Anniversary Game 3 - Cindy Kate Meet Up [GAME OVER - TOWN WIN]

[MacDougall]

That said I think its reasonable for Alison to think that given our exchange so

Far too generous young Clem

[Alison]

I am going to have a lot of fun with Mac in DVC.

[Millium]

I got distracted from Santy's case reading it again now

[Alison]

The best case scenario is that I get exed today and he gets shot tonight. That way I can chill with him in DVC and he won't be around to shield Santy for no reason and throw the game.

[MacDougall]

I am going to have a lot of fun with Mac in DVC.

Oh miss me with this shit everything you are saying is like tailored to trying to play at my insecurities.

[Alison]

That said I think its reasonable for Alison to think that given our exchange so

Far too generous young Clem

He literally said it's reasonable for me to think it, if you're going to try to use his statements to paint me as a liar then you're the one being confbiased. Get your shit together Mac.

[Seanzie]

Yeah kinda think Belzy needs to fullclaim in the thread.

@Belzy [VOTE: belzy] aubergine

[EnderWiggin]

[VOTE: Alison] aubergine

[MacDougall]

The best case scenario is that I get exed today and he gets shot tonight. That way I can chill with him in DVC and he won't be around to shield Santy for no reason and throw the game.

It's okay when you flip red I'll chop Santy for you anyway cuz you're obviously wolf teammates

[Alison]

I am going to have a lot of fun with Mac in DVC.

Oh miss me with this shit everything you are saying is like tailored to trying to play at my insecurities.

I am not gonna make fun of you lol.

I mean I might a little bit but when have I ever hugely flamed you even in games like Cats and Dogs where we were at each other's throats all game? I literally meant chilling together with you when I don't have to deal with you having wrong reads on me. And my next post makes that clear.

[MacDougall]

That said I think its reasonable for Alison to think that given our exchange so

Far too generous young Clem

He literally said it's reasonable for me to think it, if you're going to try to use his statements to paint me as a liar then you're the one being confbiased. Get your shit together Mac.

He literally never even commented on Santy's case and is saying it's reasonable for you to think that he thought it was illogical when you said that he said it was.

Fuck the hell off lol.

[MacDougall]

I am going to have a lot of fun with Mac in DVC.

Oh miss me with this shit everything you are saying is like tailored to trying to play at my insecurities.

I am not gonna make fun of you lol.

I mean I might a little bit but when have I ever hugely flamed you even in games like Cats and Dogs where we were at each other's throats all game? I literally meant chilling together with you when I don't have to deal with you having wrong reads on me. And my next post makes that clear.

If you are town there is only one explanation.

You have taken some sort of medication that has flicked the mafia skill switch in your brain from the "goat" to "potato" position.

[Alison]

That said I think its reasonable for Alison to think that given our exchange so

Far too generous young Clem

He literally said it's reasonable for me to think it, if you're going to try to use his statements to paint me as a liar then you're the one being confbiased. Get your shit together Mac.

He literally never even commented on Santy's case and is saying it's reasonable for you to think that he thought it was illogical when you said that he said it was.

Fuck the hell off lol.

"Everyone who isn't mafia or honorary mafia thinks it's made up."
"is saying it's reasonable for you to think that he thought it was illogical when you said that he said it was."

Hey if you want to play stupid pedantic wording games and call people liars based off it I can play those games too. I used the word think, see?

[dyachei]

mac the AtE from you this game is disgusting. I disagree with your reads, that doesn't mean I'm treating you like a moron. How about instead of mocking me, you play the game?

[Alison]

I am going to have a lot of fun with Mac in DVC.

Oh miss me with this shit everything you are saying is like tailored to trying to play at my insecurities.

I am not gonna make fun of you lol.

I mean I might a little bit but when have I ever hugely flamed you even in games like Cats and Dogs where we were at each other's throats all game? I literally meant chilling together with you when I don't have to deal with you having wrong reads on me. And my next post makes that clear.

If you are town there is only one explanation.

