Anniversary Game 3 - Cindy Kate Meet Up [GAME OVER - TOWN WIN]

[MacDougall]

"This push is toothless. This is not a real reason to scumread someone over Millium "Selfvote" Wisp and Porscha "Wolfy" Porscha."

this is the funniest post of the game...

[ilario]

@Chamomile Read Lily case on me and stop having Skill Issue tbh

No need you're fine.

Is there any reason why Lily isn't being voted for btw? Seems like she has TMIskies.

Lily is obvtown tier for me rn. The case is really good tol so thats why I directed you to it, so you harvest a townread on both me and Lily tbh

Case probably just comes from TMI. The Porsha defense isn't believable from town!lily perspective.

the porscha defense? i don't know if she's town but I haven't seen a good reason to SR her

I am going to want actual reasons if people are wagoning one of my fav people to play mafia with

i feel as though lilys defense of porcha is moreso personal based than for any actual read on porcha. which still makes it not wolfy for me

[MacDougall]

damn it i was gonna solve the game but ender has now distracted me with the most hilarious casing of all time

[MacDougall]

@EnderWiggin now do ilario lol

[EnderWiggin]

damn it i was gonna solve the game but ender has now distracted me with the most hilarious casing of all time

Are you saying it doesn't actually read like a proper case to you? I at least appreciate you enjoyed the humour I added in.

[EnderWiggin]

@EnderWiggin now do ilario lol

I can have a look but I just spent hours on Dya and my brain is eh. Lemme give a shot.

[ilario]

You waste a day by killing Wisp.

In a way, it’ll progress the game and it’ll shift a lot of reads that people have tbh.

It’ll also look worse for Porscha and her teammates if she’s mafia.

I still believe wisp is leaning town so we’ll see how that goes.

I’ll feel vindicated if wisp flips town tbh.

Hmmmmmm

I just feel that wisp is likely to flip town tbh

Hmmmmmmm

Inb4 Aro TMId Wisp town

this sequence isnt damning per se, but its odd that neon keeps their vote on wisp despite outing this and not changing to aro

[MacDougall]

damn it i was gonna solve the game but ender has now distracted me with the most hilarious casing of all time

Are you saying it doesn't actually read like a proper case to you? I at least appreciate you enjoyed the humour I added in.

no dude it's a straight up slam dunk burial master case on someone who has been pinging me non stop all game, it's catharsis

[ilario]

[VOTE: Aro] aubergine

nvm they did

[dyachei]

Once again en Der you sussed me in constellations and were wrong there.

I'm still not a wolf but you can vote me if you want to lose the game faster.

I focused d1 on people I know. You'll note that I read Mac that day too

[MacDougall]

Day 1 votecount

Arogame (9): Lily, Seanzie, Alison, Dya, SPF, Santy, Neon, Mac, Tigarial
Millium (5): Cham, Porscha, Belzy, Arogame, Millium
Cham (2): Rondo, Ender
Alison (1): Nanook
Porscha (1): Ilario

I think seanzie, alison, neon, and tilg are most suspicious. I think tilg maybe less than the others because the pile on at that point would probably be something mafia would avoid. Seanzie's actions all game have really confused me but I think he's probably played more games with aro on TS where aro is apparently revered.

alison is good at pushing her agenda when she has one.

ignores lily

[dyachei]

Mac just wants you to be right because he thinks I'm trying to treat him like a moron

[dyachei]

I don't know lily that we'll Mac. Why would I focus on her?

[dyachei]

Mac try playing without being emotional about it because you've been treating people like they're out to get you all game

[EnderWiggin]

Once again en Der you sussed me in constellations and were wrong there.

I'm still not a wolf but you can vote me if you want to lose the game faster.

I focused d1 on people I know. You'll note that I read Mac that day too

I straight up called your slot town to your face and told you to bury Persona slot and you ignored me and I was right.

Don't.

I did sus you earlier before Punchy flipped mafia and that is on me.

[EnderWiggin]

But also I was pushing SilverKeith more at that point and I was ALSO right about that.

Fun fact I was right about half the team in Constellations it was just the half that snowed me flipped first which didn't work well for my cred lmao.

[EnderWiggin]

Eh what am I saying I actually sucked in a lot of places in Constellations.

I still am frustrated by some of my play in that game.

[ilario]

ender ur case is towny lol, but i think ur just confbiased. compare how dya played d1 to someone like santy, its not all that different imo

[EnderWiggin]

ender ur case is towny lol, but i think ur just confbiased. compare how dya played d1 to someone like santy, its not all that different imo

Wrong.

Search the ISO of Santy and see how many times Porscha and the wagon is mentioned.

Santy definitely was wrong, but they at least interacted and recognised the Porscha wagon.

Dya straight up ignore's its existence until Alison asks them.

[EnderWiggin]

ignores*

We are not sure how that apostrophe got in there.

