac was very fluffy.

Neon received an unwarranted TR early. I do think that this is bait though.

Mac pretty much avoided all HK discussion.

Mac was probs toast after I said he didnt town tell and then like 15 minutes later he specifically @ me to say he towntold

[hollowkatt]

I miss queek

the good thing about breaking character is now maybe this jack wagon goes away.
I'll die for jack tbat's a good trade

Sorry im not allowed to talk to you

I thought we just couldn't talk about us, but that we could talk about others.
I think you town read Jack right? If I missed something I'm sorry.

If you do town read him and he does flip and he is town do you think his wagon is wolf driven or just town wilding?

Hes in my poe

cool cool
does his shift to break gimmick shift things for you? I think his gimmick posting was fair but post break it's been pretty on fire

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

The shift away from the gimmick doesn't move the needle for me, he has incentive to do so as either alignment

[hollowkatt]

The shift away from the gimmick doesn't move the needle for me, he has incentive to do so as either alignment

cool beans

[Porscha]

The shift away from the gimmick doesn't move the needle for me, he has incentive to do so as either alignment

cool beans

I think he has incentive either way but the frustration he showed when he broke character read as townie to me

[Porscha]

Currently brain thinking on how mac repeatedly said everyone was clearing wilgy and esooa too easily cuz he felt we were underestimating them

[DrWilgy]

I feel like trusting with my life now in Ris, Porscha, nook and Lily. Prob in that order.

I thought that maybe ow kill was one to maintain status quo in thread, but just glossing at player list wilgs was there and feels like far more juicier then Outed Wolf there to kill so eeeeeh Im still lost on why ow could die.

I see the mac case and like yeah, could be. But also it isnt like, too much level 0 as a take? Mac isn the only scum so there should be two other people who would agree with that and why???

Explain the read on Risiinq please.

really? you're going to antagonize me after quoting 3 quotes that aren't bad for me at all?

Where am I antagonising you? I want to know why Santygrass townreads you so that I can figure out whether or not he and/or you are mafia. Do you have a problem with that?

forgive me for the overreaction. i just felt like you weren't treating me as a "fellow townie" in any of the posts recently where you quoted one of my posts and probed me.

Well I am currently of the mindset that you're likely not town so that would be a correct feeling to have. That doesn't have to upset you. It's a mafia game, it happens all the time.

This is just an odd interaction. I'd vote for Ris.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Alright I'm back to townreading wilgy

[Porscha]

Alright I'm back to townreading wilgy

Based off what

[Lilypetal]

Wait snow as a wolf solves this game. Santy even went out of his way to shield her. Town santy would shield a wolf here. I'm voting snow

[DrWilgy]

I think HK kinda has to be mafia based on how I'm reading people.

If Sabi is town the game is probably a lot easier so here's my hypothetical readslist in that context.

Town

Sabi
Porscha
Neon

Lean Town

Achro

Nanook
Jack
Santygrass

Lean Wolf

Esooa or Lily

Wolf

Risiinq
HK

I can't really see town winning this game if HK is town.

HK removed from PoE

[DrWilgy]

Do I need to. Make a town case on neon, Wilgz and esooa for yall to keep them out of poe

such a weird post

Low key starting to tinfoil Sabi

[DrWilgy]

Do I need to. Make a town case on neon, Wilgz and esooa for yall to keep them out of poe

such a weird post

Low key starting to tinfoil Sabi

Like I have no reason to add them back to PoE when using logical brain.

Emotional brain is like "WoweaheWaWAaAAggHhweEaeaWhAaa"

[DrWilgy]

Queek was not here for end of day. Queek was doing many important task-things.

Old-thing wagon looks full of good skaven like Queek and others who are not as smart-wise as Queek.