You have taken some sort of medication that has flicked the mafia skill switch in your brain from the "goat" to "potato" position.

Tell you what, we'll get spoiled together, if Santy is mafia I make fun of you a little bit and if Santy is town you make fun of me a little bit.

[MacDougall]

mac the AtE from you this game is disgusting.

citation needed

[MacDougall]

Hands up if you feel like this game has been made worse by Mac's ate?

[Millium]

Flipping Porscha is a win win because she has the most entertaining reactions when she is wrongfully killed for no reason so even if she is town we get some value out of it.

OTOH we should vote the guy that is actually mafia if we want to win.

how does, "letting Porscha live to D3, because if she was town she would body two wolves"
coincide with, "at least if she is town we get funny reactions"

I know I one point you said you didn't care

[dyachei]

mac the AtE from you this game is disgusting.

citation needed

telling me that I'm treating you like a moron is AtE and I'm not impressed

done talking to you now

[Millium]

didnt Porscha's wagon like completely die bear the end of EoD
that would probably partially be my fault though, so hard to read

[MacDougall]

I am going to have a lot of fun with Mac in DVC.

Oh miss me with this shit everything you are saying is like tailored to trying to play at my insecurities.

I am not gonna make fun of you lol.

I mean I might a little bit but when have I ever hugely flamed you even in games like Cats and Dogs where we were at each other's throats all game? I literally meant chilling together with you when I don't have to deal with you having wrong reads on me. And my next post makes that clear.

If you are town there is only one explanation.

You have taken some sort of medication that has flicked the mafia skill switch in your brain from the "goat" to "potato" position.

Tell you what, we'll get spoiled together, if Santy is mafia I make fun of you a little bit and if Santy is town you make fun of me a little bit.

Acceptable.

And if you are mafia as always, I will be a gracious victor and only speak about how impressive your determination was even when you were entirely outed and predicating your arguments on thin air.

[Alison]

Flipping Porscha is a win win because she has the most entertaining reactions when she is wrongfully killed for no reason so even if she is town we get some value out of it.

OTOH we should vote the guy that is actually mafia if we want to win.

how does, "letting Porscha live to D3, because if she was town she would body two wolves"
coincide with, "at least if she is town we get funny reactions"

I know I one point you said you didn't care

If she is town and lives she gets two wolves
If she is town and dies we get funny reactions

But she isn't so point is moot

[Seanzie]

Uhhh clearly the only reasonable elim today is either Belzy or Mac.

[Alison]

Uhhh clearly the only reasonable elim today is either Belzy or Mac.

We're mostly just killing time until Belzy comes back and fullclaims which is why we're only arguing slightly about my actual case on Santy and most of it is just jokes about DVC mockery.

[MacDougall]

didnt Porscha's wagon like completely die bear the end of EoD
that would probably partially be my fault though, so hard to read

Yeah only had ilario on it at the end.

[MacDougall]

mac the AtE from you this game is disgusting.

citation needed

telling me that I'm treating you like a moron is AtE and I'm not impressed

done talking to you now

Person 1 - You are offending me because you are making me feel like you think I am inferior.
Person 2 - No I'm not you're offending me by telling me you're offending me.

What is person 2?

[Marmot]

Attention players. I'm here to remind you that this is a game of mafia. I understand that this is an extremely competitive group of players, and as such, emotions and tempers may flair, but insulting each other or mafia communities is not a permissable response. If you are growing frustrated with the game or other players, please us my and/or @Justplayingitcool's DM, not the thread, to direct it. Please respect your fellow players.

Spoiler: show

@Allison
@arogame123
@Belzy
@Chamomile
@dyachei
@EnderWiggin
@ilario
@Lilypetal
@MacDougall
@Millium
@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
@Neon
@Porscha
@RondoDimBuckle
@santygrass
@Seanzie
@staypositivefriend
@Tilgarial

[Seanzie]

Uhhh clearly the only reasonable elim today is either Belzy or Mac.