[MacDougall]

@EnderWiggin they are both just trying to head fuck you and it's blatantly obvious. They are mafia together. Ilario is not this prone to being pocketed. If he was town he'd be all over Dya like a rash. They are treating you the same way right now they've been treating me.

[ilario]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

[MacDougall]

Belzy
Dya
Ilario

Are all entirely outed mafia.

The only question I have is which of Lily/Neon is the other one.

[ilario]

@EnderWiggin they are both just trying to head fuck you and it's blatantly obvious. They are mafia together. Ilario is not this prone to being pocketed. If he was town he'd be all over Dya like a rash. They are treating you the same way right now they've been treating me.

Lol I openly said it can be a pocket, I just don’t find his case convincing, but on the plus side I think it’s helped me find him as town haha

[MacDougall]

Belzy
Dya
Ilario

Are all entirely outed mafia.

The only question I have is which of Lily/Neon is the other one.

Given I was in the process of highlighting how it's always Lilypetal and Ilario was blatantly pushing Neon instead, and their entire gameplan appears to be to just powerwolf like there's no tomorrow, I'm gonna assume it's Lilypetal.

At any rate Nanook and Millium are never mafia. Nor is Ender. So we have three very firm town here now.

[EnderWiggin]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

[MacDougall]

@EnderWiggin they are both just trying to head fuck you and it's blatantly obvious. They are mafia together. Ilario is not this prone to being pocketed. If he was town he'd be all over Dya like a rash. They are treating you the same way right now they've been treating me.

Lol I openly said it can be a pocket, I just don’t find his case convincing, but on the plus side I think it’s helped me find him as town haha

If you don't think that case is convincing there is not a case on Earth that would convince you my guy. You're just mafia. Let it goooo.

[MacDougall]

@Lilypetal @Neon one of you is a wolf. Figure it out.

[ilario]

Belzy
Dya
Ilario

Are all entirely outed mafia.

The only question I have is which of Lily/Neon is the other one.

Given I was in the process of highlighting how it's always Lilypetal and Ilario was blatantly pushing Neon instead, and their entire gameplan appears to be to just powerwolf like there's no tomorrow, I'm gonna assume it's Lilypetal.

At any rate Nanook and Millium are never mafia. Nor is Ender. So we have three very firm town here now.

i agree with ur lock towns lol

[ilario]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

[MacDougall]

Ender: Posts a masterwork burial on an s-tier town that shows they blatantly pushed town all game while shielding an openly polarised mafia slot. Literally unredeemable.

Ilario: I just think ur confbiased

[EnderWiggin]

I think Belzy is absolutely loverised mafia with Mac, which means Mac if you shoot them tonight you kill yourself.

Which, unfortunately, I think you have to do kinda.

[ilario]

ender im pretty sure my rxn to ur case that game was different

[MacDougall]

Ender: Posts a masterwork burial on an s-tier town that shows they blatantly pushed town all game while shielding an openly polarised mafia slot. Literally unredeemable and tried to gaslight the top poster in the game, and plausibly Ilario too. Unrepentantly incorrect town killing robot dyachei.

Ilario: I just think ur confbiased

Ebwop

[EnderWiggin]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

...

No?

It was D3.

Then I buried him and you eventually came around to it after I argued with you.

And I helped you find the last wolf.

That was the basketball game.

And sure it was one of my better town games. But I am no nonce.

ALSO

How do you explain my point about how Dya overtly treated Mac as if he was loverised?

[ilario]

Ender: Posts a masterwork burial on an s-tier town that shows they blatantly pushed town all game while shielding an openly polarised mafia slot. Literally unredeemable.

Ilario: I just think ur confbiased

lets say dya flips town does that make ender outed? he will also be guilty of what you are accusing dya of.

thats why i think results based thinking like this are kinda circular, imo. the game isnt an easy solve, we've been trying for days and its still hard. in an environment like that it means it is quite normal and okay for townies to be wrong.

[EnderWiggin]

ender im pretty sure my rxn to ur case that game was different

You're right. Your reaction that game was townier.

=P

[MacDougall]

I think Belzy is absolutely loverised mafia with Mac, which means Mac if you shoot them tonight you kill yourself.

Which, unfortunately, I think you have to do kinda.

Haha I strongly doubt Belzy is going to survive this day even if it means I'm out.

But me flipping town and heading into DVC here is probably fine.

[ilario]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

...

No?

It was D3.

Then I buried him and you eventually came around to it after I argued with you.

And I helped you find the last wolf.

That was the basketball game.

And sure it was one of my better town games. But I am no nonce.

ALSO

How do you explain my point about how Dya overtly treated Mac as if he was loverised?

what is wrong about dyas treatment there?

[MacDougall]

Ender: Posts a masterwork burial on an s-tier town that shows they blatantly pushed town all game while shielding an openly polarised mafia slot. Literally unredeemable.