If old-thing is a wolf-thing who has given up, why did other wolf-things not buss him? Tell me if this is good thought or if Queek needs to execute scouts who reported it.

how can anyone be scumreading this

I mean, I'd kill Jack just out of dislike towards smelly ass skaven

[DrWilgy]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

Damn esooa neon wolves...hate to see it...proof is undeniable

True ^^

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

I... disagree but your probably right cause I suck at mafia

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Alright I'm back to townreading wilgy

Based off what

His posting between the post you quoted and when I said I wasn't TRing him

And partially off not really wanting to change reads around much with sick brain

[Jackofhearts2005]

Queek was not here for end of day. Queek was doing many important task-things.

Old-thing wagon looks full of good skaven like Queek and others who are not as smart-wise as Queek.

If old-thing is a wolf-thing who has given up, why did other wolf-things not buss him? Tell me if this is good thought or if Queek needs to execute scouts who reported it.

how can anyone be scumreading this

I mean, I'd kill Jack just out of dislike towards smelly ass skaven

Spoiler: show

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

Its a throwaway joke response to a barebones push on them lol

[Jackofhearts2005]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

Seems like kinda a nothing look tbh.

Like it's a one word joke post.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

I... disagree but your probably right cause I suck at mafia

Idk im on your side

[Jackofhearts2005]

If we yeet a wolf today, I'm going back Queekposting js.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Wow such synergy

[DrWilgy]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

I... disagree but your probably right cause I suck at mafia

Why do you disagree?

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

Its a throwaway joke response to a barebones push on them lol

Omg was i right about something

[DrWilgy]

Queek was not here for end of day. Queek was doing many important task-things.

Old-thing wagon looks full of good skaven like Queek and others who are not as smart-wise as Queek.

If old-thing is a wolf-thing who has given up, why did other wolf-things not buss him? Tell me if this is good thought or if Queek needs to execute scouts who reported it.

how can anyone be scumreading this

I mean, I'd kill Jack just out of dislike towards smelly ass skaven

Spoiler: show

You know what you did.

If I had a penny for every unit I had to waste to block gnawholes...

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Fighting the urge to reflexively TR jack and neon

[DrWilgy]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

Its a throwaway joke response to a barebones push on them lol

Hmm... I suppose it is a layer hedgey and within a joke bubble.

I'll take a look at Achro's legacy then ris for context next.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Queek was not here for end of day. Queek was doing many important task-things.

Old-thing wagon looks full of good skaven like Queek and others who are not as smart-wise as Queek.

If old-thing is a wolf-thing who has given up, why did other wolf-things not buss him? Tell me if this is good thought or if Queek needs to execute scouts who reported it.

how can anyone be scumreading this

I mean, I'd kill Jack just out of dislike towards smelly ass skaven

Spoiler: show

You know what you did.

If I had a penny for every unit I had to waste to block gnawholes...

Wait, you actually play for realzies warhammer?

Collecting a skaven army for real life is something I'd do if had a lot more money and space and was less into video games.

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

I... disagree but your probably right cause I suck at mafia

Why do you disagree?

The above posts people noted after I said this is part of it. And I really hate when people say "Well I actually want to vote over here but I'm not going to" it's rarely beneficial to town and is an easy way to make you look distanced.

[DrWilgy]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

Seems like kinda a nothing look tbh.

Like it's a one word joke post.

So what is the context that makes it a joke? Am I dumb or something, I got 3 of y'all pointing it out but I don't see it.

[Esooa]

Alright I'm gonna go play league and probably hate my life.

Maybe take selfies and post them on all my discords so people lie and call me pretty and I feel better about myself.

I really think Mac is town. GL town hopefully I'm wrong.

idk lol i think neon is wolfing that last post just makes me think mac is gonna flip town

Or I just actually think Mac is town and the wagon is bad and the structure is bad and this EoD is bad.

Sabi Mac Porscha Town

HK Santy probably town

Everyone else skill issue.

I still think the wording of these posts is pretty good. Like especially the second one. I just don't think she comes out that strong like that even if she is town reading Mac. But reading this makes me wonder why she was so fine with voting me, I thought she was town reading me before. So I guess @ neon if you want to explain that it'd be cool

@Neon

[Jackofhearts2005]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

Seems like kinda a nothing look tbh.