We're mostly just killing time until Belzy comes back and fullclaims which is why we're only arguing slightly about my actual case on Santy and most of it is just jokes about DVC mockery.

acceptable I guess.

[Millium]

Maybe its just me, but given the experience I've had with Alison, them at least evaluating a dead town's reads
shouldn't really be a point against them

can't say the same with their handling of Nanook, and his vote though

[MacDougall]

Maybe its just me, but given the experience I've had with Alison, them at least evaluating a dead town's reads
shouldn't really be a point against them

can't say the same with their handling of Nanook, and his vote though

what is it that shouldn't be a point against them?

I don't think a single person has criticised Alison for evaluation Arogame's reads

[Alison]

Maybe its just me, but given the experience I've had with Alison, them at least evaluating a dead town's reads
shouldn't really be a point against them

can't say the same with their handling of Nanook, and his vote though

You do not understand my meta.

I know this because every statement you have made about my meta and my approach towards mafia play is wrong.

[dyachei]

i told alison I would look into santy as mafia more if she flips villa. She's not lying about it

[Millium]

Uhhh clearly the only reasonable elim today is either Belzy or Mac.

no, Mac isn't part of that picture, if Mac kills a town with this he just looks bad, could probably walk out of it
but if he is a wolf and alison is town, there is literally no need to derail the Alison train with something like that

+ belzy is the key to everything, if they are town, Mac is confirmed
if they are a wolf, Mac is still cleared honestly, cause why the hell do this

[MacDougall]

Mac: Alison is mafia because they are not being factual
Alison: Mac doesn't understand my meta, is misrepresenting my meta

TIL I learned that Alison has a "invents facts" town meta.

[dyachei]

calling your offense on alison reachy and frantic is not an insult, it's not treating you like a moron, it's making a read.

then you tried to make me feel guilty off of it. That's the definition of AtE.

[dyachei]

gonna repeat, mac is in his town meta. I think he's just wrong on his reads this game

[Millium]

Maybe its just me, but given the experience I've had with Alison, them at least evaluating a dead town's reads
shouldn't really be a point against them

can't say the same with their handling of Nanook, and his vote though

You do not understand my meta.

I know this because every statement you have made about my meta and my approach towards mafia play is wrong.

i played two games with u, 3 if we count Orange's shit fiesta of a game on Chief delphi
all I am hearing is that I should just believe you are a wolf at this point

this was from my PoV, of which I dont recall in the two games I played with you, you actually reading into the people you have buried
maybe I am dumb, that's just what I remember

[MacDougall]

i told alison I would look into santy as mafia more if she flips villa. She's not lying about it

that is not what alison said though

[MacDougall]

calling your offense on alison reachy and frantic is not an insult, it's not treating you like a moron, it's making a read.

then you tried to make me feel guilty off of it. That's the definition of AtE.

I am withdrawing from this conversation as per the request of the MoD. Let's talk about mafia.

[Alison]

Maybe its just me, but given the experience I've had with Alison, them at least evaluating a dead town's reads
shouldn't really be a point against them

can't say the same with their handling of Nanook, and his vote though

You do not understand my meta.

I know this because every statement you have made about my meta and my approach towards mafia play is wrong.

i played two games with u, 3 if we count Orange's shit fiesta of a game on Chief delphi
all I am hearing is that I should just believe you are a wolf at this point

this was from my PoV, of which I dont recall in the two games I played with you, you actually reading into the people you have buried
maybe I am dumb, that's just what I remember

I don't really care what alignment you think I am, I'm just asking you to stop making statements that begin with "based on what I know about Alison, she would X in Y situation". Because every time you say that it's wrong.

[MacDougall]

Alison said that you, Nanook and Lilypetal said that Santy's case on her was illogical.

I don't believe any of you did.

You saying that you would look into it, is not that.