Ilario: I just think ur confbiased

lets say dya flips town does that make ender outed? he will also be guilty of what you are accusing dya of.

thats why i think results based thinking like this are kinda circular, imo. the game isnt an easy solve, we've been trying for days and its still hard. in an environment like that it means it is quite normal and okay for townies to be wrong.

your endless hypotheticals designed to make me consider impossible worldviews and scumread town have run their course

[MacDougall]

noting that dyachei came into the thread moments ago to try to use ATE ON ME to get me to reconsider

[ilario]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

...

No?

It was D3.

Then I buried him and you eventually came around to it after I argued with you.

And I helped you find the last wolf.

That was the basketball game.

And sure it was one of my better town games. But I am no nonce.

ALSO

How do you explain my point about how Dya overtly treated Mac as if he was loverised?

no cos im pretty sure on d2 i wanted to kill brad but then mac kept trying to kill me so somehow he ended up dying that day

[EnderWiggin]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

...

No?

It was D3.

Then I buried him and you eventually came around to it after I argued with you.

And I helped you find the last wolf.

That was the basketball game.

And sure it was one of my better town games. But I am no nonce.

ALSO

How do you explain my point about how Dya overtly treated Mac as if he was loverised?

what is wrong about dyas treatment there?

If Belzy is scum that loverised with Mac.

Who else treats them like they're a loverised town with a mafia partner?

Dya is the only one that overtly does that.

Go reread and tell me how I'm wrong on that.

[Millium]

@MacDougall
@ilario
your last chance to get anything from me was yesterday
I just skimmed the 160 posts that happened while was asleep
your best betis to condense anything u want me to respond to

[EnderWiggin]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

...

No?

It was D3.

Then I buried him and you eventually came around to it after I argued with you.

And I helped you find the last wolf.

That was the basketball game.

And sure it was one of my better town games. But I am no nonce.

ALSO

How do you explain my point about how Dya overtly treated Mac as if he was loverised?

no cos im pretty sure on d2 i wanted to kill brad but then mac kept trying to kill me so somehow he ended up dying that day

I can't remember if you scumread Brad D2.

But D3 when I made the case I was directly against both you and Alexa who I had to win round and even then getting Brad voted out wasn't easy.

[EnderWiggin]

@MacDougall
@ilario
your last chance to get anything from me was yesterday
I just skimmed the 160 posts that happened while was asleep
your best betis to condense anything u want me to respond to

Read my case on Dya.

[MacDougall]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

...

No?

It was D3.

Then I buried him and you eventually came around to it after I argued with you.

And I helped you find the last wolf.

That was the basketball game.

And sure it was one of my better town games. But I am no nonce.

ALSO

How do you explain my point about how Dya overtly treated Mac as if he was loverised?

no cos im pretty sure on d2 i wanted to kill brad but then mac kept trying to kill me so somehow he ended up dying that day

that is a very ridiculous retelling of that game where I had a POE of literally brad/alexa/wiml the entire mafia team but go off king

[RondoDimBuckle]

Thanks Rondo.

You're welcome, I tried

[ilario]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

...

No?

It was D3.

Then I buried him and you eventually came around to it after I argued with you.

And I helped you find the last wolf.

That was the basketball game.

And sure it was one of my better town games. But I am no nonce.

ALSO

How do you explain my point about how Dya overtly treated Mac as if he was loverised?

what is wrong about dyas treatment there?

If Belzy is scum that loverised with Mac.

Who else treats them like they're a loverised town with a mafia partner?

Dya is the only one that overtly does that.

Go reread and tell me how I'm wrong on that.

But dya has had mac as confident town since d1, it’s not like the read came out of nowhere. Alison treated mac the same way lol

[EnderWiggin]

Like I get what ur saying, but alota the things you think are wolfy such as focusing on specific slots is quite normal for dya, they normally open every game focusing on who they know best and solving one slot at a time. If they come into the game late then it’s quite expected their d1 worldview would be narrow imo

Remember that game where I cased Brad when you townread him and you told me that all of what I was calling scummy was entirely in his town meta?

yeah that was d1, then i read ur case, read the game and buried him the next 2 days lmao. and then killed his partner the day after

...

No?

It was D3.

Then I buried him and you eventually came around to it after I argued with you.

And I helped you find the last wolf.

That was the basketball game.

And sure it was one of my better town games. But I am no nonce.

ALSO

How do you explain my point about how Dya overtly treated Mac as if he was loverised?

what is wrong about dyas treatment there?

If Belzy is scum that loverised with Mac.

Who else treats them like they're a loverised town with a mafia partner?

Dya is the only one that overtly does that.

Go reread and tell me how I'm wrong on that.

But dya has had mac as confident town since d1, it’s not like the read came out of nowhere. Alison treated mac the same way lol

Alison spent half the game saying Mac must be mafia for how he treated her.