Like it's a one word joke post.

So what is the context that makes it a joke? Am I dumb or something, I got 3 of y'all pointing it out but I don't see it.

Snow has a very mild, very impersonal push on Mac.

Mac calls the push "toxic" but you couldn't really push in a less toxic and offensive way if you tried.

[DrWilgy]

Queek was not here for end of day. Queek was doing many important task-things.

Old-thing wagon looks full of good skaven like Queek and others who are not as smart-wise as Queek.

If old-thing is a wolf-thing who has given up, why did other wolf-things not buss him? Tell me if this is good thought or if Queek needs to execute scouts who reported it.

how can anyone be scumreading this

I mean, I'd kill Jack just out of dislike towards smelly ass skaven

Spoiler: show

You know what you did.

If I had a penny for every unit I had to waste to block gnawholes...

Wait, you actually play for realzies warhammer?

Collecting a skaven army for real life is something I'd do if had a lot more money and space and was less into video games.

Buy a 3d printer and just play with friends at your local game store instead of the Warhammer store.

I just printed and build a Great Unclean One and a Warhound Titan last week.

Spoiler: show

In GW plastic I have Fyreslayers, Flesh Eater Courts, Custodes and Ad Mech.

[Lilypetal]

We don't need to discuss this anymore tbh snow is an outed wolf. The santy tell is absolute

[Lilypetal]

Queek was not here for end of day. Queek was doing many important task-things.

Old-thing wagon looks full of good skaven like Queek and others who are not as smart-wise as Queek.

If old-thing is a wolf-thing who has given up, why did other wolf-things not buss him? Tell me if this is good thought or if Queek needs to execute scouts who reported it.

how can anyone be scumreading this

I mean, I'd kill Jack just out of dislike towards smelly ass skaven

Spoiler: show

You know what you did.

If I had a penny for every unit I had to waste to block gnawholes...

Wait, you actually play for realzies warhammer?

Collecting a skaven army for real life is something I'd do if had a lot more money and space and was less into video games.

Buy a 3d printer and just play with friends at your local game store instead of the Warhammer store.

I just printed and build a Great Unclean One and a Warhound Titan last week.

Spoiler: show

In GW plastic I have Fyreslayers, Flesh Eater Courts, Custodes and Ad Mech.

That's so sick wtf

[DrWilgy]

i'd rather it be everyone tbh

(seriously speaking i would like mac to be a wagon again, im only not voting him rn bcuz i wanna vote esooa for a while)

toxic

This, however, is a good look for ris

Seems like kinda a nothing look tbh.

Like it's a one word joke post.

So what is the context that makes it a joke? Am I dumb or something, I got 3 of y'all pointing it out but I don't see it.

Snow has a very mild, very impersonal push on Mac.

Mac calls the push "toxic" but you couldn't really push in a less toxic and offensive way if you tried.

I see now. Also Neon's point is critically correct.

[DrWilgy]

And so Ris is Snow right? Was just using context for the most part on that one but confirmation would be nice.

[DrWilgy]

Spoiler: show

how can anyone be scumreading this

I mean, I'd kill Jack just out of dislike towards smelly ass skaven

Spoiler: show

You know what you did.

If I had a penny for every unit I had to waste to block gnawholes...

Wait, you actually play for realzies warhammer?

Collecting a skaven army for real life is something I'd do if had a lot more money and space and was less into video games.

Buy a 3d printer and just play with friends at your local game store instead of the Warhammer store.

I just printed and build a Great Unclean One and a Warhound Titan last week.

Spoiler: show

In GW plastic I have Fyreslayers, Flesh Eater Courts, Custodes and Ad Mech.

That's so sick wtf

Ty! Wanted to test the limits of the Mars 2 Pro, so figured let's go for something structurally questionable.