[Seanzie]

Uhhh clearly the only reasonable elim today is either Belzy or Mac.

no, Mac isn't part of that picture, if Mac kills a town with this he just looks bad, could probably walk out of it
but if he is a wolf and alison is town, there is literally no need to derail the Alison train with something like that

+ belzy is the key to everything, if they are town, Mac is confirmed
if they are a wolf, Mac is still cleared honestly, cause why the hell do this

I mean, I don't disagree with you, but anytime anyone claims something as damning as Mac did, you resolve between the claimer and the claimee. That's all I'm saying.

[EnderWiggin]

Ftr anyone who hasn't got the memo yet Mac is town.

Again.

I've said or implied this so much.

[Alison]

I have determined that further conversation is likely to be unproductive so I'm going to go watch a movie and wait for other people to come in that I can talk to that aren't the person I am hard pushing, Macdougall, or Wisp.

Any recommendations? I'm watching this with someone I'm close to and he's really into Disney. We have Netflix.

[Millium]

Maybe its just me, but given the experience I've had with Alison, them at least evaluating a dead town's reads
shouldn't really be a point against them

can't say the same with their handling of Nanook, and his vote though

You do not understand my meta.

I know this because every statement you have made about my meta and my approach towards mafia play is wrong.

i played two games with u, 3 if we count Orange's shit fiesta of a game on Chief delphi
all I am hearing is that I should just believe you are a wolf at this point

this was from my PoV, of which I dont recall in the two games I played with you, you actually reading into the people you have buried
maybe I am dumb, that's just what I remember

I don't really care what alignment you think I am, I'm just asking you to stop making statements that begin with "based on what I know about Alison, she would X in Y situation". Because every time you say that it's wrong.

ok how about based on what I think, cause that's how I talk
/shrug

[Alison]

Also Mac is green checked by Belzy.

[EnderWiggin]

Uhhh clearly the only reasonable elim today is either Belzy or Mac.

no, Mac isn't part of that picture, if Mac kills a town with this he just looks bad, could probably walk out of it
but if he is a wolf and alison is town, there is literally no need to derail the Alison train with something like that

+ belzy is the key to everything, if they are town, Mac is confirmed
if they are a wolf, Mac is still cleared honestly, cause why the hell do this

I mean, I don't disagree with you, but anytime anyone claims something as damning as Mac did, you resolve between the claimer and the claimee. That's all I'm saying.

What if I believe Belzy was telling the truth and merely forgot to mention it was a oneshot until they realised Mac was assuming it wasn't?

I don't see how that's not a world that exists with this claim. I don't see why we are required to resolve there.

[dyachei]

I have determined that further conversation is likely to be unproductive so I'm going to go watch a movie and wait for other people to come in that I can talk to that aren't the person I am hard pushing, Macdougall, or Wisp.

Any recommendations? I'm watching this with someone I'm close to and he's really into Disney. We have Netflix.

dragon prince is fun

[Alison]

Uhhh clearly the only reasonable elim today is either Belzy or Mac.

no, Mac isn't part of that picture, if Mac kills a town with this he just looks bad, could probably walk out of it
but if he is a wolf and alison is town, there is literally no need to derail the Alison train with something like that

+ belzy is the key to everything, if they are town, Mac is confirmed
if they are a wolf, Mac is still cleared honestly, cause why the hell do this

I mean, I don't disagree with you, but anytime anyone claims something as damning as Mac did, you resolve between the claimer and the claimee. That's all I'm saying.

What if I believe Belzy was telling the truth and merely forgot to mention it was a oneshot until they realised Mac was assuming it wasn't?

I don't see how that's not a world that exists with this claim. I don't see why we are required to resolve there.

Personally I suggest waiting for Belzy to make a full claim and going based off that instead of giving her free safeclaims/explanations if she is indeed mafia.

[Alison]

I have determined that further conversation is likely to be unproductive so I'm going to go watch a movie and wait for other people to come in that I can talk to that aren't the person I am hard pushing, Macdougall, or Wisp.

Any recommendations? I'm watching this with someone I'm close to and he's really into Disney. We have Netflix.

dragon prince is fun

I'll go for that, thanks